33 ms·
Is education no longer the ‘great equalizer’?
- donezo 5y agoSurely it still is the great equalizer. Everyone I know claiming to be educated is certainly the same.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- blakesterz 5y agoThis one seems kind of tough to quickly summarize, since it covers so much. I guess the final paragraph does a decent job: Education, training in cognitive and noncognitive skills, nutrition, health care and parenting are all among the building blocks of human capital, and evidence suggests that continuing investments that combat economic hardship among whites and minorities — and which help defuse debilitating conflicts over values, culture and race — stand the best chance of reversing the disarray and inequality that plague our political system and our social order. https://archive.is/gggnc https://archive.is/gggnc
- temp8964 5y agoSounds amazing. So the group of kids with 70% fatherless can achieve the same as the group of kids with 30% fatherless! Wow.
- pedro2 5y agoYes! Forbid procreation, import people from overpopulated countries!
- Ensorceled 5y agoWhat does this even mean? What in-group jargon is this?
- fatsquirrel 5y ago30% of white and Asian kids are born of divorced parents while it’s 70% for Black and Latinx kids.
- im3w1l 5y agoI think he says that 70% of kids in one group are fatherless, and 30% of kids in another group are. And then saying that there must be an achievement gap because of this difference.
- temp8964 5y agoSee data here: https://datacenter.kidscount.org/data/line/107-children-in-single-parent-families-by-race?loc=1&loct=1#1/any/false/1729,37,871,870,573,869,36,868,867,133/asc/10,11,9,12,1,185,13/431 https://datacenter.kidscount.org/data/line/107-children-in-s...
- rayiner 5y agoPart of the conflict over “values and culture,” however, is over things that affect human capital. As a Bangladeshi immigrant who married into a white American family, it’s really hard for me to not notice the devastation mainstream American culture has racked on the ability to develop human capital. My younger siblings in law, who are in their early 20s live in towns (these are mainly white, working to middle class towns) where everyone’s parents are divorced, drug use doesn’t get you a beating from your dad (who often isn’t there), etc. Kids can’t get their feet under them because their home situations are always changing. For boys this is particularly bad, because their natural inclination is to cause trouble and the only thing that can keep them in control is a network of older men. (My dad grew up in a village in Bangladesh and remarked that he couldn’t do anything anywhere in the village without word getting back to his father.) Money can paper over a lot of problems, I’ll give you that. But it seems to me that if Americans were as poor as Bangladeshis, their society would totally collapse. The culture isn’t suited for survival or upward mobility.
- lappet 5y agoI think this is the main con of American individualism. The alternative is the culture in Asian societies and perhaps to some extent in European ones as well - there is always an Uncle or Aunty who is watching out for you. Of course that has cons where you can't do things that are unconventional, but at the very least you have a stop gap to help young people who are lost.
- wyager 5y agoThe greatest and most rapid creation of wealth in human history occurred in the US under an even more extreme form of American individualism than exists today. Europe is quite poor relative to America precisely because its anti-individualism prevents the formation of economic-political environments conducive to wealth creation.
- bhupy 5y agoOne could argue that this historic wealth creation also coincided with a high degree of Judeo-Christian religiosity. We're yet to see if the same success can be replicated under an equally individualistic culture, but one without a unified moral fabric via religion. And I say this as an Asian who was raised a Hindu and is now an atheist.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- John23832 5y agoTwo parts: First, I think the ability to DO THINGS is the great equalizer at this point. Being a do-er lifts you out of poverty (or at least out of poverty's worst resting state). Being a do-er expands your network. Being a do-er prolongs your life (people with jobs/daily activities tend to live longer healthier lives). The best part about this is that technology has made it easier to become a do-er. You don't need as much specialized education or tools, and trial and error is free. Secondly, education's place as the great economic equalizer has weakened because we have weakened the education. In public schools (the most widely used education institutions in the US), kids are just shoveled through. Why? We put an emphasis on standardized testing and graduation rates while also chronically underfunding schools. That leads us to lower quality/quantity of teachers who are told to march to the drum of hitting numbers. The emphasis on "just graduating" pushes teachers to push kids through, event when they have not actually learned anything. That same philosophy then propagates to college, where TA's want to research for their Masters/PHDs, not teach. You then get a "working class" with no real skills/education/ambition... they do not "do", which leads back to my first comment.
- zozbot234 5y ago> while also chronically underfunding schools Schools are not underfunded in the U.S., they waste money. Big difference.
- John23832 5y agoSure. I can agree with that. The point being that, with the current schooling infrastructure, the amount of money needed to do what needs to be done isn't there.
- marcinzm 5y agoNo amount of money will fix a broken system from the inside since the money will go to those who broke the system in the first place.
- marcinzm 5y agoYup, from what I can tell the US has one of the highest per student spending amounts for primary and secondary schools.
