25 ms·
Video tutorials now on PeerTube
- clipradiowallet 5y agoSome examples of what the OP means by "lost sovereignty" would be useful. I assume he means ability to monetize how he wants, or to avoid algorithmic claims against his work etc....but who knows - the author does not explain.
- elliekelly 5y agoHe posted a video[1] about why he left. It sounds like YouTube updated terms of service that required him to allow YouTube to put ads in his videos and he never wanted to monetize his work, he’s making the videos to share information, not to make money for him or anyone else. [1]https://peertube.linuxrocks.online/videos/watch/6b779810-671e-49ae-91fb-93f08a236f2c https://peertube.linuxrocks.online/videos/watch/6b779810-671...
- RL_Quine 5y agoEvil company decides not to take a loss on hosting probably zettabytes of video? It's really hard to paint youtube as the villain here and keep a straight face.
- gameswithgo 5y agonobody called anyone a villain. he simply didn’t like the change and moved to a new service. basic free market forces working well and we can all be happy about it
- acomjean 5y agoThats a good point. Hosting isn't free, so someone is going to have to pay some cost. Even if the original goal was just to share information and not profit, there are some costs associated with running a site. One wonders if youtube had an option for you to pay them to host videos for you without ads, if that would be popular. Of course then someone with a 1 million+ view video and a large bill would then start complaining.. You can always host yourself but you loose the audience youtube brings.
- danparsonson 5y ago"Poor giant video hosting company has to play multiple ads before, during and after every video otherwise they go broke" doesn't really work either. Having the most content available to show viewers has made them the de facto video sharing website - videos freely contributed by people who wanted to share something with the world have helped to put YT in the position where they are basically a monopoly and they are now aggressively capitalising on that. I don't believe they need to monetise everything just to keep the lights on. Ultimately though, the guy doesn't want his content monetised so he's removing it - that's his prerogative just as much as it is Youtube's for advertising however they please.
- EugeneG 5y agoNot a monopoly there’s a ton of video sharing sites - like I guess peertube? Creators can walk away and bring their business elsewhere, as he did. YouTube happens to be very good at advertising your videos and driving you viewers (just like, say, NBC was good at bringing viewers to Seinfeld).
- serf 5y agono one called anyone a villain, but most will agree that having the terms of service changed out from under you after you already have hosted content/a social following/an internet 'home' is a pretty shitty thing to experience. does the means justify the ends? should this be allowed to ensure that the YT bottom line isn't red? I don't know; all I know is that the personal experience of the content creator got to such a negative point that they decided to forego all the benefits of YouTube and host elsewhere -- and that's really the only point that matters.
- _wldu 5y agoIn general, when we use someone's platform to publish, we give up control. People continually rediscover this fact. If you want more control, publish on a standard website on a standard Linux machine.
- serf 5y ago>In general, when we use someone's platform to publish, we give up control. People continually rediscover this fact. In broad strokes : you're right. For the sake of a bit more nuance, i'd like to add that 'the control' isn't just given up by the user. 'The control' is promised by providers, and then slowly dwindled until some threshold is met where users are lost to competitors. YouTube became popular because it gave creators just enough independence, while handling the technical stuff for them. Now that the technical part is becoming increasingly easy to deal with, it stands to reason that YouTube must become more flexible, or lose market share. Will G/YT be flexible enough to keep everyone happy enough to exist within their walled garden? Personally, I don't think so -- and people like the parent article are proving that point by packing up and taking their data elsewhere. Discoverability is becoming less and less of an issue due to the pervasiveness of many different types and styles of social media; IMO that's YT's big advantage and I feel with anti-creator stuff like this stuff, along with YTs recommender being one of the biggest industry in-jokes on the planet -- they really squandered that advantage.
