6 ms·
It was extremely difficult getting my knowledgeable and smart sister to vaccinate for COVID19, an eminent disease that we both agreed was killing hundreds-of-th
by dragontamer 5y ago
It was extremely difficult getting my knowledgeable and smart sister to vaccinate for COVID19, an eminent disease that we both agreed was killing hundreds-of-thousands of Americans. Fortunately, I pushed her hard enough with a little bit of help from the Demon Slayer: Mugen Train movie (we will go to theaters if you vaccinate).
Honestly: I don't know how I would have done it without that movie, lol.
Now my sister's sister-in-law also is an anti-vaxxer. Lets call her "C".
------------
Frankly, my political capital is still 100% on COVID19. I don't have enough political capital left to spend on climate change.
If I can't convince these people of the eminent dangers of COVID19, and the incredible relative safety of the vaccines... then climate change is hopeless.
C isn't dumb. But she's part of a family of conservatives. "Conservatism" is part of their identity, and right now, that means that they want to believe that the virus will go away on its own, that masks are stupid, the vaccine is made by Bill Gates (wtf??) etc. etc. etc. And climate change is fake is part of that identity they hold.
Pushing this part of their identity away from them is extremely difficult. Just pushing one concept onto them (ex: get the freaking vaccine) is hard enough.
- briefcomment 5y agoYou talk as if you're 100% certain about these things, which is obviously not possible.
- dragontamer 5y agoI'm 100% certain in the vaccine's effectiveness on the average American. Sure: Immunocompromised individuals may not be saved even with the vaccine (not enough B-cells or T-cells to fight off the disease even with the vaccine training them up). But its pretty much 100% proven at this point that the vaccines are 99.999%+ safe (all deaths due to vaccine are measured in the 10-in-a-million or smaller magnitude), while being 95% effective at preventing symptoms against the disease in question. Because the vaccine has been deployed to over 100-million Americans, I have evidence on how it works!! There's no doubt anymore in my mind. There wasn't any doubt in my mind in December 2020, and we've only got 7 more months of evidence: the virus is surging in unvaccinated areas (ex: India), while receding in vaccinated areas. Something like 100% of LA's COVID19 deaths were from unvaccinated indivuals, despite only having ~50% vaccination rates (so 50% / 50% split of vaccinated vs unvaccinated in that population, but 100% deaths coming from only the unvaccinated pool?) What more evidence do you want?
- Supermancho 5y ago> I'm 100% certain in the vaccine's effectiveness on the average American. The effectiveness is in giving them COVID and helping them fight against the intentional infection, via mRNA antibody response. COVID will eventually become yet-another-endemic-disease, that everyone is vaccinated against. There are some people who are marginally genetically susceptible, who will survive with the vaccine. There are some people who are genetically susceptible and with or without the vaccine, will die once infected. The question is, why get vaccinated and take the chance if, due to vaccinations your chances are low to get infected (albeit almost guaranteed over 10 years imo)? That's ok with me. The fact that the unvaccinated individuals are the majority of people dying is unsurprising (as expected, there are some vaccinated deaths as well). This is the uncomfortable truth, which doesn't change what can be done or will happen. The big difference vaccines have made, is an overall reduction in total deaths (as intended) and speeding up the process of total viral exposure (as intended).
- briefcomment 5y agoAnd are you 100% certain your sister and sister-in-law are average Americans?
- dragontamer 5y agoI believe them to be well above-average Americans on the scale of intelligence. If its this difficult to convince them of the facts, when they're open to understanding scientific data, then I don't expect much from the average American.
- Pokepokalypse 5y agoThe vaccine is 0% effective against denialists.
- tdfx 5y agoI did not downvote you, but I want to explain why some people might be. I don't doubt that the majority of people here, even people downvoting you, don't disagree that the vaccine seems to be mostly safe and effective, based on the limited data we have so far. But you're not saying that: you're saying you're 100% sure and willing to bet your life and the lives of others on that certainty, which is not rooted in statistics but rather emotion. You're following the same style of thinking as the conservatives you criticized, just at the opposite end of the political spectrum.
