5 ms·
Could a four-day working week become the norm?
- perfunctory 5y agoAccording to the Betteridge's law [0] the answer is no, but I really hope it will. I've been working 4 days a week or less for years now. It's been the single best improvement to my quality of life. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
- theonething 5y agoIf you don't mind sharing, could you give more details on how you found 4 day a week jobs?
- Tade0 5y agoI can answer this, since I have a friend who's been doing this for years: you boil the frog. He started by taking the second half of each Friday off, because it was easy to sell his superiors on it. During the next performance review he asked to have the whole Friday off, and was granted permission to do so. A while after that he moved his day off to Monday.
- perfunctory 5y agoYou look for regular jobs and then negotiate.
- dbbk 5y agoYou ask for it, it's not complicated
- stavros 5y agoI've been working four day weeks for years too, and this is how: I asked them whether they'd be okay with me working 20% less for 20% less money and they said sure.
- raunometsa 5y agoI'm keeping a list of remote jobs with 4-day weeks here, but I have to say there's not too many of them yet :) https://remotehunt.com/remote-jobs-with-4-day-work-weeks https://remotehunt.com/remote-jobs-with-4-day-work-weeks So it's probably better to negotiate your current job.
- fighterpilot 5y agoBetteridge's law is false, and it says so in the Wiki article you linked.
- stavros 5y agoNew headline: "Is Betteridge's law true?"
- dbbk 5y agoLazy take.
- shadeslayer_ 5y agoI really hope that a four-day working week becomes the norm. Speaking for the tech industry, I think has been proved time and again that the output of a person is in no way directly proportional to the number of hours (or days) worked - and having that extra day to recharge our batteries will help a LOT of us focus better on the remaining days. I know for a fact that it would help me.
- prox 5y agoI hear you. I really think this is the way forward. A friend of mine started to do a 4x9 schedule and he wouldn’t want it any different now.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoI did 36 hour work weeks last year, day off every second week. I quit doing it this year because one, because I'm working from home I have no commute anyway, and two, because of the 'rona there were no pay rises, but my cost of living keeps growing.
- prox 5y agoThat’s definitely a downside. Costs can go up quickly from home!
- ChrisRR 5y agoI wonder if this varies by country. In the UK an office seems quite happy to put their heads down and just plow away with the work apart from taking tea breaks and the occasional natter But when I've spoken to American colleagues, they seem quite happy to admit how little they've worked, and how they've spent a few hours of their work day just hanging out and chatting. It seems to be their normal day.
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago>Speaking for the tech industry, I think has been proved time and again that the output of a person is in no way directly proportional to the number of hours (or days) worked If you were looking at it from a productivity perspective I suspect five shorter days is going to be more effective than four normal days.
- chhs 5y agoOne can only dream. It seems that workers become more and more productive over time, but their wages do not increase with productivity. I wonder, if not an increase in productivity for the same cost, could result in an improvement in conditions for workers?
- throwawaysea 5y agoIn a global economy we would need to avoid a race to the bottom to defend shorter work weeks somehow. Perhaps that means limitations (tariffs) on trade with nations that don’t enact the same labor laws?
- Mordisquitos 5y agoJohn Maynard Keynes was already dreaming this for his grandchildren in 1930. He may have been a bit too optimistic in terms of the timeline, but hopefully he will eventually be proven to have been on the right track: > For many ages to come the old Adam will be so strong in us that everybody will need to do some work if he is to be contented. We shall do more things for ourselves than is usual with the rich to-day, only too glad to have small duties and tasks and routines. But beyond this, we shall endeavour to spread the bread thin on the butter-to make what work there is still to be done to be as widely shared as possible. Three-hour shifts or a fifteen-hour week may put off the problem for a great while. For three hours a day is quite enough to satisfy the old Adam in most of us! Source: http://www.econ.yale.edu/smith/econ116a/keynes1.pdf http://www.econ.yale.edu/smith/econ116a/keynes1.pdf
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.is/k1ZKA https://archive.is/k1ZKA
- filleokus 5y agoI wonder how large percentage of the workforce have jobs where time spent working is very strongly correlated with "output"? I'm thinking of stuff like nurses, bus drivers, shop clerks, probably a chunk of people in hospitality industries (restaurants/hotels/theme parks etc). Probably also some/many roles in manufacturing industries. It seems obvious that a lot of "HN jobs" probably could have the same output while working less. But for almost all non-office jobs, we would still need someone to drive the bus, or take care of people in hospitals etc. Wouldn't a switch to four-day working week just mean a 25% pay increase for those employees?
