27 ms·
The EU’s disputed system of geographical indications is taking over the planet (2017)
- zeristor 5y agoSurely the USA can develop its own authentic regional foods?
- dougmwne 5y agoWhat's interesting is that the US absolutely has a huge amount of regional food. Many food items are tied to a specific city, and this goes way beyond the Philadelphia Cheesesteak. The food was often a reimagining of immigrants' foods from back home, but with a distinctively new twist. But rather than identify and celebrate these food traditions, the US chooses to structure its policy around Kraft and General Mills and allows its companies to homogenize its culture. The US could develop and celebrate GI's but it won't.
- iso1210 5y agoFlorida Orange Juice, Vidalia onions, Idaho potatoes, and of course the "Made In USA" stamp.
- 123pie123 5y agoI'm I right in thinking that 'Florida Orange Juice' has to come from Florida? what law would a company be breaking in the US, if say a company used oranges from a different state than Florida and made Orange juice and labeled it 'Florida Orange Juice' because the company used the same type of oranges or the owner was from florida?
- quesera 5y agoBut "Florida Orange Juice" is a trademark of the Florida Department of Citrus. This is a state agency tasked with promoting Florida's members of the citrus industry. They created and registered the trademark. Before they started using it, the mark did not exist. They funded ad campaigns to spread the trademark, and they license it at no cost to Florida producers of citrus products. The difference between trademark protection and a PDO is that the PDO seeks to unwind the historical dispersion of language and culture, purportedly for consumer benefit (and certainly there is some benefit) but -- let's be honest -- this is clearly economic protectionism. Edit: "Florida Orange Juice" is also clearly economic protectionism! Californian (and Brazilian) growers are disadvantaged by the active and ongoing efforts of the FL Dept of Citrus. But they have a trademark. My objection to PDOs is that they're often re-fighting battles that were lost hundreds of years ago. Historical revisionism promulgated by economically self-interested groups, backed by governments, with the goal of global enforcement, and sold as consumer protection ... is silly when it fails, and abhorrent when it succeeds. IMO!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Arnt 5y agoYes, in principle, but why would Kraft Foods help develop something that's tied to a part of Michigan instead of something that's tied to Kraft? The US has unusually many large companies and unusually few small ones and farmers, so this question matters.
- ginko 5y agoEver heard of Unilever or Nestlé?
- Arnt 5y agoOf course. But what do you mean to say? Do, for example, try to suggest that Unilever or Nestlé sells as much "parmesan" in Europe as Kraft sells in the US? (I mention parmesan and Kraft because the article does — feel free to substitute any other product/conglomerate pair.)
- rsynnott 5y agoI assume their point was that enormous food conglomerates aren’t just a US thing.
- Arnt 5y agoSounds likely, coupled with a blind assumption that since the conglomerates dominate most segments in the US, they'll dominate the geographical products in Europe (and where relevant, elsewhere) to a comparable degree.
- Telemakhos 5y agoThere are regional US foods. There are, for example, many regional kinds of barbecue, including two varieties of pulled pork in North Carolina (eastern Carolina barbecue with a vinegar-pepper sauce, and western or Lexington barbecue that adds tomato and sometimes sugar), Texas brisket, and many others. Likewise there are Surrey hams (nothing like so-called "Virginia" ham despite representing colonial-era Virginian ham smoking and curing recipes), red-eye country hams, city hams (the so-called "Virginia" ham), spam, etc. There are Virginia peanuts that are larger and crispier than any others you'll find, but in Louisiana you'll find boiled peanuts instead. Kentucky has its juleps and Derby (or "May Day") pies as well as hot-browns. Florida serves key lime pie, mojitos, Cuban sandwiches (really invented in Tampa and blending Cuban and Italian deli traditions) and Cuban coffee. Hawaii has poké, which is now spreading everywhere. There are authentic regional foods in the United States, some with roots going back to the colonial era, some more modern. It would be politically incorrect to protect those with a European-style system of regional designations, however. On the right, regulations, especially those creating the potential (or certainty of) cartel pricing, are unwelcome. On the center and moderate left, there is little desire to promote regionalism over a national picture that emphasizes a common "America" that all citizens share. On the far left, you find the absolute denial that America (or more specifically white America) has any sort of culture of its own. The federal United States is not quite set up for regional distinctions the same way that the EU, as a much looser set of sovereign nations, is.
