6 ms·
Health insurers are threatening not to cover some patients’ ER bills
- BrianOnHN 5y agoMisaligned incentives. The government I the only entity with the incentive to maintain the health of its citizens. Anything else is a farce.
- tomohawk 5y agoYOU are the only entity with the incentive to maintain your health. The government could care less. It's a giant unfeeling AI that follows rules and incentives laid down by politicians. The overriding concern when government gets involved is cost, not outcomes or quality of care.
- yohannparis 5y agoThis is mostly an U.S.A. point of view. As an European, and now Canadian, of all the countries I lived in, the U.S.A. was the only one who did not think that the health, education, and opportunities of their citizens was good for the nation and more importantly the state.
- BrianOnHN 5y ago> Education Is why they can't connect the dots in the US.
- Retric 5y agoGovernments do have incentives to keep the population healthy, as seen by free covid vaccinations by a GOP administration. The dead don’t pay taxes. The important bit is a lot of healthcare makes minimal difference. People have a huge bias around doing something even if it doesn’t help. Governments on the other hand care a lot more about the cost/benefit from healthcare thus vaccination is considered an obvious win but Medicare puts limits on physical therapy etc.
- makomk 5y agoPaying taxes can only act as an incentive for governments to keep the population healthy if it costs them less than they'll get from that person in taxes - so if you're old, retired, or not able-bodied enough to work, well... (This kinda resembles how the NHS in the UK decides what treatments to fund if you squint, though that's not the official justification.) There's also a lot of pressure to fund treatments of dubious effectiveness for high-profile diseases like cancer which politicians tend to give into because they care about being re-elected, whilst unglamorous but quality-of-life affecting stuff like physical therapy gets deprioritized.
- refurb 5y agoOf course that's not true. I mean, the Netherlands and Switzerland have private insurance for healthcare. Are you saying they have no incentive to maintain their health?!?
- matthewdgreen 5y agoThe Netherlands subsidizes about 75% of healthcare costs using taxpayer money, and implements a system of price controls on private insurers while making coverage mandatory. This would certainly be called nationalized, universal healthcare by the standards of US politics.
- refurb 5y agoIf it’s private insurers and private doctors how can you call it “nationalized”?
- matthewdgreen 5y agoBecause the government stepped in and said “we are going to use the enormous power of the state to make sure every citizen in this country is covered”, whether that involves using private insurance but dictating how and when it can charge, or paying for service directly, or subsidizing costs and then allowing private insurance to administrate. It doesn’t matter to me if you call it “nationalized insurance” or “universal healthcare” or “healthcare that is overwhelmingly funded and controlled by the state but leverages some private components in controlled ways” -— that’s just semantics. All that matters to me is that we don’t try to fool people into thinking that the Netherlands or Sweden have anything like the broken medieval mess we have here in the US, when obviously what they’ve done is radically different.
- refurb 5y agoNationalized means “government owned”. Maybe pick a different word? The govt has strict rules around drug manufacturing but it’s not accurate to say the industry is “nationalized”.
- EMM_386 5y agoI have an unstable shoulder and have been to the ER on a couple of occasions to get it reset. Unbelievably painful and debilitating, but an "emergency"? My life wasn't in danger. There are guides online on how to "handle this yourself". I don't think we want to get started down this road.
- macintux 5y agoI went once when I found a tick in a spot where I couldn’t safely remove it by myself. I felt badly, but they were pretty bored that evening. It’s rather like calling 911 for something that is important or urgent, but perhaps not an emergency. Hard to know where to draw the line.
- matt_the_bass 5y agoYeah I had a similar experience with a secondary infection 11 days after a lion fish sting. I went to my primary care DR as a “sick visit”. After evaluation he said to go to the ER. Since I needed treatment sooner than a schedule procedure could be scheduled, the only option was ER even though I could have waited a day or two. It seems like something between the two would be valuable. At least I had an uncommon condition so nearly every dr and resident on duty came by to check it out. I didn’t get forgotten in the crowd and had some nice chats while waiting for a slot in the imaging schedule.
- Retric 5y agoThe US has urgent care for situations that need attention, but are not hospital worthy. Edit: Infections can be really serious, but “I found a tick in a spot where I couldn’t safely remove it by myself.” and sprained ankles etc don’t need to go to the ER.
- mcherm 5y agoYes, but urgent care would not have been able to address the issue described here. In general urgent care is only qualified to address simple, common illnesses and conditions.
- kishinmanglani 5y agoIt’s incredibly disappointing the government has shown little interest in lowering the cost of healthcare. Instead, elected officials seem obsessed with talking about breaking up big tech and the associated political grandstanding.
- maxpert 5y agoAgreed. The development plans, break big tech, taxing, and other political stunts are useless if foundational issues around education and healthcare are not addressed.
- peteretep 5y agoThat’s a weird framing. One party would introduce single-payer in a heartbeat, the other demonises it. Let’s not pretend we’re talking about “government” as a whole here, rather than the GOP
- kcatskcolbdi 5y agoDidn't President Biden say he would veto Medicare for All if it came across his desk to sign?
