4 ms·
When a car manufacturer sells a car, in many parts of the world they're supposed to still offer parts for it for 7 years after they stop selling it, by law.
by oblio 5y ago
When a car manufacturer sells a car, in many parts of the world they're supposed to still offer parts for it for 7 years after they stop selling it, by law.
- joering2 5y agoMoreover, I think WD defense here will be that while you could, you did not have to plug your WD device to internet, in order for it to serve its purpose. They will try to argue that the majority of their offer is hard discs, and if your drive has extra ability to connect to internet, that's extra feature.
- cesarb 5y agoYes, but that "extra feature" is most probably the main reason that model was bought instead of a cheaper model without a network connection. That is, that "extra ability" would be in fact the main differentiator of that model.
- roel_v 5y agoBut consumer electronics are written off on much shorter timeframes than cars. Are we going to require support for electronics for 7 years? I would be in favor of it, but I don't see it happen. Device was EoL in 2015, the vuln is from 2019, breach 2021. Even if we take the vuln date, that's 4 years after EoL. The question then becomes: is it reasonable to say that electronics are expected to have a life half of that of cars? I could argue both ways on this.
- sokoloff 5y agoNB: The average age of a car in the US hit 12.1 years last year. https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/average-age-us-vehicles-hit-record-121-years-2020-ihs-markit-2021-06-14/ https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/averag...
- dtech 5y agoI'd argue that this is serious enough that EOL doesn't apply. Yeah sure EOL for updates, features, minor issues etc. But this is literally "Anyone in the world can remotely make your product unusable and destroy everything on it while you use it as intended" I don't care if a car manifacturer EOL'ed a car model, if an issue gets discovered that will make the engine explode at random they better do recall.
- Nursie 5y agoFor reference - my 13 yr old BMW just got a recall repair due to a potential problem with the air conditioning system.
- alisonkisk 5y agoThat's an interesting case. BMW knew about that back in 2012 but covered it up for 5+ years before finally agreeing to a recall. They perhaps are covering their butts against lawsuits due to thirty negligence. And they wouldn't want a new fire triggering extra attention to an old fire, and also they want to burnish (ha!) their brand image, unlike WD who has practically no competition. https://www.forensicdjs.com/blog/bmw-hvac-blower-wiring-recall/#:~:text=Earlier%20this%20month%2C%20BMW%20announced,concerns%20of%20potential%20fire%20risk.&text=Notable%20in%20the%20NHTSA%20filings,chronology%20associated%20with%20this%20recall https://www.forensicdjs.com/blog/bmw-hvac-blower-wiring-reca....
- Nursie 5y agoReally? Huh. It's the second recall it's had in the last 4 years or so, the first one was a power connector of some sort...
- alisonkisk 5y agoBut it's EOL. EOL means end of life, not just "no longer sold". EOL means we agreed it's trash and you are using it at your own risk. It's not the manufacturer's fault if your expired fire extinguisher or medicine fails. Internet things are out durable goods. They require maintenance or they fail. If EOL is unreasonably short, that's a factor in purchase decision or contract or commercial code violation if they surprised you with accelerated EOL.
- smoe 5y agoIn my opinion the difference should be whether something is the first generation of a product or an iteration. Basically somehow using the Lindy effect to determine how long it should be supported. E.g. if I had bought the very first generation of the iPhone it would have been much more out of couriosity, not long time usage expectation. But I think there now has been enough development on it, that I should be able to expect the iPhone I bought in 2020 to last say to 2030 somehow if I want to stick with it.
- roel_v 5y agoOK, well now come up with a formula that says (from a series of objective and not-readily-gameable characteristics) for a random electrical/electronic device (or, if you want to separate the two, provide a way to do so - is a 1980's microwave with an 8-bit controller for the timer 'electronics' or 'electrical'?) how long the warranty should be, how long it should be 'supported' (for a definition of 'supported') and how long critical errors should be fixed. Also specify which issues, and at which time point, should be paid for or not. There is a lot of 'everything should be supported for eternity for free' in this thread, but I see no (at least somewhat) concrete suggestions for better solutions. If it was easy, we would have done it people.
- southerntofu 5y ago> There is a lot of 'everything should be supported for eternity for free' in this thread, but I see no (at least somewhat) concrete suggestions for better solutions. If it was easy, we would have done it people. That's the easy, concrete solution. It's just not "profitable" from a capitalist perspective, and that's why no manufacturer is doing it. Well not exactly nobody. Some manufacturers like FACOM (probably others) that are not into electronics have (or used to have) lifetime warranties and will happily repair or replace a product that is decades old. The question is: as a society, do we want to pursue everyone's good and make things more efficient and ecological? or do we want more profits for the industry owners and more inequality and damage to the environment? These two paths are fundamentally opposed. There is no conciliating them. If you want "nature" and "consumer rights", then you need to abolish "capitalism".
- 5y ago
- usr1106 5y ago> But consumer electronics are written off on much shorter timeframes than cars. They are, but it kills the planet. We have 12 year old PCs in the family. Well, back then they were high-end models bought for work. Now they are running Linux just fine for general family purpose. They use a bit more of energy than a new model, but where we live you have to heat buildings at least 8 months a year anyway. I am sure producing a new one would have required much more resources.
- southerntofu 5y agoIt's also important to point out that despite using more energy because it's older hardware, it'll use considerably less energy during its all life, than it takes to produce a new computer. Replacing old hardware with "more energy-efficient" hardware is a trap from green capitalism and the numbers do not add up usually.
- benlivengood 5y agoI find this claim a little hard to believe. Data centers routinely replace ~3 year old computers because the number of old computers they would need to keep running and cooling exceeds the cost of new more efficient hardware. The price of new hardware includes all the energy costs of producing it. Obviously the environmental externalities of energy aren't fully priced in, but that is also the case for data center energy. What might be a more useful comparison is a $20 5W raspberry pi vs. a 2009 100W (at best) desktop computer where a month of continuous desktop operation costs more in energy than the new raspberry pi and ~1 year of usage.
- usr1106 5y agoIt depends on scale. In my home I need heating 8 months of the year despite having a couple of computers. Data centers need cooling.
- mnd999 5y agoSqueezebox touch still going strong here. Maybe I'm an outlier, but things shouldn't be disposable after a couple of years.
- iSnow 5y agoThat's not exactly great, tbh. A car can easily run for 10y (mine is due for a replacement at 19yo), so 7y seems ecologically unnecessarily wasteful. I get that it doesn't make sense to offer parts for 20yo cars, but if we want to live in a sustainable future, people need to stop replacing cars after 5y or so.
- oblio 5y agoMy point wasn't clear. 7 years is quite a long time. And as far as I know in general they can't prevent after market parts being produced. So car manufacturers are forced to allow their cars to be repaired, not necessarily with their parts, a long time after they've stopped selling them. IT stuff should start following the same lifecycle.
- mrspuratic 5y ago7 years is a relatively long time for a product, but not necessarily for a car. The average car age at scrap time is 13.9 years (UK stats). [Wildly off topic ranting about the balance of embodied versus emitted CO2 for the typical ICE vehicle omitted. Clue: 10 years is about the break-even point.]
- tpxl 5y ago> Wildly off topic ranting about the balance of embodied versus emitted CO2 for the typical ICE vehicle omitted. Clue: 10 years is about the break-even point Do you mean it takes about 10 years for the car to emit the same amount of co2 that was used in producing it?
- alisonkisk 5y agoIf so, that's not "breakeven". Breakeven is when future emissions savings from a newer better car make it worth scrapping (not just selling) a car and replacing it with a newly manufactured one.
- tiagod 5y ago