- Dah00n 5y ago>To some, the very idea of signing away their heritage still rankles, however. "The Old World supplied the immigrants. It seems to be very weird that you’re saying that people can’t take culture with them," said one dairy negotiator This is no different than if Apple workers from China start selling iPhones in the US that is actually branded Apple iPhone, completely different from a "real" iPhone or exact copy, same thing. If anything the hundreds of years old "brands" should be more protected, not less so. Calling something made in the US Champagne is the same as printing Made in Champagne, France on the bottle. If European businesses started making big bucks on products pretending to be Native American people would go berserk.
- neximo64 5y agoThis isn't a very strong argument. The closest equivalent would be saying another Chinese brand says its designed in California but it is not Apple. Apple is a legal entity and California is a region.
- yokaze 5y agoNot quite, as the geographical indication not only only means that it was produced there, but also has other constraints on how it is produced, etc... So it is very much a brand, in the very same meaning, that it doesn't necessarily guarantee quality, but that the brand of the region is a means of ensuring some quality standards. E.g. there are wines from certain regions, but they do not have the geographic indication, as they have not been produced according to the regional standards. And going with food it is even more important so, as it is close to impossible to reproduce the climate and terroir somewhere half around the world. That doesn't mean, that it is worse, just that it is not the same. Take Lambrusco as an example, they do have (or had?) a bad reputation and suffer for it. It's a good motivation for regional producers to keep each others in check.
- anoncake 5y agoAs a customer, why should I care if I get an iPhone or an exact, functionally identical, copy?
- gerikson 5y agoArticle is from 2017.
- greatgib 5y ago<<They instead have to rebrand and use labels such as "Parmesan-style," which often turn off consumers who may see the products as unauthentic.>> The wording is strange, it looks like they say that it is wrong to say that it is inauthentic. But, there is no doubt, if you buy Greek feta that is manufactured in Australia in addition with different recipes and ingredients origins, it is clearly inauthentic and deceptive.
- rat9988 5y agoBut feta without greek wouldn't be deceptive.
- anoncake 5y agoYou can use the same recipes in Australia as in Greece. Ingredients could be tricky, but let's assume that you can make sheep milk in Australia that has the same properties as Greek sheep milk. Then why should it matter where the feta has been manufactured?
- dopidopHN 5y agoCybernetic again, cheese is more than the sum of its part. I’m only half joking. Plus, for some recipe the food that the cow ate and the altitude do make a difference in the output. I’m all for other places making cheese and whatnot. But when you buy the said cheese to find the exact taste you know since childhood, and that you miss in the exotic land you are living as a adult… You can be picky on the product. I want the Madeleine de Proust. Not a taste-a-like. Those labels help me do that. If I want the real deal I will buy it and the label will help me archive that goal. ( not always, see below ) If I feel adventurous, I have nothing against trying other cheeses. Some are good, some might event be identical to the label-cheese. I’m open to that. Furthermore, and tangentially related … folk should be open to the idea that some produce don’t travel well. They just don’t. My favorite cheese is embarrassingly bad when I found the official label in the US. The taste is more sauer and the consistency different. It’s just sad.( to eat )
- anoncake 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- edejong 5y agoThe result of these policies is that hard cheeses are produced in low-income countries, shipped over long distances and then relabeled “Parmasan” in the Parma region, to be shipped long distance again to its end destination.
- detritus 5y agoI find this hard to believe, given how protective Italian regions are over their fayre. Do you have a source for this?
- zmb_ 5y agoThis is not true. The GI specifications are very strict on where and how the protected product is produced. With Parmigiano Reggiano, for example, the cows producing the milk must be within the geographic area, and even their fodder must primarily come from the region.
- pimterry 5y agoIf this happens, it's not within the rules, that's straight up fraud. PDOs like Parmesan require all production and processing to happen within the registered area, and usually following some quite strict rules, depending on the name in question. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_designation_of_origin https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_designation_of_ori... has some interesting details.
