11 ms·
> Faculty members at prestigious universities are 50 times more likely than the average person to have a parent with a Ph.D. American meritocracy has become a c
by sokoloff 5y ago
> Faculty members at prestigious universities are 50 times more likely than the average person to have a parent with a Ph.D. American meritocracy has become a complex, inefficient, and rigged system conferring its graces on ambitious children of highly educated and prosperous families.
What’s the ratio in other fields of top achievement for kids to follow in their parents’ footsteps? It’s entirely unsurprising that academics raise academics, doctors doctors, Olympians Olympians, teachers teachers, etc.
It’s equally unsurprising that the ambitious children of highly educated and prosperous families themselves pursue such a similar path and achieve similar outcomes. I’m an engineer and my spouse a scientist. Our kids have commensurately higher chance to pursue one of those or a closely related field due to exposure and biases.
- ttul 5y agoYou likely don’t realize that your kids will also have an easier chance at succeeding because of other privileges they enjoy, aside from the merits of having intelligent and educated parents. Take a similarly educated family who happen to live in Gaza, for instance, and it’s obvious that the children will have a different set of opportunities available to them.
- sokoloff 5y agoIs there any basis for your assumption that I don’t realize that?
- jedberg 5y agoFrom the NYT: Working sons of working fathers are, on average, 2.7 times as likely as the rest of the population to have the same job but only two times as likely to have the same job as their working mothers, according to an analysis by The New York Times, one of the first to look at mothers and daughters in addition to fathers and sons. Daughters are 1.8 times as likely to have the same job as their mothers and 1.7 times as likely to have the same job as their fathers. [0] From the General Social Survey[1]: If your father was a legislator, you are 354 times more likely to be drawn to that career, too. Kids whose father was a doctor are 23 times more likely to follow in his footsteps. If your father was a lawyer, you’re 17 times more likely to become one, as well. Jobs in the trades figure into these statistics, as well. - The sons and daughters of plumbers are 14 times more likely to pursue a job in this field. - The sons and daughters of electricians are nine times more likely to pursue a job in this field. - The sons and daughters of carpenters are five times more likely to pursue a job in this field. And, maybe it’s all that brushing and flossing – but the sons and daughters of dentists are 13 times more likely to become one, too. [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/01/learning/will-you-follow-in-your-parents-footsteps.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/01/learning/will-you-follow-... [1] http://gss.norc.org/About-The-GSS http://gss.norc.org/About-The-GSS
- retrac 5y agoI was just going to look for data on plumbers and carpenters. One common theme to all these jobs is that they tend to be quite stable, and require a life-long set of skills. My father did metalwork before moving to an office job in the civil service. He was the son of a die pressman. Who was the son of a blacksmith. Dad taught me how to weld and cut and so on before my teens. My intellectual interests went to math and computers early on, and he did encourage me to go wherever that might lead. Yet after university and exploring the world I end up in a job where I make circuit boards. It's nearly all automated now but I still do far more welding in my job than most people with a degree. Sometimes it feels like our life scripts are often sketched out by circumstance and trends long before we're even born.
- ozim 5y agoI went into software dev while my father was a construction worker. He is really proud of buildings he was working on and that he was able to build things with his own hands. Even though I have an engineering degree and work in totally different environment I think that something I took from him is that I am really happy with the systems I have built and ability to create things on my own. I did it with keyboard while he did it with hammer. So I don't think it is "cartels" it is still a lot of what you experience in your childhood. If your parent is a dentist he will talk about that and you won't have problem to understand things in that area, maybe you will visit his practice and be able to play with the tools even. Well it still is some kind of upper-hand but not every child can have the same exposure to dentistry and I am fine with that.
- kingsuper20 5y agoLooking back, I think that one superiority of construction over software is that your work has real permanence. Now and again I'll see a very expensive thing I worked on on eBay for a penny on the dollar. Maybe it's time to build a Museum of Me in a spare bedroom.
