18 ms·
Ohio GOP ends attempt to ban municipal broadband after protest from residents
- dr-detroit 5y agoTake my access to voting I don't care just keep your hands off my facebook dopamine drip and high speed pornography.
- threatofrain 5y ago> As we wrote earlier this month, the Ohio Senate approved a version of the budget containing an amendment that would have forced existing municipal broadband services to shut down and prevented the formation of new public networks. The proposed law was reportedly "inserted without prior public discussion," and no state senator publicly sponsored the amendment. > It was approved in a party-line vote as Democrats opposed the restrictions in municipal broadband.
- CameronNemo 5y agoHow can an amendment get proposed without a legislator publicly sponsoring it? That is insanity.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dvtrn 5y agoBallot initiatives are one way it happens in some states. A means for the population to ask their legislators to enact a law or statute absent the legislature making such a proposal on their own.
- kissickas 5y agoThis is an amendment to a bill.
- dvtrn 5y agoI’m aware of that. I was answering the question that was asked, not intimating this was the way it happened in Ohio.
- ummonk 5y agoThe question was "How can an amendment get proposed without a legislator publicly sponsoring it?". You did not answer that question.
- dvtrn 5y agohttps://www.ncsl.org/research/elections-and-campaigns/initiative-referendum-and-recall-overview.aspx https://www.ncsl.org/research/elections-and-campaigns/initia...
- IncRnd 5y agoSorry. That's different kind of amendment. I don't think you've read what people have written to you. You are misunderstanding the subject of "amendment to a bill". PS Intimating is the wrong word. I think you meant infer instead of imply.
- perl4ever 5y ago>You are misunderstanding the subject of "amendment to a bill" Probably. >PS Intimating is the wrong word. I think you meant infer instead of imply. ...no, I don't think they did? They denied implying anything about Ohio. Incidentally, it seems like the usage of both imply and intimate in this way comes from about the same time, ~1580s.
- emodendroket 5y ago
- bluejekyll 5y agoI had the same question, I found this site to try and answer it: https://legislature.ohio.gov/publications/rules-of-the-senate https://legislature.ohio.gov/publications/rules-of-the-senat... I read everything that mentions amendments, and it appears that they either must come out of committees, or be sponsored by a single senator. It looks like the Clerk would know who sponsored an amendment. Though, I'm not sure how this plays in, but at least one of the rules specifically says, "This rule does not apply to the President Pro Tempore, the Majority Floor Leader, the Minority Leader, or the Assistant Minority Leader of the Senate," in regards to limits on number of amendments to a bill. My guess is that it's not "anonymous" in the sense that no-one knows who added it, but that it's not "transparent", i.e. came out of a committee or was put in by one of the leaders (above) in the Senate. I'm sure they know who added it, the question is do they have to tell anyone (they should have to for government transparency).
- cat199 5y agoseems like a clear case where version controlling & signing changes to draft legislation would be useful
- TeeMassive 5y agoAs a Canadian I've always found it weird (and worrisome to some extent) that the two dominating political parties in America go all the way up from the Presidency to all the way down to municipal politics. I mean the term "conservative mayor" is pretty much unheard of in terms of party lines.
- ur-whale 5y agoIf only that was the only weird thing about American politics.
- ramraj07 5y agoAll fine and dandy but you do see the irony of a Canadian showing American problems with legislation affecting broadBand speeds right? Canada has one of the shittiest broadband scenes of any developed country! And it probably ties directly to the systemic problems Canada faces, just like the US and every other country does. No place is heaven, only that most developed countries put in sufficient social nets before the internet came so they're more livable than the US.
- pbourke 5y ago> I mean the term "conservative mayor" is pretty much unheard of in terms of party lines. Is that true? The current mayor of Toronto was the leader of the Ontario PC party.
- TeeMassive 5y agoYes, he can be conservative as in the political philosophy, but not in the sense of being a member of the Conservative Party of Canada.
- freedomben 5y agoCan someone explain (preferably steel man) the GOP argument here?
- lvspiff 5y agoNineteen states currently have laws limiting and in some cases effectively prohibiting municipalities from offering commercial services on broadband networks. Most of them did so under the guise of constructing and operating community broadband networks requires taking on public debt via bond offerings, tying up money that could otherwise have been used for public safety, public pensions, roads and other infrastructure.
- DudeInBasement 5y agoGreat steel man run down. It's hard to compete against tax cows.
- mistrial9 5y agonot involved, not a lawyer here - there is a theory in local US law about "regulated monopoly of municipal services" .. related to the way relatively expensive infrastructure is built, who pays for that, and who has rights to revenue and who has rights to do business on the infrastructure. It has been ruled in most places that I know of, that certain utilities like water are in this category, but also sometimes things like garbage collection. The reason is that it does cost capital to build acceptable infrastructure, and also the services are less expensive to the consumer when a single business can recoup their costs over a longer period of time. naturally, corruption and cronyism also thrive in this environment, seeking long-term returns as vendor lock-in. The amounts of money over years, plus the security of income, can be very attractive to certain parties. I suspect that this background affects the debate and policy, but generally, political talking points do not rely on precedent and fact, more the emotions and loyalties.. no idea on that
- legerdemain 5y ago- Municipal broadband is a government handout. It artificially lowers prices. - Municipal broadband expands the role of government. It's an extra program for the municipality to manage. - Expanding government programs is a tax on residents, even if they don't benefit from broadband access. - Municipal broadband is hostile to business. Companies cannot reasonably compete with a service that the government pumps money into.
- luke2m 5y agoThank goodness. My town has muni, but I’m still waiting to get it out to my area.