- dmitriid 5y agoI'm from Moldova, and Moldovan alcohol producers were hit by this. Since the Soviet times lots of things like cognac, champagne, cahors, port wine and so on were produced in Moldova often using traditional recipes. And then association with EU happened. Ooops, can't use those names anymore, you must devise new names for what is essentially the same exact product.
- tchalla 5y agoMoldova has 5 wines and 1 spirit protected under the GI status. https://www.tmdn.org/giview/gi/EUGI00209900380 https://www.tmdn.org/giview/gi/EUGI00209900380 https://www.tmdn.org/giview/gi/EUGI00209900381 https://www.tmdn.org/giview/gi/EUGI00209900381 https://www.tmdn.org/giview/gi/EUGI00209900382 https://www.tmdn.org/giview/gi/EUGI00209900382 https://www.tmdn.org/giview/gi/EUGI00209900383 https://www.tmdn.org/giview/gi/EUGI00209900383 https://www.tmdn.org/giview/gi/EUGI00209900383 https://www.tmdn.org/giview/gi/EUGI00209900383 https://www.tmdn.org/giview/gi/EUGI00209900385 https://www.tmdn.org/giview/gi/EUGI00209900385
- dmitriid 5y ago1. So what? Some of those "protected wines" didn't even exist before the agreement and no one cares if they are protected, or not. This is basically a "in exchange of a few thousand names [1] that you can never use even if you produce an identical product, we will protect some names many of which not even you care about, or weren't even ever used before this agreement". 2. That "protected spirit"? That's the new invented name for cognac. As wikipedia puts it [2], emphasis mine: === start quote === Divin - represents the name, patented in the Republic of Moldova, of the country's brandy, produced in conformity with the classic technology of cognac production. === end quote === So, it's produced like cognac, looks like cognac, has the same ingredients as cognac, smells like cognac, tastes like cognac, but don't you dare call it cognac, invent a new non-sensical name to call it something else but cognac. The same goes for dozens of other names. And we're talking only about wine and spirits. Imagine if no country could call whisky, well, whisky, and each country had to invent their own name for it. [1] Annex XXX-C https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?qid=1582887589555&uri=CELEX:22014A0830(01)#d1e32-445-1 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?qid=15828875... and Annex XXX-D https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?qid=1582887589555&uri=CELEX:22014A0830(01)#d1e32-485-1 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?qid=15828875... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moldovan_wine#Divin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moldovan_wine#Divin
- tchalla 5y agoThe US has 681 Geographical Indications which are registered and/or protected under agreement [0]. 679 of them are for wine products, 2 for spirits (Bourbon/Tennesee Whisky). The US has applied for 1 food product GI - Alaska Pollock Fish in 2021 [1]. [0] https://www.tmdn.org/giview/gi/search https://www.tmdn.org/giview/gi/search [1] https://www.tmdn.org/giview/gi/EUGI00000018025 https://www.tmdn.org/giview/gi/EUGI00000018025
- mantas 5y agoPersonally I just stopped buying "true" Parmesan. Local hard cheese is good enough if not better. After few tries it's easy to figure out what to use if recipe asks for Parmesan(tm).
- denton-scratch 5y agoParmesan from Parma is a particular food. If you're OK with pecorino, that's a different taste, but it's a decent substitute in many recipes, and pecorino is preferable for some recipes. No doubt there are very nice hard cheeses made in places that are not famous for cheese; that's cool too. BBut let's not mush all hard cheeses together under the name of the most-famous hard cheese. It's famous for a reason.
