8 ms·
From the NYT: Working sons of working fathers are, on average, 2.7 times as likely as the rest of the population to have the same job but only two times as lik
by jedberg 5y ago
From the NYT:
Working sons of working fathers are, on average, 2.7 times as likely as the rest of the population to have the same job but only two times as likely to have the same job as their working mothers, according to an analysis by The New York Times, one of the first to look at mothers and daughters in addition to fathers and sons. Daughters are 1.8 times as likely to have the same job as their mothers and 1.7 times as likely to have the same job as their
fathers. [0]
From the General Social Survey[1]:
If your father was a legislator, you are 354 times more likely to be drawn to that career, too. Kids whose father was a doctor are 23 times more likely to follow in his footsteps. If your father was a lawyer, you’re 17 times more likely to become one, as well.
Jobs in the trades figure into these statistics, as well.
- The sons and daughters of plumbers are 14 times more likely to pursue a job in this field.
- The sons and daughters of electricians are nine times more likely to pursue a job in this field.
- The sons and daughters of carpenters are five times more likely to pursue a job in this field.
And, maybe it’s all that brushing and flossing – but the sons and daughters of dentists are 13 times more likely to become one, too.
[0] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/01/learning/will-you-follow-in-your-parents-footsteps.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/01/learning/will-you-follow-...
[1] http://gss.norc.org/About-The-GSS http://gss.norc.org/About-The-GSS
- retrac 5y agoI was just going to look for data on plumbers and carpenters. One common theme to all these jobs is that they tend to be quite stable, and require a life-long set of skills. My father did metalwork before moving to an office job in the civil service. He was the son of a die pressman. Who was the son of a blacksmith. Dad taught me how to weld and cut and so on before my teens. My intellectual interests went to math and computers early on, and he did encourage me to go wherever that might lead. Yet after university and exploring the world I end up in a job where I make circuit boards. It's nearly all automated now but I still do far more welding in my job than most people with a degree. Sometimes it feels like our life scripts are often sketched out by circumstance and trends long before we're even born.
- ozim 5y agoI went into software dev while my father was a construction worker. He is really proud of buildings he was working on and that he was able to build things with his own hands. Even though I have an engineering degree and work in totally different environment I think that something I took from him is that I am really happy with the systems I have built and ability to create things on my own. I did it with keyboard while he did it with hammer. So I don't think it is "cartels" it is still a lot of what you experience in your childhood. If your parent is a dentist he will talk about that and you won't have problem to understand things in that area, maybe you will visit his practice and be able to play with the tools even. Well it still is some kind of upper-hand but not every child can have the same exposure to dentistry and I am fine with that.
- kingsuper20 5y agoLooking back, I think that one superiority of construction over software is that your work has real permanence. Now and again I'll see a very expensive thing I worked on on eBay for a penny on the dollar. Maybe it's time to build a Museum of Me in a spare bedroom.
- noizejoy 5y agoI'd say it's a script filled with probabilities rather than absolutes. And isn't that all of life, the universe and everything?
- Spooky23 5y agoAnother big aspect to trades is there’s often a union bureaucracy or something similar to navigate. It helps to have someone to show you the ropes.
- hellbannedguy 5y agoIt's a test for most union trades. To those interested, call the union hall where you live. So, it's usually a test, and a interview. The interview counts for 1/2 of the hiring process. The test is usually an 8th grade, or high school equivalency test. It's not hard, but in certain high paying markets, like San Francisco, a 1000 guys might show up to take the test, so you need to get most questions right. Once you get into the union, it's kinda a cake walk. You can achieve a middle class income, health, and retirement. It wasn't for me, but a lot of people like it. (answering the top question. I never wanted to do what my father did. We had a strained relationship the minute I stopped agreeing with him. Even as a kid, I loved my father, but didn't want to be like him in any way--including career.)
- marcosdumay 5y agoSo, looks like contacts and internal knowledge are much more important for a PHD than it is for most professions, but the situation is still much better than for politicians. I'd say that means the PHD job market has a large problem. When politicians are the ones you can compare yourself to look good, it's because things are not good at all.
- the-lazy-guy 5y agoThat is one interpretation. Another interpretation is that in pursuing academic career requires a certain attitude towards studying which people growing in a family of academics are a lot more likely to have. In STEM it makes a lot more sense financially to enter the workforce after graduation so staying in university for another 5+ years requires some real love for science. In my experience people with parents in academia are more likely to get financial and moral from their family while they are doing phd.
- hackinthebochs 5y agoNot to mention shared genes for educational attainment and interests.
- sleeper_service 5y agoIs there a proven role of genetics here or is this pseudoscientific determinism?
- hackinthebochs 5y agoIt is pretty well established that educational attainment is significantly heritable [1]. Although less studied, there is evidence of significant heritability of interests as well [2] [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41539-017-0005-6 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41539-017-0005-6 [2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8407707/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8407707/
- namesafe77 5y agoThats Indian Varna system right there.
- devnonymous 5y agoAn underrated comment this. For those who don't know, the Varna system, also known as the caste system has long been justified as the 'natural order' of a scholar's child being a scholar, a warrior's child being a warrior, a tradesmen child being a tradesman and the lowest class of a menial worker's child being a menial worker. The fact that so many are willing color the discussion with - observable trends seem to suggest this is a natural fact of life is only elementary is both disgusting and unsurprising.
