18 ms·
America’s Obsession with Self-Help
- ddingus 5y agoActually getting help is often associated with high costs, risks and stigmas of various kinds. Obsession? Hardly.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoThat's if you can even find help. There are many times it is lacking completely.
- ddingus 5y agoAgreed.
- rednerrus 5y agoThis is why self-help books are so important. You can figure out the issue, make a plan, and get started in the comfort and safety of your home for the price of a library card.
- ddingus 5y agoI consider that dark humor.
- war1025 5y agoI gravitate towards self help because expert help has almost always resulted in very large expenses and my actual problem not being solved. Every experience I've had with a doctor that was less severe than "I am actively dying" has just been "Take pain killers for a couple weeks and come back if it isn't fixed by then, also here is a $200 bill." The one time I hired someone to fix something on my house (to fix some water damage), I had a literal stream of water coming in to my house above the repair the next time it rained. In most cases, it seems you need to know the answer to the problem yourself before you can trust someone else to diagnose and fix the problem correctly.
- swiley 5y agoTrusting other people to administrate your home computer is totally ok though because they're actually experts.
- truffdog 5y agoThat is the Kaseya business model.
- potatoman22 5y agoConversely, sometimes you need that outside expert perspective to help open your eyes to the real problems.
- war1025 5y agoAnd that's the real rub of it. I don't know what I don't know, but I also don't know where to get that knowledge, so a reasonable first step is to investigate the people pushing "self-help" methods. From there you can often learn the right keywords to get a foot in the door with someone knowledgeable and have them actually tell you something useful rather than just taking your money and sending you on your way.
- rajin444 5y agoMost of us work in a profession where we hire teams of people to maintain systems with a fraction of the complexity of the human body (not to mention our understanding of how computers work is orders of magnitude higher than our understanding of the body). Contrast that with a doctor seeing a patient for the first time.
- deregulateMed 5y agoAhhh the good ol "Medicine is Art and Science". How many people have died because we keep letting physicians tell us this? I'm pro Evidence Based Medicine, but physicians can't buy mansions if the medicine can be discussed by scientists.
- alexpetralia 5y agoThere are productive (empowering) and unproductive (parasitic) forms of self-help. I have found the former to be useful for as long as I can remember; the latter to be strongly avoided.
- alexpatin 5y agoHow does one discern between productive and unproductive forms of self-help?
- BitwiseFool 5y agoIt's up to each individual to decide, but is progress being made, or at the very least, are behaviors changing as a result of the person's efforts and not only because of the outside help?
- toivo 5y agoWell I'm not American and I read mostly "self-help" books, from "In Search of Meaning" to "Code Complete" to "Extreme Ownership" to "High Output Management" to "Never Split The Difference". I always read one before I go to sleep.
- topspin 5y agoCode Complete is a self-help book? I never imagined that book would be categorized as self-help. With a definition of "self-help" broad enough to include it the question in my mind is "What isn't self-help?"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Sr_developer 5y agoI think you are confusing "Self-Help" with "non-fiction".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jbrun 5y agoAs a Canadian and a French citizen, America definitely has this puritan streak of trying to be the best person you can be - or the purest you can be. Work harder, drink less, exercise more, etc. My French grandparents lived until they were 100, were perfectly content, had 8 kids, ate great food during long meals and drank lots of wine. I don't think they jogged a day in their lives.
- swiley 5y agoCoincidentally I think the best self help book I've read was written by a Canadian. Maybe it's because he had the rest of the culture to contrast his ideas against.
- dominotw 5y ago> I don't think they jogged a day in their lives. i don't think they were sitting all day eating highly processed food either.
- markbeare 5y agoExactly
- lumost 5y agoIt is curious why we haven't figured out the difference between a "healthy" french/mediterranean/home cooked meal and a tv dinner yet. Obviously something gets lost in the macro nutrients/vitamin content - but I don't think I've seen a formal study of why they are different.
