8 ms·
Barclays stops UK clients from sending funds to Binance
- varispeed 5y agoIt's no longer your money if you cannot spend it as you wish.
- johneth 5y agoSo it's not your money if you can't spend it supporting, for example, terrorism?
- thedudeabides5 5y agoMaybe it’s not a binary thing of “your money is free or not free” but rather it is and always has been on a scale. There have always been things it hasn’t been ok to purchase, but as per comments above, it’s the ability to enforce these whims on a global scale that’s new
- elric 5y agoSpending money on illegal things, is illegal. Spending money on dubious things, is not. I'm sure crypto exchanges and the like are illegal in some parts of the world. But it isn't clear to me whether that's the case in the UK. The argument here, presumably, is that banks shouldn't have a policing function. You can choose to (dis)agree with that, but it's a valid argument.
- pfisherman 5y agoThis is a rather facile statement. States going back to antiquity have maintained the right to prohibit certain transactions. For example, you cannot legally buy or sell people most places in the world. Likewise the marketplace for many hazardous substances - such as explosives - is tightly controlled.
- yaa_minu 5y agoExcept this is neither a state prohibition nor about explosives.
- notapenny 5y agoStrictly its not state since the FCA operates separately from the UK government, but they do have quite some authority in regulating financial markets. So a body regulating the market on behalf of the state is doing the prohibiting. I don't know about the legalities, but it may well be that banks have little choice but to comply versus going against the regulator. Though Barclays' line about "we want to protect your money" is a bit much.
- cblconfederate 5y agoNo they haven't really. The state control of money is very recent concept, post gold-standard. States and empires even rarely had their own coin. The opium war was less than 200 years ago. Even passports werent enforced until WW1. Control on the scale we have today was never possible , for technical reasons
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- notahacker 5y agoState control of customs and excise pre-dates the Magna Carta, so the English state has devoted resources to chasing participants in transactions it deems unlawful for several hundred years. Modern money laundering controls weren't possible until electronic money and record keeping, but then for related technical reasons it was much harder to evade the primitive controls they did have.
- chalst 5y agoThis is not very accurate. In ancient times, mints frequently adulterated the content of coins, so coins were usually worth more within the kingdom or empire than outside it. Gold was not the ubiquitous denominator of value: silver was widely used in ancient times. Generally empires needed coins to pay armies so gold and silver mines had strategic value. In medieval times, this was the story in Christendom, although interestingly the Islamic world was associated with mints that did not adulterate their coins, which therefore kept their value outside the Islamic world and were much sought after in China. You are right about the recency of passport enforcement.
- robertlagrant 5y agoI have a pound. I wish to spend it on buying your house. Can I assume we have a deal?
- notapenny 5y agoYou're confusing something that's for sale freely with something that's not. Though maybe if you add a few more pounds... But more relevant to the parent's comment; would your bank prevent your from trying to spend that pound?
- Jochim 5y agoShould your bank prevent you from spending that pound if the transaction is for something illicit? If your bank knows you've stolen that pound being used to purchase a legal good/service, should they allow you to spend it?
- Graffur 5y agoMy bank is a place I store money when not using it.. so that it's not in my house or at risk of being stolen. The fact I use the bank as a utility to also spend that money is unfortunate. Thank God (Satoshi) for crypto so that I can spend my money without needing a bank to allow it.
- null_object 5y agoJust a reminder: you don’t need satoshi to spend your money wherever you want. You can just withdraw it from your bank as cash first. Just think this freedom has existed for thousands of years without the need to burn up the planet with meaningless computations as a prerequisite.
- hulahoof 5y agoIn Australia they have moved to BSB cash transactions over $10K, with a stated goal of becoming a cashless society. I wouldn't be so sure this will always be an option.
- rchaud 5y agoIs Binance even a currency exchange if they are limited to electronic transfers?
- justinholmes 5y agoNon paywall https://archive.md/587ZH https://archive.md/587ZH
- The_rationalist 5y agoI am a neophyte, can someone tell me what this imply for the following scenario: Lambda wants to buy a product X for N Bitcoin to a UK based e-seller, and the buyer do the transaction through binance, what happens? Note that in this scenario the buyer is not in the UK.
- celticninja 5y agoYou don't need to use Binance. Binance is one way to buy bitcoin to send to the seller but it is not the only way. If you are not in the UK it makes no material difference to anyone involved in the trade.
- pinkybanana 5y agoBitcoin pretty much always works 100%. It is the fiat that often has problems. In this case the issue is that you can't deposit British Pounds to Binance. If you already converted all your useless fiat currency to various cryptocurrencies, you are safe and free to use your money however you like.
