5 ms·
So if I can summarize the article, the economics of dollar stores are "sell things for more than it cost to buy them". I mean, it seemed like the article wante
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
So if I can summarize the article, the economics of dollar stores are "sell things for more than it cost to buy them".
I mean, it seemed like the article wanted to have some nefarious take, but offering smaller quantities of items so people can afford them, even if the per-unit cost is higher, doesn't seem like some unexpected malicious intent. I mean, I certainly expect to pay more per gram if I'm buying a travel size of toothpaste vs. the 4 megatube family pack at Costco.
And the fact that the stores are oriented so the popular items are in the back - just like literally every grocery store in the country - is also unsurprising.
- krm01 5y agoI too was under the impression that there was some kind of clever way these shops operate, based on the title. But the economics are exactly like any other shop.
- ghayes 5y agoThere’s a good Planet Money on this from NPR. They imply that the real profit is from not stocking fresh goods and other items that 1) spoil, 2) have lower margins and 3) require employees to constantly restock. So they basically sell high-margin goods (negotiated in bulk) with absolute minimum costs. That’s it. [0] https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2019/04/26/717665452/episode-909-dollar-stores-vs-lettuce https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2019/04/26/717665452/epis...
- myself248 5y agoI haven't RTFA, but it's always struck me as funny that some of the items at the dollar store are 49¢ at the big box. Stuff like hose clamps comes to mind. You can get quite ripped off if you let yourself think "dollar = cheaper than everywhere else".
- amelius 5y agoYeah, but the article provides relevant numbers.
- grae_QED 5y agoI feel the same way. It feels like the article has some anti-capitalism undertones. They are clearly trying to vilify dollar stores. I think the author is butt hurt that "big dollar" is taking advantage of poor people. But in reality, dollar stores are what poor people want. If they thought they were being taken advantage of or manipulated then poor people wouldn't buy anything from dollar stores. They want cheap stuff, and dollar stores provide just that.
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoI often go to a "cheap shit by the container load" retail chain called Action and they are always packed. And all kinds of people go there- Dutch people are infamous for their love of cheap and it's considered a point of pride. Capitalism always wins.
- LambdaComplex 5y ago> If they thought they were being taken advantage of or manipulated then poor people wouldn't buy anything from dollar stores I've seen people (whether they be college students or just people living paycheck to paycheck) talking about how they only have e.g. $5 USD to spend on groceries for the next two weeks (because that's how much they have in their bank account, and that's when payday is). If your choices are "something you can pay for at the dollar store at a less-than-optimal unit price" or "something you literally cannot buy because its purchase price exceeds the number in your bank account" then you really don't have a choice. Poor people don't want dollar stores; they just want to survive.
- k2enemy 5y agoThe article kind of contradicts itself by bringing up this point, then later saying that people make a lot of impulse purchases and the average trip costs $16. I don't doubt that your anecdote is true, but it seems to not be the typical case.
- baobabKoodaa 5y agoThat's not a contradiction. A store can have more than one type of customer.
- rootusrootus 5y agoI think it's useful information, even if it should be intuitive. I know a number of people who shop at the dollar store because they believe they're saving money. In particular I think it's nice to shed some light on the special arrangements the stores make with manufacturers to produce products that look like the equivalent of what you get in a normal store but only cost a dollar, while in fact containing so little of the actual product that they're a worse deal.
- tialaramex 5y agoPound Shops, a similar idea in the UK, seem to have several different economic strategies in every store. In some cases they are selling (for £1) a product that your supermarket pays 70p for and sometimes sells for £1.50 and other times "discounts" to 75p. If you bought it from the Pound Shop when it's £1.50 at a supermarket that seems like a bargain, if it was 75p at the supermarket it seems like a rip off. But it's the same product either way. In some cases as you described they have a 300g version of a 450g product, theirs costs £1 and the "ordinary" version is £1.40 from many retailers. So they are more expensive on a "per-unit" basis. But let's face it, you were going to eat the entire product even though the manufacturer says it's for "sharing", so maybe they did you a favour. In some cases the manufacturer is engaged in simple price discrimination. The pound store has the exact same quantity of the branded product, but it's wrapped with a label explaining that it only cost £1 whereas the version in the supermarket is unlabelled and costs £1.50. The manufacturer guesses that many people who can afford £1.50 will choose not to visit a Pound Shop, so any sales at the lower price are extra sales and don't cannibalise supermarket sales. In some cases they're End of Line goods. The supermarket doesn't want to stock a product with a finite supply, especially out of season - it looks desperate, but a Pound Shop can put boxes of "Santa Shapes" candy on shelves in January for £1 (original RRP £2.50) and customers will buy them because candy is candy, who cares if it's Xmas themed when it's so cheap? Or after supermarkets pull the £1.85 "barbecue flavour" chocolate assortment you launched because it doesn't sell, bundle them two for £1 at a Pound Shop and they disappear. Do the Pound Shop's customers eat them? Who cares. The final category that's most interesting to me is bulk electronics. If you stock sixteen different adaptors in an electronics shop, they move so slowly you probably have to charge £2.50 or more for them even though they're quite cheap to make. But a Pound Shop can pick one adaptor they think sells (say, USB A to USB C is plausible) buy an entire container of them, put them on shelves for a few weeks at £1 each, and they vanish. Want that USB A to C adaptor a month later? Too bad, now they have a GU10 LED lamp, and a month after that maybe it's a laser pointer. Could I get these products on Amazon any time? Yeah, but either the postage kills the deal, or it's "free" and the price is higher.