9 ms·
London and Switzerland seeking to dodge G7 global minimum tax
- Irishsteve 5y agoBy dodge do they mean regions that govern themselves choose not to opt into an agreement a bunch of other people made?
- wolverine876 5y agoThe elected representative of the City of London, i.e., the UK's Chancellor of the Exchequer, made the agreement.
- shkkmo 5y agoNope. These regions don't have a choice about whether to opt in because they are part of larger political units that have the power to make this choice for them (as long as they remain part of those political units.) What they are doing is trying to subvert the agreement without leaving those larger political units that are signing on to the agreement. (For the London this is the UK and for Switzerland it is the European Market.)
- Glavnokoman 5y agoRubbish. How come EU market is a political unit?
- shkkmo 5y agoBecause you must cede a small part of your sovereignty to be part of that market. Switzerland had done this through treaties with the EU. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Single_Market https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Single_Market
- drcongo 5y agoLondon's entire existence depends on letting large global corporations, oligarchs and criminals hide their money. If they stopped doing that the city and the country would spiral.
- smcl 5y agoI'm no fan of London but saying its entire existence depends on that is a bit of a stretch. That's like saying Ireland's entire reason for existing hinges on its low (zero?) corporation tax. Both are important and I'm sure they'd both suffer if they lost their respective tax advantages, but a death spiral? Maybe not.
- disgruntledphd2 5y agoIt's not zero: https://www.irishtimes.com/business/economy/top-10-companies-now-pay-more-than-half-of-corporate-tax-1.4553695 https://www.irishtimes.com/business/economy/top-10-companies... To be fair though, the old approach was only to pay tax on irish revenue, which was almost zero, given how small Ireland is.
- drcongo 5y agoIt's worth watching the documentary Offshore Incorporated (also known as The UK Gold for some reason). It's very broad brushstrokes, but still true. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt3057428/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt3057428/
- smcl 5y agoBut ... it's entire existence? Like without the Oligarchs etc parking their money there it would wither away and cease to exist? I mean I am all for London having a diminished status within the UK, but that's taking a widely accepted fact (that a lot of laundered money goes through London) and blowing it way out of proportion.
- hogFeast 5y agoNo, it doesn't. The UK is the number one loser globally from corporate tax avoidance (the reason why we have a 15% rate is because the UK functionally stopped being able to collect corp tax because of the big EU tax havens agreeing deals with large companies). The reason why the UK doesn't like these proposals is because they are a fairly transparent attempt to get companies paying more US tax, regardless of the consequences for anyone else (and the proposals have been skilfully tailored to produce the most agreement from France and Germany whilst promising the least possible change). As for "oligarchs and criminals"...those are two different things. The UK already applies extraterritoriality to money coming into the UK (i.e. if you bring money into the UK that is the proceeds of crime in another country that money will get taken, even if you haven't been charged in your own country). But most people view oligarchs as criminals, they are not. Running a business is not a crime, and we shouldn't make into a crime because that person happens to be the wrong nationality (btw, what most people don't understand is that the UK was a haven for oligarchs who were anti-Putin, not pro...the reason why they came here is because they had to leave Russia because of Putin).
- ______- 5y ago> But London and Switzerland are already working to ensure they don't get badly hit by the minimum tax rate, as they fear it will make their financial districts less attractive Well they're missing the point of this imposition, because it was designed expressly to avoid companies choosing 'favorable' locations to manage their tax affairs. Suck it up London and Switzerland.
- legitster 5y agoWhy should they? What incentive do they have to join an agreement against their wishes? Surely it's not the politicians jobs to lose jobs and income to other countries for nothing in return.
- philistine 5y agoThe G7 includes the UK and Switzerland-by-proxy of the EU, since Switzerland is in the European Market. They're not signing anything against their wishes. They're trying to water down the deal. The question at play here is whether or not they'll get away with it, and I sure hope they don't. Giving exemptions to the rule will create massive incentives to game those exemptions.
- Rochus 5y agoAgain, a lot of disinformation is spread to create envy. The current average profit tax rate in Switzerland is 15.1%. Here is a recent article on this: https://www.organisator.ch/steuerreport-2020-vergleichsweise-tiefe-unternehmenssteuern-in-der-schweiz/ https://www.organisator.ch/steuerreport-2020-vergleichsweise... There are a lot of places with lower or even zero taxes (even some within the USA).
