9 ms·
So how does this explain why Windows 10, which I have paid like $150 for per license, is now infested with ads, tracking and online presence - and close to impo
by XorNot 5y ago
So how does this explain why Windows 10, which I have paid like $150 for per license, is now infested with ads, tracking and online presence - and close to impossible to buy without that. They aren't even trying to put a $ figure on what they think it's worth - because they can't be stopped from doing it.
There is no implied agreement, it's exactly as stated.
- 6502nerdface 5y agoI guess someone could argue that it only costs $150 because of the ads. Windows 95 cost well over twice that when it was launched (inflation adjusted). Maybe in the same way that airfares are way cheaper than they were in the 90s, but with much crappier included service.
- jonathankoren 5y agoLet’s be honest though. Windows is supported through OEM licenses. M$ (yeah, I’m dusting this off here, due to the context) isn’t strapped for cash.
- chrisweekly 5y agoscrapped -> strapped
- jonathankoren 5y ago¯\_(ツ)_/¯ I’m on mobile. Whatever
- esperent 5y agoHow many more copies of windows 10 were sold compared to Windows 95?
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoHow many more engineers work on Windows 10 compared to Windows 95?
- rawsta 5y agoI don't think that many. Afaik they closed some teams and replaced them with some automated Tests and stuff. So it's not unthinkable that there were eben less engineers on win10 than on winXP.
- fny 5y agoThey're = being leaches. Sure Windows 95 is expensive, but so were PCs. If you look at inflation adjusted OS prices, you'll see significant declines that reflect a lot of competition: - Windows 95 was $210 in 1995: $370.94 in today's dollars. - Windows XP was $199 in 2002: $297.78 in today's dollars. - Windows 7 was $159.99 in 2009: $200.75 in today's dollars.
- stjohnswarts 5y agopretty sure I gave like $50 for a license for win95
- privacythrow1 5y agoCertainly the costs in the 90s were tied directly to physical distribution and comparatively lesser market demand. Whereas nowadays digital distribution is king and market demand is ubiquitous. I'd consider those factors to be responsible for driving prices down before I'd give a multinational corporation credit for allowing me to use their product (that I paid for) in return for pervasive advertising.
- Thorrez 5y agoWindows 95 had a suggested retail price of $209.95 https://archive.seattletimes.com/archive/?date=19950607&slug=2125167 https://archive.seattletimes.com/archive/?date=19950607&slug... This magazine from 1995 had a CD full of stock images for sale for $18.98 https://the-avocado.org/2018/03/16/lets-read-pc-magazine-july-1995/ https://the-avocado.org/2018/03/16/lets-read-pc-magazine-jul... So I don't think the physical distribution was a large percent of the price.
- metaphor 5y ago> This magazine from 1995 had a CD full of stock images for sale for $18.98 ..."for 100 stunning photos on each CD-ROM. $18.98 each" [1], just in case anyone else wanted to square the comparison in proper context. [1] https://i0.wp.com/the-avocado.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/img_3196.jpg https://i0.wp.com/the-avocado.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/03...
- privacythrow1 5y agoMaybe I attribute too much value to the costs of physical distribution. Either way, my point is that I don't think in-app advertising is the sole driver of the price point we see for Windows today compared to the price point we saw in the 90s. I find it hard to accept the explanation that in-app advertising is the tradeoff I get when buying a tech product at a given price. Either it's free and it serves me ads, or I pay for it and I get to opt-in to ads if I choose. It's the same argument for Smart TVs. These companies know they can have their cake and eat it too.
- phreeza 5y ago
- msravi 5y agoOk, so why isn't there an option to just buy the thing at its actual cost without the subsidy and without ads? Are they unable to put a $ value on how much the ads will garner them over, say, a 3-year period? FWIW, I have Linux Mint on all laptops at home, including the ones used by the kids and the elderly, even though I've already paid for the Windows 10 license by virtue of having purchased them default installed.
- thomasahle 5y ago> Ok, so why isn't there an option to just buy the thing at its actual cost without the subsidy and without ads? Are they unable to put a $ value on how much the ads will garner them over, say, a 3-year period? That's the classical problem with ad-free subscription models: You remove all the people with cash to spare from your advertising pool, thus decreasing its value. At that point you might as well make the product ad-free for the people not paying as well.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoThe single killer feature of windows, unrivaled by Mac or Linux, is playing video-games. Expensive professional software is often available on Mac. Probably the target market for windows evolved to become people who tolerate advertising (or at least that's what PMs at M$ think). Half the price is paid in the license fee. The other half is a lifetime of ads exposure.
- noduerme 5y agoThe killer feature of Ryan Air is that it costs £10 to get to a stag party in Malaga, for people who are too blitzed to care about comfort, basic customer service, getting hijacked by foreign governments, etc. The difference is, there are still professional-grade alternatives to Ryan Air, and the company you work for isn't going to make you fly them for business every day. (If they do, you should really quit).