- mc32 5y agoI think that’s a bit facile. When you look at other traditional cultures, or unmodernized cultures offspring still likely follow their parents’ footsteps, but that doesn’t mean those are caste systems. People are permitted to pursue alternatives and aren’t forbidden.
- devnonymous 5y ago> People are permitted to pursue alternatives and aren’t forbidden. Systematic barriers are seldom built consciously, yet they exist and without conscious effort to break down continue to be perpetuated. From the point of view of opportunities/privileges available to an individual, is there really a difference between the caste system and a class system?
- sokoloff 5y agoI think there is a difference. As I understand the caste system, it’s inherited durably. If I’m X, not only will I always be X, but my kids and grandkids will also be X, so there’s no point in trying to become “not X”. Not so for socioeconomic class. My grandfathers milled steel and mined coal. They made sure their kids became the first generation in the family to attend college. My parents became teachers and made sure their kids focused on education and we all attended “good colleges” and have built careers. My generation is saving for college while the kids are still in diapers. That’s still systemic advantages from the family, but it’s marked change in economic class in just two generations, which is IMO dramatically different from the Indian caste system. It still matters who your parents are, but in a significantly different (and I think more fair) way.
- darth_avocado 5y agoPretty obvious when you think about it. My Father was an engineer, although a different one than I am. As a child you pick things up when you grow. The fact that I had a computer at home back 3 decades ago, automatically meant I already had an upper hand and a better understanding of how computers work than most of my classmates who only got to see a computer almost a decade later for an hour every week in school. Also having an engineer as a father meant you had these weird books full of knowledge that you could browse through and get immersed in, for free, since I was basically a toddler. He could help me with homework, even if it was to explain integral calculus, which I could not comprehend before. Not saying that I couldn't choose any other profession, just that I naturally had the upper hand and years of experience in certain things even before going to college. I'm sure its the same for pretty much every profession as long as parents stay involved with their kids.
- dorkwood 5y agoI still resent my parents for not keeping any books in the house apart from the dictionary. I can't remember how many times I flipped through the dictionary out of boredom growing up. Whenever I'd go to my grandmother's place, I loved to take random books off the book shelf and read through them. I honestly feel like a great way to educate kids is not to teach them anything directly at all, but to instead leave lots of material around for them to discover themselves.
- xattt 5y agoThis is essentially the Montessori method of teaching, which is why families with higher incomes make such a fuss about them.
- spacechild1 5y agoMy father had a big book shelf in his office room in our house which spanned two of the walls. As a kid I loved to browse the shelf and pick up different kinds of literature. I remember reading Jules Verne's “Journey to the Center of the Earth“ around the age of 10 and although it was a rather tough read, I was blown away.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoThe thing many of these have in common is that connections help you. In other words, if your parent is in x career, it means that you get a starting bonus if you do the same. On top of this, most children have some knowledge of the job conditions: Familiarity seems to lessen risk (even if it doesn't - it is the reason showers seem safe but airplanes might not). Legislators seem to get more done if they are well-connected, for example, and a parent introducing you to their connections makes you a better legislator, probably at a younger age than your parent. Yes, you can do some job shadowing at this other dentist's office: I can put in a good word for you at the electrician's union so you can get into the schooling they offer. Yes, you can work at my plumbing company and learn - it isn't like this state requires licenses, so you'll be just fine.
- jordan_curve 5y agoI’d be interested to see what the rate increase is for Athletes. I think of landing a top research as the equivalent of getting a spot on an NBA team (or other major sports team). Both are extremely competitive with only a select few spots in the entire country. Additionally, starting at a very young age is a huge advantage for both athletes and aspiring academics.
- bena 5y agoThere are plenty of current professional athletes whose parents were also professional athletes. Pat Mahomes's son may be familiar to you, Patrick Mahomes. Peyton and Eli Manning are the sons of Archie Manning. Ken Griffey Jr. and his dad played on the same team at one point. Jr.'s son "Trey" made it into the NFL as a wide receiver. It does seem to matter to a degree. It's not a guarantee though.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoso it seems that the better paying a field is the children of parents in that field are more likely to choose that field as well. on edit: by paying I also mean all the perks you get as well (just as when I negotiate on a job I also negotiate the perks), when you're growing up and see you have a pretty good life that would be something that might attract you to the field your parents are in. So academics might not get paid as much as the private sector but at the higher levels there are some pretty sweet perks.
- bg4 5y agoFor me, the progression has been: software engineer, software engineer, railroad engineer, railroad engineer, farmer. I will be very interested to see what my son picks and I very much plan to allow him to pursue his own interests.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoIt is a little off subject, but I agree. I am watching my kid develop with great interest and while I do have preferences, I recognize she will need to play to her strengths. Unless she turns out to be an idiot, in which case I may need to force a path.
- citrin_ru 5y agoWhy anyone is surprised? Parents are the most powerful role models for children, especially at early age. Also they have good opportunity to teach they kids and what they will teach depends on what they know. This limits social mobility, but all proposals to fix this so far IMHO will do more harm (to high acheivers) than good (to under achievers). This is a difficult problem to tackle so I don't expect easy solutions to work here.