7 ms·
An interesting way to test whether it is a victimless crime is to pay prostitutes $100,000 and to see how quickly they return to the profession. One possible th
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
An interesting way to test whether it is a victimless crime is to pay prostitutes $100,000 and to see how quickly they return to the profession. One possible theory is that prostitution is a victim of poverty.
- solveit 5y agoSure, but are you willing to apply the same test to every other job and outlaw the ones that fail?
- jakelazaroff 5y agoMaybe not what GP was getting at, but I would like to structure society so that people don't have to spend big chunks of their lives doing menial jobs in order to afford their basic needs!
- rootusrootus 5y agoMore automation. Menial jobs still need to get done.
- danbruc 5y agoPay the menial jobs better. The person cleaning the toilets at Facebook should earn more than the developers there. EDIT: This is not meant literally, I am not talking about toilette cleaning jobs at Facebook, I am talking about paying people for the time they spent working and maybe how physically taxing or unpleasant the work is. This is in contrast to paying people what you can get away with because of the available supply of workers or how much money you have to throw around because you can get it from your customers.
- username90 5y agoThen you would have millions of people applying for a few thousand jobs. How would you decide who gets to work there and earn those salaries? Facebook does it by reducing the salary bit by bit until the number of people who wants to work there is roughly as many as they need.
- wpietri 5y agoI don't think you've tried very hard to figure out ways to decide. The obvious one is lottery, but there are many more. I'll note that lots of people want FB developer jobs, but they don't solve that problem by cutting salaries until the number of applicants is roughly equal to the number of jobs. It's a tell that you use one hiring heuristic for people in your social class and a different one for people seen as lesser. That's a great illustration of the overall problem that the original article is part of.
- username90 5y agoA lottery doesn't feel very fair though, does it? Why should a few people get paid more for the same work? Doesn't make sense.
- tablespoon 5y ago>>> Pay the menial jobs better. The person cleaning the toilets at Facebook should earn more than the developers there. >> I don't think you've tried very hard to figure out ways to decide. The obvious one is lottery, but there are many more. > A lottery doesn't feel very fair though, does it? Why should a few people get paid more for the same work? Doesn't make sense. A lottery is about the fairest way to distribute a scarce resource imaginable. And it seems even less fair to declare that everyone whose job is to clean toilets should continue to get equally crappy wages, while there's massive inequality in income all over the place.
- username90 5y agoThat is such a stupid argument, lottery is one of the worst way to distribute a scarce resource. It is better to split it up and pay everyone dividends rather than give a few the whole thing. In the case of Facebook we would tax it to hell so everyone could share, not do a damn lottery so a few janitors can get rich. Of course that is if you are in the "distribute resources to the people camp", but I see no reason why a lottery would ever be the right thing to do here no matter what camp you are in, it isn't like the world would be better off if we had a lottery of who gets to inherit the billions of dollars the 0.0001% owns rather than distribute it. So in short, the right thing to do is either leave facebook as is, or tax it so that neither its software engineers nor its janitors can earn much more than an average American.
- wruza 5y agoCosts. Facebook cannot replace a developer’s desk with auto-development station, but it definitely can do that to a toilet room. The only reason a toilet cleaner has a job is that they are cheap. If it was paid $300k/yr per floor, anyone at FB would automate floor mopping and sanitizer spraying in few weeks, if not rethink a toilet room completely. (Which isn’t a bad idea given how much of ancient legacy shit we are still dragging in this area.)
- danbruc 5y agoCut the salary of everyone by 5% and you can have one cleaner for every 20 developers. My point is simply that work should not be cheap, if someone works 40 hours a week for you, you owe that person a wage that allows a decent life, otherwise it is just a mild form of slavery.
- wruza 5y agoif someone works 40 hours a week for you, you owe that person a wage that allows a decent life I agree, humanely. But our entire competitive all-eating-optimizing nature works against this. Raising min.wages would likely lead to the situation where they have no job at all, because if low-paid jobs were enforced as decently paid by law, companies would simply automate them. They didn’t do that yet, only because it’s cheap to use human labor. Taxi, delivery, cleaning, you name it. If low skill job workers could get $$$$$$ jobs, they would. But they can’t, for various reasons. This is not fixable at the level we discussing. https://www.google.ru/search?q=raising+minimum+wage+increases+unemployment https://www.google.ru/search?q=raising+minimum+wage+increase...