- _jstreet 5y ago> Wouldn't a switch to four-day working week just mean a 25% pay increase for those employees? Would that be a bad thing? As we've discovered over the past year, a lot of those people play a crucial role in society today - why do they get paid so little for that?
- carlhjerpe 5y ago> why do they get paid so little for that? What follows isn't necessarily right, but I believe It's why they're paid little. Because they're all easily replaceable, companies doesn't have to invest more than maybe a week of salary into replacing them if they ask for higher pay. At my company we're having a hard time finding people, so sometimes even questionable talent gets hired and trained because we need people. But in low-skill work people will always be paid what is regulated. If we increase their salary enough, then I wouldn't want my job, even though I enjoy what I do, because of the mental burden of never having my head to myself. The best job I've ever had was when backpacking Australia, was taking care of gardens, hedges and stairwells. It paid shit, but every day I felt gratification because I worked with my body and actually finished something (even though It had to be done again in a week or 2 since things grow like crazy in Brisbane). What I do now is an endless struggle of never being finished, so my brain keeps computing solutions to these problems even once I'm off the clock, so if a bus driver all of a sudden has my salary, why on earth would I want a job that requires more of me. As in, I'm not just the current meatbag at this place. I bet we could even stretch this into that it would reduce output of society greatly, since people that otherwise would pursue "high skill" work (Idk, somehow i feel like anyone could be taught my job in a week, but this is more Imposter Syndrome than anything i guess) could be just as happy or happier doing something that doesn't increase human efficency. I will argue for this "to death" (since It's really one of my core beliefs), but i would also love someone to be able to change my mind as it could potentially increase my mental well-being. I'm sadly looking "down" on "simple work", I think as a means to justify wtf I'm doing. > Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.
- fighterpilot 5y ago"According to the report, overall output did not dip in most workplaces, and in some it improved." So did output drop on average, or did it not? And if it dropped then by how much in proportion to the number of hours reduced?
- justshowpost 5y agoI read like 3 or 4 articles on that experiment and they never disclose what exactly happened with productivity. Looks like there is nothing to brag about. Too bad The Economist doesn't question that at all, the whole staying on the same pay deal depends on 11% productivity increase.
- soco 5y agoAll economists predicted that productivity increasing and life quality improving, people will need to work less and less hours. Now (for selected countries) productivity does indeed increase, quality does indeed improve but this consequence is not only not visible, not only difficult to imagine in many job types, but even raises hefty resistance whenever discussed. There's a disconnection, somewhere.
- mjfl 5y agoIt's called the rising standard of living. Is that not obvious?
- joelbluminator 5y ago> productivity does indeed increase That's debatable. GDP is rising (slowly) but debt is rising faster, this isn't generally good.
- beberlei 5y agoI believe the problem is specialization of "Human capital" as the economists would say. I can't reference any scientific reseach in this regard. But anacodically, when I as a business owner have gone through the tremendous transaction costs of finding good employees, then its much better for me to employ 3 of them at 40h/week, then 4 of them at 30h/week.