- input_sh 5y agoMentioned in the first minute here: https://peertube.linuxrocks.online/videos/watch/6b779810-671e-49ae-91fb-93f08a236f2c https://peertube.linuxrocks.online/videos/watch/6b779810-671... He had no intention to ever monetise the channel, but with YouTube's ToS update he had to agree that YouTube can monetise his channel even if he doesn't want it to. Considering he's basically forced to serve ads he has no control over and he does not earn a cent from it, I'd say "lost sovereignty" holds true.
- izacus 5y agoWas his expectation that YouTube would cover his hosting, encoding and bandwidth costs for free forever? I wonder what his backup plan is and where will he host the videos now. (It's still kind of wierd that YouTube doesn't support simply paying for their hosting.)
- doublejay1999 5y agothis is the shittiest take. does youtube expect him to keep giving them content free forever ? without contributing to his production costs ?
- EugeneG 5y agoThey don’t expect that. They create an incentive structure to attract creators they want at the price they want and are ok I assume if others choose to not work with them. It’s not like YouTube called him and said “hey what the heck man, why did you stop uploading?”
- ikiris 5y agoWhich do you think costs more? I can tell you the marginal value for most all content is basically zero. The hosting costs aren't.
- doublejay1999 5y agoit obviously costs more to produce content than it does to host and stream it. That's why you watch a show costing 10 millions dollars per episode, for 10 bucks a month.
- tyingq 5y agoA transcript of his video "I'm leaving YouTube", that I pulled from the closed caption file[1] https://pastebin.com/8ZTwaJEm https://pastebin.com/8ZTwaJEm [1] https://peertube.linuxrocks.online/lazy-static/video-captions/e123625b-bfa8-463b-bb69-984b4a13c4dc-en.vtt https://peertube.linuxrocks.online/lazy-static/video-caption...
- RL_Quine 5y agoIt's pretty hard to imagine what people think they gain by "switching" to PeerTube. Beyond idealism, there's not a whole lot going for the platform technically; it isn't peer to peer meaningfully. It would be better to just claim you are paying to self host your videos, which is what the author is doing.
- jcims 5y agoIs there a downside to going to peertube versus self-hosting? Even if you just use it as a CMS for your videos, it seems like it’s all upside to me. Plus it adds a drop to the bucket of network effect for the platform, which appears to be the only viable alternative to YouTube in which the publisher retains the lion’s share of authority.
- marci 5y agoTechnically, if I understand correctly, one of the thing going for peertube is that it allows you to survive [insert any popular forum]'s hug of death. Some website don't even handle a surge of connections when it's just text. With peertube, most of the time, you're serving directly from your website, but in case of virality, the video will be distributed across most of the simultaneous viewers.
- RL_Quine 5y agoIf the website is "hugged", nobody can reach the page with the javascript to make WebRTC connections. People tend to close the window after they're done watching anyway, which sort of negates the whole concept.
- godshatter 5y agoIf people want sovereignty, they can run their own server, but no one would find it. Peertube is a good middle ground, especially since you can run your own instance if you really want more control.
- ergot_vacation 5y agoI think Peertube is "marketed" in the wrong way, perhaps inescapably. Making a simple video-hosting platform is going to invite comparisons to Youtube, but Frama is very clear they don't see themselves that way. Peertube is NOT an alternative to Youtube, and it can't be with the tiny team working on it. However, it does have one edge-case use that's come up a few times. If you have a few bucks, moderate technical knowledge, and just need a way to put 20 or 30 videos online in a form that's easy to link to and navigate for the non-technical, Peertube can be a handy tool. In the past you might say "Why not Youtube?", but Youtube has become increasingly obnoxious to use for simple "throwaway" cases. What's the alternative? Tossing the files up on a shady site like Mega? Running an FTP server or hosting a torrent? Youtube used to be a no-brainer for something like this, but there are so many techno-bureaucratic gotchas now that an alternative just might be worth it. There's zero discoverability, no ad revenue, and you have to deal with hosting and security, but at least Peertube is a ready-made package that mostly "just works."
