7 ms·
These are exactly the kinds of issues antitrust legislation needs to be updated to handle. I have no issue with a company running a store and selling its own p
by crazygringo 5y ago
These are exactly the kinds of issues antitrust legislation needs to be updated to handle.
I have no issue with a company running a store and selling its own products within, but it has to provide a level playing field.
It's good they fixed it -- that the VP in question didn't know it had been done and then nixed it -- but this shouldn't even be legal in the first place.
- Railsify 5y agoWould that extend to grocery stores, where would you force walmart to put their own brands?
- donmcronald 5y ago> Would that extend to grocery stores, where would you force walmart to put their own brands? It's not a fair comparison if you're at a physical store since things are too different for an analogy. However, if I'm searching on their website and type in a specific brand so I can find which aisle it's in I would expect to get the brand I searched for, not a Great Value knockoff.
- Spivak 5y agoI mean that is basically how I find the store brand all the time. Look for the brand name thing I know by heart because the logo has been seared into my brain since birth and then go from there.
- mikestew 5y agoYou mean the grocery stores that have many competitors who also sell groceries? How would you extend that analogy to the iOS App Store, which has no competitors whatsoever who sell iOS apps?
- imNotTheProb 5y agoWeb Apps? Apple users are used to lower quality products, making them visit a website should be no big deal.
- gruez 5y ago>You mean the grocery stores that have many competitors who also sell groceries? google? >How would you extend that analogy to the iOS App Store, which has no competitors whatsoever who sell iOS apps? By that logic costco has no competitors whatsoever that sell kirkland signature products.
- passivate 5y agoWe need to re-evaluate what "rights" mean in a digital age. Apple should not have a monopoly on digital stores on iOS. "Apple made it so they can do anything they want. Take it or leave it" - is not an acceptable position (in my opinion). >By that logic costco has no competitors whatsoever that sell kirkland signature products. Can you explain how you came to that conclusion and what 'that logic' is?
- gruez 5y ago>Can you explain how you came to that conclusion and what 'that logic' is? Because the parent poster was applying arbitrary restriction on it (apps, but only ios) to make a point. I replied with the equivalent example for costco (grocery store products, but only kirkland signature).
- ksec 5y agoBecause you have both Costco AND Walmart Stores selling their own brand within the same state which allows heavy Store competition within the State along with dozen of others Stores? The iOS state has 65% of users and 75% of App spending and it has one Store. You can perfectly have your own retail brand when there are plenty of competition within the market. If you argue there is still another state with diverse choices, you are either hit with a Duopoly argument, or a monopolistic power argument where iOS have too much power within market economy. People have been using these over simplify analogy with Xbox and Retail and there are not even the same. Either way, there should be no denying there is something wrong with the way things are currently being handled.
- 5y ago
- AlphaSite 5y agoThe Web is a great competitor for the most part.
- passivate 5y agoA grocery store has limited storage space, a limited amount of advertising space, limited staff, etc, etc. The amount of upkeep is also very different compared to a digital store. I think its not really an apt point for comparison.
- crazygringo 5y agoI don't see any uneven playing field when it comes to grocery stores. The national brands and store brands are always next to each other on the same shelf. So there isn't any problem that needs solving. Also brands already pay for promotional positioning (like the ends of aisles), and when the store puts its own brands in those spots it loses out on those payments, and so is effectively paying equally. So the field doesn't need any evening out there. If grocery stores ever started putting the name-brand stuff in a back room that took twice as long to get to, then it might become an issue, but as of right now it's just not.
- singlow 5y agoThe brand names pay for their spot, so its moot. There is no meritocracy in grocery store product placement. For the most part the grocery store doesn't have a formula to decide where to put most things based on sales data. If you sell a cereal or soda or fancy mustard and you want premium shelf height, just pay extra for it. The store basically rents the shelf space out.
- MiscIdeaMaker99 5y agoThis is absolutely true in the USA. Frito Lay has done this for years, paying supermarkets for more and more shelf space, while the smaller, regional competitors were left with less and less room to sell. This happened to my father in the 1980s when he owned a distributorship for a regional potato chip company here in the Midwest United States.
- bombcar 5y agoYou don’t see the brands they don’t carry at all. Only the brands they carry get displayed and they often make more money on the name brands anyway.
- hnick 5y agoI've heard from a friend (in Australia) if you don't frequently buy placement you get bumped, and buying placement can be a losing proposition. They raise the price to squeeze all margin so it's just on the edge of making it affordable. You have to say yes to losing money during the promotion ("you'll make it up with brand awareness!") to claw it back by staying on the shelves in between. Otherwise another brand, or sometimes a house brand, takes your place.
- heavyset_go 5y agoI can go across the street to a dozen different stores. If I travel a little further, I can go to even more stores. No matter where I go, with Apple and Google, I'm have to use their payment systems and give each of them a 30% cut of my apps' revenue. They both have a duopoly in the mobile operating systems market and the mobile app distribution market, and Apple has the majority of the market share in both markets in the US.