- lordnacho 5y agoI think for a fair number of HN jobs people are being paid for success in a certain sense: someone needs to know how stuff works and keep an eye on the systems, but the level of effort varies greatly. When something breaks people can end up working really late, but when things are smooth it's not stressful at all and you can read HN. While the business is making money, it's happy to share that with the devs, even if they can see that people aren't busy. There are also jobs where the output is open ended: you can work more on those powerpoint slides, or you can declare victory early and it will still look like a slide deck that's finished. In that sense there's not really an "amount of days worked" and with WFH this gets even more blurred as you don't even need to go anywhere. There is a sense in which this is detrimental for such workers to go to 4 days. Employers will pressure people to get paid 20% less, for effectively the same work. This is especially the case with women who feel a lot of pressure to be with their kids. The employer takes the other side of the above deal and feels entitled to the same work (which is nebulous). This has effects on both pay and career advancement, and stress. My wife got offered one of these "deals" and rejected it, mainly because her boss seemed like an exploiter.
- bryanrasmussen 5y ago>but when things are smooth it's not stressful at all and you can read HN. ok, and while I do like to do that, it is a really poor substitute for being able to do whatever I like.
- lordnacho 5y agoThere's a continuum of both on-call conditions and a continuum of "whatever I like". Some on-call is basically getting paid for doing one thing a month. Others are reliably going to require work. Some "whatever I like" is being at home idling, others are "cave diving in another country". In the middle there's plenty of space for compromise, because you can find a happy medium where both are satisfied.
- villgax 5y agoStartups should pioneer this & make it a norm across the board, kind like how WFH has gone from being once a month to full-time remote
- pjerem 5y agoDo you really think startups could pioneer anything that promotes working less ? Startups are the worse companies on the topic of reducing working time, they even tried all the hacks to squeeze the more hours they can from their employees : free lunch at the office, free childcare, concierge services ...
- villgax 5y agoI mean yeah ones which promote good behaviour & expectations, startups are way better are at least trying out drastic changes than bigger cos.
- elisom78 5y agoI think it will be great if there are 4 working days. The work will be much more productive and there will be enough time to rest and recuperate. This will also avoid frequent burnout at work (https://ivypanda.com/essays/stress-and-burnout-in-the-workplace/ https://ivypanda.com/essays/stress-and-burnout-in-the-workpl...)
- Animats 5y agoSome companies in China are moving to 996. 9 AM to 9 PM, 6 days a week. [1] Get back to work, slackers! [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/996_working_hour_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/996_working_hour_system
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoSome companies in the US do that too, but it's called hustle culture (positive, self-empowered, fast lane to burnout) or crunch culture (either negative or expected of you in e.g. the video game industry). You (the person reading this) are also doing it if you work in e.g. software development during the day, then volunteer in e.g. open source at night / weekends.
- rickard 5y agoIt’s like they need a socialist revolution in China. Workers of the world, unite!
- hnbad 5y agoI mean, yeah, but unironically. China is state capitalist, not communist, despite having a "Communist Party". It's governing ideology is Dengism, which replaced Maoism (which itself in practice was state capitalist just like Leninism was in the USSR) and defines "special economic zones" which are explicitly capitalist and are ideologically justified as being temporary, promising that the capitalists they create will be disowned by the people when the time has come (whenever that is). Ending capitalism not only means "getting rid of" the capitalists (which state capitalism does by substituting them with the state) but getting rid of the capitalist mode of production, i.e. the employer-employee or capitalist-worker dichotomy. The easiest way to understand this when coming from a capitalist realist mindset (which is probably most people on HN) is in the form of worker cooperatives, where workers either decide how the business is run democratically or delegate decisions to a representative (and being able to revoke this delegation at any moment if their interests are not reflected properly). There's no single "owner" external to the "workers", the workers control the company. State capitalism was intended as a "transitional state" to enable a communist revolution. The USSR justified it by stating that a communist revolution would require a level of industrial development Tsarist Russia didn't have (being a primarily agrarian society) and then claiming that a communist revolution would have to be global in order to succeed (which is a great justification for imperialist expansions and authoritarian rule to "maintain order" until then). Some people would say that if you contrast Lenin's writings with the politics he supported directly following the Soviet revolution, he was more of an opportunist seeking political power than an actual ideologue. Mao was similarly focused on "creating the conditions" to enable communism at some point in the future rather than actually promoting radical democracy and equality directly, although his death count was mostly the result of authoritarian bureaucracy going wrong and naïve optimism about foreign technological accomplishments, which arguably was a problem he inherited rather than created. That said, I don't think revolutions work, certainly not at scale and not if you want to create a more egalitarian society rather than another autocracy. The dynamics of revolutions require a small group exerting power on a larger system, which is in itself antithetical to the idea of how a communist society would be structured (hint: basically the opposite way). A lot of socialist revolutions during the Cold War were derailed by either side trying to turn them into a proxy war resulting either in violent defeat or a red authoritarian client state of either the USSR or China. It's probably a better strategy to strengthen communal bonds by creating parallel local structures that can take over when capitalism fails. Worker cooperatives would help with this as they tend to contribute to local communities rather than merely exploit them as resources. (Small) unions can also be an important tool as they can force capitalist corporations to act more like cooperatives by enabling collective bargaining against the owners. Oh, sorry for the lengthy response. You were probably intending this as an absurdist quip, not a genuine suggestion.
