12 ms·
Do patents kill innovation? The US patent office is asking
- cryptica 5y agoI can't speak for every industry but in the software industry, they are 100% counterproductive and harm innovation. It's good that many countries do not recognize software patents.
- hota_mazi 5y agoI see little evidence of that latest claim. China doesn't recognize software patents and it's rife with cheap copies and clones of existing products and produces very little innovation. The US recognizes patents and is the most innovative country on many fronts (not just software).
- cryptica 5y agoAustralia and Europe do not recognize them either. Australia is pretty innovative in the software industry considering its small population (which is less than 1/10th of the US).
- anthk 5y agoEurope doesn't have software patents neither and you have lots of complex teleco hardware.
- tester756 5y ago>The US recognizes patents and is the most innovative country on many fronts (not just software). how? Semiconductors are in Taiwan, South Korea and EU tooling Is there more bleeding edge tech than Semiconductors?
- debacle 5y agoPatents in theory or patents in practice? The patent system has been gamified, and is now optimized for the corporatocracy.
- hota_mazi 5y agoI've lived through a few instances where software patents fostered innovation. We had implemented a certain GUI without realizing that we had copied an existing one. It was completely accidental, the kind of thing that happens without really thinking about it. We received notification from our competitors that we had to change our approach because they had a patent for it. We did. It set us back a whole month but at the end of the day, we ended up coming up with a solution which I think we superior in all the ways. So the software patent worked here: it forced us to not be lazy and come up with an innovative approach instead of copying an existing one.
- Buttons840 5y agoYour being sarcastic, right? A system like patents needs to demonstrate a clear and very large benefit to offset the fact that it removes people's freedom to implement ideas of their own inventions, to implement their own thoughts. That should be a hard thing to take away. I don't think patents demonstrate a large enough benefit to justify that.
- hota_mazi 5y agoMy story is an exact contradiction to your last point. By the way, you're*.
- dangus 5y agoYour story absolutely isn’t a counterexample. It’s blind luck that the situation you described led to innovation. Even if it did lead to innovation, it still wasted a month of time that could have been invested in more impactful innovations. You were still forced to hold out on shipping for a month entirely due to the patent system. The alternate ending to that story could have very easily (and more likely) been “we had to scrap the feature because there was no way to do it without violating the patent.” Or the result could have been that they only alternative you came up with was worse. Or the result could have been that you needed to pay the other company a licensing fee. Essentially you just got lucky that the competitor didn’t think of the best idea first, because if they had you’d be forced to ship something inferior. For example, Amazon patented buying something with one click. How do you propose innovating around that? You can’t, you have to license the patent from Amazon or add another step to your checkout process. There’s only one way for one click to buy something.
- underseacables 5y agoI think its too easy to get a patent, and that leads to a great proliferation of patents that serve little purpose but to slow innovation. I worked at a patent law firm about 15 years ago in my wild youth. I’ll never forget hearing an attorney explain that getting a patent is basically bullying the examiner, and if that doesn’t work, appealing repeatedly until it’s eventually accepted. Are there statistics of the number of patent applications rejected? Even better, I would love to see the number of patent applications filed by the Apple computer corporation, and how many were accepted, and how many were rejected. Edit: Autocorrect error.
- paxys 5y agoToo easy from the technical side, too difficult/expensive from the legal side. Solo inventors and startups working on genuinely new and interesting technology do not have the funding to hire fancy law firms, while companies like Microsoft and IBM file a dozen patents a day (not an exaggeration). It's the exact opposite of how a patent process should work.
- deelowe 5y agoAnd a perfect example of how regulatory capture works. I don't have a solution, but I am convinced that over time this is the end result of ANY regulation. It doesn't matter what the original intent is/was.
- dantheman 5y agoThe answer is to not grant patents.
- wpietri 5y agoI look it as an evolutionary system, an arms race. Capture will happen if the regulators don't keep up. But it's possible to keep up. US financial markets have a lot of internal regulation for traders, so they're wrangling some of the most aggressive do-anything-for-a-buck people on the planet. Nonetheless, the traders are generally kept in check. I used to do tech for derivatives traders and we knew to never, ever fuck around with a market. That didn't always stop our traders, of course. We had some based in Frankfurt who hated living there. They decided they wanted to live in London, and so quietly shifted their trading terminals to our London office. This was strictly forbidden; at least at the time, the mid-90s, trading on the Deutche Terminborse was to take place on German soil and nowhere else. Eventually the regulators got suspicious and so they were standing outside ringing the bell while watching our trading activity. So one of my technical colleagues had to rent a van, load everything up, drive it 10 hours back to Frankfurt, and have it all working by the next morning. Which we did, and so avoided formal sanction, but it was close. That probably kept those traders from doing something foolish for at least another year.
- ssivark 5y ago”The study particularly wants to find examples of where a patent has been denied in the US but accepted in other jurisdictions, which will be a key area for European electronics companies. […] The study is looking at patent prosecution strategy and portfolio management as well as research and development, employment, procurement and marketing. It is also interested in the impact on the ability to obtain financing from investors or financial institutions and investment strategy as well as the impact on product development, innovation and competition.” Sounds like they might think it’s _too hard_ to get patents in the US?
- jqpabc123 5y agoPatents don't kill innovation but they do next to nothing to promote it. Only a very small percentage of patents are ever successfully licensed to anyone. Around 3% recoup the cost of filing the patent. Half of all patents expire prematurely when the owner declines to pay the required maintenance fees.
- errantspark 5y agoThese are all features and should be accelerated. There shouldn't be a possibility to renew.
- alok-g 5y agoThat 97% of the patents don't go recoup the cost is a statistic known to companies and patent lawyers. This should only serve to make them more careful about filing patents. In other words, inventions less likely to be effective would be passed upon by them themselves.
- Buttons840 5y agoFor those who read the comments first / only: The article is really short with no fluff or filler.
- liuliu 5y agoCombining transferrability and making patent dirt-cheap to acquire means that most patents will end up with companies that won't put it in productive use (most recent example, see Lecun's account for convnet patent: https://twitter.com/ylecun/status/1412549942229487620 https://twitter.com/ylecun/status/1412549942229487620). The hoarding behavior is killing innovation. Two ways to solve this: 1). limit transferrability, for example: patents can only be owned by natural persons and cannot be transferred to other persons or legal entities; 2). making it very expensive to keep the patents.
- tablespoon 5y ago> Two ways to solve this: 1). limit transferrability, for example: patents can only be owned by natural persons and cannot be transferred to other persons or legal entities; 2). making it very expensive to keep the patents. Or require active productive use after a certain time period to maintain the patent, at least for certain classes of owners [1]. [1] ...because small-time inventors will probably have more trouble putting their inventions to productive use, and you don't want to disadvantage them w.r.t. some big corporation (e.g. if all patents expire in five years without use, the corp may just decide to wait instead of paying). This probably could be phrased as an exception to a general rule for entities that only control a small number of patents.
- morcheeba 5y agoSixteen years ago, I had the idea for headlights aimed by GPS and started to make some prototypes. Then I read a patent that was basically "a plurality of inputs + processor -> headlight aiming" that covered everything imaginable. I knew the patent wouldn't hold up in court, but I wouldn't have the money to fight it. More recently, I've been working on a self-driving wheelchair. It's a fairly obvious straight line from self-driving car to self-driving wheelchair, but someone's gone out and patented it. I still don't have the money to fight it.
- pdonis 5y agoThis problem would be a lot easier to deal with if independent invention was a defense (as it is supposed to be, but in practice basically never is) against a patent infringement claim--particularly if the owner of the patent has done nothing to actually implement it.
- morcheeba 5y agoYep, that would help. From what I can tell, the wheelchair patent is aspirational and they haven't actually implemented the majority of standard autonomous vehicle practices.