- Bostonian 5y agoEducation is a multiplier of IQ, not an equalizer. Many people, although policymakers won't admit it, don't have the IQ to study at the high school level, for example learning algebra. Even more people don't have the IQ to study at the college level, for example studying calculus and writing a coherent, footnoted term paper. And only a small fraction of the population has the IQ to do significant research and earn a PhD. Charles Murray has discussed the IQ prerequisites of educational levels in his book Real Education. The article says, "In the U.S., the big achievement gaps across lines of race or social class open up very early, before kindergarten, rather than during college." Race and class differentials on IQ tests have been well documented but are in Paul Graham's category of What You Can't Say.
- benrbray 5y agoIn my own perhaps limited experience, I've never really encountered anyone who is simply incapable of deep thought / critical thinking. I've met plenty of people who have a learned helplessness when it comes to, say, math. I've studied alongside classmates who could't spend as much time studying as me, simply because they had to support themselves with part-time or full-time work just to keep their head above water. I've met plenty of people who are more or less happy with their current job, and spend time thinking critically about their hobby or other non-academic things. Sure, all other things held equal, maybe inherent intelligence is the limiting factor. But that's the point -- not everything else is equal. There are barriers other than IQ preventing people from achieving more, and I think we'd all be better off helping them overcome those barriers. Besides, IQ tests are a pretty phony measure of intelligence. They're about as reliable as lie detectors.
- kingsuper20 5y ago> I've met plenty of people who have a learned helplessness when it comes to, say, math. That strikes me as an insightful point. I'd say that the main point of math, considering how little the average person actually uses it beyond the elementary school level, is to teach people to learn and to approach problems in a different way. It has the same value as learning Latin or simple computer programming for a non-specialist. Also, the learned helplessness applies across society. A time and place filled with the self-employed (mostly farmers) has been replaced with worker bees. For various reasons normal skills sets now lack construction, vehicle repair, clothing fabrication, food production but are big on increasingly arcane theories of software development. It seems to me that learned helplessness is the largest single change of modern times.
- Kenji 5y agoIt still is, but you no longer get educated at school ;)
- kingsuper20 5y agoYou have to ask if the majority of 'educated' people actually do things of value. Perhaps we should simply follow a Lysenkoist approach of simply handing out a diploma to one and all. Forgive me for the old man moment, but I was just musing about how little my life has changed since the 1970s. Noticeable differences: TVs have more pixels, airliners look the same but are slower, you can order manufactured goods from your house without using the mail system, improvements in medicine where they can see what they are doing (surgery),these kids music it's all noise. Digital music and arguing on a communications network have been around since the 1980s. After all the fuss and fury, it's really all on the margin. You have to wonder what all these newly minted degree holders actually do. The growth of the FIRE industry is one answer.
- ipaddr 5y agoA degree holder in any field in 1970 could open many doors. Today a degree by itself could land you at Burger King. You need more education to obtain less now.
- kingsuper20 5y agoI expect that the main value was in proving you could sit at a desk for eight hours a day.
- username90 5y agoDoesn't even prove that, many college degrees are easier to pass than high school.
- beerandt 5y agoIt doesn't help that any student can get a loan to study whatever they want, often without any regard for future income potential. Most STEM majors don't have problems finding jobs. The days of an Art History degree being enough to qualify you as a "college graduate" for a 9-5 desk job in an unrelated field are certainly over. Which makes sense, economically. More college graduates means more specialized degrees to fill niche jobs, which generally pay better. Bushiness have a better chance of getting someone who's degree matches the job position, and don't need to settle for "college graduate" in unrelated field.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- whb07 5y agoControlling education is a political life source for the Democratic party in the U.S. One of the largest, if not the largest, unions is the teacher's and they are a major donor to the Democratic party. Thankfully, the one good thing about the shutdowns has been the ability for parents to observe a couple things: * how little the school system cares about the child * the indoctrination and political ideas being passed to children There are a number of states that have passed a "school choice" this year and its a rapidly growing movement. The idea is primarily to tie the funding money to the child rather than to the land. It generally means that if you move your child from school A to B, without school choice, school B wouldn't receive the money because it was bound to A. Heres an article from Reason talking about West Virginia passing the school choice: https://reason.com/2021/03/23/school-choice-is-coming-to-union-stronghold-west-virginia/ https://reason.com/2021/03/23/school-choice-is-coming-to-uni...
- doytch 5y agoI'm not American, but the core flaw that I've never had explained away for me in voucher or "school choice" systems is how "bad" schools get better. E.g., school in my district is bad. They don't have enough resources, or their teachers are bad. People begin taking their kids out of the school which means the school now has less money. Assuming they could fire teachers at will, they can't even now afford the "better" teachers who would likely cost more. They definitely can't afford more learning resources or an expansion to lower class sizes. So how do you prevent schools either going into a vicious or virtuous cycle?
- ModernMech 5y agoYou haven't gotten an explanation because people who advocate for "school choice" systems don't want the bad schools to get better. They just don't want their kids to interact with people who go to the bad school.