- ChrisRR 5y agoStudies always miss one important piece of information, whether the increased productivity actually lasts after the initial novelty has worn off.
- MattGaiser 5y agoI wonder how much of this is just attached to the morale boost?
- beberlei 5y agoI believe since the study ran 3 years, this is covered by the length. This is a much more robust result than an experiment trying this for just 3 month for example.
- Proven 5y agoOf course it can become the norm: a) Pressure.. sorry, "invite" employers to shorten work week to 4 days, and introduce 4 day working week for state-owned enterprises and government employees b) Give tax breaks to those who private employers who cooperate c) Give various handouts - aka Basic Income - to everyone who can't make a living working 20% less d) Grow public debt and/or print money to fund that madness Would that increase overall wealth and living standard? No, but that's not the purpose of this plan anyway.
- misja111 5y agoI have been working 4 days a week for a couple of companies in the past, and I didn't like it. In the beginning the extra day off was great, but after a while I got used to the long weekends. What I didn't get used to though was to switch back to working mode every Monday. This was much harder after 3 days off than after a normal weekend; 3 days was just enough to get in a 'holiday mode' so every Monday felt like the first day after a holiday. Not very pleasant. In the end I even started to do some work on Sunday afternoons so the switch wouldn't be so abrupt. So instead of working a full working week I was now working 4 days paid and half a day unpaid, which doesn't make much sense of course.
- bloak 5y agoWhat do you think it would have been like if you'd taken Wednesdays off instead of Fridays?
- misja111 5y agoNo idea. I also thought it would be great to work 4 days before I actually tried it a couple of times. So I find it really hard to predict how it will feel in reality.
- stavros 5y agoI've been working four day weeks for five years and have the opposite experience. The weekends feel twice as long and the week half as long. I love it, it's a great balance between work and rest.
- notahacker 5y agoI worked four days week for six months and had the middle experience: frankly it wasn't really that dramatic a change! (Especially not compared with being a freelancer with less work and an almost fully flexible schedule). Imagine it'd have been different if I'd had kids or used the long weekends to visit someone a fairly long distance away.
- joelbluminator 5y ago
- CalRobert 5y agoThe funny thing is, considering that my expenses are very low, and the marginal rate of taxes where I live mean I keep less than half of the last euro I earn, I'd love to work half as many hours for half as much pay (maybe even a third as much pay since my takehome would still fall by only ~50%), but that seems nearly impossible to find.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ArcturianDeath 5y ago1. Software programmers are nerd savants that didnt foresee that A.I. will code. 2. Psychedelics once per month is ridiculous. 3. The arcturians, anshar/anunaki, and possibly other aliens have used the intoxication of psilocybin mushrooms upon the human brain to facilitate psychic attack. They tried to get me to do them, but I declined, they succeeded in getting another targeted individual to do them twice, to which they orchestrated a gangstalking and psychic attack to etch terror and cause physical organ damage for the sake of propaganda.