- bluGill 5y agoThe patent office should start demanding working models for everything. You shouldn't patent something unless it actually works.
- jandrese 5y agoMaybe demand a working model for the patent, but also reject a patent if anybody else has something similar in development? So you have a brilliant idea like "lets put email on a cell phone", but the infrastructure isn't in place to support it yet. A few years later you finally get it working, but now you can't patent because there are 5 other companies who started the process at basically the same time--once the prerequisite technology was in place. This would reduce the number of patents on "the most obvious way to solve this obvious problem that only appears because the technology has advanced enough" that patent trolls love. So many of the "do X, but now on a computer" patents wouldn't be a thing. Requiring a working prototype would also make it hard to issue vaguely worded and extremely broad patents, so someone can't claim ownership over the entire concept of sending push notifications for example.
- RocketSyntax 5y agoinnovators ship
- procombo 5y agoand innovative entrepreneurs don't let their competitors see them as competition
- hota_mazi 5y agoPatents have a good intent, the real danger is non practicing entities (patent trolls). I think that you shouldn't be allowed to acquire a patent (via acquiring the patent owner) unless you are in the business of the patent, or you go to market with an application of that patent within a limited amount of time
- sschueller 5y agoSimplest fix to me would be to reduce the time of validity. We aren't in the 19th century anymore and extremely complex things can be build within months.
- kpatrick 5y agoMy patent attorney used to tell me: "Patents are like nuclear weapons. I want to be on the side that has the most."
- floatingatoll 5y agoThis link from the article explains how to submit your comments: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2021/07/09/2021-14628/patent-eligibility-jurisprudence-study https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2021/07/09/2021-14... The USPTO will not be reading our comments here, so if you feel strongly about this issue, please do consider taking the time to submit them formally as well. There will very likely be astroturfing from supporters of restrictive laws, and while they’re good at detecting that, it still makes a difference!
- coder543 5y agoAbsolutely. The design of the patent system needs to be significantly updated. Every single new thing seems to be violating an assortment of patents, most of them for extremely obvious or common things. When Apple introduced the LiDAR sensor on iPhone, lots of people started building apps to map out the interior of homes to break the monopoly that Matterport seems to hold on that part of real estate technology. I started researching that stuff for a tangentially related idea that I have, and if you want to go from a LiDAR point cloud to a set of polygons representing a room, it seemed like you would have to violate a dozen of Matterport's patents. Truly ridiculous stuff. As I dug into the documentation around it, I realized that Apple will actually do the spatial reconstruction for you if you want, which is nice because that presumably means that Apple is the one violating the patents instead of you, right? It's hard to say. I wonder if even a lawyer could give you a straight answer to that question. Similarly, maybe I want to make a better kind of 2D barcode. QR Code patents supposedly won't be enforced against anyone implementing or using them for QR-compatible codes, if I remember correctly, but... a few years ago when I looked into this, I saw that the company that owned the QR Code patents had continued publishing new patents seemingly in order to extend their hold over QR Codes (and similar 2D barcodes) in perpetuity. So, if you make any kind of 2D barcode that is even remotely similar to a QR Code, talk to some lawyers or... good luck? And those are just two examples of things that I have run up against as an individual with ideas who would love to innovate, but feels restricted by the infinite number of patents that exist. I think some serious reform of intellectual property rights could spur significant new innovations and societal benefit, while still protecting people who are actually innovating and applying those innovations. (Keep in mind that I am not a lawyer.)
- jfengel 5y agopresumably means that Apple is the one violating the patents instead of you, right? It's hard to say. Maybe Apple is even licensing the patents. It would be kinda nice to think that the system was actually working as intended, for once. Somebody invents; somebody else wants the idea; the license is made available at a reasonable price and they get paid for it. Probably not. But a guy can dream.
- 5y ago
- cletus 5y agoPatents clearly kill innovation. Like, that shouldn't even be a question. Fun fact: when the US entered WWI they had to buy warplanes because they didn't have the capacity to build them. Why? The original steering patent related to Orville and Wright was used to stifle innovation [1]. This was such a problem that a patent pool had to be created. Likewise, e-ink devices have largely had no innovation due to the patents of the e-ink corporation being used to stifle innovation. I'm relatively OK with pharmaceutical patents... within reason. The big problem in the US is you can't import that same drug from another country where the same company is making the exact same product. I realize they do this for price differentiation but this has gone way too far and is a big reason why US drugs are so expensive. In the very least you should be able to legally import such drugs from any developed nation. But look at something like a smartphone and there are literally thousands of patents that apply to that product. That's... ridiculous. Business models shouldn't be patentable. Software shouldn't be patentable. Obvious hardware innovations (eg applying more than one texture per clock cycle) shouldn't be patentable. Software can be protected by copyright. The US PTO and the US Federal Court of Appeals are clearly in a state of regulatory capture at this point (so much so that the Supreme Court has taken to routinely slapping down the excesses of the US FCoA) so I suspect any feedback on this will be used to justify that yes patents do protect innovation. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wright_brothers_patent_war https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wright_brothers_patent_war
- bern4444 5y agoThe e-ink patent is so frustrating. Another good example of a patent restricting innovation was the patent on 3D Printers. That's why in the past few years, 3D printers have become so much more prevalent and accessible (you can buy one for a few hundred dollars today). These definitely stifle innovation. I'd think a more reasonable approach could be, you have a patent for 15 years (or whatever arbitrary number is reasonable) or until the patent holder makes some multiple dollar amount from things that use whatever is patented. That is, if it costs a million dollars to develop e-ink screens, the patent is valid until the company has had revenue of 20 million dollars on devices that have e-ink screens. Tying it to revenue instead of profit is intended since profits can be turned into revenue easily to bypass the restriction otherwise. You could also add a minimum number of years (obviously less than the max mentioned above) so companies have some protection across various metrics.
- daniel-thompson 5y agoIn the software domain, I feel like patents have mostly become a corporate pre-emptive defense mechanism, i.e. "don't sue us for your patents we're infringing on, and in return we won't sue you for our patents you're infringing on".
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoIt can be even more defensive than that. "We're patenting the things we're doing, so that nobody else can patent those things and then sue us for them." That's, um, not "promoting the progress of science and useful arts". It's at least not trying to exploit others, but it's sheer waste, having to protect yourself from being exploited.
- AlbertCory 5y agoQuestions like this will always founder if you equate software patents with real inventions. As Joel Spolsky said, there are maybe two ideas in software per year that are really worth patenting (actually, he didn't say "per year" so I was being generous). I wrote an article [1] about this seven years ago! It was cited in an amicus brief to SCOTUS in the CLS Bank case. Nothing has changed since then. We should realize that our companies' top management and the professional societies are not on our side on this. Engineers themselves will have to get it done. [1] https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2399580 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2399580
- ElViajero 5y agoFor an example take the "Loading Screen Game" patent (https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/12/loading-screen-game-patent-finally-expires https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/12/loading-screen-game-pa...) > According to the law, a person isn’t entitled to a patent if the claimed invention already existed when the application was filed or would have been obvious to someone skilled in the relevant technology area. This usually is completely overlook in patents. So, patents are ridiculous, they overlap and create a legal minefield for any small developer. Patent trolls exist because the patent system is so easily exploitable. I am not against the concept of patents, I see the value of allowing some corporation to regain invested money. But, it needs to be for real inventions that took time and effort to develop thru costly processes. Meanwhile things like "one-click buying, is the technique of allowing customers to make purchases with the payment information needed to complete the purchase having been entered by the user previously" are accepted. Patents are a useless joke, at least in the software industry. And its only goal is to increase the power of already monopolistic corporations.