- mantas 5y agoYes. Different local hard cheeses work as replacement for different famous trademarked hard cheeses. Sidenote: Pecorino Romano is one of the cheeses that I can't find a local replacement for :(
- danielscrubs 5y agoI'd love to try a Chicago-style pizza, but can't find it anywhere in my country and I'd have absolutely zero qualms about US protecting that (hard to export I know, but maybe the ingredients could be restricted?). Maybe it could even be shortened - Can I get a Chicago? I'd also like to try "Crab Mac 'n' Cheese Dog"... One thing is that in US there is always this range of quality. There is only one place in the world where I've been bitten by bed bugs and that was smack in the middle of NY. I couldn't believe my eyes when I saw the bite-marks, IM IN NEW YORK, how can this be?! But that range can be devastating when marketing. The "no regulations"-crowd can... hinder... progress as well as help. On a more positive note [Wikipedia]: "Bourbon's legal definition varies somewhat from country to country, but many trade agreements require that the name "bourbon" be reserved for products made in the United States. " "Tennessee whiskey is straight whiskey produced in the U.S. state of Tennessee. Although it has been legally defined as a bourbon whiskey in some international trade agreements,[1][2][3] most current producers of Tennessee whiskey disclaim references to their products as "bourbon" and do not label them as such on any of their bottles or advertising materials. "
- unishark 5y ago"Chicago-style pizza" would be ok, according to the article. But not "Chicago pizza" if it wasn't really from Chicago (and if it was protected by law/treaty, which I don't think it is). New York City feels rather like a foreign country to me, though the range-of-quality observation is indeed true everywhere in the US.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Kim_Bruning 5y agoWe all agree that roads are useful. If everyone agrees to drive on the right (or everyone agrees to drive on the left), then the rules all make sense and traffic runs more smoothly. So really this is a system that is rather like trademarks, and with similar purposes. But instead of a made up name, you use the name of the town or region where something is made. This does have its own upsides and downsides; like the fact that you have to remember that people make somewhat similar cheeses in Brie and Camembert, or in Gouda and Edam[1]. But like with trademarks, you do know that you'll always get the same consistent quality; be it good or bad. It's a system. And it works well enough for its purpose. [1] I did say similar. If you're a big cheese fan, please don't hurt me!
- rodelrod 5y agoI was once offered a bottle of California "Port". I have nothing against them making the stuff, and I'm even willing to admit that some people will like it. However, Port it was not. In fact it was further from Port than many other old-world fortified wines I know. If Madeira, Jerez or Malaga didn't feel the need to name their wines "Port" (and they shouldn't because they can certainly stand on their own!) I don't see why California producers shouldn't come up with their own designation and see how it fares in the market.
- throwaway210222 5y agoThis is the logical end game of whinging about cultural appropriation: the big boys also get to play. Perhaps a licence to use the English language?
- _nub3 5y agoThe UK would be pleased. ^^
- Zababa 5y agoOther people using your language actually benefits you, that's not the case for other people using your trademark.
- throwaway210222 5y agoI really, really didn't think I needed to add a sarcasm tag.
- despera 5y agoImage caption triggered my greek cheese-seller's nerves. Those are not "slabs of feta cheese" shown but mizithra or anthotyro. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthotyros https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthotyros Now for the important part. Region locking is completely idiotic. If i was living abroad, i wouldn't dare to buy, for example, imported greek feta. White cheese is not the kind that matures. They are very delicate has to stay fresh. Surely there must be standards of HOW a certain kind of cheese is made but not where.
- rapht 5y ago(2017)
- hackeraccount 5y agoAll of IP law is a bunch of lawyers getting you to concede one reasonable point and then them taking it to a place of absolute absurdity.
- yummybear 5y agoThis isn’t just an EU/US thing - even within the EU people are unhappy about not being able to call their product Feta just because it’s created outside of Greece.
- distances 5y agoI'm sure some people are unhappy. But I am, as a consumer, very happy that I can easily distinguish proper feta from second-rate imitations that used to be sold with the same name. Same for a multitude of other cheeses: say, halloumi used to be some random chewy white blob, and now I know there's a certain guarantee behind the name.
- DiogenesKynikos 5y agoTurkish or Bulgarian feta are neither second-rate nor imitations. "Feta" is just the Greek name for a range of cheeses produced across much of the Eastern Mediterranean. But Greek cheese-producers lobbied the Greek government, and then Greece lobbied the EU, so in Europe, only cheese produced in a few regions of Greece may be called "feta." That's not because those regions produce the best feta cheese, or even because they produce a unique variety of feta that could be reliably distinguished from feta produced elsewhere. It's because they managed to convince their government to grant them a monopoly on the name. That's it.