- kumarvvr 5y agoThere are a lot of jobs that require constant presence at the site of the actual work. Nurses, Doctors, Construction workers, etc. 4 day weeks will work very well for a minority of jobs. In every other case, it is downright impractical to implement. How can a Construction Worker / Waiter / Hotel management staff, etc have 4 day weeks ?
- ianai 5y agoHire more people. Same reason the law requiring OT pay for greater than 40 hours per week of work was passed.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- melbourne_mat 5y agoHospitals operate 24x7 but individual Nurses and Doctors don't. They work in shifts of course! A 4 day working week means a hospital would have to hire more doctors and nurses of course. It's a thought bubble though: in my country doctors and nurses are severely overworked as it is. The health system could not permit 4 days a week for doctors and nurses.
- stef25 5y agoJust before the pandemic I switched jobs to one where I negotiated a 4 day week. The job turned out crap but the 4 day thing was great. Now I'm kinda unemployed, kinda working freelance. After a few months of frustration trying to work from home I rented myself a spot in a coworking space where I can work freelance and on my own side projects. The fact that I'm paying for this spot and that I purposely positioned myself so other people can see my screen are great motivators. Never been more productive. Some days I don't work at all, other days I work 15hrs. I guess what I'm trying to say is - don't ever hesitate to drop the normal schedule for something that works out better.
- LatteLazy 5y agoNo. Right now workers are a mi oruty in our democracies. This is why for the last 40 years they've gotten fewer and fewer rights. We've seen big rises in incomes taxes, cuts to services workers use (everything from education to infrastructure) and unions driven out of most markets. Life will continue to get harder for workers because they lack political power.
- jasiek 5y agoThe original paper describes that the reduction in working hours has forced the workforce to develop a more efficient way of working. Thus, they have accomplished what should have been accomplished with having better management from the get go. Given this is the government we're talking about - it isn't really that surprising, is it? They could have reduced the workforce by 20% and accomplished a similar result, while reducing costs.
- bserge 5y agoYes it could. It would make employment statistics better, so politicians like it. My predictions: - 4 day work week, 20% reduction in pay, hence the need to take up a second and even a third gig job, - The Internet is happy (we did it, 4 day work week, what is reality?), - Many well-paid people are happy, - The lowest paid are even more unhappy (2-3 extra jobs, more commute time, less free time, tax confusion), - The government likes the employment stats that hide reality, - Automation is phased in somewhat gentler than it would be if people just lost their jobs completely.
- bruce343434 5y agoThis makes me wonder what the transition to the 8 hour work day was like. Did the pay stay the same? Ironically I don't have the time to research it.
- gugagore 5y agoOr even the transition to the 5-say work week with a weekend, which as I understand it is an outcome of labor movements.
- social_quotient 5y agoFor tech consulting agencies like mine that sell hours… our revenue would reduce immediately. Projects would take roughly +20% longer. Scheduling Tetris woth stakeholders would get more difficult. Work week travel would be more challenging since I’m asking people to work on their off day. Coordinating with offshore non 4 day teams would be interesting but doable. As an employer and company owner my bias is showing but this is not where I would want to go. Stuff like this in me excel and ms project would need to be updated =NETWORKDAYS() =WORKDAY()
- gugagore 5y agoThis is incredibly myopic. The subject at hand will certainly have sweeping effects for generations to come. It would require some changes to the way things get done. Personally I think the changes are worth it. But surely you don't actually believe that the burden of having to update some configurations has any place in an argument in defense of the status quo. Right?