- bee_rider 5y agoA bounty system for patent invalidation might be nice. An idea could be: * When you get a patent, you put up a bond. * If someone invalidates your patent, they get the bond. * Otherwise, you get it back when your patent expires An extra, funny, probably impractical idea is that when filing for the patent, you decide on the value of the bond. But, the value of the bond is the maximum payout you can be awarded for a given instance of infringement. So, you have to essentially 'price' the value of your patent yourself.
- Tostino 5y agoAh, an even more pay to win system? Sounds like it'll work perfectly and no one will ever abuse their capital to unethically tie up patents. /s
- bee_rider 5y agoIf they are throwing money at patenting actually novel ideas, then they are using the patent system as intended. If they are throwing money at the sort of ridiculous obvious patents that people here are complaining about, they are essentially funding an army of private investigators to go out and invalidate bad patents.
- michaelbrave 5y agoYes and no. There are countless innovations that have been lost over time (I.E. Ancient Roman's had stainless steel but it was lost), some were rediscovered some weren't, patents hope to prevent that by giving some incentive. This hasn't always worked though, for example Philo Farnsworth basically invented the modern TV but the large companies just waited for his patent to expire before moving on thus making it so he never really got paid anything but to contrast that the expiration on patents for 3D printers is what's causing so much innovation in that space today. The main problem is when stupid ones (like the same thing as before but now with software) are granted it drags everything down, and the very concept of patent trolls is a destructive force not contributing to humanity at all. Combine that with how most patents are forced through by submitting it until it sticks and it's a pretty broken system tbh.
- a-r-t 5y agoI can't think of a single patent in software that actually had a positive impact on the industry. Copyright provides enough protection for any actual investment in software. Other industries where R&D cost is high and the end result can be very compact (a chemical formula, a new material, etc.) can benefit from patents, but that R&D cost needs to be verifiable and substantial.
- Iv 5y agoFunny how they ask it now that China took the lead in patents. Why does US only recognize a bad idea when they end up on the receiving end?
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoI don't think China has anything to do with it. People have been complaining about patents (and especially abuse of patents) for years/decades.
- Iv 5y agoYes, ever since the beginning. Which is at least 2 decades. And until now, it was totally in vain.
- zubspace 5y agoJust watched this video [1] by someone who got sued because his "android app uses a license server". Those patent troll shell companies sue one victim after another and forward the incoming money to other companies. So there's no use in going after them directly. The victim can negotiate better terms if he signs a non-disclosure agreement. The patent trolls are protected by politicians, judges and lawyers. [1] https://youtu.be/sG9UMMq2dz4 https://youtu.be/sG9UMMq2dz4
- exabrial 5y agoYes. But it's an easy fix: * Anything that is copyrightable cannot be patentable. That should be obvious. "inventors" must be forced to choose one protection * Software should not be patentable in every circumstance: It's well established that math cannot be patented. It's well established that business processes cannot be patented.
- SeanLuke 5y ago* Anything that is copyrightable cannot be patentable. That should be obvious. "inventors" must be forced to choose one protection That's the case today. Algorithms can be patented. Computer code can be copyrighted. These are different things.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoWell... I'm in embedded systems. There, software can be part of the machine, performing concrete, physical actions. Would the same thing be patentable if you implemented it as an FPGA? How about as discrete logic? If so, then it should be patentable if you implement it as software. But this is very far from a software-only patent, or a "doing X, but with a computer" patent. I guess the difference might be that, if it's part of the functioning of an embedded system, then it's not math (or at least not just math) in the same sense that a mechanical machine is not just physics.
- exabrial 5y agoNo. If you invest a machine to dispense a weighted amount of ice cream using a microcontroller and software, that should not be patentable for the reasons listed above. This may be tough to hear, but there is nothing novel, inventive, or unique about using a general purpose device (a microcontroller) to accomplish a specific task. Now, inventing a new breed of general purpose embeddable device, that might be a bit different.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoTake anti-lock brakes, for instance. Was that patentable? Yes, it was, and rightly so. But it used some software. Did that make it not patentable? Or take your ice cream dispenser. Let's say that I invent an ice cream dispenser with a camera. It's going to estimate the user's BMI, and based on that, it's going to decide whether to dispense regular or fat-free ice cream. (Sorry, it's a horrible example, it's the only one I could come up with for an ice cream dispenser.) Well, you know there's going to have to be a CPU in there running some algorithm to try to derive the BMI from the image from the camera. Does that make it unpatentable? (Yeah, I know, it should be unpatentable because of the overall insanity of the idea. That's not the point.) As our physical devices become smarter, more and more of the new behaviors are implemented in software. Does that make them unpatentable? As I asked before, if I implemented the same logic in an FPGA, would that make it patentable? If so, why?
- beefield 5y agoTax patents. Progressively. Start from say $USD 1000 per year and double each year until the patent holder decides to not pay and gives the patent to the public domain. Feel free to add a couple of free years in the beginning or tweak some other parameters to suit needs of different industries.
- inglor_cz 5y agoI think a similar approach would work with copyright, too. Only with a grace period. Say, your original copyright lasts for 20 years since creation of your work. If you want to prolong it, you can, but you must register your work and pay a yearly fee that starts somewhere around USD 5, but grows exponentially to reach millions after 50 years and billions after 100 years.
- beefield 5y agoNot sure how such copyright tax would be interpreted in Berne Convention context. (Would happily support that as well, though)
- bluGill 5y agoJust renegotiate that. I'm convinced that copyrights > 25 years are not a limited time via the constitution, and thus the treaty isn't constitutional in the first place. Of course I'm not in a position to do anything about this.
- FemmeAndroid 5y agoThe Copyright Act of 1790, just a few years after the constitution was signed, enabled a 28 year copyright grant (14 years with a 14 year extension.) So unless you think the copyright laws haven't been legal since their inception, you probably want to bump your number up at least five years. Edit: Also, if you're interested in this argument, and IIRC the most recent Supreme Court opinion on it is Eldred v Ashcroft (2003).
- thekyle 5y agoI wonder if a system where keeping a patent active requires paying an exponentially increasing annual fee would help. So anyone could file a patent for say $1,000 in the first year, but then it would cost $2,000, $4,000, $8,000, etc. to keep it active in subsequent years. That way, it would be financially infeasible for even the largest companies to hoard patents for years, but an individual inventor could start small and pay the fees as their business grows.
- not2b 5y agoPart of the problem has been that, the way the system is currently set up, after an inventor invents something genuinely novel but with a narrow focus, their company's patent lawyers massage the claims language to make the patent much broader, sometimes effectively claiming any possible way to solve the problem instead of just claiming the specific invention. These ridiculously overbroad patents are the ones that are most valuable to trolls, and it is only the claims that matter.
- HPsquared 5y agoWhy aren't patents just "use it or lose it" like trademarks? That would seem to eliminate most of the abuse in a targeted way. Unless I'm missing something...
- bluGill 5y agoBecause sometimes you need a lot of money to setup manufacturing. The covid vaccines are easy to make in a lab at a rate of 10/week. To make them useful though you need the money to setup manufacture them at scale, and one easy way to get that is to sell a patent. Use it or lose it means anyone who might buy the patent is incentivized to wait until you lose it and then use it for free.
- stickyricky 5y agoIn my opinion, yes. It's not obvious to me that our intellectual property system encourages invention. After all, every great invention in history was "patented" (given state license to monopolize) and immediately copied just outside of its jurisdiction (and many times within the jurisdiction in complete disregard of the legality). No company on earth would accept a state license to monopolize if it meant they were subject to price controls. Especially given how useless these licenses are at preventing global mega-corps from using them. --- Intel and AMD famously rip each others intellectual property off but don't do anything about it because they're both guilty as sin. How does that protect innovation? How does these two companies ripping each other off inhibit innovation? Basically every smart phone is identical. These companies occasionally fight but not meaningfully. But if I were to create a new smartphone I would be sued into oblivion. How does that protect innovation? --- China has an incredibly agile and innovative economy. Are they the strictest IP protectors of all? --- Intellectual property exists for the big guys to keep the little guys down. Not the opposite. Happy to be proven wrong. Every argument above was made with 0 evidence just personal observation.