- duxup 5y agoI wonder at what point we as internet users will decide that we're willing to pay for services in order to maintain more control? In the meantime I sympathize with folks who in a way have ground rules changed on them, but then again were using a free service where they were the product... The internet is a weird place where we demand everything be free as just a baseline rule, and then complain when the product that we didn't pay for changes, or in some other cases just tries to turn a profit / be sustainable.
- numpad0 5y agoHTTP 402 being left unimplemented only seemed natural to me just a decade ago; today looks an incredibly stupid decision. How things change……
- acomjean 5y agoI didn't know what the HTTP 402 status code was: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Status/402 https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Status/402 Its payment required.
- daptaq 5y ago402 is not the issue, the issue is having a payment system that wouldn't just add an implicit dependency on some payment service.
- draw_down 5y agoMore control for whom? A content creator’s struggles with YouTube are only relevant to me to the extent that I am able to watch their videos. The monetization, rights, etc are between them. Not my monkeys, not my circus.
- abacadaba 5y agothe main holdup i think is truly effortless and secure, private, and widely accepted micropayments. there's plenty of stuff i'd be willing to pay for if it didn't involve creating yet another account and giving them my credit card info.
- clord 5y agoWhat are the per-viewer costs these days to host video files on a plain web server? Perhaps with a CDN?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wussboy 5y agoProbably approaching zero. But how are people going to find you. That's the problem YouTube solves.
- ghaff 5y agoIt's going to totally depend on how popular you are. For videos with a relative handful of viewers, host it wherever. If you're a popular site, costs could be hundreds, maybe thousands per month. But you'd have to make some assumptions and do the math. And, as peer says, discoverability unless you already have an audience.
- weinzierl 5y agoI'd argue the risk aspect is what prevents more people from self-hosting than the actual cost. At least it is for me: The idea of waking up to a bill of a few thousand dollars is chilling. And then there is also this conflict of objectives: With an ad-supported platform more popularity means more money, with self-hosting more popularity is less money. Can't have your cake and eat it too.
- bjt2n3904 5y agoAbsolutely loving how people are starting to abandon ship for self hosted platforms. If I had to compare this to a historical event, it would be like the Puritans leaving England for America to escape the oppressive bureaucracy that controlled their lives. There's radical freedom in decentralized social media. The question is whether or not it will take off as a viable alternative to Facebook/Twitter/YouTube -- or whether it will become the next Parler-esque shipwreck.
- muglug 5y agoPeople have been abandoning walled gardens for many decades, but still walled gardens persist. Most either value the walls, or are indifferent to them.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoWell, to be quite fair, places like England persisted, too.
- fabianhjr 5y agoI use IPFS and host my media (mainly photography) on my domain. (With cloudflare as a IPFS gateway in case a visitor doesn't use IPFS) Hosting cost: $0. Some details: https://fabian.social/posts/2020-11-07-ipfs-blogging.html https://fabian.social/posts/2020-11-07-ipfs-blogging.html Example: https://fabian.social/photography/2021-01-15-incidentes-viales.html https://fabian.social/photography/2021-01-15-incidentes-vial...
- reedjosh 5y agoWow, thanks for the example. I've been wanting to do this myself soon.
- robjan 5y agoThere's a small cost of keeping your computer on 24/7 if you aren't using a pinning service, but it can be pretty cheap if you use something like a raspberry pi
- fabianhjr 5y agoCloudflare does some caching, in my experience up to a week, and pinata.cloud (pinning service) has a great free tier and API.
- jonpurdy 5y agoI’ve briefly tried hosting with IPFS in the past and always found it to be super slow/not working at all. If one has a super low traffic site and is already hosting themselves (whether on a home computer or VPS), what’s the benefit of IPFS? My understanding is that if a file isn’t popular, it’ll be served by your own IPFS node/pulled from your local web server, which seems redundant to me. (I totally get the use case for popular files; it’s awesome for that!)