- entropyie 5y agoBlaming Ryanair for getting hijacked? That is harsh. Personally, besides the dark patterns during booking, I find little functional difference between Ryanair and the likes of Aer lingus when traveling . The difference being air travel is highly regulated, as should be surveillance marketing.
- noduerme 5y agoRyan Air makes their seats out of recycled portapotties. The owner repeatedly lobbied for standing room in the back, coin slots on the toilets, and to remove the requirement for seatbelts since "if it goes down, they're all dead anyway." The one time I flew Aer Lingus (in coach, NYC to Dublin via Shannon) I had a fantastic breakfast that still ranks as one of my favorite airplane meals. Sure it cost hundreds of dollars more but once you're in the hands of an airline unfit to transport animals, you wish you'd spent the money.
- Ntrails 5y ago> remove the requirement for seatbelts since "if it goes down, they're all dead anyway." I mean, he's got a point here. Surely if we actually wanted plane passengers to survive crashes they'd have something more substantial than lap belts? I'd have thought, as a simple laymen, facing the seats backwards would make any impact far more survivable than crouching in the insane way that the "safety pamphlet" suggests?
- behnamoh 5y agoWhile I don't like Windows 10 telemetry and other shady diagnostics services that lurk in the background, I've never seen any ads "infesting" the OS at all, and I'm online almost all day. Which part of Windows displays ads?
- l33t2328 5y agoWhat part of windows is infested with ads?
- ygra 5y agoMost of those are manageable or can be disabled, but it can become annoying: - Start Menu showing suggested apps (the infamous Candy Crush) - Task bar shown weather and news - Lock screen sometimes showing ads - Sometimes, with updates, new things are installed that auto-launch and prompt you to, e.g., buy an Office subscription.
- yellowapple 5y agoDon't forget: - Constantly nagging about using browsers other than Edge
- _trampeltier 5y agoWhat I don't undestand, even Win 10 Pro has XBox and candys all over the place .. serious in a pro version?!? With the terrible EULA it all felt just like a joke to me and I deleted all my Windows installations and I'm Linux only now at home. I'm not using Linux because it is free. I have 4 unused Win10 Pro licenses at home now. But I just can't say yes to the EULA. So I dumped them all. In the late 90s I also bought Linux distros, because I was not able to donwload those over a 33.4kb modem. So it is not because it free or it cost something. It is about freedom.
- watwut 5y agoThe XBox game bar is useful for work actually - it is easy to make videos of bugs or how to use app with it.
- spdebbarma 5y agoI like using Nvidia Shadowplay to do any video recording on my screen.
- s3tz 5y agoI can do the same thing on linux and macos without the app being an ad.
- distalx 5y agoIs there anything specific in EULA that stands out or overall it's bad for their users?
- aembleton 5y ago> I have 4 unused Win10 Pro licenses at home now. Why don't you sell them?
- Ziomislaw 5y agoWindows license forbids to resell them (or was, last time I checked). Fortunately due to the local law I can ignore this paragraph but not everyone can.
- 29athrowaway 5y agoWindows 11 is more invasive than 10. Why? Because all the anti-privacy bullshit on Windows 10 worked and nobody complained... We can call this situation the "Fuck yourself" pattern, where you give money to companies so they can innovate in new ways of fucking you.
- raxxorrax 5y agoThey pay for it but they aren't able to connect the dots. Have you looked at the developer community of MS frameworks lately? Seems like a ghost town. Of course this is not the only reason, but for quite a few developers it is. I dropped .net completely because it isn't worth developing against a badly behaving OS. I am very sure the ad income doesn't recoup the loss in trust at all.
- kasajian 5y agoFacebook and/or Microsoft can choose to charge you for their content as well as serve you ads. Serving you ads doesn't exclude you from paying for content if that's that's what they choose to do. I believe there's versions of Kindle and other such devices that are cheaper because they have ads. Windows would be more expensive if they didn't serve ads.
- nvarsj 5y agoOr my $1600 LG OLED which takes screen captures by default and sends them to ad tracking cloud servers.
- AstralStorm 5y agoGet one from EU (or with EU firmware) and it does not by default. Good side effect of GDPR.
- brokenmachine 5y agoI'd be sandboxing that shit real quick.
- npteljes 5y agoThat's the real fuck you pattern right there. When they make you pay for it handsomely, build a moat with questionable practices so third parties have a hard time, make it part of the cultural context so that people expect it to be the "normal" or "baseline" system, and then there's still ads.
- culopatin 5y agoThe company you purchased from decided to do it that way. If you don’t agree just don’t buy into it, or create a competitor. Did the license you bought said it would have no ads?
- stjohnswarts 5y agoWhy do I see no ads in windows 10? Have you tried using WPD?