- nradov 5y agoEven in a worst case scenario with no vaccination, COVID-19 would kill less than 1% of the world population. So it's a serious public health problem but not an existential risk to human civilization. I certainly encourage everyone to get vaccinated if they can so as to get us to herd immunity faster, but as a practical matter the disease isn't much of an eminent danger to most people who are otherwise in good health. The potential long term effects of anthropogenic global climate change are more severe. We may see large regions of the world become essentially uninhabitable. That's a far more serious concern than any infectious disease.
- dragontamer 5y ago> Even in a worst case scenario with no vaccination, COVID-19 would kill less than 1% of the world population. Wrong. 5% of people need a ventilator, and 20% of people get hospitalized. When you run out of ventilators, the death rate spikes (see Italy). When you run out of hospital beds, things will get even worse. Worst case scenario is probably closer to 10%. When you literally can't breath on your own, you die rather quickly. We have lots of ventilators in this country, but not enough to cover even just 1% of our population. If the virus ran completely rampant without restrictions, we'd reach the 5% mark rather quickly as those people suddenly can't breath for a week.
- nradov 5y agoThat's just completely wrong. Please stop spreading misinformation about a serious subject. You can find the CDC's best estimates of fatality rates here. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/planning-scenarios.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/planning-scena... Doctors have mostly stopped using ventilators to treat COVID-19 patients. Those often do more harm than good.
- dragontamer 5y agohttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7316113/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7316113/ > COVID-19 is a highly contagious infection with no proven treatment. Approximately 2.5% of patients need mechanical ventilation while their body fights the infection So I'm a bit off with my estimate. But I still stand by my logic.
- tdfx 5y ago> they want to believe that the virus will go away on its own Pandemics have never "ended". Their effects just slide to a level that people stop talking about it.
- dragontamer 5y agoSmallpox. With a high enough vaccination rate, even a disease with R0 of 20 can go away (COVID19 has an R0 of 3 to 6, maybe 9 if we include Delta variant). We've literally eradicated a more difficult and deadly disease before. I'm not saying we need to eradicate COVID19, but its absolutely within our power.
- saalweachter 5y agoThe word "pandemic" ~didn't exist prior to vaccines; arguably, it's too early to say whether every pandemic or no pandemic has ended. We didn't used to have pandemics. We had plagues and poxes. We only had pandemics once we started having the option to not have everyone die of communicable diseases regularly.
- nradov 5y agoUnlike smallpox, SARS-CoV-2 has animal reservoirs. So eradication is not a feasible goal. But widespread vaccination can minimize the long term death toll.
- dragontamer 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cowpox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cowpox The relationship between Smallpox and Cowpox was well known even in the 1700s. (Though the concept of infectious diseases was not understood until the late 1800s, the people who hung around cows a lot didn't die of Smallpox as much). Turns out that Cowpox was the same viral-family as Smallpox, and that Cowpox could be used to lessen the effect of Smallpox. So there were absolutely animal reservoirs of the Smallpox viral family. The disease was shown to hop from different species (from humans to cows and vice versa).
- 5y ago
- anonAndOn 5y agoCOVID is an evolutionary filter for the anti-vax movement. If freedom loving Americans want to roll the dice on survival, let 'em.
- dragontamer 5y agoI happen to care about my sister-in-law's life. So that's not an option.
- lamontcg 5y agoEven if it worked that way, its a poor filter since the IFR is only 1% and it mostly kills people that are very old anyway. Plus ideologies aren't genetic. And even with genetics the whole "evolutionary filter" concept fails due to reversion to the mean. Plus it is a fundamentally right wing political concept. "Evolutionary filters" are about as scientific as the antivax movement.
- anonAndOn 5y agoIt doesn't need to be perfect nor does it need to kill to be effective. You can negatively impact the fertility rate just by diminishing the quality of life.
- lamontcg 5y agoAgain, that is about as scientific as the antivaxxers.
- anonAndOn 5y agoOn the contrary, we have a great public health experiment underway that will be dissected for years to come. Hospitalization rates, medical bankruptcies, prevalence of long COVID, birth rates, excess deaths, etc. For science!