- peteretep 5y agohttps://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2020/mar/10/facebook-posts/when-biden-was-asked-if-he-would-veto-medicare-all/ https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2020/mar/10/facebook-p...
- bestcoder69 5y agoWell he’s president now and has not only not pushed for M4A (duh), he also has not pushed for the public option he campaigned on as an alternative.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoIt’s a weird framing when the only way you propose to lower costs is through a revolutionary change which sees major political barriers to actually happening. How about lowering costs anyway? I assure you, there are real and meaningful ways. Start by removing anticompetitive Certificate of Need laws, at the state level.
- dmcgee 5y ago"There isn’t good evidence that people overuse the ER" Have any of the people quoted been in an ER? Even accepting the premise that hospital prices are outrageous for ER visits, walk into any hospital and it should be clear that a lot of the patient population is not there for an "emergency". In the US, the ER acts as a catch all for what often should be handled by social services (some of which don't exist). Drug seeking patients, homeless patients, and patients with mental health issues very often end up in the ER.
- Jare 5y ago> Drug seeking patients, homeless patients, and patients with mental health issues very often end up in the ER. Doesn't sound like those are the kind of patients this insurer is concerned about? Or is it?
- leereeves 5y agoUnited Healthcare administers many Medicaid insurance plans. And many people with drug or mental health issues also have successful careers and private insurance plans. So UHC does pay many of those bills.
- joshgel 5y agoyes! I'd probably argue that a majority (or at least significant plurality) of acute care (hospital care) in the US is the direct result of the failure of social services. I include in this mental health issues directly resulting in poor health, inability to access primary care (so minor/treatable issues become severe), housing issues, drug issues, lack of elder care options, etc.
- whoknowswhat11 5y agoSF general a lot of years ago. I went once and got right back out. I think people were basically living there?
- elliekelly 5y ago> Drug seeking patients, homeless patients, and patients with mental health issues very often end up in the ER. A lot of these people end up in the ER because they don’t have any health insurance at all. But that’s well outside the scope of the “issue” the health insurance company describes in the article. I have had friends and family who had to be dragged to the ER because they didn’t think their situation was enough of an “emergency” but it absolutely was: chest pains were a heart attack in progress and a fever with a stiff neck was a pretty serious infection, for example. How many legitimate emergencies vs “non-emergencies” will be discouraged from receiving ER treatment? I suspect legitimate emergency treatment foregone will be larger (and represent a significantly larger cost savings to the health plan) at the expense of our collective long-term health and well-being.
- peteretep 5y ago> United Healthcare framed the maneuver as a way to contain costs Profit in 2020: $15,403,000,000
- makomk 5y agoThe way US healthcare is structured these days, I think increased costs mean more profits for the insurers - it's their customers as a whole that get screwed.
- tomohawk 5y agoA coworker is a volunteer EMT. The majority of his calls involve going to various homeless encampments. Once there, they have to walk around and figure out who needs help. More often than not, it is a malingerer who is good at pretending. They cannot refuse transport to the emergency room. Once there, the malingerer gets free food and a respite from the heat/cold, which is what they wanted. After the trip, the crew has to delouse themselves and the ambulance, which takes a long time. I'm not a fan of United Healthcare, and would never subject myself to their tender mercies, but why should they and other insurers end up holding the bag for colossal policy failures like the above?
- whoknowswhat11 5y agoThis might explain my SF general experience
- QuesnayJr 5y agoMalingers in homeless emcampments have insurance through United Healthcare?
- eyeball 5y agoYeah, lots of them do. United Healthcare administers Medicaid for many states.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- djakaitis 5y agoYou think these folks are submitting claims to United Healthcare?
- thallium205 5y agoWho do you think runs many state medicaid programs?
- 5y ago
- fundad 5y agoNot mentioned is that they’ve been doing this forever. Private insurers exist to deny reimbursement, the so-called “administration” could be handled by a SAAS billing package.
- eyeball 5y agoA high portion of health insurance claims are automatically adjudicated, but it’s far more complex than you would guess.
- hestefisk 5y agoAnd this, my ladies and gentlemen, is why healthcare shouldn’t be “insured” but a fundamental human right catered for by an essential public utility (universal healthcare).
- swiley 5y agoRoutine healthcare shouldn't be insured, but dealing with unforeseen health problems should. There's no level of coverage that could possibly considered complete so it should be up to the individual to decide how much resources to dedicate to it. The problem with this approach in the US is: 1) Until very recently there was no law requiting even estimated costs for medicine. Since the insurance company always pays for this there was just about no market pressure to lower costs (in other words: we took a "free market" approach without actually having a market.) 2) Insurance is used to cover routine medical procedures. This is the polar opposite of what insurance should be used for. 3) The US has a fairly week social safety net. Most other countries have fairly extensive social programs but in the US people are supposed go ... somewhere. This is probably the case that you're most upset about.
- mindslight 5y ago1) Until very recently there was no law requiting even estimated costs for medicine This is the wrong way to frame it. At the most basic level, forming a contract requires agreeing on consideration. For some reason, medical providers are allowed to create arbitrary post-facto charges and then enforce their baseless fantasies through the legal system, likely due to corrupt state laws. For any meaningful market-based healthcare reform, this and other regulatory capture needs to be addressed.