- HPsquared 5y agoThe name for this is cross-licensing. If you have some patents which could affect someone else's business, and they have the same to you, you can cross-license each others' patents. Anyone not party to the agreement is fair game. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cross-licensing https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cross-licensing
- abfan1127 5y agoConceptually, it should help protect innovation. In reality, it inhibits it. Small guy has a brilliant idea. He files a patent, and starts shipping. Some other guy copies the idea. Small guy has 3 options. 1) invest in better products and out innovate copycat. 2) invest in marketing to create brand appeal. 3) get lawyers involved. #3 is the most expensive for the return on investment. #1 or #2 are likely the better path, but patent protection helps neither of these paths. On the dark side of patents is patent trolls. They only seek to extract value for infringers, almost always via legal system intimidation (see #3). Again, the system intended to help innovation is killing it.
- FpUser 5y agoYes sir. Them patents certainly do.
- PicassoCTs 5y agoIf that were the case, china should be IP wise blooming. It does not. The more stiffing factor was and always has been, monopolies and oligopolies. Huge power concentrations murder the competition were they can find it. Which is why the original fractured nature of Europe was such a breeding reactor for innovations. Local leader does not like your project xyz? Just pack it in, go a few miles, to the next local leader in opposition who will welcome you with open arms. Situation wise, a fractured, heavily competitive economy, with some "safe havens" (academia) for involuntarily happening knowledge exchange is the optimum for innovation. PostScriptum: To zoom in further, on the lab level, to promote innovation, is quite distant from the pursuit of excellence everyone agreed on as the optimum today. The ability to learn,apply and reproduce past gathered knowledge does not make you a innovator, quite contrary. Mimicry while flattering, is not able to reproduce true geniusgenesis. One needs a gear-shifting approach, a combination of incremental researches (to follow a path through to the optimums it reveals and explore the terrain methodically) and one needs for lack of a better description, schizophrenia affected individuals, who even though their grades suck, are able to constantly recombine the currently existing ideas into new "conspiracies" and filter out the useful ones from the avalanche. Needless to say, that guiding such a lab with the constant conflicts and drama, is a task more fitting to a theater-director, then the classic academic bureaucrat. P.S.S: I'm not responsible for whatever hiring catastrophe this advice may produce. You may jam strange devices made from people into the leviathan at your own risk.
- hosteur 5y agoYes. Duh.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jokoon 5y agoNot for medicine though. Once a molecule is researched and found to work, it should be patented. Although not if it receives public funding.
- SaltyBackendGuy 5y agoI wonder if we removed the ability for companies to patent, only individuals (or groups of individuals) would help. Limit the patent protection for lifetime of said individuals. I feel like that would remove the patent troll economy.
- peter_retief 5y agoWe definitely need patents to protect intellectual property. There is a lot of hard work and resources needed to actualize products that can be easily copied without any effort. I have attempted a few patents in my time but it was too expensive and the process itself was daunting. Now I use secrecy to hide critical methods and open source everything else.
- lettergram 5y agoHaving spent a significant amount of time developing and patenting new technology — I think patents are both necessary, BUT need an overhaul. Particularly, I think design patents are likely positive, but I think utility patents need a different mechanism. For instance, I think the patent should work for X% of revenue of a given item is provided to the patent holder, provided they don’t reach an agreement. This would ensure anyone can use patents and the revenue would be defined. I also think a patent should be limited to 3 years without it being put to use. “Use” should have a lower bar, but effectively made or reduced revenue in some manner. In reality, you can build what you and ignore patents. Patents don’t matter until you are in business and make money. At which point, if someone uses you; you’re already successful and they’ll want a slice of that success. This is the advice I’ve always been given (from investors and attorneys, off record).
- kabdib 5y agoPatents were supposed to provide enough information so that someone else could build a widget, in exchange for a limited time monopoly on that widget. "You teach the world, we'll let you eat for a while on that." What we got: A convoluted, arcane and rent-protected process which is gamed by the big players, and in fact diminishes advances by sowing fear, expense and uncertainty. I'm a software engineer, but a while back I got a chance to read hundreds of patents (with expert help from some compan lawyers) in an attempt to carve out an "IP space" in an already crowded and contested space. Pretty eye-opening. In a couple of cases the parties we were looking at were trying to patent stuff you could have lifted from a textbook. The screening process for "is this a patentable idea?" seemed utterly broken. To this day I can't keep a straight face when a lawyer says, "... and here, the '843 patent teaches that....". /Teaches/, yeah right.
- maverick-iceman 5y agoPatents foster innovation. Without patents people who are technically skilled but socially inadequate would not ever try to build stuff. Same goes for those who can promote themselves but just love the technical challenge much more and want to focus on that. These are among the most productive demographics and without patents they'd be sitting idle because they would be too scared of working thousands of hours in vain, just setting the stage for the socially competent people to rip them off and cut them out of the enjoyment of the monetary and social rewards for the thing they have built. At least with patents there is some sort of protection or I should say an illusion. Say you have an idea and then one of the big guys with deep pockets and a huge marketing and PR department steals it from you or executes in a way which becomes world class, with a patent you have grounds to sue and you can also go to lawyers and convince them to work pro-bono because they'll get so much media exposure. You can also go to a bank and ask for loans to promote your story and you can get a favorable interest rate due to the fact that you have the optionality to settle for cash. A patent gives you options. It's also a concept which unlike so many corporate jargon terms is easily understood by the general population, and that is an advantage when you are a small startup or individual inventor going up against a behemoth...it enables you to convey social hatred against the giant company A much more complicated instrument such as NDA/NCA gave the Winklevoss bros the ability to sue Zuck and to put themselves on the map with the movie "The Social Network", a patent as I said is much more clear and easy to understand, both for the courts and the court of public opinion
- 8note 5y agoPatents also mean that the big co that copied your idea can sue you out of business for violating one of their myriad of patents, and that your patent is actually a derivative of one of theirs.
- maverick-iceman 5y agoYou want to drag the big company in front of the court of public opinion. If your patent is perfectly nailed, then your version of the story will win. In short you gotta have something to show to the journalists and lawyers who are your allies because they want to be the guys bringing down the behemoth and win the Pulitzer/lawyer of the year award. If you don't have anything they won't write your story and they won't defend you. Once the story is out there the entire public opinion will be on your side and you are looking at the very least at a hefty settlement which the behemoth would pay you in order to make the story go away. A patent is a checkpoint for an individual inventor or a small startup
- moron4hire 5y agoI think the bigger question is, will this be more than an exercise in confirmation bias, and even if it makes a valid determination, will it actually lead to policy change?
- jbverschoor 5y agoNo they don’t. But the process and cost is not working for smaller inventors.