- mbg721 5y agoThat describes why people pay for private school more than it describes why people would support vouchers. The theory is that "school choice" would mean everyone would flee the worst schools and they'd be compelled to clean up their act or dissolve.
- dsign 5y ago> Is education no longer “a great equalizer of the conditions of men,” ... but instead a great divider? The article is very "feet on the earth", it reviews existing data and arguments, and generally advocates for a "no" as an answer to that question. But what if education were a great divider? What if--like wealth--the education gap were self-reinforcing, even across generations? To the well-educated, that seems far-fetched, but it's easy to find examples across the world where some people choose to believe or live according to X, which results in less emphasis put into "modern" education, which in turn makes it easier to keep believing in X, and so on. On the other side, learning skills A, B and C may require a considerable investment in time and money. Right now is not that bad, but just imagine for a moment that ten or fifteen years of education were needed for job K, which pays three orders of magnitude more than the jobs that people who live according to X have access to. Still, death would seem the perfect equalizer (not education), except if expensive life-extension is added to the mix...
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoI think it's cultural, but not perhaps in the way you describe. Parents who believe in education often produce better-educated children. Reading to them when they're small, helping with homework when they need it, talking about college even when they're young, and just not letting them give up on school. I suspect that, at least to some degree, that is transmissable - that is, it tends to produce children who, when they are adults, will value education for their children.
- TrackerFF 5y agoIn a lot of European countries, a robust social safety net is the great equalizer. You don't get locked up to work in order to afford healthcare, food, etc. - and are thus more free to take chances. Furthermore, strong labor laws have compressed salaries towards the mean, so people are not locking themselves into poverty by working low-wage / low-skill work, but there's a difference enough that people are incentivized to get educated. I think it's a decent harmony - compared to other countries, where you have a poor working class and rich/wealthy middle/upper middle class. I think that if education is the only ticket to a better life, then you get stuck with the problem that not all educated people are equal, and only certain educated people get to climb socioeconomic classes (too many schools, too many graduates, i.e inflation)
- ipaddr 5y agoYou think in Europe people are more free to take chances than the US? There is less of a need to take a chance so people play it safe. Why risk it all or anything when your needs are met and money gets taxed highly at the upperend.
- yoz-y 5y agoThere is that, and also less funding and more regulation.
- slibhb 5y ago> You don't get locked up to work in order to afford healthcare, food, etc. - and are thus more free to take chances. If Europeans are more free to take chances, why is there substantially less innovation in Europe? I don't think Europe is "worse" than the US. I think Europe is optimized for the poor whereas the US is optimized for the middle class and above. There are good arguments for both of these situations. In the US, it is widely felt that the system should serve the tax payers. Europeans, on the other hand, seem to have a lot more solidarity with the poor who, for whatever reason, don't pay significant taxes. Additionally (and controversially), I think a significant amount of the European attitude comes down to ethnic solidarity. European countries are ethnostates and the US isn't. One interesting thing is that Europeans benefit from American innovation. They have iphones, windows pcs, use google, etc like everyone else.
- MattGaiser 5y agoIs the education the new to education people on the bottom level are getting really the same? We have heard plenty of stories of grades watered down to meet graduation targets, students being unable to get less than 50%, the proliferation of crappy for profit schools like Corinthian, and students being piped into college just to take tons of remedial courses.
- yzombinator 5y agoWhy is a gap between different socio-economic strata amazing? Do people really assume parents have absolutely nothing to add to the table? Only government? Of course they do! Which means, a gap must by definition exist. That gap is the reason people want to move up a class. Any program that the state adopts as policy will have a weak implementation. As a family will surely see the stakes and counteract/use it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kstenerud 5y agoEducation never was the "Great Equalizer". Its purpose has always been "to educate people in what they need to know." Now, "what they need to know" differs by caste. The high caste learn how they deserve their privileged position, how to perpetuate their position, and who are the key players. The medium caste learn how to set up or run business and merchant operations, how to be an exec, how power works, who are the key players within their field, and how to cultivate their networks. The low caste learn how to do the jobs they're destined for, how to take orders, how to climb the ladder (somewhat), and hopefully how to politick at work. The bottom caste are lucky to learn anything beyond reading, writing, and a smattering of arithmetic. They might learn a few things to help them in their jobs, but there's really no point since they're easily replaced anyway. Education follows our birth caste. That's all we're raised to realistically aspire to, and that's also all the higher castes will allow for you unless you get VERY lucky (i.e. someone wasn't paying attention), or someone throws you a bone (scholarship or the like - and even then you're limited in how far you can rise without resentful pushback). New money is always frowned upon for at least a few generations. Most of us are in the bottom two castes. Medium is reserved for the 2% whose families are wealthy and influential enough. I doubt you know anyone in the high caste.
