9 ms·
Did lead poisoning cause downfall of Roman Empire? The jury is still out
- aliasEli 5y agoThe decline and fall of the Roman Empire was very likely caused by a combination of factors. The article makes a reasonable case that lead poisoning could be one of them.
- zhdc1 5y agoYep. Another plausible cause that doesn't get as much traction is climate change - particularly, the cooling period during the second and third centuries that may have contributed to the fall of the Han dynasty and the Roman crisis of the third century. Although Rome, China, and (not mentioned earlier) Perisa managed to reconstitute themselves, the subsequent decline in trade both within and across empires had to have had an effect (although to what extent, I'm sure others on here know more about it tham I do).
- jnmandal 5y agoThis sounds super interesting. Could you share some resources to read up on this?
- vondur 5y agoI think you can certainly google most of it. But certainly the combination of climatic change and the bubonic plague certainly helped bring down the plans of the Emperor Justinian to reunite the Empire. An excellent resource is the Fall of Rome Podcast. Most historians will agree that no one reason alone caused the Empire to fall, rather it's a combination of factors that together brought it down.
- sol_invictus 5y agoInteresting considering the world currently has a plastics poisoning problem
- mkl95 5y agoWhether it caused the downfall of the Roman Empire or not, is lead poisoining (used for water pipes and cooking vessels) the oldest example of technical debt? Edit: just realized technical debt is a software engineering term. I still think it's a great analogy for how large unmaintained codebases rot over time.
- tgv 5y agoIs it technical debt if you don’t know, much less understand the problem?
- mkl95 5y agoGood question. Romans studied lead poisoning to some extent. Their word for lead poisoning was saturnism [1]. Which makes me think they either didn't know any better, or they found out so late that they could not afford to replace their lead with a safer material. [1] https://archive.epa.gov/epa/aboutepa/lead-poisoning-historical-perspective.html https://archive.epa.gov/epa/aboutepa/lead-poisoning-historic...
- yesenadam 5y ago> Romans studied lead poisoning to some extent. Their word for lead poisoning was saturnism[1] The linked article, surprisingly, doesn't seem to give any support at all for either of those statements.
- mkl95 5y agoHere's another one that focuses a bit more on Rome: https://culturacolectiva.com/history/plumbism-disease-that-might-have-sparked-deliriums-in-roman-emperors https://culturacolectiva.com/history/plumbism-disease-that-m... > Known as plumbism (or saturnism in Latin as a reference both to lead and plumb, but also to the god Saturn known to be mentally unbalanced and aggressive), this was a very well-known disease by ancient alchemists though it wasn’t really attributed to Roman emperors.
- 5y ago
- wavefunction 5y agoI thought it was the Ottoman conquest of Constantinople? I think it's pretty well understood that the Western Roman Empire towards its end was plagued by pandemics, in-fighting, self-interest and loss of centralized control, and the pressures of migrating peoples due to climate change. The weakening of the Imperial power coincided with the rise of the power of the Christian church supplanting the anemic WRE state.
- pfraze 5y agoThat’s the trouble with the lead-poisoning theory, it’s one of those things where you can describe all the issues as the net result of poison. The rise of the church always interests me in this story. As I understand it, Christianity was a kind of rebellious liberalizing movement which the state ultimately tried to coopt (Constantine). It’s pre-state adoption was a movement away from more brutal practices, such as crucifixion. Eventually it developed into a competing power structure.
- fidesomnes 5y ago> As I understand it, Christianity was a kind of rebellious liberalizing movement A religion popular with slaves which promised a better life after death. As described by Nietzsche ad nauseum.
- Ericson2314 5y agoOttomans reuniting the eastern Mediterranean thereafter doesn't feel like a fall.
- wavefunction 5y agoMehmed II did declare himself Kayser-i Rum after taking Constantinople so perhaps you're right.