- throwawaycities 5y agoCan you find examples of patents killing innovation? Sure. But the idea of a patent is to give the inventor time to bring the invention to market, and it would be impossible for any inventor to have the chance without the protections offered by patents. Show me an inventor that hasn’t obtained a patent that successfully out competed an established competitor that freely copied the inventor’s invention. The USPTO doesn’t care about innovation, and it is not their job to care about that…so why the question and why now? Lobbying and special interests of the big companies. If anything get rid of patent protections for big businesses, it’s not like a big tech or big pharma patent is what’s keeping the small guy from competing with them, but if the small guy can not protect their IP from being copied by big businesses then they will never be able to compete.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoNot in principle; but the current practice of accepting highly dubious patents with little or no scrutiny is only serving the least innovative companies. The fix would be to make it more expensive to defend a patent and cheaper to challenge one instead of the current practice of flooding the system with dubious patents knowing full well that challenging them is prohibitively expensive and the scrutiny from patent offices is minimal. When companies exists whose sole purpose is accumulating and exploiting such patents for profit with absolutely 0$ budget for R&D, something is deeply wrong. The fact that some judges seem to be unwilling to actually lift a finger to do anything about such companies is not helping either. E.g. Texas seems to be a preferred venue for patent extortion where patent trolls and judges pretty much openly work together. Some call this justice, I call it institutionalized corruption. Plain and simple. Maybe no money changes hands but it seems corporations are actively putting their fingers on the scales when it comes to electing judges into very lucrative jobs and everybody understands there's a quid pro quo. Just putting a stop to that would be helpful. Something is deeply wrong when shady companies can just buy "justice" like that. This would incentivize companies to file better patents and only file those patents that they are actually willing to defend as opposed to filing numerous patents opportunistically in the hope that smaller competitors will settle out of court and pay a license fee rather than risking bankruptcy through the courts. This also would free up patent offices to actually do their job properly as opposed to dealing with a never ending flood of largely BS patents. Rejection rates ought to be much higher than they currently are.
- nybble41 5y agoSet a cap on the number of patents issued each year. Like 500, max, across all industries. Or set a limit of 10,000 active patents, with new ones only accepted as old ones expire. If you want a chance at a patent you file with the PTO (under NDA, in case the patent isn't granted) for a nominal processing fee and at the end of the year the best 500 are selected from the perspective of "most useful disclosure of information", "least likely to be reverse-engineered or independently reinvented", and "lowest cost to the public in being restricted from freely implementing the patented invention for the next 20 years". Variations: Let the filer pick the duration of the patent, with a shorter duration improving the odds of being selected (lower cost to the public). Or replace the monopoly with a one-time cash payout to make the invention freely available for the public to implement immediately.
- fouric 5y agoI wonder if the USPO is asking about whether the idea of patents kills innovation, or the implementation does (e.g. how easily patents are granted, which things are eligible for patents (I know many people who think that patents are a good idea in general but generics and software shouldn't be patentable)). Also, if patents were removed entirely, wouldn't that just benefit the largest companies? That is, whenever someone has a new idea, their idea would just be taken and most efficiently built by the largest companies, because those would be the ones with the most engineering, manufacturing, and marketing resources. What's to prevent that from happening?
- marcodiego 5y agoPatents were created to encourage inventors to explain how their inventions worked. Instead of hiding their secrets, inventors simply published how their inventions worked and gained a monopoly to sell their use for a few years. A very noble intent. Now, we're in the 21st century. We are no longer in the years of inventors like Graham Bell, Thomas Edison, Guglielmo Marconi, Nikola Tesla... Inventions today are discovered by large groups of researches who get their money from many sources private and public. These researchers, the real inventors, often get just a small part of the profit gained from their inventions. The largest parts ends up with companies which get giant profits and benefits from the lack of competition. While patents were invented to guarantee that small individual inventors could be protected from giant companies attacks and encourage information sharing, patents these days do exactly the opposite of that. Apple being able to patent the "genie dock effect" is a clear example that the "patent system" is broken.
- pksebben 5y agoI was under the impression that Edison was actually more how you describe a 21st century shop, and was more of a CEO type, but I admit that this isn't based on deep knowledge. I often wonder how many of our rosy perceptions of the past are due to a lack of granular information. we kind of know that those exploitative structures exist now because we have access to perspectives at all levels; an inventor or other employee can tweet about this stuff, but if I had created something for Edison and he stole it, he has access to newspaper publishers and I don't.
- punnerud 5y agoI see that companies get lower taxes revenue linked to patents. Isn’t they then incentivized to fight for the patents and “protect” every part of the company for tax reasons? So the real fight is against tax attorneys, because if the patent is not valid the governmental tax attorney can argue that you should pay more tax? So it’s basically noting to do with protection against competition
- salawat 5y agoI'm going to go out on a limb and say that the actual purpose originally intended for patents was to get people to describe and record innovative discoveries, and eventually add them to the public domain for others to build off of. I think transferability, renewability, and gaming of the definition of "novel" and "non-obvious", is actually what kills innovation. The transferability is even more of a sticking point in my mind, because of it's endemic exploitation in the "automatic assignment of patent to employer" sense for disenfranchising creators of unrelated or only tangentially related work off the company clock. Then again, I can't offer a more elegant system to replace it, so I kind of have to take a Chesterton's fence-pill on that one. And besides which, having worked with engineering management, it does kind of degenerate down to "inform legal, and have them draft a waiver for an exec to sign stating the company waives interest", which is a functional, but less than ideal compromise.
- motohagiography 5y agoWondering if it be viable to train a classifier on a set of patents that are known to be vague, abused, and pernicious and see what else it digs up. This works for malware, and simple things like being owned by known patent trolls, who have selected them for their crappiness are easy indicators of what a bad one looks like, a history of litigation, clusters of ones with similarities, etc. Surely this is somebody's ML driven patent troll startup right now?
- _Nat_ 5y agoYeah, the current patent-system is completely ridiculous. To pick out one especially bad problem: it's too inconsistent, relying on legal-battles to resolve inconsistencies. And then people are just afraid to do stuff, because they don't want to have to fight those battles.
- dqpb 5y agoDoes China or Russia sponsor any US patent troll companies? And if the answer is no, why not? It seems like a dead simple way to stifle American innovation. Use our own toxic legal system against us.
- MrStonedOne 5y agoPuget Systems popularized the concept of the submerged water computer/aquarium computer. They released a video showing a proof of concept, but it had an obvious design flaw. Shortly after they released that video, a patent firm patented the same thing, but with the design flaw fixed. Some time later puget sound announced version 1 of their fish tank computer, obvious design flaw fixed, only to get forced into discontinuing it because of said patent. So i'd say yes.
- Animats 5y agoThe weakening of patents has led to a rise in extreme trade secrets. Now, we have no idea how anything recent works. Nobody publishes much on self-driving. Nobody outside Tesla really knows how Tesla cars work. Progress relies on reverse engineering and teardowns.
- nybble41 5y ago> Progress relies on reverse engineering and teardowns. Progress has always relied on reverse engineering and teardowns. (Or independent reinvention.) You don't learn how anything really works be reading the patents, which tend to be deliberately obfuscated if not outright misleading. Anyone working in the industry will be instructed not to read patents anyway for fear of a willful infringement claim and trebled damages. Only in very rare cases can anything of notable value be maintained as a closely-held trade secret for longer than the duration of a patent.
- Veedrac 5y agoThe virtue of the patent is that it rewards invention, and its productization, in cases where either the invention itself or its productization would not have otherwise been profitable, either because of the difficulty of inventing it, or because it isn't affordable to be the first to develop it. This suggests a very natural rule of thumb for patent admissibility: would the patented idea reasonably have been independently invented or productized prior to the date that the patent expires? Invention and productization are very different roles here, so perhaps an invention patent could last up to, say, 15 years, whereas a productization patent would only last half that. So a “one click shopping” invention patent would have to argue that within 15 years nobody else will have the idea, and a “one click shopping” productization patent would have to argue that within 8 years of the idea being public but not acted on, nobody would have been willing to front the cost to productize it. This allows precisely those patents which one would expect provide value, and not the rest.
- nybble41 5y ago> This allows precisely those patents which one would expect provide value, and not the rest. That's only true if we assume you have a handy oracle available to determine what actually would happen if the invention were neither published nor productized by the original applicant or their licensee. Otherwise the patent office is merely speculating without any evidence on which to base their decision. Once the invention is out in the wild there is no objective way to determine whether it "would have been" independently invented or productized by someone else, so you can't even get feedback (15+ years delayed) on how accurate your speculation has been.