- alexgmcm 5y agoI somewhat agree with the sentiment although I think it's a bit pessimistic and as described holds a stronger resemblance to a YA dystopian novel than reality. I went to a state school (i.e. public school in American terminology) in a poor area and studied hard and did well, got scholarships, went to Uni etc. There are some problems with people not being able to afford to dedicate time to study - this can be solved by offering a maintenance allowance to all students, as I believe is done in some Nordic countries. But the biggest issue I saw in my high school was people either giving up on education altogether, or having unrealistic expectations leading them to choose University degrees with poor job prospects. Note, I include the trades in education as in fact they better than many University degrees when it comes to helping people improve their lot in life.
- rejectedandsad 5y ago
- slumdev 5y agoThe first statistic in the article (high school completion rate) is not an appropriate measure. There's a growing body of evidence that high school seniors are being graduated whether they're capable or not, so a diploma in 2016 means much less than a diploma from 1976: https://www.uschamber.com/above-the-fold/high-school-seniors-not-making-the-grade-math-and-reading https://www.uschamber.com/above-the-fold/high-school-seniors...
- fatsquirrel 5y agoThe article is paywalled so I can’t read it, but I think it’s about degree inflation and watered down education. Kids aren’t learning valuable career skills, but merely that mitochondria is the powerhouse of the cell.
- omgwtfbbq 5y agoColleges and Universities were never meant to be a Job Training program, I never understood people who think of them that way. Corporations have somehow passed the buck for on the job training to colleges while simultaneously complaining that grads aren't ready for the job. If they want trained employees they should be training them or we need a completely separate system of credentialing "trained" workers, the College and University system was never meant for this.
- LightG 5y agoSorry, education is very important. But more important is who you know ... however that came to be. Might be family, chance, lucky, fortune. But it's true. I hate that it's true, but it is true. Hence, education is not the great equalizer, it is the mildly helpful stabiliser. Don't believe me? Look around ... many good examples of educated people making it, but many more people of educated people who knew "someone" making it. Worse, many uneducated people matching or exceeding that performance.
- neartheplain 5y agoInteresting to see this on the front page right next to "Software Developer Shortage Is Coming": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27606393 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27606393 Can't speak to other forms of higher education, but my degree in computer science has more than paid for itself and acted as my ladder to the upper-middle class.
- ignJack188 5y agoUnfortunately, education in the US is becoming really expensive. The cohort based learning is the way to go! sites like Maven are the future.
- asdff 5y agoGoing to school in state is still cheap for most Americans. UCLA is 13k a year in state, CSULA is 6k a year in state. USC gives you a full ride if your household makes below a certain amount. It's no small chunk of change but its possible to put a dent in it if you work long hours in the summers between classes, and have roommates or live with family.
- synergy20 5y agoIn public education, it's no longer 'equal opportunity', the no-child-left-behind has evolved into 'equity result', i.e. the ISD and teachers are rated based on how all students' scores are the same. in high schools I know ,the tests are designed so easy that many can score 90+, so you see the whole class are all squeezed into the 90~100 range, everyone is happy and feeling justice and fairness, except that they will fail in college so we will need increase H1B cap more. these I feel are not good for the future of the country, good intentions do not necessarily mean good result, quite the opposite.
- clarkmoody 5y agoEducation and schooling are different things. There is a lot of schooling going on. I can't say the same for education.
- heresie-dabord 5y agoCitizens in a democracy need to learn to how to participate in a democracy. Citizens in a capitalist system need to learn how capitalism works. Citizens in an engineering economy need to learn engineering. There is a little of the latter happening.
- mgh2 5y agoEducation is worthless if there are no opportunities. In Argentina, there are PhDs as cab drivers. Opportunities are correlated to how well authorities run the country. There is some data trying to pinpoint relationships with other factors: GDP, corruption, and religion, etc. https://m-g-h.medium.com/in-data-we-trust-2978dacc8c22 https://m-g-h.medium.com/in-data-we-trust-2978dacc8c22
- basementcat 5y agoI had a tow truck driver who had a Ph.D in mechanical engineering. He worked for an engineering company for a few years before he decided to move back to the mountains. I learned so much about control theory riding with him in the cab of his truck.
- nnadams 5y agoPeople like that resemble modern day "wise men" or sages to me. Our middle school janitor was a math PhD who left academia, became a farmer for decades, and eventually our janitor. He rarely told anyone his credentials. Most people thought he was just some old man. I watched parents and teachers be rude to him, but he'd always smile and be polite. Some of us used to help him from time to time. He was very kind and would always listen to our kid-sized problems while we worked.
- hpoe 5y agoI looked through your link and apart from a handful of sources linking to random Guardian articles and Wikipedia it didn't actually cite the source it used as it's central claim and then proceeded with rather disjointed points each poorly supported and ended with some sort of vague platitude about how we need to look at data despute never actually making a conclusion.
