17 ms·
Can someone explain (preferably steel man) the GOP argument here?
by freedomben 5y ago
Can someone explain (preferably steel man) the GOP argument here?
- lvspiff 5y agoNineteen states currently have laws limiting and in some cases effectively prohibiting municipalities from offering commercial services on broadband networks. Most of them did so under the guise of constructing and operating community broadband networks requires taking on public debt via bond offerings, tying up money that could otherwise have been used for public safety, public pensions, roads and other infrastructure.
- DudeInBasement 5y agoGreat steel man run down. It's hard to compete against tax cows.
- mistrial9 5y agonot involved, not a lawyer here - there is a theory in local US law about "regulated monopoly of municipal services" .. related to the way relatively expensive infrastructure is built, who pays for that, and who has rights to revenue and who has rights to do business on the infrastructure. It has been ruled in most places that I know of, that certain utilities like water are in this category, but also sometimes things like garbage collection. The reason is that it does cost capital to build acceptable infrastructure, and also the services are less expensive to the consumer when a single business can recoup their costs over a longer period of time. naturally, corruption and cronyism also thrive in this environment, seeking long-term returns as vendor lock-in. The amounts of money over years, plus the security of income, can be very attractive to certain parties. I suspect that this background affects the debate and policy, but generally, political talking points do not rely on precedent and fact, more the emotions and loyalties.. no idea on that
- legerdemain 5y ago- Municipal broadband is a government handout. It artificially lowers prices. - Municipal broadband expands the role of government. It's an extra program for the municipality to manage. - Expanding government programs is a tax on residents, even if they don't benefit from broadband access. - Municipal broadband is hostile to business. Companies cannot reasonably compete with a service that the government pumps money into.
- psychometry 5y agoWell done. Not one of those is even a little bit reasonable, but I could totally imagine your standard Repub attempting to argue those points.
- fooker 5y agoWhy are none of these reasonable?
- Retric 5y agoFor one municipal broadband can be profitable without subsidies. It can be run by local governments but can also be spun off after the infrastructure is built etc.
- bduerst 5y agoAlso the state government stepping in to block city governments in the name of "stopping government expansion" is actually government expansion. Let the municipal governments dictate how they govern themselves with their own infrastructure.
- edrxty 5y agoThey're not unreasonable at face value (obviously, that's how the game works) but they're entirely in bad faith as none stand up to any real scrutiny. US political discourse is about boiling a complex system down to feel good talking points that sound snazzy and evoke strong emotions. "government handout" leading language, no substance various "expands government" also leading, still no substance/data "hostile to business" obviously, that's the point. Private enterprise has failed here and created a number the most customer hostile organizations in existence.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> they're entirely in bad faith as none stand up to any real scrutiny The expansion of the role of government bit is not nothing. Yes, there is a cozy relationship between the federal government, many state governments and ISPs. But municipal broadband makes it much easier for e.g. the Louisville police department to influence how much of what type of information is collected on whom, and under what circumstances it may be shared. I support municipal broadband. Any competition is good competition. But it's disingenuous to write off the concerns so quickly.
- amznthrwaway 5y agoIf individual voters have contact with a portion of the government that performs well and offers good value, it undermines the Republican effort to vilify all publicly provided services. There are other talking points, but making municipal actions illegal also stands against GOP talking points around local government and control. It’s just an attempt to make sure people don’t like their government; because liking government is a gateway drug to voting against Republicans.
- justinzollars 5y agoThis GOP argument is the capitalist argument. It also often overlaps with centrist Democrats like the Clinton/neoliberal view. The government is not productive. The Government can't create broadband because the government doesn't actually create anything. But the government can implement a mandate, for something like "broadband for all". It sounds great, but it will fall short. The Government will inefficiently allocates resources leading to downtime and shortages. The free market allocates resources properly and will provide better and less expensive broadband internet, at no cost to the tax payer.
- dr-detroit 5y agoThe infrastructure is/was built with our tax dollars. But GOP are freeloader culture they dont want to pay me back just take take take and then blame it on the blue place.
- jliptzin 5y agoSo then why institute a ban? If opponents are so confident that the private sector will do such a good job, let the municipality compete with private providers and offer residents the choice, see who wins.
- Grimm1 5y agoLargely because you’re running that experiment at the expense of tax payers.
- akomtu 5y agoIt's the taxpayers who want it and vote for this experiment.
- Grimm1 5y agoClearly not all of them or we wouldn’t be in this thread discussing it under this particular OP. I don’t care either way though I was just working through what the GOP logic likely is. Not representing my own opinion.
- barney54 5y ago* There is a limited role for government. For example, government should provide public goods, but should not be in the business of competing with private businesses. * There is no need to have government involved in the provision of broadband (or phone service or cable TV).
- winstonewert 5y agoI think I can articulate the argument: In order to ensure the best outcome for consumers, we want customers to have a variety of competing options for broadband service. That way they can select the option which gives them the best cost/value proposition. No individual provider can abuse or take advantage of customers, because they can just switch to another provider. Municipal broadband, by its nature, is incompatible with this competition. Such service is at least partially taxpayer funded which means that everyone pays for it whether they use it or not. Further, the city controls access to the corridors needed for providing internet service. The consequence is that the city ISP would have a great advantage over other ISPs, preventing any real competition. The case then is that we need to ban city-run ISPs so as to promote competition amongst ISPs in order to ensure the best service. However: I'm not sure of a good defense of forbidding it at the state level, instead of allowing individual municipalities to make their own decisions. Furthermore, I'm not sure of a good defense ensuring competition by forbidding public isps but not also requiring cities to make it easy for new isps to enter markets by giving access to corridors.