- Veedrac 5y agoFor sure the actual award would be a matter of judgement, as would any challenge in court. But right now patents are judged on whether they were “obvious to the person skilled in the art, at the time the application was filed”, which is both no less a matter of judgement, and a bar much easier and fuzzier to cross. This is what fundamentally results in patent races, where any ideas that can claim to take any nominal amount of intellectual effort to think of must be rushed to the patent office before the competitor discovers it themselves. Because it doesn't matter for elligibility if three people all thought on a problem simultaneously and all stumbled on the same answer, as long as that answer took at least a little time to discover in each case.
- bitwize 5y agoThe people: yes Corporations with billion-dollar gold-plated megaphones: NO, THE PATENT SYSTEM PROTECTS INNOVATION, NOTHING TO SEE HERE, MATTER OF FACT WHY DON'T YOU MAKE IT STRONGER SO WE CAN BE MORE INNOVATIVE
- rubyist5eva 5y agoIsn’t that kinda the point of a patent?
- luckydata 5y agoThere should be some kind of "patent reset". Let's say next year, all patents granted until now are null and void, and new more stringent criteria are applied to new ones. I would be real curious to see the results of an experiment like this - which to be clear, will never happen.
- keonix 5y agoPatents also preserve knowledge in publicly accessible and well documented form. Without patents the only option to recoup investment in R&D would be to make innovations a trade secrets. This will lead to frequent reinvention of the wheel and lost knowledge. The system is broken, but abolishing it is even worse
- armoredkitten 5y agoI have to believe that there's been research on this in the economics literature...right?? Like, maybe research on "patent trolls" specifically hasn't been studied (or perhaps it has), but there has to be research on the economic impacts of patents, and the dynamics both within and between countries. I'd be astonished if economists haven't looked at this.
- tomrod 5y agoMake a patent and copyright expire after 3 to 5 years. This gives the holder enough time to go to market if they choose.
- tombert 5y agoWhen I worked at Apple, we used this (in my opinion terrible) framework called "WebObjects", which used to be publicly available but not open source. After digging around, I found out that the reason they didn't open source it was because their own patent lawyers wouldn't let them, something about having dot-properties for configuration variables... Something that nearly anyone who frequents hacker news could reinvent themselves in an afternoon.
- alok-g 5y agoFrom the OP: >> The study particularly wants to find examples of where a patent has been denied in the US but accepted in other jurisdictions, which will be a key area for European electronics companies. The question at hand does not seem to be what the title of the OP indicates, but rather about patent applications denied in the US but approved elsewhere. Looking briefly at [1] too is hinting that the interest may rather be to relax the patent eligibility criteria so that more of patent applications in the US are approved. Note: IANAL. --- [1] https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2021/07/09/2021-14628/patent-eligibility-jurisprudence-study https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2021/07/09/2021-14... Excerpts: "Last year, after a split panel decision concluding that a method for manufacturing drive shafts was patent ineligible, ... The questions presented in the petition are: (1) What is the appropriate standard for determining whether a claim is directed to a patent-ineligible concept under step one of the Alice two-step framework?; and (2) Is patent eligibility a question of law for the court or a question of fact for the jury? ... The Senators indicated a particular interest in learning how the current jurisprudence has adversely impacted investment and innovation in critical technologies like quantum computing, artificial intelligence,[6] precision medicine, diagnostic methods, and pharmaceutical treatments."
- stefantalpalaru 5y ago> the impact of patents on areas such as quantum computing, artificial intelligence, precision medicine, diagnostic methods, software and networking Look no further than data compression: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arithmetic_coding#History_and_patents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arithmetic_coding#History_and_...
- taylodl 5y agoWe need to do what we did with pharmaceuticals - provide a period where the patent has to be licensed so that the owner can be remunerated for their research. Should that be 7 years, 10 years, 15 years or more - I don't know and that's a good discussion to have. Meanwhile I think we can all agree that patents should have an expiration. That seems to strike the balance of incentivizing innovation while protecting research investments.
- xutopia 5y agoMatt Ridley seems to think so in his book on innovation.
- magila 5y agoI think firearms related patents are an instructive example. It has long been standard practice to patent new firearm designs. For the most part it works well, the patents prevent companies from immediately churning out cheap clones of successful designs. However, every once-in-a-while a patent becomes problematic, like the infamous Rollin White revolver patent. White patented a revolver design using then new metallic cartridges. The design itself was not commercially successful, but the patent was construed to cover any revolver design where the chambers were bored completely through the cylinder. It turns out this is the only reasonable way to make a revolver using metallic cartridges so it lead to many years of legal battles and bizarre designs attempting to avoid the patent. I'm not sure how to reliably identify Rollin White type patents, but there certainly seems to be a distinction to be made between beneficial and detrimental patents.
- im3w1l 5y agoI agree that it's nuanced. I think the question should be rephrased to "When do patents kill innovation". And the answer is that it happens when a new field opens up and the long hanging fruit is locked away for longer than the innovation merits. The reward should be, if not in perfect proportion, at least in rough proportion to the r&d work done.
- Ericson2314 5y agoBounties would be much better than parents, across the board. In a world with too much consumption and work for no good reason, where new products fight for limitted demand, parents in theory even are solving the wrong problem. Bounties mean the goals are defined up front, and the reward for putting a round peg in a round whole is you don't even need a business plan, equity-based investment, or any of that other crap. Take some funding to hit the bounty, everyone cashes out, move on to the next thing. All the benefits of "aquisition culture" without the problem of concentrated ownership. (The bounty giver should ideally be the state and not own the thing.)
- 8note 5y agoPatents last too long. The time it takes to scale up an operation has gone way down, and the patent length should correspondingly shrink
- sbpayne 5y agoFor AI/ML related patents, I’m not sure innovation is stifled insofar as people mostly don’t pay attention to them. Most of the techniques that _every_ company is using are patented, but no one seems to notice. Admittedly I’m sure there are cases where it did stifle innovation in this space, but I think on average perhaps not. It’s interesting to see the comments on eink patents — I was never aware of how much it stifled innovation in that space!
- robinsoh 5y ago> It’s interesting to see the comments on eink patents — I was never aware of how much it stifled innovation in that space! I'm really curious which comment that people are referring to because I happen to work in the display industry. I'd never heard anything like that amongst my peers or during conferences. The main place I've seen this refrain is on HN. Please have a look at my comment history as I keep asking about which patent people are talking about. I'm still trying to figure out if the issue is real.
- temptemptemp111 5y agoYou guys can't be discussing this! The idea that parents kill innovation is patented! And we can prove you're trying to make profit via our method of using this idea! ;)
- sandworm101 5y agoMandatory licensing. Rather than grant a monopoly, a patent could give you the right to a certain percentage of all sales. That would allow competitors to serve markets that the patent holder refuses to address (ie cheap 3d printers.)
- kazinator 5y agoPatents encourage innovation because without them, the moment an inventor's idea gets out, it will be copied and monetized by some corporation with the resources to bring it to market, without compensating the inventor in any way. Now idiotically evaluated and granted patents (in particular software patents, but not necessarily just software patents) stifle innovation. Crowd-sourcing this kind of question just seems like ploy for the USPTO to make even less of an effort. Suppose that the answer from the crowd is "yes": patents in those areas kill innovation. What can the USPTO do with the information, other than just not hand out patents in that area? Summarily tossing a patent application takes even less effort than slightly thinking about its merit.
- visualradio 5y ago> What can the USPTO do with the information, other than just not hand out patents in that area? They could require the IP holder to declare the price at which they were willing to permanently release the discovery into the public domain in exchange for a one-time payment, and levy an increasing maintenance fee on a % of that price due at the end of each financial quarter. This may eliminate unnecessary court costs and legal fees and supply chain interruptions resulting from legal disputes, while still ensuring that the original inventors are compensated and that there is an incentive for disclosure. Suppose a defendant is notified of patent infringement and pending legal action. Instead of hiring a lawyer or halting production they could crowd-source the money to pay the inventor's fee through the patent office. The patent office then forwards the payment to the original inventor, the patent is destroyed, and there is no basis for further legal action. Large companies may find that it is always cheaper to pay the patent office to permanently destroy each other's patents than it is to go to court, which would also level the playing field for smaller firms and startups as the discoveries would be placed in the public domain.