- mgh2 5y agoThe conclusion is that there might be a correlation between a country's culture, largely shaped by its majority religion, to its GDP over time. It is too complex to explain so the article is just an inquiry into an overlooked factor, often ignored by economists.
- naturalauction 5y agoThe oped touches on one thing I noticed during my time at the University of Cambridge. Almost everyone I talked to there had parents who invested heavily in them either monetarily (hiring nannies, intensive pre-school/after-school care/private school) or time wise from a young age. Increasing access to early child education as argued for by the author seems like no-brainer to bridge some of the gap between children of parents who invest more in their kids’ future and children of parents who either can’t or don’t want to.
- aroundtown 5y agoImproving access to education is not enough. You have to improve opportunity. For example, I grew up extremely poor, and went to a small school. The most my parents knew about college was that I was going to go to one. Now I had the intelligence to get into just about any school I wanted, but I had no idea what/where those schools were. I also was unaware of how scholarships worked, or that I could have afforded most schools because we were poor. So I didn't apply to the few dream schools I knew of (MIT, Harvard, and Yale were the only big schools I knew about). I applied and was accepted to two state schools in my region and went to one of those. My partner is appalled at the lack of opportunities I had growing up. No amount of money at the time would have fixed the situation, only moving to an area with better opportunities for me would have.
- naturalauction 5y agoI think you slightly misunderstood my point. I'm not talking about kids who are considering college, or even know about college. I'm talking about children who are in elementary school or even younger, before they can take care of themselves at all. Studies linked in the article show that availability of free preschool likely had a casual impact on high school graduation rates and college attendance at all. IMO improving those rates are more important than the tail-end of the distribution (MIT vs other colleges) as it would lead to markedly less inequality. Elite schools admit such a small number of students that I don't think educating kids about them would make much of an impact on aggregate (it obviously would for specific kids).
- 5y ago
- jhoechtl 5y agoFor Austria it has been an equalizer in the 1970 to the 1990 when Socialist parties guaranteed free quality education for everyone and parental leave (for woman back then) of more than a year. Since then the educational system has been largely privatized, education by means of sheer oversupply completely devalued and turned into a money game. The more money you are willing to pay, the easier it will become to get a degree, mostly unaffected by the cognitive ability of the student. As this fact is increasingly tickling into society, the effect is that education is no longer an equalizer.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- arminiusreturns 5y agoThe oligarchs have been working to detroy the middle class for a long time now (see the Norman Dodd interview or The Leipzig Connection), and education is a key piece of that work, because it truly can be a great equalizer. You will notice not just different curriculum, but entirely different methods being used at a posh place for the elite like Eton, vs a (US) public school or even most upper middle class private schools. Class war is real, the rich are winning, and education is a key part of that war.
- wutbrodo 5y agoI believe the gap between private schools and public schools, because I've seen it (a good friend of mine had to repeat a grade coming from his rich-area public school to our private school). But is there any evidence of a gap in instructional quality between (eg) Eton and upper-middle-class private schools? I don't know a ton about the topic, but this would be pretty surprising given my current low-confidence understanding. I believe that there's a success gap, but that's plausibly down to the inescapable networking advantages of concentrating elites, and isn't relevant to the specific claim you're making.
- derbOac 5y agoEven here on HN I've seen "looking to hire" posts where they basically come out and say they will only consider people from elite colleges and universities. It's hard to see stuff like that, so blatant, and not conclude there's a signaling-networking phenomenon going on. It comes up in other things I've seen too, where I know some idea has been floated over and over again by various groups, and then some deal is announced in the news where some institution (university or corporation) is given the grant or funding or whatever, for the same thing as all the other proposals, and it's obvious it's a rich get richer phenomenon. These issues are always so complicated because they don't operate in any of the ways that people assume stereotypically. One person will be hit by circumstance positively or negatively in a way that's idiosyncratic to them, and privilege operates in subtle ways sometimes. As for your question, a few years ago there was a blog post making the rounds showing that across colleges, students improve across their undergrad years on standardized testing, but it's pretty much uniform across colleges. More selective colleges have higher means (and in some studies lower variance) but the rate of learning isn't any different, and there's huge overlaps in distributions between institutions. I've tried to find it but haven't been able to from where I'm at at the moment.
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.is/gggnc https://archive.is/gggnc
- twiddling 5y agohttps://www.manhattan-institute.org/educational-pluralism-in-united-states https://www.manhattan-institute.org/educational-pluralism-in... "In reality, the U.S. is an outlier. Educational pluralism—a school system in which the government funds and regulates, but does not necessarily provide, public education—is the democratic norm around the world. The list of educationally plural systems is long, and it includes the United Kingdom, Hong Kong, Belgium, Denmark, Indonesia, Israel, Sweden, and France."