- philjohn 5y agoThat's all well and good, but 88.3m americans are only served by a single ISP. The market has resoundingly failed to work.
- asteroidbelt 5y agoThe response to this should measures to increase competition rather than government managed providers which kill competition even further. For example: * fewer regulations * additional taxes for monopolies * tax subsidies for new internet providers
- yazaddaruvala 5y agoBy and large, thank you for the argument it’s well articulated. The one thing I want to no clarify, > Such service is at least partially taxpayer funded which means that everyone pays for it whether they use it or not. If the muni-broadband increases competition from 1 to two, and reduces costs for everyone, then even if some tax payer that fund the muni-broadband don’t use it actively, they do benefit from its existence.
- steve76 5y agoYou can get me online. But you can't stop the murders stop the thieves stop the arson stop the ODs stop the corrupt feds from using military intelligence weapons on me stop your Marxist friends from mass murdering millions with a bioweapon Asia in the sixties left everyone else alone. Greatest economic boom in history. More people out of poverty than ever. Limit the violence. Stand up to the criminals. Enforce the law. That's all you have to do. Once you drop the fantasy of unchecked celebrity ambition, everyone lives better and makes much better decisions. If you want to go into the internet business, go into the internet business. If you want to govern others, govern others. Why do you just light up when it comes to telling people to build servers and run wire, but then just go mute when some murderer is raping and killing everyone?
- antattack 5y agoGovernment employees tend to vote Democrat.
- fuzzylightbulb 5y agocitation needed
- antattack 5y agoPoll: Biden Leads Trump Among Federal Workforce by 28% https://www.govexec.com/workforce/2020/09/poll-biden-leads-trump-among-federal-workforce-28/168581/ https://www.govexec.com/workforce/2020/09/poll-biden-leads-t... Democrats Lead Ranks of Both Union and State Workers https://news.gallup.com/poll/146786/democrats-lead-ranks-union-state-workers.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/146786/democrats-lead-ranks-uni...
- Jtsummers 5y agoI suspect that Trump's policies working against the federal workforce may have skewed those results. For an example, see this: https://www.govexec.com/pay-benefits/2020/02/white-house-revives-controversial-retirement-cut-proposals/163015/ https://www.govexec.com/pay-benefits/2020/02/white-house-rev... Not sure about state and local government employees.
- dfxm12 5y agoThe proposed law was reportedly "inserted without prior public discussion," and no state senator publicly sponsored the amendment. They aren't even trying to make an argument, since they aren't owning up to it. Maybe they were either just hoping it would sneak by with no one noticing, or they just let the ISP lobby write it and didn't bother to read it themselves.
- akomtu 5y agoAnother argument I've seen on redstate (a GOP news agency): "and the left keep shifting goalposts of what speed is considered broadband, they say you need 1 Gbps, while a typical video stream fits in 3 Mbps, and reality is that 25 down / 5 up is a great speed!" I guess the big ISPs don't forget to donate to GOP.
- wonderwonder 5y agoPrivate broadband contributes / donates to Republican politicians. Private broadband does not want municipal broadband. https://www.theverge.com/2017/3/29/15100620/congress-fcc-isp-web-browsing-privacy-fire-sale https://www.theverge.com/2017/3/29/15100620/congress-fcc-isp...
- gameswithgo 5y agoIt is a perfectly normal GOP position to be against a government service that isn't police or military. What is kind of weird is when the GOP bans at say, a state level, something some cities might want to do. This does run counter to some of the other GOP political ideas, that local governments should be free to make their own decisions and not hampered by state or federal government. Perhaps they are worried that municipal broadband will be popular and thus spread, if cities are allowed to do it, which then would threaten some of their donations, and some of their fundamental ideas.
- ZoomerCretin 5y agoThe public argument or the private argument? The private argument is that it lowers profits for the corporations who give them campaign contributions.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nitwit005 5y agoDespite all the discussion here, the real answer seems to be that there is no such argument. As the article notes, they won't even admit they're in favor of it: > The proposed law was reportedly "inserted without prior public discussion," and no state senator publicly sponsored the amendment. It's purely a favor to industry slipped in by some senator.
- justin66 5y agoAs it's a conservative measure [0] and as we're talking about the Ohio Senate here, it's entirely possible it was inserted into legislation by someone who might or might not know how to read and written entirely by ALEC. [1] [0] nominally conservative. Ohio conservatives give a lot of lip service to "home rule" authority for municipalities. Broadband is one of several areas including LGBT measures and civil rights, oil and gas drilling, education policy, voting, and basically anything you could name where they violate their stated principles of home rule without any apparent irony when the mood strikes. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Legislative_Exchange_Council https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Legislative_Exchange_...
- fungiblecog 5y agoWe get money from businesses to oppose measures that would harm those businesses. End of.
- cortesoft 5y agoThe other arguments in the replies here covered a lot of it, but one other that I didn’t see is that it is unfair to the broadband companies who built out networks. The argument goes, the broadband company spent a lot of capital to build out a network, but they can’t compete with a government run system that doesn’t have to make a profit. It is an interesting argument, but I don’t find it compelling. I think internet access is a public good.