4 ms·
> mRNA can only be used to make the body make proteins that, well, the body can make. This might seem obvious, but it’s a pretty key part of where Moderna’s “so
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> mRNA can only be used to make the body make proteins that, well, the body can make. This might seem obvious, but it’s a pretty key part of where Moderna’s “software of life” analogy falls flat. It’s a limited software with limited toolkits. You’re not going to use mRNA in humans to make, say, an antibiotic that’s naturally produced in fungi.
Hmm? I keep hearing about plants and bacteria that have been genetically modified to secrete e.g. animal proteins. Do fungi assemble their proteins from a different set of amino acids than animals do?
- ejstronge 5y agoAntibiotics are not necessarily proteins but can be arbitrary ‘small molecules’ which could require a suite of enzymes instead of just one enzyme
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- manwe150 5y agoI don’t see that exact quote, but the article seems to be a list of many of the reasons just inserting the same mRNA sequence may not work as desired. To compare contextually also, researchers now spend substantial effort to teach simple monocellular organisms to produce various proteins of interest, because the pathway and other influences in the cell can influence whether it is translated and how the protein folds.
- G3rn0ti 5y agoPlants and bacteria lack an immune system like the human‘s. Fully fledged immune systems with antibodies, T killer cells and B memory cells is something mammals „invented“.
- vinay427 5y agoYour point of course stands, but from what I can tell (as someone very much not an expert, i.e. glad to be corrected), the history of the adaptive immune system is far more continual and definitely precedes mammals, with the "fully-fledged" versions found in early vertebrates and some mechanisms preceding that as well. The abstract here seems quite well-written: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2919748/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2919748/
- passivate 5y ago> I keep hearing about plants and bacteria that have been genetically modified to secrete e.g. animal proteins. Do fungi assemble their proteins from a different set of amino acids than animals do? You're correct that the genetic code is _almost_ universal, and we do use mammalian expression platforms without problems. However, using a live human to express a protein that we normally never do is a bit of an ethical problem due to the associated risk. You don't want a partial expression or maybe a protein gets cleaved and turns into a toxin, or is misfolded and then ends up killing the host or causing a fatal disease (hello prions!), etc, etc. (Source: Just stuff I picked up at work, I'm not an expert on these topics)
- unanswered 5y ago> using a live human to express a protein that we normally never do is a bit of an ethical problem due to the associated risk Wait, so are you saying there's an ethical problem with triggering the expression of a strictly viral protein known to cause damage in and of itself?
- passivate 5y ago>Wait, so are you saying there's an ethical problem with triggering the expression of a strictly viral protein known to cause damage in and of itself? :) We're discussing the expression of therapeutics. But, it is true that if you could control the process there would be no ethical problem. But it never is so simple. The cute analogies and diagrams (I do think they are useful for beginners) don't convey the real risks of the technology. Its really hard to wrap your brain around it, at-least for me, even after working in vaccines for close to a decade now I can only grasp a very limited amount of the complexity of our internals.
- thehappypm 5y agoThere is, which is why it took so fucking long for these vaccines to get approved, they needed to be strenuously tested for safety and efficacy among tens of thousands of volunteers.
- 5y ago
- twic 5y agoI believe this a reply to klevertree's comment, rather than the article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27682445 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27682445
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thaumasiotes 5y agoAh. It's not really a response to klevertree's comment, but it is a response to the article klevertree links, rather than the article at the head of the page.
- f6v 5y agoA protein is often not just amino acids, but also a bunch of so-called post-translational modifications(PTM). These could be carbohydrates that have distinct functional roles, e.g. targeting. Members of different kingdoms have distinct PTMs which makes it difficult to just make a bacteria produce human protein. But bacteria you can modify genetically, human - not so much.
- dekhn 5y agothe statement as written is not specific enough to be useful. We certainly have moved genes and entire synthetic pathways between organisms.