- fabianhjr 5y agoMy main argument (even for low traffic sites) is the following: > Centralized personal sites/blogs become fragile and expensive while a decent(ralized) alternative (like what is in use here) is anti-fragile and inexpensive. > The only costs are the domain registration and running my own computer (where the IPFS daemon takes less than 1% of my cpu usage and 200 MB of memory) and some bandwidth. > The more popular something is, the more peers replicate it. > As such more bandwidth and redundant fetch locations become available that could get the content to you (the reader) at lower latencies. (It is challenging to do a hug of death / slashdotting on such sites/blogs)
- rvz 5y agoGood. YouTube cannot be fixed and they will never change, and it is no more about 'the creators' anymore, It's for the big influencers, advertisers and now for the already established cable news networks. It's for the best to start leaving the platform since it is completely skewed for them. At least there are some sane alternative platforms that exist which make the switch possible to some.
- reedjosh 5y agoCentralized ad based services are never in your interest. What you spend your time on matters, so I try to be critical of my browsing habits. Some sites/services I currently use: neeva.com Paid search that I'm liking atm. Feels like I can find stuff again and it's 4 months free. For video hosting and content I like Odysee.com as an ad free decentralized Youtube, but the network effect hasn't quite taken hold yet. Social I like peakd.com as a decentralized blogging and social platform.
- deadalus 5y agoYoutube Alternatives : Centralized : Dailymotion, Bitchute, Rumble, DTube, Vimeo, Vidlii Decentralized : Odysee(LBRY), Peertube
- Covzire 5y agoI'm pleasantly surprised how good Odysee's UX is, for the viewer anyway.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Jyaif 5y agoIn my experience Vimeo is great, while Dailymotion is absolute garbage: the streaming itself stutters at low quality and the amount of unskippable super long ads is insane.
- fabianhjr 5y agoPeertube is Federated not Decentralized (via ActivityPub)
- dilap 5y agoAndrew Kelley of Zig also moved away from YouTube because of forced ads (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qjz6xNO63mI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qjz6xNO63mI) YouTube is an amazing collection of knowledge, but it's unfortunate that it's in the hands of an entity whose primary goal and motivation is avarice. A degradation of the experience over time seems inevitable. How to organize human endeavors in a way that captures the innovation and superbly focused effort of early-stage companies without devolving into the raw exploitation, rent-seeking, and monopolistic behavior of late-stage companies seems an open problem.
- duxup 5y ago>it's in the hands of an entity whose primary goal and motivation is avarice And we gave it all to them, for the price of the convince of using their service.
- briefcomment 5y ago> forced ads Recently, some people were trying to tell me that ads are entirely controlled by the video uploader, when I brought up some videos that clearly had way more ads than any content creator would reasonably allow.
- mavsman 5y agoI once swore to myself that I'd never monetize videos. Now my small-time channel has ads before my videos and I don't even have enough watch-time (yet) to monetize them to grab the pennies that could be mine. Once I do have the watch-time (4000 hours per year) to monetize, I will feel sleazy about it but I don't think it would make any difference to viewers, I'll just be taking the pennies I deserve.
- freeopinion 5y agoYou can monetize your videos from day 1. Just line up sponsors. If you want you can embed ads for your sponsors. Oh, wait, you mean you can't monetize without exerting some actual effort? How is that Youtube's fault?
- TheChaplain 5y agoI understand and a sympathize with his opinion, at the same time the platform must be financed somehow, no? Yeah I know Google are rich but still, from a technical standpoint YT is pretty damn good. I've never had any issues watching videos or streaming, and instantly served in EU, Asia and the US. For that and the massive selection of content I'd say it's worth it for me.
- rchaud 5y agoYes, the platform must be financed somehow. However, that 'somehow' didn't seem to be an issue for 15 years. A video series about parametric 2d/3d CAD is not going to do Logan Paul numbers, so what merit is there to jam ads into it anyway?
