18 ms·
The landing page contains logos for clubhouse, discord, and shippo, which are presumably companies use the service. Does anyone find those usages to be unnecess
by gruez 5y ago
The landing page contains logos for clubhouse, discord, and shippo, which are presumably companies use the service. Does anyone find those usages to be unnecessarily intrusive? Maybe it's just me, but a chat app or shipping site asking me for a drivers license scan + selfie would make me never want to use the service again. It's appalling how this sort of stuff is getting normalized, eg. google asking for id scans for age verification.
- 4b11b4 5y agoWhat's the difference between filling out your address in text versus scanning? Is your face not on the internet yet? Just curious what specifically would make you never want to use it?
- oauea 5y agoWhy would these companies need to gather enough data to steal my identity?
- wyager 5y agoI can easily provide a fake address to protect my privacy. Harder and legally risky to provide a fake ID to protect privacy.
- DharmaPolice 5y agoIf you enter an address in as text you're in control of the data you're supplying. If you have to upload/scan a document then there might be other information they extract/store. I'm not someone concerned with such things but it's easy to see how they're different.
- floatingatoll 5y agoScanning lets you audit for photoshopping and sets a vastly higher bar for counterfeiting. (For example, Blizzard’s name change process requires you to cover irrelevant areas of your ID with actual paper, because no digital editing permitted.) See also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27503674 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27503674
- huhtenberg 5y ago> Is your face not on the internet yet? Careful there, mate. This is just another form of the infamous "Nothing to hide" fallacy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nothing_to_hide_argument https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nothing_to_hide_argument
- mcrae 5y agoClubhouse lets you collect payments to join some channels. Isn’t KYC reasonable in that case? Re: Age Verifications on Google & YouTube: this has been covered well elsewhere. Google is required to do so by EU law. Blame regulators not the companies.
- gruez 5y ago> Clubhouse lets you collect payments to join some channels. Isn’t KYC reasonable in that case? If it's limited to only people receiving payments, then it's far more reasonable than what I thought was happening (eg. people getting randomly asked for ID scans to use their service).
- nucleardog 5y agoOthers have said it's limited to people who have a bot joined to more than 75 servers, or use certain sensitive scopes. So it's not quite that restrictive (only payments). But I can say that I'm in... about 10 servers as a user and have a couple of bots I hacked together for various things operating in 3 of them and have never been asked for anything but my email. And across all the people I know using Discord, I was totally unaware that they even did that sort of identity verification because it seems like no one I know's ever run into it.
- wyager 5y ago> Isn’t KYC reasonable in that case No. This is something we’ve become dangerously desensitized to.
- 3np 5y agoThey’re required to verify that users are above a certain age. There are no requirements to solicit and keep information or documents beyond that. Just because the easiest shortcut to age verification is requiring a copy of a government ID, this doesn’t mean that that’s a good idea.
- Kiro 5y agoRegular Discord users don't need to send in anything. It's used to verify your bot (only applicable for bots that are in more than 75 servers), which seems like a reasonable use case.
- sascha_sl 5y agoMore a requirement at this point. Discord had to crack down on malicious bot developers after some decided to log essentially every bit of information ever sent to them to be put on the internet, including information from private channels. Some scopes require this verification outright now.
- d110af5ccf 5y ago> decided to log essentially every bit of information ever sent to them Kind of like IRC? Which is basically what Discord is. Why would you assume anything you put on the internet isn't part of the permanent public record? (Wait until you find out about mailing lists, Reddit mirrors, the Internet Archive, ...) (Aside: The only halfway sane solution to this is having separate disconnected identities for each service you use and cycling them semi-regularly so you don't need to worry too much about small identifying details being aggregated.)
- sascha_sl 5y agoAre you seriously Internet Archiving me right now. Okay, where do I start… One, Discord is still primarily used by underage people. Two, most Discord guilds are not public, this was a case of malicious bots. If you install an app on your phone, is your expectation automatically that it will skirt all App Store rules and dump the contents of your phone on the internet? I hate people that obsessively archive everything, but even I can see the case for IRC being expected to be public. Especially without SSL enforcement on a channel. Discord does not work like that at all. You are advocating for a treasure trove for the likes of Kiwifarms. (Which is exactly how dis.cool ended up being used, as a stalking tool) Three, the people who say “every litte piece of info on the internet becomes part of the public record, be careful” are also the ones doing the archiving. Nobody else cares enough. Stop doing it. Not everything is worth preserving only because you are a data hoarder. I’m happy you think you’re building the library of alexandria, just make sure it’s not built out of piles of shit and PII. If it was technically feasible to permanently record every public place outside the internet and make the recordings available to everyone, would you be in favor of that too? Just because the internet makes that technically feasible doesn't mean it's a good idea.
- judge2020 5y agoDiscord uses it to verify the identity of bot makers - my understanding is that bots have been abused for a long time for data collection (think logging when users come online, go offline, change status, etc).