- tjoff 5y agoHow is average relevant? And why would they go out of their way to avoid something they already do?
- Gustomaximus 5y agoSo locations that benefit from <15% tax rates want to avoid it. Hardly a surprise. It might of been an interesting article if they had a rationale beyond "In the UK, Chancellor Rishi Sunak is worried that banks based in London, which he says pay adequate tax, will be wrongly dragged into the 15% rate." The entire point of this tax minimum is 1) No countries are excepted so they dont attract investment/HQ purely on tax rates. or 2) Countries that dont agree face other punishment that outweighs point 1. Personally I think its quite selfish if countries dont sign up to this. Its much needed and capitalism greatly benefits from "a level playing field" (also a core tenant) as it tends to focus innovation to areas that matter, over company X has a market advantage because they are headquartered in the Cayman Islands and can buy market share over domestic company paying 25% on profits.
- briandear 5y agoWhy shouldn’t a country be selfish? Isn’t that the point of a country: to promote the interests of the citizens of that country? It’s selfish that France doesn’t send me free Champagne. “Selfishness,” or in other words “self-interest” is what drives markets to efficiency. Minimum tax rate agreements are the same thing as a price floor — and have similar effects. It’s essentially a subsidy for high tax countries. How is it the fault of Ireland that France has a higher tax rate? Why should the Irish pay out of their pocket to bolster the treasury of France? What’s in it for Ireland?
- wolverine876 5y ago> Why shouldn’t a country be selfish? Why shouldn't everyone be selfish? Because other people matter, and because if people work together and cooperate, which includes making some sacrifices, then everyone gets better results in the long run. > Isn’t that the point of a country: to promote the interests of the citizens of that country? That's one view (nationalism, if I'm using the term correctly), but certainly not the only one. There are higher purposes than one's personal interests.
- refurb 5y ago
- RegnisGnaw 5y agoA source close to the G7 talks told The Guardian that several other European Union countries wanted financial services to be excluded from the minimum rate. "The Europeans don't want to pull too many companies into this — they're mostly interested in US tech," the source said. So basically I want to tax everyone else, that's not me.
- consumer451 5y agoHypocrisy recognizes no national boundaries.
- vkou 5y agoThe US did the exact same thing when it came to aerospace, in order to kill Bombardier.
- machello13 5y agoThat's literally the parent's point. "the US did it too!!!" doesn't make it a good thing.
- vkou 5y agoOnly if you have a dogmatic adherence to globalism. That is not the only valid lens through which to view international trade.
- legitster 5y ago> The Europeans don't want to pull too many companies into this — they're mostly interested in US tech I mean, they are so blatantly honest here it's hard to even be mad.
- MichaelZuo 5y agoWell it does provide good ammunition for said ‘US tech’ who can credibly point to double dealing european interests to deflect one sided criticism.
- legitster 5y agoThe global tax essentially functions as a cartel, and there is no reason to believe it will be stable in the long run. It's a classic prisoner's dilemma - the incentive to cut out is just too strong. Furthermore, by setting such a low anchor price, if the cartel eventually fails, countries would be racing to the bottom from an even lower tax rate. I'm not super optimistic about this tax, but have been pretty surprised by how quickly it seems to be getting adopted regardless.
- WanderPanda 5y agoIf some country drops out I'm sure it can use some "democracy" spread by the cartel
- ethbr0 5y agoI dunno. Majority control of international trade (exports or imports) is a heavy cudgel with which to wield against uncooperative or defecting parties. It seems like with enough economic backing they could (and probably will) enforce the agreement. The more unstable question is whether the respective democracies can get it through their lobbying systems intact.
- riffraff 5y agoOPEC is a cartel and has been running for 60 years, that would be a fairly good run for a global agreement. But I think you misclassify this from a game theory point of view. Larger countries with higher tax rates can effectively punish companies that take advantage of the other ones if the cartel is broken. This is the same reason the agreement was reached in the first place, it's "give up a little or we'll fight and you'll lose", much like it was for bank secrets in Switzerland.
- AdrianB1 5y agoOPEC is a very good deal for the countries that are members; this deal is a very bad deal for most of the countries that are part of.
- Dracophoenix 5y ago
- Proven 5y agoThe real question is what are the idiots running the rest of the countries involved doing? Do elected persons from those other countries work for their electorate and try to attract business and jobs by competing against the incompetent and wasteful governments, or do they scheme against their electorate and work on behalf of globalists? Thumbs up to the Swiss and the UK.