- handrous 5y agoPortions are the #1 culprit as far as food goes, I'd say. There may be a bunch of other factors, but I'd expect that they're secondary to that. I'm also very curious how much better US health would be if we could wave a magic wand and replace all sugary drinks with water. 64oz of sugar-water with a meal is a lot, but not uncommon thanks to free refills and helpful waiters always topping everyone off. Lots of people have way more than that on an average day, too. I'm sure it wouldn't fix (anywhere near) everything, but I bet that single factor is an awful lot of the cause of dietary-related illness rate differences between the US and other countries. The others have soda too, but it doesn't flow as freely and cheaply as here[0], and enormous cups/bottles of the stuff multiple times a day isn't common most places. [0] With some exceptions—I understand Mexico, for example, consumes lots of sugary soda.
- jokoon 5y agoHumans are always looking for things to believe in. When people become less religious, they still need something to put their faith in. Motivation and happiness are vague words or concepts. Existentialism and existential nihilism explain this. Those books are not based on science, and if they were, they would talk about it. Apart from saving the world from climate change and tax justice I cannot find any meaning I could find in those books.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- borepop 5y agoI enjoy some self-help books because they seem to articulate an underlying gameplan for pursuing whatever one considers "success," which are ideas my parents and school only taught me implicitly or inaccurately. My parents' advice to me as a kid was "do what you love and the money will follow," which is not true, and/or "join the Navy," which I had no desire to do. So I've ended up trying to find my own way in life, however imperfectly. Essentially, a lot of these books are about executive functioning skills, the meta-level planning and goal-setting and failure-analysis efforts that are necessary to make progress in whatever field. I think it is also true, as other commenters note, that to some extent they fill an ethical or existential void left by the decline of religion.
- pyrale 5y ago> "join the Navy," Maybe they hoped this way you'd get to learn the science technology? :-)
- deregulateMed 5y agoThinking of Mortimer Adler's How To Read A Book... Self Help is either a How To book or Philosophy? Both have quite a bit of value to the individual. Even as the author describes this as feeding the business machine, both self help and philosophy can make you aware when this is happening. I read these genres and can see clearly why my boss was told to repeat company statements. I sit back and witness corporate propaganda/marketing and am aware they are coming for my brain. Without self help and philosophy, would I be hacked into mindless compliance?
- jf22 5y agoI'm going to try and give up self-help and business books and podcasts and only read sci-fi. My career is fine, I'm fine, I know enough about tech and engineering management to be at least mediocre. There is a 50 book 40k series out there I think I'd rather spend more time with.
- robotnikman 5y agoAs a fan ok the 40k series as well, which books in particular?
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.is/RdFmK https://archive.is/RdFmK
- recursivedoubts 5y agoAmerica, in contrast with most other countries, has very little cultural infrastructure to guide people. Freedom and individualism (however shallow) is emphasized. To quote an american catholic saying something very uncatholic, but very american: “At the heart of liberty is the right to define one’s own concept of existence, of meaning, of the universe and the mystery of human life.” We should not be surprised that into this psychic vacuum rushes various alternatives such as self-help, sports-worship and so forth.
- FredPret 5y agoSports-worship is a strong feature of many religious and traditional nations as well. Think of European football fans, among many other examples.
- nkssy 5y agoWell, if your view is around individualism and shaping yourself then maybe the whole self-help industry isn't so accidental. Maybe its a progression of a strong need for materials to support that view. Other countries also have it as well but its nowhere near the seemingly overwhelming desire as in the US. Or perhaps theres a travelling sideshow element to self-help that appeals to the PT Barnum types. But I'm not so cynical.
- BeetleB 5y ago> America, in contrast with most other countries, has very little cultural infrastructure to guide people. Freedom and individualism (however shallow) is emphasized. This is very accurate. Having lived in other countries, I can say the "other" side suffers from a different extreme: Sticking to flawed social constructs that impede their progress and/or happiness, no matter how much research and/or self help you throw at them.
- bryananderson 5y agoAs a counterpoint, we in America certainly do not seem to be immune to sticking with flawed social constructs that impede our progress/happiness. For that matter, less-individualistic societies such as European countries don’t seem immune to some of the symptoms the parent comment mentioned, such as sports-worship. There is something to the notion that American individualism comes with its unique pathologies, but there’s clearly a lot more to the story of why things like self-help have exploded. For one thing, as traditional sources of meaning have withered under the harsh lights of science and modernity, all wealthy societies have seemed to struggle with a crisis of meaning. This leaves a vacuum that gets filled with self-help (the secret to a meaningful life is here in this book), sports-worship, celebrity-worship, video-game escapism, neo-nationalism, whatever. This can be seen all over the developed world. However, America’s extreme individualism may exacerbate this crisis of meaning, since community is often itself a source of meaning. We cannot go back to pre-modernity, nor should we try. What can we do to build societies, here and now, that help people feel a sense of meaning in their lives without the ghastly drawbacks of past sources of meaning such as religion and ethnic nationalism?
