8 ms·
I wonder if the fastmail protocol could be hidden in AWS-like data streams to take an approach like telegram. If they try to block it, they shut down their enti
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
I wonder if the fastmail protocol could be hidden in AWS-like data streams to take an approach like telegram. If they try to block it, they shut down their entire digital business infrastructure.
I have been looking for an alternative to Gmail, does anyone have recommendations? Fastmail? Proton mail?
What put me over the edge is my young friend had a heart attack, went to the hospital and (during recovery) logged into his Gmail account using a laptop there; this triggered some security thing that permanently locked him out of his account.
- ojame 5y agoI’ve had a paid account with Fastmail for probably going on 8 years I’d say. It’s been a fantastically reliable service and the odd (perhaps 3 or 4 times) I’ve needed to reach out to support it’s always prompt and a real conversation.
- yarcob 5y agoI'm also a happy Fastmail customer. They actually offer customer support (at least they did a couple of years ago when I needed it). I had an issue with Fastmail where I accidentally deleted a bunch of emails, and with help from their support I was able to restore them from their backup quickly. Contrast that to Gmail, where thousands of messages suddenly disappeared from the inbox, and the only support option was a forum with dozens of other users asking for solutions to the same problem.
- O_H_E 5y ago> from _their_ backup quickly. Wow, that is something
- denismi 5y agoDeleted emails are kept for one week so that accidentally-deleted items can be restored: https://www.fastmail.com/help/receive/restoredeleted.html https://www.fastmail.com/help/receive/restoredeleted.html
- kmonsen 5y agoGmail is required by law to really delete things the user deletes. There are guarantees around how quickly it will be done.
- joecool1029 5y ago> Gmail is required by law to really delete things the user deletes. This is not universally the case and the opposite is actually stated in their privacy policy and data retention agreements as it relates to financial transaction information (which likely needs to be retained for tax purposes). While Google likely pays it safe and complies mostly with CCPA/GDPR 'rights to be forgotten' for the rest of the US, and a good chunk of the world there's no legal requirement outside of the contractual agreements provided in paid Workspaces on when they need to purge this data. Current privacy policy: https://www.gstatic.com/policies/privacy/pdf/20210204/3jla0xz1/google_privacy_policy_en_us.pdf https://www.gstatic.com/policies/privacy/pdf/20210204/3jla0x... Data retention policy: https://policies.google.com/technologies/retention https://policies.google.com/technologies/retention
- farisjarrah 5y agoI've had the same good experience as you. As another datapoint, they really do live up to their name. Everytime I test sending myself emails, I almost always get the email to my fastmail address 30-90 seconds faster then Gmail. Also gmail tends to disapear messages if they're not from a super uber reputable email provider, which sucks sometimes. Fastmail will always deliver my emails if I am playing with a local postfix server or something like that.
- stevehawk 5y agoi have a gmail account that duplicates/forwards to my fastmail and somehow fastmail shows the forwarded email waaaaaay before gmail even tells me i got the original. i giggle every time.
- yarcob 5y agoI sell an app, and people often tell me they can't find their license code anymore. More often than not, these are from Gmail addresses. This may be just because Gmail is popular. But it's still baffling how Gmails original proposition was that you would always have an archive of all your mail and could search it instantly, yet all these people can't find the email with a license code for an app.
- artificialLimbs 5y agoNice to hear about the support. I haven't had to use it. I'm a 2 or 3 year customer, bringing my own domain. Love being able to send and receive from *@mydomain.com for the entry level price ($50/year, I believe). App works great on both Android and iOS and doesn't drain my battery.
- a3n 5y agoI've been a very enthusiastic fastmail customer for N years. (I don't remember timelines very well, but N is large.)
- hexa22 5y agoFastmail seems to be the best provider currently. Have only been using them for a bit but had no issues.
- Maxburn 5y agoAround fifteen years for me, fastmail is great.
- rychco 5y agoI started using fastmail about 6 months ago and have really enjoyed it so far. My only concern is whether they’ll be around long term (10-20+ years) because it’s quickly become my default email for important stuff.
- Swenrekcah 5y agoYou can always get your own domain and only give out email addresses from that. But my prediction is that Fastmail will outlast GMail.
- beprogrammed 5y agoA bold prediction to be sure. I hope you're right!
- wgm 5y agoI started using fastmail about a year ago. They've been around since the late 1990s so I feel good about their longevity.
- rychco 5y agoI wasn’t aware of that. That’s very reassuring.
- distances 5y agoOthers commented about your own domain. It's straightforward to set up, costs maybe $7 a year. You may want to look into it. Additional bonus: use all kinds of addresses you want (me@shadyservice.domain.com) for easy blocking if an address leaks.
- melesian 5y agoI've had my Fastmail account for over 20 years. It's an employee-owned company with first class ethics and a first class service. An absolute beacon of integrity. It's too bad these qualities aren't more in demand. Make sure you use a Yubikey. An honourable service provider isn't enough.
- Shacklz 5y agoI'm a very happy customer of protonmail. They're consistently extending their offering (VPN, Calendar, Drive is up next), their pricing seems fair, albeit not exactly cheap, but to be honest though, I almost consider this to be a feature - I'm perfectly okay with paying good cash for something as important as mail. Their UI was somewhat lackluster but they recently released a completely overhauled version (just a few days ago), which seems kinda nice so far. All in all, I can only recommend it. That being said, I'm mostly only receiving mail and rarely ever sending out any, so YMMV.