- gruez 5y agoI don't get it. They're concerned about people abusing the system, and their solution is... requiring KYC? How does that solve the issue? It sounds like bot makes can still passively collect the info, it's just that when it gets discovered they can point to a real person to blame. Moreover, why do bots even need to know the online/offline status of users? Why not add a permission system so users can opt in/out of providing this sort of information to bots? I'm not a discord bot maker, but there's plenty of hobby/side projects I'm willing to provide to users for free, but not willing to attach my real life identity to.
- floatingatoll 5y agoIt lets them hold the bot author legally liable for malfeasance, which is difficult if you’re only a throwaway Gmail address.
- nucleardog 5y ago> Why not add a permission system so users can opt in/out of providing this sort of information to bots? The bots provide a function for the "server" and the server operator. That's like saying "Why not just provide a system for users to opt out of ChanServ/NickServ".
- Kiro 5y ago> I'm not a discord bot maker You don't say. Go to a random Discord server and you will see how bots are used. Your solution makes no sense and would kill most of the current use cases.
- edwinwee 5y agoChat apps use Identity to verify bots and prevent bad bots from spamming real users. And shipping services use Identity when a user is suspected as a fraudster—to double check before creating fraudulent shipping labels.
- gruez 5y ago> Chat apps use Identity to verify bots and prevent bad bots from spamming real users. Is bot spam rampant on discord or something? Are less invasive forms of verification (eg. SMS, credit card, or requiring a deposit) not enough? Can it not be solved via technical means? eg. requiring users to opt-in before receiving messages from a bot? > And shipping services use Identity when a user is suspected as a fraudster—to double check before creating fraudulent shipping labels. Yet I can buy hundreds of dollars of goods off amazon (or any other e-commerce site) without uploading my ID and giving them a live video feed of my face. For both of these use cases, I don't doubt that ID verification provides benefit, I just find the privacy tradeoff to be unacceptable. As an analogy, a store can probably cut down on shoplifting if they performed ID checks at the entrance and kept a visitors log, but I think most people would find that unnecessarily intrusive and would refuse to patronize that store.
- stu2b50 5y ago>Is bot spam rampant on discord or something? It definitely is. If you don't turn off DMs from all the public servers you're in you'll inevitably be hit with the crypto spam bots. There's also the issue of bots silently sitting on servers and logging all chats, user statuses, etc.
- d110af5ccf 5y agoAnd yet other websites (ex HN, Stack Exchange) manage to combat such spam without ID. > bots silently sitting on servers and logging all chats Anyone who thinks this isn't happening in every public communication channel is hopelessly naive.
- Dylan16807 5y ago
- dubcanada 5y agoI honestly find it weird having all of these things suddenly want a copy of my passport in the cloud just sitting there waiting to be hacked in years to come when the security measures drop. At this point there is giant databases containing everything people need to take complete control of your identity sitting there just waiting to be hacked. I have no idea how to change it/fix it. But it seems weird to me.
- emdowling 5y agoYou've nailed the complexity of this. On privacy, people are rightfully spooked about this for all the reasons you've mentioned. On safety, people are really happy about these initiatives as accounts backed by user identity are less likely to be used for harm. On security, leaks of these databases create issues to other sites and companies (eg: if Company X is compromised, then identity documents could be used to disable/bypass 2FA for Bank Y). To make it even more complicated, regulators often hold contradictory views. They want to see increased safety, but in the same breath will announce actions against companies for violating privacy. This is a super-difficult balance to strike. Specifically for Stripe, I trust them. So if I see that a new start-up is using them rather than rolling their own solution, that increases my trust. But it means there is now a big giant server in the cloud with millions (billions?) of identity documents that is worth a lot of money for hackers.
- agwa 5y ago> Specifically for Stripe, I trust them. So if I see that a new start-up is using them rather than rolling their own solution, that increases my trust Note that Stripe allows their customers access to the "captured images of the ID document, selfies, extracted data from the ID document, keyed-in information"[1]. So you still have to trust any company using Stripe not to download, store, and later leak your personal information, and you also have to trust them not to let their Stripe API token be compromised and exploited by identity thieves. [1] https://support.stripe.com/questions/managing-your-id-verification-information#data-access https://support.stripe.com/questions/managing-your-id-verifi...
- truffdog 5y ago
- tootie 5y agoI'd imagine it's for creators/sellers moreso than buyers/customers.
- nightpool 5y agoDiscord only uses identity verification for a small subset of developer accounts—when your bot application fetches the full member list or timestamped "online/away" data, AND is in more than 100 servers. Normal Discord users (and most bot developers!) don't interact with the identity verification process.
- arthur_sav 5y agoI completely agree. Also we don't know how this data is shared or used. Can't wait for new privacy laws to come in place for such data handling.