- dade_ 5y agoI suggest taking Wednesday off. It is a bit strange, but I liked it. Very little prep was needed, everyone (including clients) could accommodate rescheduling meetings and deadlines earlier or later by 1 day. I think 3 day weekends do cause a problem, it can be too long to wait for something, especially if it comes up the morning of the first day. However, we are accustomed to 2 days over a weekend, and 1 day is no big deal. While it is nice getting away for 3 days, the first day back is never very productive. Part of the day is just getting up my mind back into what I was working on and catching up on what I missed. Working 2 days feels like a super short week so it forced me to focus to make them productive, but it also tempered my habit of taking on too much. Wednesday completely feels like a Saturday, but businesses are open (well some of them with COVID). Thursday morning was a disappointment, in my mind it was Sunday. The disappointment is short though, I only had 2 more days until the weekend! I never would have tried this, but my employer gives us a day off for our birthday that I normally use on a Monday or Friday to make into a long weekend. Due to COVID, I took it on the Wednesday it actually landed on. I would have never thought to try this otherwise. Give it a shot sometime.
- apexalpha 5y agoI have some people in my team who take Wednesdays off, mostly because they have kids and the schools are half days on Wednesday. Personally I'd take the 3 day weekend everytime. Shops are also open on Fridays so that point is kinda moot. And the fact that people have to wait for me is not really my problem. They also have to wait 5 weeks for me when I'm on holiday; it's the organisations' responsibility to make it work not mine. But if we all go to work 4 days, it might be beneficial to have 50% take Wednesday and 50% take Fridays.
- Vinnl 5y agoFour-day work weeks are not that rare in the Netherlands, so my experience might be coloured a bit by that (although I haven't worked for a Dutch organisation in quite a while), but although Fridays and Mondays were the most common day off, Wednesdays are pretty common too. The main reason for that is that primary school children have the afternoon off on Wednesday though, in combination with splitting the week in two. Personally, however, I still very much prefer Friday. Honestly, the extra day is not that big a deal — sure, it's three days away, but on two of those, everybody is away, and for the rest it's pretty much the least productive one anyway. I also found that Monday is actually super productive for me, mostly because after being away for three days, I'm usually actually looking forward to work again. Your mileage may vary with how much you enjoy your work though, I guess. That said, I don't mind too much answering the odd email on Fridays every now and then if something urgent and predictable does come along. The main benefit to me lies the mental state of not needing to work, and spending just half of my week working, which brings me a lot of peace of mind.
- calebkaiser 5y agoOn a related note, I think that remote teams actually make this easier. I currently work as part of an internationally distributed team, meaning from Tel Aviv to SF and just about every timezone in between, and while there was some minor anxiety in the early days about managing the different timezones, what has actually happened is that all the stress of on-call and related time crunches has evaporated. There is always someone online—at what is a normal time in their day, importantly—to deal with bugs, to help with work that's running long, etc. If one of my teammates is nearing the end of their day and they're stuck on a problem and mentally exhausted, they don't need to push late into the night. They can simply give me context and hand off to me, since it's my AM. I think the benefits of these naturally staggered schedules are going to catch on and spread. It's easy to imagine companies with shortened work weeks, but with teams on different schedules.
- petters 5y ago> a better balance between work and life need not reduce output So what if it reduces output a little? We have had so much economic growth that we can afford this anyway, I think. Seems like a good use of increased productivity.
- juanuys 5y agoI'm in the incredibly privileged position to do this too. 4 day week, at a salary 20% under the market rate. My spare day is spent on doing a part-time masters, or personal projects in-between modules. Previously, I was a freelancer for 7 years, and would take 3 months off over summer every year to work on personal projects. I'm lucky that I don't have one of those jobs that requires constant presence, or being on-call, etc. (I build SaaS/backend systems) A little joke for all of you whose bosses won't let you live your best life: My boss arrived at work in a brand-new Lamborghini. I said, "Wow, that's an amazing car!" He replied, "If you work hard, put all your hours in, and strive for excellence, I'll get another one next year".
- philmcp 5y agoSome numbers from ZipRecruiter (% of 4 day week job listings): - 2018: 0.06% - 2019: 0.4% - 2020: 0.7% Mainstream normalisation is just around the corner imo. I'm currently building https://4dayweek.io https://4dayweek.io (Software jobs with a better work / life balance) to try and help with this :)