- paulddraper 5y agoFundamental human rights are based on billing practices?
- tim333 5y agoUh no. I think they are suggesting a fundamental right to healthcare which is a different thing.
- anu7df 5y agoI would argue that ER in the US has long ceased to be useful, unless the patient is wheeled in by police/paramedics. Last week my daughter fell and cut her forehead in a way that required stitches. We went to the nearest children's hospital (a huge one) ER, got triaged (just some gauze) and waited for a doctor. Gave up at the 4 hour mark and walked out. Went to the nearest urgent care clinic, was seen by a doctor in 10 minutes and we're out in 30 minutes after my daughter got the stitches. I am sure we will get billed an astronomical amount for this, but there were no other options. We have good insurance.
- disabled 5y agoI am so sorry that both you and your daughter had this horrible experience. I hope she is feeling better now, and is on the mend.
- anu7df 5y agoYes. Stitches are healing up nicely and she is doing fine. Thanks!
- coding123 5y agoNah, urgent care centers are not astronomical bills. Typically $150 to 250. ER are never less than $1000
- jliptzin 5y agoHe is talking about the gauze at the ER which he will probably be billed at least $1,000 for
- padastra 5y agoAmazing. I agree that the ER was not necessary for your daughter, but am impressed you can extrapolate that one experience to the entire set of patients with heart failure, pneumonia, sepsis, pyelonephritis, appendicitis, intestinal obstruction, gastrointestinal bleeds, electrolyte disorders, fractures, NSTEMIs, and many others who are not wheeled in by police / paramedics but need urgent complex diagnostics and imaging. What deep understanding and wisdom you hold, and with such high confidence too.
- kingsuper20 5y agoIt's weird that urgent care clinics aren't parked right next to the ER and that the urgent care clinics aren't 24x7. No doubt this occurs sometimes but I've never seen it. Anecdata. My wife says that most people at the ER don't need an ER. Of course they serve as a primary healthcare for the homeless.
- muaytimbo 5y agoMy girlfriend is a physician in the ER at the largest hospital in Philadelphia and her informed opinion is that very few of the cases she sees are truly “emergent”.
- cableshaft 5y agoI would happily go to Urgent Care for more things (and have gone enough times, used to basically be my PCP back in the day), but there are certain things that if I go there they just say "We don't have the ability to do these tests, go to ER". So now I paid an extra $100-150 just to be told to go to ER anyway. I don't go to Urgent Care for those things anymore (heart attack scares that end up being heartburn with heart attack symptoms, for example). There's also the issue that most Urgent Cares around here aren't 24/7, so if it happens late at night (like after 9pm), ER is all you got.
- Clubber 5y agoI agree, but the problem is the decision as to the level of care necessary is ultimately up to the person needing care. Normal people have no idea what their ailment is, much less what level of care they need. I try to steer clear of the ER at all times. If I'm not functioning enough to be able to make that decision, it's probably time for the ER. Just a personal philosophy. I had a girlfriend years ago who made me take her to the ER because her stomach really hurt. We waited for 8 hours and by the time she got seen, her stomach didn't hurt. I could have strangled her.
- andyana 5y agoI bet a butter knife could have cut the tension during the drive home.
- stefan_ 5y agoI'm just building CRUD software and I don't scoff at the kinda stuff people report as bugs, particularly non-technical users. But working in an ER and judging people for being unable to judge the severity of their ailments? That borders on sociopath lack of empathy.
- ericwooley 5y agoI'm a little confused by this article. Around 2010, I separated my shoulder and couldn't move my arm. I went to the er and got checked out. A few days later the insurance company called and said they didn't want to pay for the visit because "it wasn't an emergency". I very calmly explained that their position was nonsense, and I went to the ER because I COULDN'T MOVE MY ARM. Eventually the insurance agreed the ER was justified. According to this article, it sounds like this would be a new behavior for insurance companies. But it seems to me like they are just making this behavior official now.
- GoodJokes 5y agoThreatening? Haven’t they been not covering for years and years and year.
- hakfoo 5y agoIt's hard to say the ER is overused because most of us are not medically qualified to decide what constitutes an emergency. A heart attack, an infected gallbladder, and heavy duty heartburn present similarly enough that the suffering patient can't be expected to walk himself down a diagnostic flowchart. But if we could get proper diagnostics and triage in before admissuions and a lot of other resource allocation, it might improve results. I could see adding the a bank of triage experts "in front" of the ER. The ambulance, of course, skips this phase, but if you come in conscious and able to walk in, they can perform some basic checks before admission, and turn away some patients as better served by urgent care. Maybe this costs some modest flat rate, billed sort of like a repairman who doesn't charge for the trip and diagnosis if you get actual repairs performed. I suppose then you get into a related matter-- once you're at the hospital, being told to go somewhere else means "get back in the car and travel to the strip mall urgent care elsewhere" which would lead to frustration and delay.