- kazinator 5y agoWhy not just do that for all patents from now on? It seems like a good idea.
- mikeabraham 5y agoYes.
- neverminder 5y agoThey should start by making patent trolls illegal. Also shorten the patent expiry to 5 years instead of 20. If the patent holder is actively using it, it should be enough time for them to recoup their R&D costs and make profit. Of course that's never gonna happen because too many people stand to lose - too many vested interests, bought out politicians, armies of lawyers, etc.
- FemmeAndroid 5y agoI'm assuming in this 20 -> 5 transition that would be 5 years after the patent is granted rather than the current 20 years after filing? Part of the issue is that a patent can take 5+ years form filing to grant, and frequently take 3+ years.
- pdimitar 5y agoOf course patents kill innovation and the reasons are very simple and known to many. It doesn't matter what the law says. It doesn't matter if the patent is generic or very specific. It doesn't matter if it covers a currently trendy area. None of these things matter one bit. Only one thing truly matters: how much budget for a lawyer does the suing side have. That's it. Only that. A talented and highly-paid (and thus motivated) copyright / patent lawyer is literally the most dangerous adversary you will ever encounter in your civilized life (we're not including stuff like Mexican cartel hating you, of course). It doesn't even matter what legislation grounds for suing you does the litigating side have. If they have a square inch, they'll use it and expand it to be as big as the USA. A lot of small businesses are well-aware of the power imbalance and I've heard founders give up on ideas, citing various copyright / patent trials from the last 10+ years. Truth is, if a big player comes after you and if the government doesn't help you have some semblance of a fighting chance (by covering your legal expenses and/or hiring a competent defender for you) then the 99.9% predictable result is: you'll run out of money and will be forced to settle if you are lucky -- and in most other cases you'll have to pay damages or royalties for years, which might very easily make a homeless person out of you. -- I am glad that the US patent office is making an inquiry but at the same time slightly disappointed because what I just said above is common knowledge in many circles.
- Sleepytime 5y agoMost IP should be scrapped completely in the age of free and cheap information. I really don't have any sympathy to big corps making money from IP, and small entities are finding more and more ways to give their IP away and find revenue elsewhere (hardware, swag, live events, Patreon, etc). Scrapping IP would be a big step in making more, smaller, and more sustainable businesses instead of our current 'grow or get bought out' mindset. Ideas are a dime a dozen, execution is all that matters. I would wager that most reading this website have had strangers and family alike approach them for help with with their huge ideas, which really means "you are the programmer you do it all". Most of which are utterly unoriginal, yet they want you to sign an NDA or promise to keep it secret. Patents and to some extent copyright/trademarks tilt the scale heavily away from innovative ideas toward 'derivative but licenseable'. I am running on 4 hours of sleep, hopefully my word salad makes sense.
- porknubbins 5y agoIdeas being cheap and execution being everything applies mostly to businesses that laypeople people can think up and start. Because they are not usually in a position to do new research, but great execution is always scarce. In pharma (which I’ve worked in) and I guess other industries like semiconductors, materials etc good ideas are everything and competitors could copy the invention that took years to decades for just single or double digit millions so patents arguably drive a lot of research there.
- streetcat1 5y agoThe key to the patent system are the patent lawyers, not the innovation per se. As long as the patent lawyers revolve with the USPTO, the system will not change. Please do not be naïve.
- zepearl 5y agoGeneral question by throwing ZFS into this discussion: I never exactly understood what's the problem related to ZFS' adoption in Linux (problem related mainly to the ARC algorithm?). I read e.g. here ( https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/what-cant-be-patented.html https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/what-cant-be-... ): > You cannot patent a formula. However, you can patent an application of that formula. So... with "application" does that mean that Oracle/Sun patented some piece of ZFS (e.g. the ARC mentioned above) in the context of "IT data caching technology" and that therefore anybody that wants to use it in IT (even by writing the logic from scratch) in any area (programs, databases, filesystems, etc...) cannot without paying fees, but if I use/implement that ARC logic to e.g. handle my inventory of "shoes to rent" (dummy, but let's say that I have such a shop which has multiple rooms used to store shoes and I keep in the main one the shoes that have been most frequently & recently rented, in the other rooms other stuff split by the same ARC-logic) then I'm OK because the "application" is different than what is mentioned in the patent? Thx :)
- cesarb 5y ago> I never exactly understood what's the problem related to ZFS' adoption in Linux (problem related mainly to the ARC algorithm?). The problem with ZFS adoption in Linux is copyright, not patents. The license used by the ZFS code and the license used by the Linux kernel are incompatible, so one cannot distribute the combination of both without violating one of the licenses. This means that the ZFS code cannot be incorporated in the Linux kernel, so it's doomed to forever stay out-of-tree. This could in theory be worked around by a clean-room reimplementation of the ZFS code, keeping the same filesystem format, but I suppose most people who could do that work either are already working with the ZFS code, or find it more interesting to create their own filesystem. It would also be a lot of work, and take a long time until the reimplementation would be considered stable.
- zepearl 5y agoAha - got it, thank you :)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ypcx 5y agoImagine being on your death bed with your only contribution to this world having been vaguely worded abstract patents which didn't translate to any real products. Especially knowing that had you not helped to stifle medical/tech innovation, maybe you would still have a few extra centuries to live. Yep, that must feel like being a cockroach and a failure in one. Also, the article has a wrong title. A patent office would never undermine their raison d'être. In this case they're only asking to be compared to other countries so that they don't issue fewer patents than them. The patent system is so bad that, at this point, the only way to fix it is to completely abolish it. Do you still believe that the patents are here to protect you, a garage inventor, against the mega-corps with unlimited free-money bank funding? The real philosophical question here is where do your thoughts come from - did you really create them, are you really so special that given enough time nobody else would come up with that idea? Are you aware of the concept of multiple discovery? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_discovery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_multiple_discoveries
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jjlustig 5y agoHN loves to focus on only one of the normative goals of patents - to incentivize innovation. But there is another almost equally important goal of the patent system - to incentivize disclosure. While I agree that the use of vague language in patent publications perverts the public disclosure goal, other forms of public disclosure may arise from it. For example, companies can openly talk about inventions, whether it be with the public, potential business partners, or suppliers, without fear out misappropriation. I am not a fan of a bright line rule that prohibits software patents. Software is so explicitly tied with most inventions these days that it would be hard to tease out what qualifies for patent eligibility. Is a novel design of a robot arm that contains some software elements patentable? Instead of a bright line rule, I’d prefer to see a strengthening of 112 - written description / enablement requirements and 103 - obviousness requirements. Imagine if 112 required software patent holders to provide a hard copy of the implementation code (or at least a more detailed description of the invention). And as to 103, the policing function of obviousness needs to be ramped up. The USPTO should invest in better prior art searching techniques and hire Examiners that care about enforcement. Currently, the incentives of USPTO Examiner's misalign with the goals of the patent system, as Examiners are evaluated via a point mechanism that rewards churning out patents rather than tightly policing them. Also, when people on HN argue about the "patent troll" problem, the real issue seems not to be with patents themselves, but with how the U.S. litigation system can be weaponized to extract fees from using patents. Thus, I think the key issue is trying to figure out low cost and effective ways to litigate patent issues. IPRs have helped, but perhaps we can develop other ways for companies to cheaply dispose of garbage patent suits that have no merit.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- csours 5y agoOnce phonorecords of a musical work have been publicly distributed in the United States with the copyright owner’s consent, anyone else may, under certain circumstances and subject to limited conditions, obtain a “compulsory license” to make and distribute phonorecords of the work without express permission from the copyright owner. U.S. Copyright Office, Circular 73 - Compulsory License for Making and Distributing Phonorecords --- Maybe something like this, but for patents?
