4 ms·
I'm sure YT is going to trot out some stock reason for not re-instating the videos. But this is pathetic. When YT goes on a bandwagon for some cause or other,
by mc32 5y ago
I'm sure YT is going to trot out some stock reason for not re-instating the videos.
But this is pathetic. When YT goes on a bandwagon for some cause or other, this doesn't happen, but it appears to happen when the politics don't align with either their own politics or may offend one of their markets or their sponsors.
So, I guess it's their platform and they can do what they want, but there is a danger that this will tilt one-way and leave no room for this kind of dissent. And that is a great loss.
I hope they grow a conscience but I rather doubt it.
- imglorp 5y agoThis is kind of a new thing for society though. We used to have many media outlets, corporations, and governments. Now most media outlets are owned by a very few corporations, and they are tightly entangled with government interests globally.
- tehwebguy 5y agoYouTubers have no alternative platform for their content if they want ads but advertisers have new options every month when another TV network drops a streaming app. The incentives are super clear.
- codeecan 5y ago> it's their platform and they can do what they want this is not true for monopolies, AT&T can't disconnect your line because they don't like what you're saying on your calls.
- azinman2 5y agoI’m certain they can for your Internet if they don’t like your packets. But in either situation, phone calls are not analogous because they’re 1:1. YouTube is about public broadcast. You also don’t pay for their service to host your videos.
- adventured 5y agoIdeally the parent's comment is forward hopeful. As in, in the near future big tech will be shackled as Ma Bell was, and then carved up. Several of the big tech monsters started a fight they can't win with half of the country that now absolutely hates them (and will at one time or another control vast amounts of political power), and the other half which still wants to see them restricted anyway. The question is how far the Feds and states will go in curbing big tech's abuses on eg cancel culture and content censorship, given the various monopoly positions of these companies. Florida's law on deplatforming is a small, correct first step. Texas is guaranteed to follow, and a lot more restrictions will follow after that. The notion that they can do whatever they want with their monopoly platforms, is already probably not an accurate premise. In the near future, it will definitely not be. We're in about inning one of laying down innumerable restrictions on what big tech can do with their platforms. The odds are quite high the regulators will in fact go further than they should over time, severely damaging the US tech economy. The free-run days for big tech are very clearly over. They're merely too arrogant to recognize it. What was the last major acquisition by Facebook? There are three other prominent US social networks out there with a collective $200b in market cap now. Everything Facebook has is very stale, boring. Instagram is a giant yawn at this point, it's old, increasingly boring and lame. Which is why young people flocked to TikTok so quickly. Facebook has been de facto barred for a long time from eating any of their major competitors. All that money piling up to the ceiling and FB can't even use it to further their monopoly, and they know it. The party is largely over, although big tech will continue to drift for a while on enormous momentum. If Amazon were smart, they'd be in the process of spinning off AWS right now, to unshackle it from so much anti-trust attention that the parent draws, to get far out in front of that. That's guaranteed to happen within the ten or so years after the Bezos era regardless. Google could probably do the same with YouTube, but they'll aggressively fight against that (Amazon will willingly spin off AWS as their stock stagnates, in the typical unlock shareholder value move).
- busymom0 5y agoI agree with most of your comment except the Florida/Texas/States lawsuits. I don't think this can be dealt on the state level. This needs to be done by the federal congress and senate passing laws. Force any Big Tech/Corporations/Banks with over 1 million daily active user-content generating users in the USA to be declared common carriers. And this can be joined by other countries to make it global and thus put pressure on the CCP.
- philipov 5y agoAT&T is a common carrier. You'd have to, I don't know, get Youtube categorized as a common carrier. It's not like that's controversial a fight that Google has won every time it's come up. It's not like there are laws in places like NY that explicitly exempt information systems from being considered common carriers. We're a long way from being able to casually make a comparison between AT&T and Youtube that will be taken seriously.
- saurik 5y agoBut since the issue at hand is that people often believe people should get to behave however they want with their own platforms, you only need to point to one high-profile counter example to disprove that that's some universal maxim: that the law currently usually sides with Google doesn't mean the "it's their platform" argument is sufficient.
- busymom0 5y agoYep. Only way to solve this is to change the laws to force any Big Tech/Corporations/Banks with over 1 million daily active user-content generating users in the USA to be declared common carriers. And this can be joined by other countries to make it global and thus put pressure on the CCP.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mannerheim 5y agoChina isn't even a market for them since YouTube is blocked. That's what makes this even more pathetic.
- justicezyx 5y agoThere are plenty of Chinese brand advertising on YT. And there is a large population consuming YT videos through VPN, and oversea Chinese people myself for example (you can pretty much find every Chinese content creator with decent followers, probably >100k, mirror their video between Chinese ddomestic sites and YT.
- hnick 5y agoI've heard China encourages/allows/supports some creators on YouTube for cultural export too. I mean if YouTube is 'banned' then someone like Dianxi Xiaoge with 7.5 million subscribers isn't exactly under the radar if they wanted to enforce their rules.
- justicezyx 5y ago> China encourages/allows/supports I don't know any such concrete measures to support some creators. I do see that CCP wants to tell a more positive side of China on all sorts of media platforms. That in itself is pretty reasonable. I mean, certainly no other political group are going to say good things about China anyway.
- mannerheim 5y agoNo, it's wholly unreasonable to allow China to use these platforms to disseminate propaganda when they ban them in their own country. The federal government should ban Chinese propagandists from YouTube, the New York Times, etc. unless China unblocks these sites.
- justicezyx 5y ago> disseminate propaganda What are the criteria to label things as "disseminating propaganda"? Also, you'd follow the laws. Doing such thing as you suggested violates a lot of US laws. And in fact, China does have laws to force operators to follow other Chinese laws, including censorship laws. Technically, Google and FB and all those banned firms are leaving China voluntarily because they decide not profitable to follow those laws. So if certain laws are passed to shut out Chinese propaganda outlets, that'll be totally fine. But again, this will be banning individual outlets, not just platforms. China probably will retaliate to bann individuals as well.
- tjpnz 5y ago>I'm sure YT is going to trot out some stock reason for not re-instating the videos. Doesn't have to be particularly good either. They could adapt the one GOG used to censor a Taiwanese game developer: "After receiving many messages from users, we have decided not to list the Xianjiang videos on our service." That blew over quickly.
- elefanten 5y agoIt’s so sad. Google used to be one you could look up to but it has moved so far in the wrong direction. Capitulating to China would be the final straw for me.
- colordrops 5y agoYT has been horrible for equal representation of politics, ideas, and stories for years now. This is not a new development.