- judge2020 5y agoThe difference is that Walmart didn't build the street or the city and doesn't have a right to take a cut of sales on other people's property. A more apt comparison would be the third-party hotels that, if they want to use some of Disney's 25,000 acres in Florida[0], literally have to lease the land from Disney and Disney can impose terms like a cut of sales (or a forced Disney merchandise store within the hotel). iOS is like the consumer choosing to live exclusively within the confines of Disney's property (with the difference being that, once you 'leave' iOS, you can't bring stuff back into the city - honestly this is the digital equivalent of what Walt Disney wanted with E.P.C.O.T.[1]). 0: https://dpep.disney.io/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/fact_sheet_walt_disney_world_resort_2020_Q4.pdf#page=7 https://dpep.disney.io/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/fact_sheet... 1: https://youtu.be/tKYEXjMlKKQ https://youtu.be/tKYEXjMlKKQ
- shkkmo 5y agoYou actually OWN your device and should have the right to do what you please with it. This analogy is poor.
- vel0city 5y agoThere are tons of resorts and hotels completely unrelated to Disney that exist right at the gates of Disnyworld that offer shuttles. There are even more resorts in Kissimmee that are just a short drive away. As someone who has been to Disneyworld over a dozen times and never once stayed in a Disney resort, there are a ton of places to stay and still visit Disneyworld.
- 5y ago
- vel0city 5y agoIt costs me less money travel-wise to go to a non-Walmart grocery store. Within the same cost comparison of traveling, I've got about four different brands of groceries all within a similar price range. If I had an iPhone, it would be a several hundred dollar proposal (at least!) to shop at a competing store.
- GeekyBear 5y ago>selling its own products The Files app is bundled with the OS, but not installed by default. It's not exactly "sold" as it's free and isn't ad supported either. It's hard to find a profit motive here. Google, on the other hand, has long allowed you to bid on your competitor's product name so you will show up ahead of them in the search results. They also have a history of scraping other people's content and then more highly rating that scraped content on their own sites in their search engine. It's easy to find a profit motive there.
- netizen-936824 5y agoThe profit motive is keeping users in their ecosystem
- webmobdev 5y ago> It's hard to find a profit motive here. Promoting the use of iCloud - when your space runs out, you will consider paying for it.
- GeekyBear 5y ago>Promoting the use of iCloud The Files app transfers files back and forth between SMB shares, local flash drives, and any of the major cloud services. iCloud is not required at all. Try again.
- webmobdev 5y agoIf you are ignorant about it, iCloud support is integrated into the Files App and is the most promoted on its support documents too - https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT203052 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT203052 and https://support.apple.com/en-in/HT206481 https://support.apple.com/en-in/HT206481 ... If you use DropBox app, you are obviously going to prefer DropBox cloud service over iCloud - that not only means a potential loss of revenue in the future but also the fact that they aren't tied into Apple ecosystem and can abandon it. Additionally, anyone not using the Files app also denies Apple the means to collect file metadata which are valuable to profile you.
- vmception 5y agoSo you would be fine if a separate "Apple Apps Inc" was required by law to exist, and it had created the Files app instead, and it had the same dropbox integration and it was therefore in the accurate metadata, and it surfaced higher than the dropbox app anyway? Congratulations, we did it guys.
- zaptheimpaler 5y agoMakes no sense. The whole point is they manually boosted Files to make it surface higher. If it surfaces higher under a level playing field, that is fine.
- vmception 5y ago“Makes no sense, makes sense” so at least you would be fine, thanks, I wonder what the person I replied to thinks we’re doing it guys!
- mhh__ 5y agoSpeaking of anti-trust, surely Apple must be getting close to (or beyond) what Microsoft were? Total control over their users, hidden APIs, apparently biased store, rentseeking etc. My £0.02 is that if they aren't already over the line the line should be nudged against their favour.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoThey're nothing like Microsoft was; Windows was something like 97% of all PCs. I'm not aware of Apple having more than 50% of any market. You can't abuse a monopoly that you don't have. (Of course, collusion/duopoly and saying that they dominate some smaller market, say paid mobile apps, are valid arguments, but nothing like as cut-and-dry as peak MS).
- xmprt 5y agoAnti-trust is more than just being a monopoly. You can have a 1% market share and still be caught up in an anti-trust case.
- pg_bot 5y agoThey have more than 50% of the US smartphone market.
- ksec 5y ago>They're nothing like Microsoft was Anti-Trust is about Power. Not market share. I dont know how others that were there in the 90s thick about it. But I do think Apple today is way more powerful than Microsoft in the 90s. Your PC in the 90s were not the access point of anything in the society other than some games or spreadsheets. Not to mention most of the population dont even have a PC. PC in terms of reach to population is basically a niche. These days it is hard to argue that. Excluding child and grannies US literally has 100% smartphone ownership. And smartphone ( or more like a pocket personal computer ) is our access point for a lot of thing in our society, and increasingly for almost everything. And it has to go through App Store where Apple is the judge, jury and executioner.