- kergonath 5y ago> Turkish or Bulgarian feta are neither second-rate nor imitations. They also have local names, which would be fine to use. People are not completely stupid. I mean, halloumi was unheard of here [some continental EU country] a couple of years ago, and now it’s quite popular. So people can learn new names. We can understand that cava and prosecco are similar (to a first order approximation, please don’t bite). Same for raki and ouzo. Or port and madeira. There is nothing wrong with that.
- DiogenesKynikos 5y ago
- Bayart 5y ago>"The Old World supplied the immigrants. It seems to be very weird that you’re saying that people can’t take culture with them," You can take the culture, not the terroir, that's the point. Actual buffalo mozzarella from Campania, to take something that would be familiar to an English-speaking audience, just tastes different. Using the same process isn't enough. And that's assuming the culture survives untouched, which it never does.
- djbebs 5y agoTheres no such thing as "terroir" the whole concept is bullshit intended to justify the unjustifiable.
- Bayart 5y agoIt's a core part of how we think about food. And pretty much all of the Old World works the same, really. There's a reason why it's a complete non-issue in Asia. What's that so-called « unjustifiable », dare I ask ?
- dariosalvi78 5y agothen try the real buffalo mozzarella and any other copy you find elsewhere. I am from Naples and I have lived about half of my life in other countries, and in each country I have tried to find a decent local substitute of mozzarella: I couldn't. Maybe it's a secret technique, maybe it's the air, who knows, but the fact remains that the only real mozzarella comes from there.
- quesera 5y agoI agree and I sympathize, but ... Your preferences and your conditioning bias you to believe that there is only one correct interpretation. It is your favorite, and you can justify that by believing that it is the original and the only proper version. You miss that product when you are away from home. I feel the same way about some local foods that I grew up with, but I don't support Global Trade Law that would prevent someone else from trying to reproduce (or interpret) the food in question without being required to invent a new name for it. I think a more equitable (and workable) approach to this problem is to establish organizations whose members a) create defensible trademarks, b) accept memberships from producers who meet quality/regionality/whatever standards, c) promote this differentiation in the market. I understand that "Champagne" means something special to residents (and economic development groups!) in that region of France. But to the vast bulk of the world, "champagne" is just a product and usually a pretty crappy one. Buffalo wings, and buffalo mozzarella. Two great tastes that taste great together. You might not think this is an even exchange, but many will disagree, and it's entirely subjective anyway. So I say "Thank you and you're welcome!" :)
- himinlomax 5y agoThe US argument against it, based on immigrants, is rather convoluted — and quite idiotic. How many poor Champagne producers do you think emigrated to the US? Not one, considering how it's always been a luxury product and it's not that ancient. Do they deserve protection? Well Coca Cola sure does, why not them?
- _nub3 5y ago"Champagne" does sound better and more exclusive compared to "sparkling wine".
- kergonath 5y agoThis is quite subjective. One Californian (or Australian, or whatever) sparkling wine producer could set a trend with a new, memorable name, and become more exclusive.
- himinlomax 5y agoThis is fine Australian Champagne wine. It's a wine with a message, and the message is: beware!
- Zababa 5y agoEspecially with wine: did the immigrants bring soil with them? They didn't. You can't produce Champagne in the USA, just like we can't produce Californian wine in France.
- _nub3 5y ago> To Washington, Brussels' insistence on protecting GIs smacks 0f arrogance and greed. The hubris is strong in this one. Too bad, Brussel does not have any natural oil reserves.
- wcoenen 5y agoThe EU does produce oil, though production has been in decline since 2004. And much more is imported than produced. https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=Oil_and_petroleum_products_-_a_statistical_overview&oldid=315177#Production_of_crude_oil https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php...
- raverbashing 5y agoLet me sum up the article in one phrase: "Businessman are annoyed that names actually mean something and that quality/origin/procedure is non-negotiable sometimes and are behind-hurt about it". Cue Coca-Cola's lawyers arguing "Vitamin Water" can't be expected to have vitamins. Cue McDonald's "dairy-thing slice that looks like cheddar" (that tastes nothing like cheddar but can have something like a single digit % of material actually coming from a cow - who knows)
- lamontcg 5y ago> To Washington, Brussels' insistence on protecting GIs smacks of arrogance and greed. Would you like some whine with your Camembert?