- jcranmer 5y agoAsking the question of when the Roman Empire fell leads you into a decently difficult task of asking what constitutes a fall, and indeed what actually fell in the first place. The traditional answer of 476 is interesting for things that didn't happen in 476: * The capital of the Roman Empire wasn't sacked, nor was the capital of the Western Roman Empire sacked. * The last claimant of Augustus of the Western Roman Empire wasn't killed. (Although the imperial court in the Eastern Roman Empire didn't recognize his claim). * No vestiges of Roman rule, such as the Roman Senate, ended. * Contemporary political discussions didn't feel that a major event or break in history had happened. * Archaeological evidence doesn't point to a major break in the economic conditions or the material record of the era (that would come later, with the Plague of Justinian). Of course, many pedants will come out saying that the Roman Empire really fell in 1453, because that it is when the Ottomans sacked Constantinople. But again, why 1453? * Why not 1204, when the Latin Empire sacked Constantinople and ruled from there for 60 years? * Why not 1461, when the Empire of Trebizond (another rump state of the Byzantine Empire created by the sack in 1204) fell to the Ottomans? * Or indeed, why not 1475, when the Principality of Theodoro, itself the rump state of the Empire of Trebizond, also gave in to the Ottomans? * Or 1460, when the Despotate of Morea--the last part of the Byzantine Empire supposedly conquered by the Ottomans--was disestablished as a tributary state by the Ottomans? * Indeed, it's worth pointing that the last Byzantine Empire had to have his accession to the throne confirmed by the Ottoman Emperor of the time (Murad II)--the Byzantine Empire by the 1440s was itself basically an unruly tributary state of the Ottoman Empire. So going back to the article's question, if lead poisoning is supposedly one of the reasons for the fall of the Roman Empire, which fall of which Roman Empire are they talking about, and why didn't it contribute to the not-falling of the contemporary not-exactly-the-Roman-Empires running about?
- christkv 5y agoI've always thought about the fall of an empire as the moment the bureaucratic wheels seize to function and the shared cultural values fall apart. If a new war lord storms in but just sets themselves on the throne with the machinery in place the empire staggers on culturally and bureaucratically. A mongol like situation and the whole structure and culture is shattered. Rome in 476 I think had a broken bureaucratic system and shattered culture. The Byzantines kept that stuff in place until the final fall of Constantinople.
- goto11 5y agoThe article posit "erratic rulers" as a possible cause for the downfall of the Roman Empire. As examples of such erratic rules it mention Claudius, Caligula and Nero. The problem with this theory is that the fall (if we take 476 AD as the date) happened about 400 years after these rulers.
- jcranmer 5y agoThey're only off by as long as the US or any of its antecedent colonies have been around. That's not a big deal, right?
- boomboomsubban 5y agoThe article shows that many emperors from ~0-200AD had a lead rich diet, and I'm guessing the paper stopped when it did because sources suffered during the Crisis of the Third Century. If the early emperors ate a lot of lead, it's reasonable to expect many of the later ones continued doing so, which could have played a role in the downfall.
- goto11 5y agoCouldn't you just as well conclude that lead-eating emperors lead an empire to expand and prosper for centuries?
- boomboomsubban 5y agoIt'd kinds depend on which of the 19 loved lead containing food, there was only about 70 years of conquest over that period. But I think the overall goal of that unrelated claim was just to show lead poisoning likely did happen, with other things claiming it became more wide spread.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- science4sail 5y ago210 Reasons for decline of Roman Empire: https://courses.washington.edu/rome250/gallery/ROME%20250/210%20Reasons.htm https://courses.washington.edu/rome250/gallery/ROME%20250/21... I guess that strengthens the case for #121 (for now).
- SeanLuke 5y agoIf I might insert an almost entirely unrelated tidbit. In 49 BC Julius Caesar crossed the Rubicon, trespassing the legal limit on his ruling territory, and marking in some sense the start of his conquest of the known world. Hence the terms "crossing the Rubicon" and Caesar's famous saying "The die has been cast". Fast forward to modern times, and people in the area of Romagna, near Ravenna, Rimini, and Cesena, had long claimed with no evidence that a polluted little creek in the region was the actual Rubicon: though its specific identification had long been lost to time. Nonetheless they named it "Il Rubicone". The mouth of the river opens directly south of Cesenatico, a beach town on the Adriatic and the family home of my in-laws. See the bust of Caesar on this bridge over the mouth: https://www.google.com/maps/@44.166995,12.440708,3a,75y,274.24h,80.55t/data=!3m8!1e1!3m6!1sAF1QipOnGL_O8tPcbERzQK1jX82rrqoEBVf4FoFVuuq6!2e10!3e11!6shttps:%2F%2Flh5.googleusercontent.com%2Fp%2FAF1QipOnGL_O8tPcbERzQK1jX82rrqoEBVf4FoFVuuq6%3Dw203-h100-k-no-pi-0-ya25.303179-ro-0-fo100!7i7200!8i3600 https://www.google.com/maps/@44.166995,12.440708,3a,75y,274.... Now Italians are famous for unnecessarily goosing local legends to make their neighborhoods more historically important than they are. (For example though Leonardo da Vinci did draw a small survey of Cesenatico's historic canal -- not related to the Rubicon -- for the Borgia Popes, that's not enough for the locals: the town has a local plaque saying he created the canal despite the fact that it preexisted him by hundreds of years.) But as it so happens, historical research culminating in the late '90s has verified the river's legend: the creek is in fact the actual Rubicon. In Italy, folk history goes way way back.