- noizejoy 5y agoI'd say it's a script filled with probabilities rather than absolutes. And isn't that all of life, the universe and everything?
- MattGaiser 5y agoYeah, so many of these arguments about who comes from what category seem to assume that talent and inclination is randomly distributed among 18 year olds and that university where you find yourself.
- jvanderbot 5y agoThis seems obvious and unharmful. Its funny, my co worker insisted that his children shall go to MIT so they can have all the opportunities he did. He didn't see any irony is saying this to me, his peer, a first gen engineer from University of Midwest Farm Community. And I agree, its not surprising kids learn by example and inherit so much from their parents.
- JKCalhoun 5y ago> first gen engineer from University of Midwest Farm Community Fellow alum!
- rejectedandsad 5y agoEven your undergrad (which I’m interpreting as UIUC) is elite compared to most state schools for CS, and is very selective for direct to major. People like me are doubly screwed.
- jvanderbot 5y agoUIUC is a fairly huge assumption. Are you sure you want to do that? I think you're imaging a person that has more advantages than you do (or I did -- UIUC wouldn't have me). That's very likely not the case, at least not nearly as much as you think. Don't sweat it. You're not screwed, and it's not a competition anyway. I came from humble academic beginnings and failures and managed to get a job I love that pays the bills and helps me save for the future. It was the passionate people I met that got me through it, not the credentials of the university (by quite a long shot)
- rejectedandsad 5y agoPerhaps I don’t! I also went to an ag school, except one that’s objectively unimpressive. I honestly can’t save as much as my peers, make a pittance compared to the Ivy Leaguers and have never achieved a fraction of what most of these hyper accomplished folks did even while being much older. Sometimes I feel like I should just wither away because there’s not much hope of ever achieving anything at this rate if I’m just innately inferior.
- zamfi 5y agoAlso, what is this “has become” language for? It implies that the this elite group is more self-reinforcing than it used to be, but there’s no evidence for that. Harvard’s 1940s admission rate of 85% was certainly not a more meritocratic time. The ratio you ask for is almost certainly decreasing over time, not increasing, right?
- an_opabinia 5y agoAdmissions rates mean a lot less than people think they do. Meritocracy - what you’re really saying is, the most qualified people get to do the thing with the scarce stuff - has risen. Anyway, historically, if you felt wronged by an educational institution, you made your own schools.
- m00x 5y ago> Anyway, historically, if you felt wronged by an educational institution, you made your own schools. Source on this? I doubt that spinning up a whole new school was ever this simple and accessible.
- lordnacho 5y agoSo for instance the story is that Cambridge University was founded by people who were disgruntled at Oxford. Also there's a number of institutions that were founded due to religious affiliation, IIRC UCL in London. Nowadays there's an entrenchment that makes it hard to just go and do your own uni. It's not illegal, but you need to find supporters who won't just say "hey why don't you just go to X existing uni". And there's already a uni for whatever speciality you're into, plus the big names that are the specialists for every subject.
- kansface 5y ago>The ratio you ask for is almost certainly decreasing over time, not increasing, right? Since the 40s, most likely. Since some time in between then and now, I'm not so sure.
- bsder 5y ago> What’s the ratio in other fields of top achievement for kids to follow in their parents’ footsteps? It’s entirely unsurprising that academics raise academics, doctors doctors, Olympians Olympians, teachers teachers, etc. Actually, I suspect that most teachers discourage their children to follow in their footsteps ... And your points about doctors, olympians, academics, etc. have a common point: Large, up front expenditure of money. A child of a steelworker simply isn't becoming a doctor short of a very, very small number of paths (generally involving military service). A child of a high-school teacher simply isn't becoming an Olympic figure skater. The monetary investment is far too titanic. Engineering used to be one of the few fields where you could transition from blue collar to white collar even if you were a child from a poor family. Sadly, that doesn't seem to be very true, anymore.