- 0ld 5y agowhen driving through poland recently, i've heard a commercial on a radio for a locally made halloumi [0] (a cyprus' protected origin cheese). they somewhat amusingly called it "haluni" [1] so, the chinese-abibas-style is still alive and kicking even within the eu with all its "disputed systems of geographical indications" [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halloumi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halloumi [1] https://www.krasnystaw.eu/produkty/ser-haluni/serek-haluni https://www.krasnystaw.eu/produkty/ser-haluni/serek-haluni
- mucholove 5y agoBranding, intellectual property, are important but…the most important thing to protect is taste. In this regard the US is so far off the mark (and so chemically manufactured) as to cheapen the expensive and flavorful foods Europe continues to produce. When I was in Barcelona, the quality of the sausages and charcuterie was so far and above anything produced in America. It would be a real shame if they shared the same name. One place where this becomes very difficult in particular is when ordering the Gouda cheese—where Gouda from Gouda is great and the rest is NOT. Go EU! Go taste!
- mejutoco 5y agoFor anybody wondering, one of the most common is „fuet”. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuet https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuet
- adeltoso 5y agoFood in the US is just such a pile of shit and ability to distiquish quality from garbage in americans is so non-existent that it doesn't surprise me that there is someone here in the US that really believes you can make Parmiggiano or Feta outside the area they got invented. They just don't get it and I feel sorry for them. I lived decades in Europe and US. If you are a dairy and have milk, make your own cheese, maybe in 500 years it will be decent, just don't produce knockoff products because "they sell", you are doing a disservice to your fellow americans by depriving them from learning how to taste things.
- oh_sigh 5y agoAh yes, food snobbery at its finest. Quality and garbage is generally easy to distinguish by price and taste, and shopkeepers discretion. And I really don't understand what part of the parm making process is necessary to happen in central/northern italy vs anywhere else in the world.
- denton-scratch 5y agoSo that's OK; if you don't think parmesan from Parma is better, just buy Kraft parmesan - it's a fifth of the price. But if there aren't labelling laws, then I won't be able to buy real parmesan with confidence. Price is not a reliable guide to quality. Nor is "shopkeeper's discretion". Knowing that the cheese is made in accordance with strict regulations is a good guide.
- oh_sigh 5y agoAgain, food snobbery. "If it isn't from Parma, then it must be Kraft quality" > But if there aren't labelling laws, No one argued against labeling laws except the strawman in your head. The question is whether something is specifically necessary about occuring in the region of Parma in the cheese making process of Parmesan. I don't think it is necessary to not let Kraft call their product "parmesan cheese" for the sake of consumer protection, when existing laws already make it illegal to falsely label your product - for example, trademark laws would not allow you to fake the DOCG label, and existing laws don't let you lie about the origin of the product (Kraft could not say "Made in Parma, Italy" on their product). > Knowing that the cheese is made in accordance with strict regulations is a good guide. Again, which is nothing I argued against. You can have strict regulations while not restricting the commonly understood usage of a word. In fact, you seem to agree in your actual usage, since you called it "Kraft parmesan", and not "Kraft parmesan-like cheese product"
- cheese_goddess 5y agoFrom the article: > That means non-EU farmers and exporters take a direct hit. When the EU wins protection for, say, Italian Parmesan and Greek feta in a deal with Japan, it means that Australian and U.S. dairies are barred from selling their products there under those labels. They instead have to rebrand and use labels such as "Parmesan-style," which often turn off consumers who may see the products as unauthentic. Because they are! For example, as far as I can tell, most of the "feta" cheese made in the US is made with cow's milk, whereas Greek feta is traditionally made with sheep's milk and up to 30% goat's milk. This part of the tradition is protected by the feta Protected Designation of Origin. Btw, cheese made in the same way as feta, but with cow's milk, is instead known as "telemes" in Greek (and I think telemea in Romania). Telemes is also a Greek PDO cheese. So the cow's milk "feta" sold in the US should be more correctly labelled as "telemes", but of course "feta" is more recognisable. On