- Applejinx 5y agoA lot of people here need to talk to some entrepreneurs. It doesn't matter how good, or how well funded, the school system is: if the family is poor, you're not going to be able to float rent on the storefront you need, or purchase initial inventory of whatever you're making, much less soak up a few false starts, much less take out a bank loan to do any of these things. Period. This does not in ANY WAY mean there shouldn't be good school funding across the board. It means that anybody who thinks 'the schools are now funded, so the kids from poor families are now equally able to start a business' is high… or disingenuous. Let's assume these kids are hungrier, more motivated, and just generally better than most people. If you expect them to simply get busy competing with lazier and less capable kids from wealth and privilege, because they ARE better than the lazy rich, you are overlooking the role of generational capital and access to capital. It would not matter if you were in fact significantly better, smarter and more motivated: banks want collateral, and entrepreneurial exploits don't always bootstrap up from zero. I think it's far more common to prime the pump, sometimes to the tune of tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars each time. By all means educate, but don't con yourself that it will matter, in the absence of any other changes.
- borodi 5y agoAs always, the easiest way to be successful is to be born in a successful family
- water8 5y agoIts better to be born in the 95th percentile in intelligence vs the 95th percentile in wealth in terms of where you will actually end up.
- syops 5y agoDo you have evidence for this? My impression is the opposite but I have no evidence that I'm right or wrong. It's just an impression that I have.
- dwater 5y agoI’m going to need a reference to support that claim. I did some searching and the closest I could find was a 2019 Georgetown study that said it was better to be affluent and in the bottom 25% of test scores than poor and in the top 25%.
- dalbasal 5y ago>>ongoing debate over what kind of investments in human capital If we start by adopting the "human capital" frame, we've already biased the discussion. The premise of this frame is that earnings are all to be understood as returns on capital. Earnings that are not returns capital are evidence if some sort of dark capital. A related frame is a supply/demand understanding of executive pay, or lawyer salaries... it's hard to square observations with theory, resulting in some pretty weird conclusions. If we want to explore new ideas, imo, it's best to avoid rhetorical or theoretical frames that yielded the old ones. This article is a perfect case in point. Models of parenting "types" as causal to earnings. What bollocks.
- ineedasername 5y agoI don't think you can separate the concept of education as an "equalizer" from the realities of the supply & demand for educated workers. As more educated workers entered the workplace, the minimum education requirements increased. As an example, my father, without an college degree, moved up from an entry level labor worker in the early 70's to the VP of operations for the entire company, something nearly impossible today with low-level management positions gated by a degree requirement. Because when most candidates have a degree, finding someone both qualified & with a degree is less of an obstacle. All else being equal, two identical resumes except for the "Bachelors Degree" on one of them, the later is more likely to get an interview and the job. Absolutely this might not always be ideal, the signal of having degree does not always actually predict capabilities, but that was the case when HS education was the minimum standard as well, and so long as companies need a low-pass filter to narrow the pool of candidates, this isn't likely to change. Whether or not it's fair or accurate is somewhat irrelevant.
- foolinaround 5y agoone root cause for poor education that does not seem to be discussed in the thread is the absence of fathers - or even the attention spent by parents of the child. If this is factored out, one could see more uniform outcomes.
- Invictus0 5y agoMy girlfriend's father died when she was 4 and her mother was an alcoholic for many years, she still turned out great and got herself into college at 17. On the other hand, I know many people with tiger or helicopter parents who lack even the most basic life skills, have difficulty socializing, don't know their physical limits, or have strong entitlement complexes. Attention to child is a poor metric for quality of parenting.
- foolinaround 5y agothats great for you both, but its' one person's data point, that does not take away from the overall statement. What I meant by "attention to child" is that children generally push at boundaries, and there needs to be mature people in their life who keep watch and bring them back in.
- jwilber 5y agoYou call out that response for being anecdotal, but provide zero evidence in your original claim or follow up response.
- foolinaround 5y agoSorry, I thought it is a no-brainer, but here is some from a google search. I dont think there are any studies claiming the opposite. https://lib.dr.iastate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=16288&context=rtd https://lib.dr.iastate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=16288... https://msutoday.msu.edu/news/2016/dads-play-key-role-in-child-development https://msutoday.msu.edu/news/2016/dads-play-key-role-in-chi...
- aroundtown 5y agoIt was only a way to move up into and through the middle class. It was never a ticket to any place else. The reason is simple, lack of opportunity. Sometimes opportunity is money, privilege, or luck. Sometimes it's being at the right place at the right time, befriending the right person at a party, or working together on a group project. Every entrepreneur that I have known has come has some sort of privilege to get them where they are. One, not only had moderately wealthy parents, but those parents raised him inside of a successful store. From a young age he was taught how to make a venture work, he had a fall back if he failed, and he had people to call if he needed advice. Because of the opportunities they had in life, they believe that it was all hard work and intelligence that got them there. My best friend from grade school was very wealthy. My friend has had more opportunities in life, just because their parents could float them while they took unpaid internships, complete graduate school, and buy them a nice big house so they could settle down and start a family. If you want a 'great equalizer' you have to provide opportunity to those that don't have it. You have to check your privilege at the door and consider for a moment that some people don't have it as good as you. You have to give people a chance to prove themselves. Even in the US and in Tech, if you were raised or live outside of a major metro, you are at a significant disadvantage to those who had the luck to living in one. If we want to fix this, we have to prioritize giving more opportunities to those who don't have them.