- jjtheblunt 5y agorandom diversion, but in the US at least, Jeep Wranglers come in a Rubicon version, with that word printed prominently on the hood/bonnet. It's supposedly the commonly purchased trim level because it costs more, so Rubicon the word is used for wealth ostentation. I've made a sport (a demented sport admittedly) out of asking folks with them what "Rubicon" means. I've not yet found a correct answer.
- nucleardog 5y ago> I've made a sport (a demented sport admittedly) out of asking folks with them what "Rubicon" means. I've not yet found a correct answer. Did any of the "incorrect" answers include "it's named after an off-roading trail"? Because it's named after an off-roading trail used by Jeep as a testing/proving ground[0]. Most of their trail rated / trailhawk models contain some sort of nod to off roading trails. E.g., their "Renegade" contains maps of popular trails embossed into various bits of plastic.[1] [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rubicon_Trail https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rubicon_Trail [1] https://www.autoguide.com/auto-news/2016/06/jeep-renegade-easter-egg-hunting.html https://www.autoguide.com/auto-news/2016/06/jeep-renegade-ea...
- nradov 5y agoIt makes you wonder what hidden public health problems are impacting us and will only be understood centuries later. Will endocrine disruptor chemicals like phthalates cause the downfall of the American empire? The jury is still out.
- bserge 5y agoShitty healthcare systems, but they're not exactly hidden. People just choose to ignore how bad they really are.
- nradov 5y agoHealthcare makes only a marginal difference. The Roman Empire managed to last for centuries with no healthcare "system" at all. Public sanitation, and access to safe food and water, are far more important than quality of health care.
- Zevis 5y agoI feel like we're already seeing the effects of chemicals like lead now. How many older people are suddenly radical Trump or QAnon supporters?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- OnlyMortal 5y agoNo. It was complacency.
- Zevis 5y agoHonestly, looking at how Republicans are divorcing themselves from reality makes me theorize that there are similar physiological/chemical effects at play in modern society (and the rise of similar movements in Europe). A lot of these people grew up when lead was far more ubiquitous. When environmental regulations were far less stringent. I wouldn't be surprised if chemicals were having long-term effects that we're only really seeing play out now.
- bserge 5y agoIt's an alluring prospect, blaming everything on some external factor. The reality might be that we're just barely out of the primitive stage of evolution and might not even make it further at this rate.
- Zevis 5y agoI'm not sure it's alluring. It's possible. I'm not sure our inherent psychology is sufficient to cause what's happening in the US.
- enragedcacti 5y agoWe have likely already seen the effects start to play out: The lead–crime hypothesis is the association between elevated blood lead levels in children and increased rates of crime, delinquency, and recidivism later in life. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead%E2%80%93crime_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead%E2%80%93crime_hypothesis
- Alupis 5y agoRadicalness is very easily seen on both sides of the US political landscape. You just have to open your eyes... The radical camps on both sides are all that's in the news it seems... I supposed the normal non-radical causes don't drive as many clicks or something. If you watched only the news, you'd think most Americans want to ban all airplanes, prevent anyone from voting, print money into oblivion, bring back slavery, and that everyone hates this country. Well, the 4th of July celebrations we just saw prove otherwise... these are radical talking points and most Americans do not sympathize with the radicalness of either ideology. > Honestly, looking at how Republicans are divorcing themselves from reality I think both Republicans and Democrats say this about each other... and have been saying it about each other since the parties were formed... and will continue to say this about each other for eternity.
- ThrustVectoring 5y agoOne of the more compelling factors I've heard of for the fall of the Roman Empire is their tax system for agricultural land. Essentially it's a per-acre tax regardless of the productivity and ease of access, with the obvious problem of marginal land getting abandoned because the tax wasn't worth paying. I read that a lot of the invading tribes were treated as liberators from the Romans for that very reason. Malthus was in full force in the era, so you had edge-of-starvation villages next to productive land that could be cultivated but wasn't due to taxes, and the barbarians rolling in meant you could do that now.