- The_rationalist 5y agoThanks
- dheera 5y agoI pulled all of my tiny amount of funds out of Binance after they had so many bugs in their UI, especially their authentication workflow. Not only did they have bugs, they refused to fix them. Time and time again I would send their support a chat message saying there was a bug and how to reproduce it, and they would always reply asking for my national ID. Fuck that. If you want my ID fix your bugs first. Otherwise I don't trust you with my ID.
- cblconfederate 5y agoAFAIK most banks will close ur account if u use crypto, of course they are not going to fund their competition. Is this different?
- swarnie_ 5y agoI've bought and sold crypto in the UK for years, this is categorically false.
- loeg 5y agoNo - that’s nonsense. Binance specifically has been rejected by UK financial regulators earlier this year.
- luka-birsa 5y agoAn subsidary that Binance bought was banned by UK financial regulators to do business in UK. Not Binance itself. This has been cleared up multiple times, but I guess if you repeat the same lie often enough people start believing it.
- loeg 5y agoDon't assume bad faith. The banned subsidiary is also named Binance.
- grey-area 5y agoHere's the source: https://www.fca.org.uk/news/news-stories/consumer-warning-binance-markets-limited-and-binance-group https://www.fca.org.uk/news/news-stories/consumer-warning-bi... The regulator made it clear that Binance itself, not just the subsidiary was not licensed to pursue any regulated activity in the UK. The confusion (some would say deliberate confusion) has arisen because the application rejected was from BML, but Binance Group itself holds no authorisations to carry out regulated activities with UK customers and has effectively been banned from transacting in the UK. Here is the statement: Binance Markets Limited is not currently permitted to undertake any regulated activities without the prior written consent of the FCA. No other entity in the Binance Group holds any form of UK authorisation, registration or licence to conduct regulated activity in the UK. The Binance Group appear to be offering UK customers a range of products and services via a website, Binance.com. This is why UK banks have banned Binance transactions, it's not a conspiracy, it's not a lie, and you should question which news sources led you to believe it was.
- signal11 5y agoContext: this warning from the UK Financial Regulator: https://www.fca.org.uk/news/news-stories/consumer-warning-binance-markets-limited-and-binance-group https://www.fca.org.uk/news/news-stories/consumer-warning-bi... (Technically the FCA is one of the UK financial regulators, the other being the PRA, but it's the one that deals most with consumer-facing issues.)
- qeternity 5y agoInteresting. I spent the first half of my career trading for hedge funds, and this is the first I've heard of the PRA. Every other registration/certification/interaction I ever had was with the FCA.
- digglet90 5y agoArticles with misleading or exaggerated information have been flowing from the British press on this topic and is clearly (sorry to use the funny jargon) a "co-ordinated FUD campaign". I'm no fan of binance but where are the articles on lack of action on money laundering in legacy banks in the UK? Or other topics like Standard Chartered links to oil investments? This hints at anti-competitive sentiments from a group of "traditional" investors/blatant media outlets who can't keep up with the pace of change. Instead of trusting the FT to manipulate your opinion you can now deal with economic media directly and this is best done via MetaMask or many other similar platforms.
- KaiserPro 5y agoIts more the case that the FSA (mostly the consumer regulator) has specifically warned that binance is not allowed to do financial services in the UK, because they have not got the correct permissions. https://www.fca.org.uk/news/news-stories/consumer-warning-binance-markets-limited-and-binance-group https://www.fca.org.uk/news/news-stories/consumer-warning-bi... Unlike the USA, there is now a fairly healthy investment and consumer banking industry. There are now a number of challenger banks who are able to out innovate the incumbents.
- digglet90 5y agoThis is correct but, crucially, not what was conveyed by the reporting on Binance in almost all of the major news outlets. For example the massively misleading previous headline "Binance banned in the UK" in the FT. The FCA ruling is not really the problem imo, i'm more reacting to the financial press such as FT and the Economist. Cooling down overleveraged small traders about to lose it all on some bad investment is definitely a good thing. However, intentionally misleading people via major newsites including the BBC is not.
- zahllos 5y agoIt isn't about being anticompetitive, it is about regulation, to protect the average consumer from being taken advantage of by unscrupulous people touting scams, and also to protect the government, as the government guarantees deposits up to £85k per person per institution. 'Retail' banks are required to ring-fence certain deposit funds from their more risky investments in an attempt to provide a buffer in the event of another financial crisis and to avoid the need for the government to bail out another bank like Northern Rock. This is on top of the usual requirements for a banking license, rules on capital leverage and the many and varied other rules banks must comply with. Banks are required to and have large audit functions and have automated systems for flagging potential fraud to these teams, and are independently audited as well. This is why they enforce rules like KYC and so on. No system is perfect and certainly some level of money laundering will always slip through, but the idea they are not acting at all is pure fiction, as the regulator has teeth. As sibling comments have pointed out, plenty of 'challenger banks' exist in the UK, e.g. Monzo, although they are not the only one, innovating just fine within the confines of 'legacy' banking. Given the scam that is tether, and the atrocious transaction throughput all cryptocurrencies vs say just the Visa network, plus the fact that through Faster Payments I can move significant sums to any UK account within seconds, I am curious why you feel UK Financial institutions are not keeping up with 'the pace of change', particularly when bitcoin types are shilling a system that reinvents all the problems in the financial system regulation has been enacted to protect against, with no backing and terrible volatility?