- xyzelement 5y agoWhile the quality of self-help material is variable, what I think is valuable (and I guess pretty American) is the focus on that which you can change for yourself. It seems more popular recently to talk about external problems that you realistically can't impact ("why should anyone be a billionaire") rather than focus on what you can actually change ("how do I grow valuable skill sets and market myself better to increase my compensation.") Obviously, not every self-help book is going to be good, or right for you, and you may not absorb and implement it, but I'd much rather bet on someone who at least tries to steer their own ship.
- KittenInABox 5y agoIf we never talk about external problems such as systems that make it impossible to meaningfully increase one's compensation, then no amount of change in self could actually fix anything. Let's say you're a disabled person who can't even get married because then you lose your income and therefore become financially dependent on your partner, which creates a super uncomfortable relationship between the two of you. What can you change yourself, or should you instead talk about the fact the government's laws and merit-gating has royally fucked you over and advocate for systemic changes? Maybe through writing a blog post or opinion article in a newspaper...
- BeetleB 5y ago> If we never talk about external problems such as systems that make it impossible to meaningfully increase one's compensation, then no amount of change in self could actually fix anything. This is merely arguing from extremes, and is responding to a position your parent did not take (i.e. strawman): He didn't say "never" or "always", he said "more popular" Also, I could make the equally correct/problematic statement: If we only talk about external problems such as systems that make it impossible to meaningfully increase one's compensation, then no amount of social reform will improve your condition. You need external things to change, but you also need to change yourself internally. The dispute is on how much of each.
- CJefferson 5y agoWhile America seems to spend a lot of time talking about "how to improve / change yourself", and the "American Dream", every study I've seen (for example https://www3.weforum.org/docs/Global_Social_Mobility_Report.pdf https://www3.weforum.org/docs/Global_Social_Mobility_Report.... ), shows it does poorly for social mobility.
- guilhas 5y agoMost important take is people want help Maybe don't know how to get it, don't have money, feel ashamed... Society needs help and reform
- neogodless 5y agoWhile I doubt my experience is even remotely unique, a variety of experiences (and perhaps genetics) from my childhood, teens, etc. left me in my 20s as an outgoing but (very) insecure person. I was constantly seeking but failing at relationships. I had dropped out of college, and was flighty and inconsistent with my career. Maybe I'd come out of all that just by time passing / aging... but I decided to read about the things I was failing to accomplish. Having a self-identity and the integrity to maintain my identity when faced with challenges. Understanding boundaries in relationships. Learning how to accomplish tasks at work and succeed in projects. I suspect a combination of the bad experiences, surviving them, learning from mistakes and the things I learned from books all contributed to an overall more capable person. I gained confidence, stability in relationships, greater diligence and sense of responsibility at work. Not everything is sunshine and roses. There's still a long list of projects I dreamed of or started, but failed or abandoned. But the list of people that seem to trust me and seek me out for "adult" advice has grown. In many ways, I am not the picture of American success, but I am happy with what I've done with myself, with the potential I've tapped, the relationships I've built, and so on. I think of myself as leaning towards the side of being discontent with unpleasant circumstances that I'm capable of changing. There's plenty that's bigger that I might not be happy about, but by having a clear picture of your locus of control, the gist of the Serenity Prayer applies. And improving your self is top of the list of things you can change.
- rednerrus 5y agoMany Americans don't have communities to fall back on. I was raised by a single mother 6000 miles from her family. We didn't have family or community to rely on. I was alone a lot as a child. As such I didn't get all of the socialization that many people got. I like to think of it like growing up without hearing language. I didn't get it as a part of my upbringing. I had to seek it out and learn it, in the same way you would a language. In the beginning I didn't have the tools to seek it out with other human beings. I didn't speak the basic "language". I feel incredibly fortunate that there were books out there that I had access to that helped with where to start. Simple things like how to ask for help. Eventually (20 something years later) I have enough "language" in my vocabulary, thanks in great part to amazing books written by incredible writers who have devoted their lives to helping other people, to navigate a complex social life. I am incredibly grateful to these authors. This is an issue plaguing Americans. There are threads everyday on Reddit and the like with people asking questions like "How do I make friends?" and "How do I get involved in a community?". We're an incredibly lonely society.