the other hand, the Greek diaspora that the article alleges are dismayed by the EU GIs should know the difference between feta and telemes, or at least they should if they have brought their cheesemaking traditions with them to the New World, again as the article alleges, and so they should be more annoyed that telemes is sold as feta in the US and that nobody can find a good slab of feta in the entire US. But I digress. The article continues: > To some, the very idea of signing away their heritage still rankles, however. "The Old World supplied the immigrants. It seems to be very weird that you’re saying that people can’t take culture with them," said one dairy negotiator who declined to be named for fear of influencing current negotiations with the EU. It's not that weird. Even in EU countries, not everyone can make a particular kind of food or drink that has a Protected Designation of Origin. This may be lost in translation, in the article, but for example Parmigiano Reggiano can only be made in (quoting from wikipedia): the provinces of Reggio Emilia, Parma, the part of Bologna west of the Reno, and Modena (all in Emilia-Romagna); and the part of Mantua (Lombardy) on the right/south bank of the Po. Parmigiano is the Italian adjective for Parma and Reggiano that for Reggio Emilia. So for instance, cheesemakers in Puglia or Sicily cannot make parmesan style cheese and call it "Parmigiano Regiano", even though they're Italians. In the same way, the feta cheese PDO only covers the Greek regions of Thessaly, Thrace, Epirus, Macedonia, Central Greece, Peloponse and Lesvos, so Greek cheesemakers in the Ionian islands cannot sell their cheese as "feta" and must sell it as "white cheese" instead. And so on. If Italians can't make Parmigiano regiano because they're not in Reggio Emilia, and Greeks can't make feta in Greece because they're in the wrong area of Greece, it is not so far fetched that Canadian Greeks can't make feta in Canada.
- 8jef 5y agoOne has to protect what has added value qualities. Industrial products made by immigrant families in the US or Canada is still industrial, without any real value other than a name, and some generic protein and calories count. Drive around and you'll find small batched terroir quality products all over North America. These are products that should protected and promoted all the way to icon land, not bad imitations of something 100 times better and originally made abroad. Big business people are always after the lowest "not hanging anymore" fruits, the ones splattered on the soil. They need to up their game and do better. Much better. Added value quality food (or else) products are sought after by many million Americans willing to pay a premium. Can't you smell the money trail?
- bar00000n 5y ago“you wouldnt steal a car”though :)))
- pyuser583 5y agoIn my humble opinion, geographic indicators are a problem when they create a requirement most consumers aren’t aware of. Plenty of people have no idea champagne must be made in a region of France. If they’re not aware of the requirement, it’s certainly not misleading to remove it. In trademark law, you have to prove that a trademark violation creates confusion. Are there any studies on how many consumers expect champagne to made in Champagne?
- denton-scratch 5y agoIt's misleading to the people that are aware. The law in this country is that you can't call it champagne if it's not from champagne. Anyone that drinks champagne knows this. Same for Melton Mowbray Pork Pies; if they're not from that region, or not made in the right way, you're breaking the law if you call them Melton Mowbray. I really can't see why it isn't bad and misleading, to use a designation of origin on a label that is false.
- pyuser583 5y agoOk great there’s an easy way to solve this issue: consumer research. If consumer research shows that most consumers are aware Champagne always comes from Champagne, and they consider sparkling white wine from Portugal to be “not Champagne” - then keep the restrictions. In the other hand if most consumers aren’t aware of the distinction, or don’t care, then it’s simply protectionism. This could create different rules in different places, but that’s just because different consumers require different protections. But the EU doesn’t seem to care about whether consumer confusion is actually happening. That’s ironic, as the EU prides itself on serving consumers via regulations. The lack of consumer research and consumer advocacy is very “un-EU.” Edit: Champagne might not be the best example, because geography does matter. Different soil produces different grapes. Edit 2: What is misleading about including the place of production in the phrase “Made in Champagne, France”. “Acme Fine China, made in the USA” makes sense.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]