- barry-cotter 5y ago> A child of a steelworker simply isn't becoming a doctor short of a very, very small number of paths (generally involving military service). This wasn’t true in Ireland in the 70s or 80s, a far poorer country than contemporary America. The US system of funding higher education has many, many problems but not allowing smart people to study more is not among them. If you can get admitted to medical school you will get a loan to cover the costs. > A child of a high-school teacher simply isn't becoming an Olympic figure skater. The monetary investment is far too titanic. Michael Phelps, the most decorated Olympian ever, is the child of a middle school principal and a police officer. Tiger Woods is the son of an infantry officer. Money is not the limiting factor on more people becoming elite level athletes. It’s some combination of talent and insane, deluded commitment. > Engineering used to be one of the few fields where you could transition from blue collar to white collar even if you were a child from a poor family. Sadly, that doesn't seem to be very true, anymore. The average US college graduate has $35,000 in debt. Engineering is one of the fields where your college matters least. More people attend college than at any time in US history.
- areyousure 5y ago> A child of a high-school teacher simply isn't becoming an Olympic figure skater. The monetary investment is far too titanic. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yuzuru_Hanyu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yuzuru_Hanyu > Regarded as one of, if not the greatest male figure skater in history, Hanyu has broken world records nineteen times ... > Hanyu was born ... the second and youngest child to his father, who is a junior high school teacher Oh, maybe this doesn't count? After all, his father was a junior high school teacher. /s
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rajin444 5y agoScience needs to advance more so that we can determine nature vs. nurture. It's all genetic (nature) in the end - but I think being able to say "x lacks the genetic makeup to dunk a basketball" vs "x was malnourished as a child so they wont grow enough to be able to dunk a basketball" is useful. I think articles looking at outcomes of the children of successful people are unhealthy and will focus too much on environmental impacts. We will see uneven breakdowns (by race, sex, height, etc.) and think that means something needs to be fixed...but we aren't able to fully explain how the breakdowns got to where they are.
- jedberg 5y agoI think it's been fairly well established that genetics determines the max values -- max IQ, max height, max athleticism, etc. and then nurture determines if you reach the max.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThere's plenty left to be directly determined by nature after setting maximum values. You've got far more food than you need. You can't get any taller -- what do you do with it? Should you eat it at all? How resilient should you be to less-than-ideal input? Say it's unseasonably cold for a few months. Should you get shorter, or is it better to just give up and die? You don't have enough food. You're not in any danger of starving, but you're not going to reach maximum height, IQ, _and_ athleticism. Which trait(s) should be lowered? By how much? Genetics doesn't just specify the maximum outcome. It specifies the entire set of possibilities, and how those possibilities are reached.
- bsanr2 5y agoThis seems overly reductionist. You have at least two cases that contradict: 1) The fact that biological processes tend not to have hard limits and "kill switches" at those limits, but rather feedback loops which increase or decrease in efficacy due to a number of factors, which are themselves factors for further downstream processes 2) The tendency towards physiological plasticity to facilitate functional homeostasis (e.g., there was a case of an athlete whose smaller blood vessels enlarged in order to maintain blood flow following an embolism; this was disabled athlete who walked on her hands in lieu of her non-functional legs) I think what is more likely is that that there is a level of a given quality which your genes will have you tend toward (with environment determining how much you will overshoot or undershoot it), but also that the human form is very adaptable and will often respond to pressures by routing around lower-functioning systems, which may require unconventional support but also create unconventional and exceptional achievement (the aforementioned athlete is a paralympian with arm-based muscular strength and endurance - a neurological matter - which outpaces most abled athletes).
- zarkov99 5y agoMost of all your kids are likely to have IQ's close to the median of you and your wife. This is likely the most important factor of all as heart-breaking and unfair as this is.
- aerovistae 5y agoThis really misses the point I feel, although I struggle to say why.
- 29athrowaway 5y agoThe median of two numbers is the average.