- throwaway77384 5y agoI say this in every thread with these sorts of issues: Not your keys, not your crypto. Keep this stuff locally and keep encrypted, non-local backups of your wallets or your wallet seed. That's the best way and insulates you against all these regulatory shenanigans. Hopefully one day there will be a crypto environment rich enough, where states can't hinder the freedom of crypto by putting barriers up between the worlds of crypto and fiat. For now there are other exchanges you can send money to, to buy crypto. I would then still withdraw it to local storage immediately.
- hogFeast 5y agoThe same bank that told regulators to do one when the UK introduced ringfencing (splitting investment from retail banks). I remember there was a story in a paper that someone from the BoE went to talk to management, the BoE told them that Parliament passed a law saying they had to split, and Barclays responded by implying they wouldn't split and would take down the UK economy if they were forced to...you cannot make this up. It is like the Devil being made Pope.
- gadders 5y agoBut they actually did split, though?
- hogFeast 5y agoCorrect. And they are now lobbying aggressively for the ringfence to be removed again (their investment bank is not regarded as economically sustainable as an independent operation).
- zahllos 5y agoI would argue yes and no (for the split). They created two separate legal structures under Barclays PLC, since they had to (https://home.barclays/who-we-are/ring-fencing-explained/ https://home.barclays/who-we-are/ring-fencing-explained/) but as a consumer would you notice? The branding remains the same and the consumer probably doesn't notice when interacting with Barclays. Can't comment on the investment bank situation, but I know they went through a few CEOs a few years back :)
- gadders 5y agoI think they did what they were required to do under the law. They don't have to become two wholly separate companies, just ensure that the investment bank going under doesn't jeopardise the solvency of the retail banking operation. HSBC has done similar.
- LatteLazy 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- X0nic 5y agoNot crypto, not your money.
- basisword 5y ago>> The London-based bank on Monday notified clients of the prohibition on debit and credit payments to Binance, which it said would start immediately and was intended “to help to keep your money safe”. They keep my money safe by holding it securely, not by deciding how I use it. That’s the regulators job and they haven’t banned Binance, just a specific part of the product. Where does this end? If I try to width draw cash will I need to tell Barclays how I intend to spend it?
- cjensen 5y agoThey are not deciding how you use your money. They are deciding which third parties they are willing to send your money to on your behalf. They're happy to send you your money. They just don't want to have any relationship with Binance.
- throwawaysea 5y agoIn the US major banks will sometimes ask you that if you withdraw a large sum or take out a cashiers check. I always tell them it’s not their business and I get back generic lines about how it is for my safety or they’re just trying to help.
- rchaud 5y agoThey ask because most large checks of this kind are real-estate related, and they want to sell you the mortgage on that deal.
- orwin 5y agoThey ask because a fith of 3k to 10k withdrawals are used to pay scammers.
- duxup 5y agoCommunity bank near me does it because they had a number of folks who were getting scammed via some scam calls (family member in jail scam, fake IRS scam, obvious scam 'investments' and so on). They've stopped a handful of scams just by asking the customer what they're doing. For a few of the folks involved the amount of losses would have been devastating financially and certainly emotionally (they're elderly with very limited finances). I know the usual 'the bank wants to sell you something' lines will come up, but it's not hard to just say no, and the teller there might not be Snidely Whiplash...
- andred14 5y agoBoycott them close your accounts. In fact close all bank accounts we don't need them anymore: #liteCASH $CASH https://www.lite-cash.com https://www.lite-cash.com
- digglet90 5y ago"Post-westphalian free market blocked from conducting transfers with financial institution investigated for potential top down fraud case related to the 2008 financial crisis" https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-51593639 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-51593639
- digglet90 5y ago"At its worst, for every £100 the banks had lent, if as little as £3 or £4 failed to be repaid, it might be enough to bankrupt them."
- elric 5y agoSeems like a pretty sound decision, in theory. But in practice, this sort of thing seems to stoke the flames of antiestablishmentarianism. People feel like banks can't be trusted, which means cryptocurrencies gain more popularity (environmental concerns be damned, apparently), which inevitably leads to more shady crypto exchanges, which end up fucking up, which leads to more banks blocking transfers ... and on it goes.