- EugeneG 5y agoDon’t like them, don’t watch/upload. Just like he did. They can put in as many ads as they want, and those who are bothered can refuse to watch.
- rchaud 5y agoI'll just keep using Ublock, thanks.
- Crash0v3rid3 5y ago> However, that 'somehow' didn't seem to be an issue for 15 years. It has absolutely been an issue. If you listen in on the earnings call, shareholders have been asking for YouTube revenue for years. Google has to show it can be a profitable business.
- rchaud 5y agoAsking about revenue is not the same as asking about profit. In any case, the 80-20 principle still applies. Monetizing already successful content categories will deliver far more profit than long-tail niche content that far fewer people see.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- leephillips 5y agoIn the early days of TV, when the first broadcast licenses were being granted, there was a legislative proposal to make advertising on TV illegal. It was defeated, resulting in a century of TV that was largely a wasteland in the service of the tobacco and fast food industries. We have a political choice.
- srswtf123 5y ago> We have a political choice. Do we though? It seems to me that a few very wealthy people have choices. The rest of us are simply along for the ride.
- stickfigure 5y agoWhat do you imagine the alternative world of 100% ad-free television would look like? Hundreds of channels of PBS? I think that is naively optimistic.
- leephillips 5y agoI don’t know what it would have looked like, obviously. But I think it would have been better than what we got. Even having just two or three PBS-type channels and subtracting the rest would have been an improvement.
- underseacables 5y agoWhat is the primary cost issue preventing greater competition and hosted videos? Is it band with, storage space, or just infrastructure? It seems this arena is very crowded with producers yet everyone is beholden to YouTube. Why?
- dredmorbius 5y agoCopyright compliance, lawsuit threats, illegal activity, legal investigations, similar such aspects have been a bane of decentralised service provision since the 1990s, if not before. One underappreciated role of a large, well-financed and well-capitalised publisher is in providing legal defence to both itself and its creators.
- specialist 5y agoNoob question: Does youtube show fewer ads on embedded videos? (Or maybe uBlock just works better against embedded videos.) If so, then maybe host a page of embedded videos. Further, for more than a handful of videos (embedded), I'd want some kind of carousel, so you don't crush the client's browser with dozens of videos pre-loading. (Hot damn I hate youtube.)
- throwawayswede 5y agoI had those solvespace tutorials bookmarked and was wondering why they went private a few days ago. I'm glad they're back and even more happy they're no longer on YouTube.
- goatmeal 5y agoI recently set up peertube on a $5 VPS using yunohost and it was very easy. definitely would need more work if I got more than 10 little views a day.
- jaworek 5y agoodysee.com is also another good decentralised alternative. YT creators can easily sign up and setup automatic sync of all of their videos. This is a great way to have a backup in case Google decides to ban them or do some wonky policy changes.
- iluvcommunism 5y agoLots of discussion on advertising. None on the blacklisting & censorship by YouTube of millions of American opinions. Of course HN is a liberal website, so this is welcomed.
- Popegaf 5y agoOnce PeerTube adds a way for plugin developers to monetize videos without ads directly on peertube, it might become much more interesting to people trying to build a career making content. Right now, the only option is to link to other pages (mostly paypal and patreon) and hope to get supporters that way. It's OK to keep it the way it is now, but there's friction in order to support content creators: you need at least one other account on another website in order to support at least one creator. I also doubt most people will support more than a few creators through those means. A "donate as you watch" plugin or something would be very useful. Transfer funds at some frequency to your peertube/activitypub account, and define rules (or keep some reasonable default) of how that is distributed. Examples: - 100% of your funds go to your favorite creator - 90% to favorite creator, 10% to the next top 2 depending on accumulated watch time in a month - Funds are distributed proportionally to watch time in a month Given that this is opensource and plugins are possible, there's a lot of room for innovation.