- randomdata 5y ago> It was only a way to move up into and through the middle class. And failed miserably even at that. Incomes have remained the same – stagnant, to use more common terminology – through the rise of post-secondary education. Nothing has been gained, only lost in direct and opportunity cost. All post-secondary education has shown is the those who have greater privilege, like not being born with a crippling disability that leaves one to struggle in school, tend to do better in school and have less struggles in the rest of their life because of those privileges.
- indymike 5y agoHonestly big student loans are the problem. Kid one goes to college, graduates with a degree in musical theater, has a $120k debt and gets a $50k first job in marketing. Kid two does two years an a plumbing apprentice. She's been making $45k per year, has no debt and just got her license... And is now making $90k.
- bejelentkezni 5y agoStudent loans are a big problem but it's not because trade jobs exist. It's because the federal government subsidizes tuition without bothering to pass any laws to cap it. Conveniently lobbied for in turn by public universities, all paid for with the public's money, turning around and selling patents to capitalists and reselling the stadium to the public. And making off like bandits. And don't kid yourself, any given city where a marketer makes $50k, even before commissions, will not be seeing plumbers make $90k.
- indymike 5y ago> And don't kid yourself, any given city where a marketer makes $50k, even before commissions, will not be seeing plumbers make $90k. Well... about that... Case in point: Indianapolis, In. Average marketing job pay: $55k. Average Plumber $78K (as of 2020). Ok, it's not $90K, but that is the average. It's similar in other cities.
- presentation 5y agoIt's harder to affect directly, but I think parenting is key for producing better educational outcomes - the parts about parenting style were pretty cool to see codified.
- khaki54 5y agoLowering the barrier to entry requires lowering the barrier to exit as well.
- pdfernhout 5y ago"Schooling" is what is really meant in the article -- not true "education" of which there is little of in most compulsory schools. According to two-times NY Teacher of the Year John Taylor Gatto, Prussian-derived compulsory schooling as practiced in the USA was primarily instituted to dumb people down and make them compliant workers, consumers, and soldiers. Gatto argues that if you give schools more money and they will only do that primary mission more effectively. Gatto calls this a "conspiracy against ourselves" where populations knowingly made a tradeoff 150 years or so ago to get the perks of cheaper mass-produced consumer goods and fearsome armies and swaddling cradle-to-grave bureaucracy -- but at a long term cost of the spirit. See Gatto's book (one of many): "The Underground History of American Education: A School Teacher's Intimate Investigation Into the Problem of Modern Schooling" https://archive.org/details/TheUndergroundHistoryOfAmericanEducation_758 https://archive.org/details/TheUndergroundHistoryOfAmericanE... "John Taylor Gatto is a former New York public schoolteacher who taught for thirty years and won multiple awards for his teaching. However, constant harassment by unhelpful administrations plus his own frustrations with what he came to realize were the inherent systemic deficiencies of our `public' schools led him to resign; he now is a school-choice activist who writes and speaks against our compulsory, government-run school system. ... In the final analysis, Gatto believes that compulsory, government-run schooling is inherently destructive to true education, the cultivation of self-reliance, and indeed to individualism - which used to be a defining element of the American character. The true purpose of our public school system in reality has more to do with control than it does with learning. This does not mean that rank-and-file teachers, principals, and even superintendents believe they are making students dumber, more conformist, less self-reliant, less capable of genuine analytical, independent thought, and more easily controlled; most people involved in the system no doubt believe that they are trying their best to really teach their students. However, the system itself (which Gatto often characterizes as a complex web) ensures that its real purpose is served, despite the efforts of individual reformers within it - that true democracy is rendered unworkable even as the trappings of democracy are allegedly bolstered. Seen in this light, these institutions that produce barely literate, dependent, conformist, incomplete individuals full of emotional and psychological problems, who lack real knowledge (and whose capacity for acquiring such is deliberately weakened or eliminated), and who are just `educated' enough to pay their taxes and buy the latest products, are not, in fact, failing schools - on the contrary, if we are to believe Gatto's analysis, they are performing their designated function PERFECTLY. That purpose is to mold people in such a way as to make them more easily controlled by corporations and the state (a clear-cut example of how, contrary to popular myth, the interests of big business and those of big government more often than not coincide.)" Or for a short essay on this, consider Gatto's "Seven Lesson Schoolteacher": https://www.life-enthusiast.com/articles/children-seven-lesson-schoolteacher/ https://www.life-enthusiast.com/articles/children-seven-less... "... Look again at the seven lessons of school teaching: confusion, class position, indifference, emotional and intellectual dependency, conditional self-esteem, surveillance – all of these things are prime training for permanent underclasses, people deprived forever of finding the center of their own special genius. ..." And while sometimes college can be a bit of a relief from some of the worst of this, graduate school and professional schools then brings it back with a new twist, as explained in "Disciplined Minds": https://disciplinedminds.tripod.com/ https://disciplinedminds.tripod.com/ "Who are you going to be? That is the question. In this riveting book about the world of professional work, Jeff Schmidt demonstrates that the workplace is a battleground for the very identity of the individual, as is graduate school, where professionals are trained. He shows that professional work is inherently political, and that professionals are hired to subordinate their own vision and maintain strict "ideological discipline." The hidden root of much career dissatisfaction, argues Schmidt, is the professional's lack of control over the political component of his or her creative work. Many professionals set out to make a contribution to society and add meaning to their lives. Yet our system of professional education and employment abusively inculcates an acceptance of politically subordinate roles in which professionals typically do not make a significant difference, undermining the creative potential of individuals, organizations and even democracy. Schmidt details the battle one must fight to be an independent thinker and to pursue one's own social vision in today's corporate society. He shows how an honest reassessment of what it really means to be a professional employee can be remarkably liberating. After reading this brutally frank book, no one who works for a living will ever think the same way about his or her job." There are of course some great teachers scattered about in many schools. There are students who evade some of the worst of this dumbing down by luck or skill or hobbies. There are families that homeschool in a variety of ways. There are even some schools that support alternative models. https://www.educationrevolution.org/store/findaschool/memberschools/ https://www.educationrevolution.org/store/findaschool/member... Here is a conference on educational alternatives starting tomorrow: https://www.aeroconference.org/keynote-speakers-1 https://www.aeroconference.org/keynote-speakers-1 But the majority of schooling for most people (at least in the USA) remains overall a dulling "equalizing" experience -- especially if you are brighter and so needed to be reduced in intensity to become a standardized product. Related on an mythical "equalizer" making people fit an arbitrary standard: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Procrustes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Procrustes
- zhangjunphy 5y agoIt is really interesting to read the comments in this thread. From an outsider's perspective, US has been the most prosperous country in this planet. People generally have good chances to move up the class ladder. And there are a lot of active enterprises. But I had the strong feeling that this stop to be the case in recent decades. The reason, as I see it, is the natural tendency of capitalism, people seeking to maximize their individual capital. In the past century, with the pressure of the cold war, this tendency is balanced by the government, as US needed its working class to actually make innovations and make products to gain the advantage in the competition with the Soviet Union. In fact, the working class got their best treatment during the cold war, and then it worsens in recent decades. Now with the Soviet Union dead, and China is still too young to be an actual competitor. There is no obstacle for the capitalists to play their games. It should be evident for most Americans that the price of properties are inflating while the increase of their salary slowed. The government also got eroded, most of the people there are either capitalists or have good relationship with them. What will be their incentives to change the rules? This is not just the problem with US, it happens also in China. And I don't see a solution to it. The lower classes are controlled tightly by the media, which is controlled by the capitalists. And the middle class is thin and divided. In fact a lot of the middle class try very hard to climb the social ladder so they can be one of the upper class. They don't want the game changed, just "modified" to benefit themselves a bit.
- wolfgangK 5y agoHas education ever been ? Can it ever be ? I'm not sure it makes sense to hope that anything could prevent offspring to be more similar (and have more similar lives) to their parents that to random member of their species. Gregory Clark is very sobering in this regard : http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/110873/1/Working_Paper_67.pdf http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/110873/1/Working_Paper_67.pdf EDIT: See also https://edi.opml.co.uk/wpcms/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/Kyrgyz-tribes-shortened-w-cover.pdf https://edi.opml.co.uk/wpcms/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/Kyrg...
- shreyshnaccount 5y agoNo it's not. Quality education has always been for the rich and continues to be. Not to be dramatic but meritocracy feels like a lie at this point. I got accepted to a T30 uni, but surprise surprise, there's no way I can attend it, cuz they don't give scholarships based on financial need, and the ones which do, would have me graduating into 6fig debt... Not in this economy I'm not gonna do that... Amazing feeling to have your dreams crushed and hard work rendered useless just due to green paper Frankly the headline is pretentious af for even asking this question
- throwaway789256 5y agoFreddie DeBoer has written about this repeatedly, including in his latest post: https://freddiedeboer.substack.com/p/education-week-review-of-the-education https://freddiedeboer.substack.com/p/education-week-review-o... Briefly: many educational institutions were not designed to increase equality, but to protect professions by acting as gatekeepers through a process of cartelization.
- charwalker 5y agoNot if it puts you in 20-150k of debt you can't drop in even in bankruptcy. Those with the means move on with an education and connections while others may not even be able to afford the maintenance on a car.