- throwawaymanbot 5y agoI think everyone is missing the point here. The point of municipal broadband is not to Run efficiently, but to keep the ATTs of the world HONEST! -- IF ATT and the rest did, there would be zero need for it. Europe shows that somebody needs to keep the "Capitalists" honest. If this is how its done. so be it. the ATTs of this industry, spend more time lobbying for laws to make enable them to charge people more for less. Its laughable, and bad for the US.
- slownews45 5y agoThe US (and its companies) will COMPLETELY dominate Europe in IT under the US's capitalist model. It's not going to be close I'm afraid. The EU is busy making rules about super complex cookie banners (largely pointless - just block / expire / delete cookies browser side). Meanwhile, I expect US (and likely chinese companies long term - see Tiktok / Zoom etc) to absolute dominate global market. What are the big EU websites being used globally? I can think of a ton of apps and more with global usage from US and China. Things like WhatsApp are being used for GOVT services internationally (!). We will see how the EU's efforts plays out globally. I'm skeptical personally.
- simion314 5y agoProbably OP was thinking at services like ISP, cable and mobile providers. I do not see US ISP or mobile companies have a chance to compete in EU markets.
- slownews45 5y agoWe'll see - it's been fun watching Oneweb vs SpaceX where this battle for global dominance will play out in part. EU again seems to be focusing on basically red tape as a way to slow folks down - if you follow EU's Oneweb protests they look pretty weak. Even the near miss stuff was weak. https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/SpaceX-OW-Ex-Parte.pdf https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/Space... In terms of ISPs a somewhat fair point domestically. That said, internationally I see I lot more penetration of US fiber deployments (think google / AWS / Microsoft / Facebook, US based CDNs for content distro, Netflix etc etc) Locally - ATT and Comcast both offering competitive service. AT&T FIBER 1000Mbps connection + HBO Max™ - $60 /mo. Comcast Up to 1200 Mbps Download Speeds $84.99 / $129 Rural is a big challenge in US. Not sure EU really has the same type of market (ie, Alaska). If so and we are getting $35/mo for gig - then that is a unique setup. But again, internationally I do expect US companies to continue to perform OK even in the connectivity space.
- pyrophane 5y agoI worry that when things like this happen, the real lesson legislators take away is to be be more sneaky about it next time.
- ianlevesque 5y agoYou are right to worry. Remember net neutrality? Those were the days.
- handrous 5y agoIn my state there was a ballot measure passed by a large margin (by voting standards, anyway). The legislature hated it (it had to do with making gerrymandering harder, among other things), so they introduced another ballot measure ASAP that read like did a couple very minor things that seem like good ideas, provided you don't think about them too much, and that was what the ballot measure highlighted—but also entirely undid the most important parts of the prior measure. It passed by like 1%. They lied and got what they wanted. 0% chance a version of that with honest language would have passed.
- nijave 5y agoSomeone aptly mentioned in the Ars thread, Ohio runs an ISP--OARnet and it's pretty successful
- draw_down 5y agoThis was such madness for them to do. Love that freedom.
- pram 5y agoWould the broadband situation today be better or worse had the Bell System been left in place as a monopoly, with the “universal service” mandate?
- gumby 5y agoThe current broadband monopolies/duopolies are strangling the US broadband markets (which lag the rest of the OECD), but I think a bell world would have been even worse (and I'm a Bell system fan!). One good thing would be that the bell system really pursued universal service, and did its best to raise the service quality floor (e.g. they did install, or take over party lines, but also did the work to eliminate such service for individual lines). The QoS requirements in city center (how many times they are allowed to have someone pick up a phone and have no dial tone; how much capacity they needed to provision (the famous Erlang unit) and so on) were the same for almost every subscriber. And even "disconnected" phone lines would still make a 911 call. BUT The flip side of what I said was true too: they didn't deploy a service unless they could tariff it and had to. They had a circuit-switched mentality and could't deal with packet-switched architectures that didn't have a tollbooth. They deployed ISDN and considered that an adequate data service. Their regulation and tariffing also lead to mistakes. For example the price to make a call was typically fixed and regulated by state regulators. Thus calls to mobile phones were the same as non-mobile phones with the person walking around paying for the radio charge (there was less capacity) because they were the ones benefiting for the convenience. This is why mobile phone numbers look the same as fixed ones in the USA. In Europe they went the opposite way: reciving a call on a mobile device was free (just like receiving one on a landline) while calling a mobile number cost extra. Thus mobile numbers had different area codes so the caller could tell. This lead to a huge uptake of mobile phones in the GSM territory while the US mobile providers were stuck in their old bell mentality, causing the US to be 10-15 years behind in mobile calling and SMS.
- fcantournet 5y agoDepends on how the mandate is specified / enforced. But generally speaking : broadband is infrastructure & utility = natural monopoly. Same applies to electric grid & production btw. Way better results to be had this way then false competition.
- mtnGoat 5y agoI love when voters voices are louder than lobbyists money. Always good to see elected officials grow a spine and actually represent the will of the electorate.
- mywittyname 5y agoThe politicians understand that the size of the bribe is directly proportional to the amount of public pressure against a measure. Lobbyists know to cough up more money next round.
- mtnGoat 5y agoSadly, this is probably very true, they will rinse and repeat with a deeper war chest.
- PostThisTooFast 5y agoWhy are Republicans such unmitigated pieces of shit?
- idownvoted 5y agoAww, I love those objective headlines. Aren't "residents" always the ones protesting? Well, while the headline isn't objective at least it has an objective: making us think that every Ohioan was protesting it.