- dylan604 5y agoWhy is it "London and Switzerland" and not "London and Zurich" or "UK and Switzerland"?
- mcrae 5y agoInterestingly the "City of London" is a specific thing that has surprising meaning [0], but used here I think it is a metonym for the financial / banking sector of the British economy. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_of_London https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_of_London & https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LrObZ_HZZUc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LrObZ_HZZUc
- SSLy 5y agoEducated guess: 95% of UK's financial industry is in London, while in Schweiz it's more evenly spread out between the biggest cities. And Switzerland has no capital either.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tweetle_beetle 5y agoI think it's referring to "financial centres"[1]. According to The Global Financial Centres Index[2], it's equivalent to: London + Geneva + Zurich. But, yes, it's a bit clumsy. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_centre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_centre [2] https://www.longfinance.net/programmes/financial-centre-futures/global-financial-centres-index/gfci-29-explore-data/gfci-29-rank/ https://www.longfinance.net/programmes/financial-centre-futu...
- smcl 5y agoSomeone mentioned the "City of London" being smaller than you might imagine - that's not just a geographical curiousity, there's a very real consequence to that: https://www.ft.com/content/41dba03e-5d29-11e5-9846-de406ccb37f2 https://www.ft.com/content/41dba03e-5d29-11e5-9846-de406ccb3... And the reason it's Switzerland and not Zurich (or another city like Geneva, or a given Canton) is that AFAIK Switzerland's famously privacy-friendly finance regulation weren't just restricted to one area, so it would be incorrect to pick one place out of them all. I know there has been some movement in recent years that has curbed Switzerland's status as a tax haven, though I don't know to what extent. Maybe someone who's a bit more familiar can weigh in on this.
- nickdothutton 5y agoThe UK currently has 20% corporation tax on profits, plus employers national insurance contribution, and various avenues to effectively reduce that a bit depending on how you spend what would otherwise be profit. The problem/complaint is with tech companies who use structures via Ireland, Netherlands, and occasionally other places to book billions in revenues and profits but pay a tax rate of zero on those profits. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_Sandwich https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_Sandwich
- s_dev 5y agoDouble Irish has ended according to your own source.
- nickdothutton 5y agoThese schemes have merely been replaced by variations on a theme. Without wanting to sound too dramatic, it’s just an arms race and having seen some this up-close myself, there is always another structure sitting on the shelf for when the current one is retired.
- 29athrowaway 5y agoLondon is the money laundering capital of the world. https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-54226107 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-54226107 Money laundering is what enables organized crime, brutal dictatorships and many of the incarnations of evil in this world to exist. The world would be a better place if one day all British banking institutions involved in money laundering closed and decided to do something else.
- marcrosoft 5y agoDodge is a sensational word in this title. They simply don’t agree to add additional taxes.
- barbazoo 5y agoWouldn't that only "add" taxes if the tax rate was below the minimum tax rate of 15%? Certainly wouldn't apply to the UK, would it?
- euroderf 5y agoThe City of London is a holdover from the feudal era, largely exempt from UK control. Really strange. Not at all the same as the city of London. The Guardian has covered it.
- willyt 5y agoNot really. It's actually the opposite, the merchants of the city rebelled against the Monarchy basically for very similar reasons that the merchants of America rebelled later and as a result there is still a tradition where the queen has to ask permission from the Lord Mayor of London to cross into 'The City' which is a small borough about 1sqm in size in the centre of Greater London. Not that they are necessarily the good guys, the coat of arms of The City has a dagger on it which is symbolic of the dagger used to murder an early trade unionist.
- AlexTWithBeard 5y agoJust in case: it's a St. Paul's sword, not a dagger.
- sbacic 5y agoI find it interesting how all of these articles keep mentioning Ireland specifically when there are countries in Europe with even lower tax rates. I suspect that the reason is that Ireland is not only offering a very competitive tax rate, but also providing quality corporate services at the same time. And I think that that is the real issue - that you can get first class corporate services for much less than in other countries, making people ask - why should I pay more for the same - or in some cases, more for less?
- jl2718 5y agoI opened a restaurant and nobody wants to pay for the food. Obviously it’s because McDonald’s exists.
- AlexTWithBeard 5y agoThat's what I keep saying all the time. You want companies to pay taxes in your country? Make it easy for them. Simplify accounting rules. Get rid of patent trolls. Ensure speedy trials by courts.