- danbruc 5y agoI essentially agree with you but I think this not an argument against raising the minimum wage. They will not lose their jobs, they already do not have a job. Ignoring the facet of work as self-fulfillment or being part of society or whatever, the relevant part of a job for a worker is that it earns them a living wage, not that they do some work. In that sense someone with a job not earning them a living wage is already jobless. And if we actually run out of jobs valued at least a living wage for some part of society - and I have no illusion that everyone can become a developer if they just tried hard enough - then this is a problem that needs addressing. Just pretending that there are still jobs because there is work that is valued less than a living wage but still more expensive then automation, is not a solution. But I am not in a position to really judge objectively where we are, whether we are already out of jobs or whether some jobs are just underpaid because it is possible in the current market situation, or what mix of the former.
- imtringued 5y agoHow do you prosecute poverty? Does poverty lose by default and you award the victim damages?
- saiya-jin 5y agoYou can do the same cash experiment with most office workers and the effects might surprise you. You can say garbage management jobs, sweeping streets or even bureaucratic positions are the result of one's poverty. Just leave the god damned people alone, its sad that in 21st century some folks still feel above the rest of us and try to push their moral views unto everybody else.
- wonderwonder 5y agoIf you give someone who works fast food 100k are the going to go back to fast food? Not really a meaningful test as the vast majority of retail level jobs would fail it. What if some people just like working in sex work?
- username90 5y agoProstitutes are paid a lot since the number of men who are interested in casual sex is a lot more than the number of women. Then the pay goes up so much that many women who aren't originally interested in casual sex also starts to engage in it, just because men value it so much. So one way to reduce the number of "victims" would be to put a max cap on how much you are allowed to pay prostitutes, that way women wouldn't do it as an easy way to earn money. Because paying women too much for sex hurts them apparently.
- klyrs 5y ago> Prostitutes are paid a lot That's not a fair generalization. Most sex workers remain in poverty, and it's extremely risky work -- for all that men's rights activists like to talk about men having the most dangerous jobs, their statistics are drawn from a perspective that sex work isn't a "job" -- so the actual #1 most dangerous job, mostly done by women, is overlooked. Even in places like Canada were the work is decriminilized and clients are criminalized, sex workers rarely go to the police after being attacked or raped because the common response is that the worker "asked for it." Sex workers are freelancers: they don't get insurance or other benefits, so they need to charge a higher rate up-front. Rather than limit the amount that sex workers get paid, it would be better to legalize it and treat it like any other job. Forced labor (pimps and sex trafficking) is already illegal; those laws just need enforcement, which will be easier with the transparency of legal employment. Also, individual workers and brothels can get insurance, medical and otherwise, hire security, etc. to improve the safety of workers. Let the free market sort out the price.
- username90 5y agoIf they weren't paid a lot you wouldn't have a problem since these women would just go and work at McDonalds instead to earn their money. And if they remain in poverty even when being paid a lot they either work very few hours or they spend it on luxury goods like clothes or trips. Edit: Anyway, the argument isn't that prostitutes are victims because there is a lot of violence related to the profession. The argument is usually that it is inhumane to subject a woman to involuntary sex, so women accepting money to have sex they otherwise wouldn't is seen as a bad thing for the woman even under perfect conditions. That is the main argument why sex work should be illegal, everything else can be fixed but that can't ever be fixed no matter how much you improve surroundings. I don't agree with that view, but that is what you are up against.
- dqpb 5y agoI bet > 95% of all working people on earth would quite their current job if you gave them $100,000.
- tinus_hn 5y agoIs $100,000 supposed to be some kind of ‘set for life’ amount of money?
- username90 5y agoIt is enough to quit your job for many years, go study something, travel, or just take a break and try to pivot to a different kind of life.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dqpb 5y agoNope
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoIt's supposed to be a "solve immediate problems and buy time and/or education to find a better job" amount of money. Not enough that you can retire but enough that you don't have to worry about making ends meet for long enough to pivot to something else.
- jjk166 5y agoIt's enough buffer to make reasonable changes so as to get a more desirable profession if that is your goal, whether that's training for new skills, moving to a different location with better prospects, getting treatment for addictions, etc.
- jsilence 5y agoThis works with almost every job.
- jjk166 5y agoI mean, if you gave a janitor $100,000 in cash would they come into scrub your toilet again tomorrow? Does that mean hiring a janitor is a crime with a victim? Most everybody would behave differently if they had substantially more money. I know I wouldn't be working where I am if I didn't need a paycheck. But choosing a shittier job because it pays better is not victimization.