- brutusborn 5y agoCan you please list some of the books that have helped you the most?
- tppiotrowski 5y agoHow to Win Friends and Influence People is a classic
- rednerrus 5y ago"What Happened To You" by Oprah and Bruce Perry https://www.amazon.com/What-Happened-You-Conversations-Resilience https://www.amazon.com/What-Happened-You-Conversations-Resil...: This helped me to wrap my head around concepts I've been working on for a long time. How what happened to you affects what you're doing now. It also has advice about how to "fix" some of it with small, controllable doses of discomfort. "What Makes Love Last" By John Gottman https://www.amazon.com/What-Makes-Love-Last-audiobook/dp/B0095PES54/ https://www.amazon.com/What-Makes-Love-Last-audiobook/dp/B00...: The underlying premise of this book is that love, friendship etc., are based on trust. It relates some of it to game theory in a way that really clicked with me. "Becoming The Kind Father" by Calvin Sandborn https://www.amazon.com/Becoming-Kind-Father-Sons-Journey/dp/B00KQ207HI/ https://www.amazon.com/Becoming-Kind-Father-Sons-Journey/dp/...: This really helped me connect with my internal voice and taught me that it's ok to create a group of people you can communicate your upset feelings with and how to manage that. There were a bunch of books that I read to understand how important physicality is to all of this. I can't think of one particular one to call out. You need to sleep enough, eat well, get some movement, and get some meditation. There are some other physical things that are helpful. I see a somatic therapist and we do therapy while she works on my body. Of all of the therapy I've ever done, it's the best. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BFqotaIc3Dw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BFqotaIc3Dw this before bedtime has been a game changer.
- civilized 5y agoThis is a common type of HN thread where the linked article is pretty bad, but the headline topic is interesting enough that people want to comment on it from their own experience. In this case, every single comment (100% as of this posting) is a riff on the headline topic and says nothing at all about the content of the article. Well, I will say one thing about the article. It summarily dismisses Stephen Covey's Seven Habits as nothing special, without engaging the content of the book in the slightest, and criticizes Covey for not talking about racism and sexism. If you want this article and its writer in a nutshell, there you go. There are a ton of articles like this out there, even on this exact topic of ridiculing self-help from the compulsive, perfunctory woke standpoint that dominates our elite media culture. This one was very middle-of-the-fairway. The best I can say about it is that it contained a tiny bit of history, and we were spared the usual exhortations to adopt more collectivist politics. (In their prescriptions for America, the writers always talk exclusively about politics, never even thinking about what people could be doing differently in their own families, friendships, neighborhoods and communities. Slaves to individualism in their own way, they would never imagine that anything but the State can save us.) Frankly, these dull, robotically woke articles from legacy media are a much more nauseating aspect of this cultural moment than bad self-help books. And Seven Habits is more worth your time than anything this author will ever say.
- TrispusAttucks 5y agoAgreed. These articles are becoming a formulaic bad trope. 1. Grab some classic American media. 2. Look at it through a perverted lens it wasn't meant to address. 3. Decry this lack of coverage as some evil ploy to suppress an outgroup. Seven habits is a great book that anyone would be better for having read.
- civilized 5y agoI'd love a poll of black businessmen to see how many of them think Seven Habits is worthless because it lacks explicit criticism of racism. I bet Covey has given them more of a leg up than a thousand woke hacks.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 5y ago> was to enshrine the central myth of early America—that the origins and long-term viability of the American experiment rested on the image of “the yeoman farmer as patriot and model citizen.” It's not a myth. It's the truth about early America. Big businesses really didn't arrive in force until after the Civil War.
- pmoriarty 5y agoFor an excellent book on this see "The Dark Side of the Light Chasers".[1] [1] - https://www.amazon.com/Dark-Side-Light-Chasers-Reclaiming/dp/1594485259 https://www.amazon.com/Dark-Side-Light-Chasers-Reclaiming/dp...