- wolverine876 5y agoRelated: There's also a Copyright Modernization Committee at the Library of Congress, and Brewster Kahle is joining it! They also have virtual public meetings, including one on July 22. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27732887 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27732887
- phendrenad2 5y agoPatents mean that you basically need venture money to being anything to market. If you're a whiz-kid programmer who makes a new OS by the time you're 16, you're just going to get buried by patent lawsuits unless you can get YCombinator money to fight it.
- mips_avatar 5y agoBragging rights plays a bigger role in patent filings than most people recognize. Yes there's some business value to Microsoft/Google/etc. having patents, but if you look at why a given team patents something it usually comes down to bragging rights.
- TomMckenny 5y agoRent seeking kills innovation. Patents as currently legislated, issued and resold are overwhelmingly just tools for rent seeking. There probably is a theoretical way to do it that encourages innovation but it’s hard to see a society ruled by self serving individuals not wrecking it pretty fast.
- korethr 5y agoSome ideas, based on some of the ideas kicked around in this thread: What about something like compulsory licensing? Copyright has something like this[1]. One can acquire a license to distribute a copyrighted song in some circumstances if you pay the mandatory fee. So how would this work with patents? First, let's cover the non-practicing entity, or NPE. Patent trolls are the most well known and hated NPEs but they're not only ones. You can have a small time inventor who's successfully invented a thing, designed and built a prototype, but hit a wall when it comes to the capital-intensive requirements of moving on to actual production. As much as I might want to stick it to patent trolls, I don't want to catch original inventors in the blast radius. So it can't be something that just punishes all NPEs, but just the parasitic subsets. So Bob discovers novel and efficient way to frobnicate foobars, and gets a patent on it. But he never takes it to production. Let's say materials science isn't quite at the point necessary that the materials needed for the frobnicating foobar can be readily had cost-effectively at scale. So he sits on it. Some years later, after some improvements in materials science, it's now feasible to build frobnicating foobars at scale. And Bazcorp, a company that's in the foobar business learns of Bob's patent, gets a compulsory license to manufacture it, and starts building and selling frobnicating foobars. Bob gets money for the frobnicating foobars now on the market, Bazcorp gets to sell frobnicating foobars, and people get to buy frobnicating foobars. Sounds win-win to me. Now, how keep patent trolls from perverting this? Make it so the fee schedule for a compulsory license is lower if the entity holding the patent gets more than, say...10% of their annual revenue from license fees. Make it so the liscencing fee schedule goes lower the older the patent is. You could combine this with annual fees to renew the patent, escalating each renewal period that the invention in the patent is not being produced, making it more and more expensive to hold a patent on a thing and not be building the invention covered. Then add a multiplier upon the renewal schedule if the patent holder gets more than 10% of their revenue on patent licensing. So Troll, Goblin & Associates, LLP, seeing the hot market for frobnicating foobars, does some research and discovers building them is covered by a patent they hold on the quux process. Said patent is 10 years old now, and has cost some coin to hold on to, so it will require quite a lot of money to turn a profit on it. So, TG&A goes to Bazcorp and demands one million dollars per unit. Bazcorp calls TG&A's bluff and files for the compulsory license of $0.10 per unit. Now, with the volume of frobnicating foobars that Bazcorp is moving, TG&A still gets a not-insignificant sum of money, but not enough to break even on the purchase of the patent and fees to renew it. Too bad, so sad, such is the risk of TG&A's non-creating, parasitic business model. Another idea: What about something like jury duty as assistant patent examiners? The patent office could reach out and compel persons skilled in the relevant sciences to assist with patent review and be remunerated for said assistance. Then, you might actually get some qualified eyes upon patent applications that could spot prior art or obvious things and reject said bogus applications. 1. https://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ73.pdf https://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ73.pdf
- joe_91 5y agoWhen I worked at Dell they were giving out cash bonuses for people to submit patent ideas with different levels of rewards depending on how far your patent idea got in the process. The crazy thing is, some people (mostly the Indian cohort) were flat out coming up with idea's and submitting them to the internal patent committee every week/month since the amount offered for them would be the equlivent of 6 months/1 years salary.
- nartz 5y agoPatents should only be enforceable for: - companies that have a history of utilizing/operating with the patents subject (e.g. no patent troll legal firms would be able to meet this requirements) - only be enforceable against competitor companies that are larger than a certain size, e.g. more than 10 million ARR, so smaller companies can still be formed and get off the ground - be different based off of the domain - e.g. it should be very hard to get a patent for software or related items
- glennvtx 5y agoPatents kill innovation, certainly, and at an ever increasing rate. The government acts as the enforcers for monopolies, as it always has been. It is based on an appeal to violence, like everything government does. It is, and has always been the principal enabler of every genocide, war, and mass abuse of human rights in history: educating people to recognize the claims of government authority as logically invalid (appeals to the populace, appeals to violence, etc. etc ) is needed.
- skyzyx 5y agoWhen I worked at Amazon, I learned that search field auto-complete on the web was patented by Amazon. When I wanted to provide a better user experience in some Amazon-owned open source software, I couldn’t because they didn’t want the Apache 2.0 license to grant patent rights to users. (If the age limit is still 20 years, I _think_ the patent expired in 2019 or 2020). Conversely, there was that time that Creative patented Apple’s iPod interface (or scroll wheel or something), then they promptly sued Apple over it. I would assert that deeper discovery be done on prior art before granting a patent. Lastly, the patent trolls who don’t create anything, but own the patent for it (e.g., Eolas suing Microsoft over then-standard NPAPI browser plug-ins). I would assert that granting any patent requires an actual implementation. I think patents have a place, but (a) see necessary changes above, and (b) I think that software (specifically) should have a shorter patent lifespan because it moves so damn fast.
- silexia 5y agoPatents do kill innovation. Why do you think we've seen no new aircraft carrier manufacturers come out in years? Because Boeing owns all the patents. Why do we see such fast innovation in so many competitors in any new space like search engines, then it seems like one company solidifies the whole market? That company has patents that prevent other people from reasonably competing. The entire patent system needs to be simply scrapped. Ideas are worthless, execution is what matters.
- throwawaysea 5y agoThe main problem with patents isn't their use as "first strike" attacks but rather their use for "defensive attacks". A big corporation can amass a huge collection of patents covering random trivial capabilities while a startup can't. This also lets the big corporation copy the innovations of a startup with impunity, because the startup doesn't have the resources for a drawn out legal battle, and they would fear the counter suits based on that patent portfolio. Someone else in this thread mentioned Amazon patenting a search field auto complete - that's the kind of ubiquitous functionality that could be weaponized in such a scenario.
- webinvest 5y agoFirst, people that patent something should have to be actively working on the patent; not just sitting on it like a patent troll. Patent trolls stifle innovation. Second, it should be easy for an inventor or developer to go create something new without having to look through a bunch of patents and see if someone already thought of something related to his idea. The more roadblocks in the way of development, the less development occurs.
- NotSwift 5y agoMost innovations happen in small companies. When they happen to develop a successful product and patent it, frequently a larger company just steals the idea and develops their own product. As a small company there really is not much you can do about it. Legislation is hugely expensive. Because most large companies have a huge patent portfolio they will probably be able to show that you are infringing on their patents so you are not very likely to win the case. If you are very lucky they will take over your company or offer you some money. The only real alternative is to stop producing and become a patent troll that sues other companies that use your invention (but that still requires a lot of money). In theory, patents could be useful, but in the current situation there are far too many patents for completely trivial things.
- thewileyone 5y agoA patent without a working prototype is meaningless and just weapons for patent trolls.