- exporectomy 5y agoCloser than other kids but with regression to the mean (of the population).
- chriskanan 5y agoDefinitely seemed very true during my PhD. Many of my peers had PhD or professor parents (I don't). I think the primary reasons for the increase are valuing the career through parents and having a mentor who knows the admissions game. I blundered my first couple times applying because I lacked good mentorship in preparing my applications.
- WalterBright 5y ago> good mentorship in preparing my applications I don't get this. Why does one need mentorship in filling out an application. I got mine in the mail, filled them out, and sent them in. It never occurred to me I needed someone to guide me. My dad (MIT) did tell me many years earlier what was necessary to get into MIT: 1. straight A's 2. high SAT scores 3. an achievement in extracurricular activities (MIT rejected me.) It's like the Boy Scouts. I talked with an Eagle dad a couple years ago, who talked about shepherding his boy through the Eagle program to get the badge. He was very proud of his son. I mentioned that I was an Eagle, too. He asked me how it was with my dad helping me. I said he never did a thing, and it didn't occur to me to ask. I just decided I wanted one, got the list of requirements, and did them one by one. None of them were hard, it just required time and persistence. He looked at me like I was an alien.
- oblio 5y ago> I don't get this. Why does one need mentorship in filling out an application. I got mine in the mail, filled them out, and sent them in. It never occurred to me I needed someone to guide me. > My dad (MIT) did tell me many years earlier what was necessary to get into MIT: 1. straight A's 2. high SAT scores 3. an achievement in extracurricular activities > (MIT rejected me.) Aren't you confirming that mentorship is needed?
- WalterBright 5y agoGood question. Although rejected by MIT, Harvard, and Stanford, I was accepted by Caltech, Dartmouth, and Johns Hopkins.
- WalterBright 5y agoPeople being drawn to professions they are familiar with is not "rigging" the system.
- dillondoyle 5y agoI would add into the mix that it's also about access and resources which give maybe a bigger leg up. Engineers, college educators, etc make more money, their kids presumably go to good schools, they presumably have more hands on time available to help their kids succeed and more connections, legacy admissions etc. I see this in my sport. One of the olympians for climbing for US comes from climbing 'royalty.' being literally born into the sport from day 1 makes a huge difference. plus having access to a groundbreaking gym and youth training program your mom literally created ;0 Not to take away achievement. strength is strength, intelligence is intelligence. it's all very impressive and doesn't come without work. but I think opportunity and access to resources are important factors to consider.
- sohei 5y ago> It’s equally unsurprising that the ambitious children of highly educated and prosperous families themselves pursue such a similar path and achieve similar outcomes. That kind of misses the point. You want to train as many effective engineers and researchers as you can. The point of the article is that most Ivies can comfortably train more people, but doing so would reduce some of the scarcity "value" of an Ivy League degree. Who cares? The goal is building. Claude Shannon and Kelly Johnson both got their start at Michigan. The Michigan model of "train as many engineers as you can without compromising substance" is a great. If the Ivies want to create artificial scarcity to avoid "diluting brand value", then their ability to access public subsidies should be curtailed. Give it to Michigan instead.
- exporectomy 5y agoBut are Ivy League universities really that much better at training people or is their success mostly due to skimming from the top of the applicant pool? If the latter, then it seems like those students would do just as well if they didn't exist and nothing's really lost or gained either way by their exclusivity. If they have a magic recipe for creating success, why can't other universities copy it? Does it depend on scarce elite professors? In that case, they probably can't scale themselves up either.
- jedberg 5y agoTheir magic recipe is putting a bunch of smart, mostly rich, people in one place and then telling them they are part of an exclusive community. Then they give them access to the older successful members of the community and constantly remind them that once they are the older successful members they need to help out the recent grads.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoSounds a lot like Freemasonry, but unlike Feemasonry, it seems to be actually working as intended.
- bsanr2 5y ago