- ByteWelder 5y agoAs a former ProtonMail customer (for several months) and current Fastmail one (~ 4 years): If you have more than 2 domain names, you'll pay 30 EUR/month for your ProtonMail account. I think that's ridiculous. The 5 alias limit for the "Plus" tier is also too limited in my opinion.
- Ly5846N929Rm6bb 5y agoI don't know how well all the features match up but you can use as many domains as you want on Migadu for $19/year.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- benhurmarcel 5y agoFastmail offers a VPN? I can't find anything about that.
- cascom 5y agoProtonMail does
- benhurmarcel 5y agoMy bad
- toomuchtodo 5y agoFastMail customer. +1, nothing but good things to say. They even championed the new JMAP standard.
- horlux 5y agomigadu is a really option
- gpm 5y agoSecond this Assuming "really [good] option"
- RealStickman_ 5y agoI've been using Protonmail for some time and started paying for it about one year ago. I mainly switched to the paid plan to get access to their Protonmail Bridge for use with a local email client and that has worked well so far.
- throwawaystress 5y agoI’m also a Fastmail user (for the past 5 years or so), but I’m considering switching to iCloud, given the announcement it’ll start supporting custom domains. Fastmail is pricey ($50/month for the non-lite tier), whereas iCloud is $1/month for 50 GB.
- tilolebo 5y agoMore like $5/month. Or $50/year
- farski 5y agoI don't think Fastmail has any plans that are $50/month
- squiggleblaz 5y agoFastmail has three current tiers: Basic, Standard and Professional. Basic is $3/user/month, Standard is $5/user/month and Professional is $9/user/month. None of them are remotely close to $50/month for ordinary single users. You would need 10 users to get to $50/month for the Standard "non-lite tier" plan. Perhaps the user has confused fastmail with another service or they might have some legacy plan which is more expensive than it needs to be. (I think I have a legacy plan...)
- innocenat 5y agoIsn't most legacy plan less expensive? I have legacy plan that's basically the current Standard plan but at $45/yr.
- newscracker 5y agoCould you link to the iCloud announcement that says it'll start supporting custom domains? I saw that it will support disposable addresses, but didn't notice anything about custom domains.
- dustyharddrive 5y agohttps://www.macrumors.com/2021/06/08/icloud-mail-custom-domain-names/ https://www.macrumors.com/2021/06/08/icloud-mail-custom-doma... - it wasn’t discussed in the keynote but it showed up on the iOS 15 new features page
- toss1 5y agoVery happy customer of kolabnow Checked out both protonmail & fastmail among others, ended up selecting kolabnow, no regrets.
- hansel_der 5y ago> I wonder if the fastmail protocol could be hidden in AWS-like data streams this reads funnily non-techy i mean web-mail exists or are you reffering to some imap/smtp-in-http? should be good as long as it is ssl-encrypted and runs over tcp-port 443, no?
- utucuro 5y agoFastmail created the JMAP Standard, published by IETF. Take a look here: https://jmap.io/ https://jmap.io/
- fauigerzigerk 5y agoWeb mail can replace IMAP/POP, but you're still going to need an SMTP server to receive email. Or is there some sort of widely supported SMTP over HTTP protocol that I'm unaware of?
- kube-system 5y agoWebmail replaces both IMAP/POP and SMTP for the connection between the user and the mail service they are using. The connection between you and a webmail provider is just a simple HTTP/S web application. It’s the connection between your mail service and the recipient’s mail server that will use traditional mail protocols.
- fauigerzigerk 5y agoI am aware of that, but you're missing my point. Webmail needs SMTP (while it doesn't necessarily need IMAP/POP). So there is bound to be an SMTP server somewhere that cannot be hidden in HTTP traffic, which is what I think hansel_der was implying.
- beprogrammed 5y agoWell fastmail's servers are not in Russia, so they can just keep using SMTP without issue, it would only be the client in Russia who would need to tunnel his traffic to fastmail.
- arihant 5y agoFor your concern, Zoho is a great option. Very reliable support. I got locked out once and they were able to help me get back my account really fast.
- genghizkhan 5y agoI'll put in a recommendation for MXroute (mxroute.com). They're geared towards slightly more technical users, ime, but there's practically no limits (apart from rate of outgoing mail). Unlimited domains, unlimited aliases, unlimited accounts, even. The entire service uses DirectAdmin as a management UI so it's pretty easy to use. They've even got plans geared towards resellers. The owner/sysad is an ex-Digital Ocean guy who's obsessed with mail delivery, so you're not likely to face any issues delivering to practically anyone. I shifted over from Fastmail (who are amazing, don't get me wrong) because I got a good Black Friday deal.
- donkarma 5y agoThat lifetime plan is tempting
- newscracker 5y agoGo to the lowendtalk.com forums and you'd probably find threads with even cheaper plans. They come with certain limitations, but are good for some people.
- BrandoElFollito 5y agoI did not know mxroute.com and went to their web site to get some information. I must say that I would not have lasted there a long tim eif it was not for the HN recommendation. I did not find any place where they actually explain what is the "unlimited part" (= can I really, for 45 USD, register my three domains, and a number of email accounts on each of the domains?). I wanted to ask the question on their chat - cannot login, a customer account is required. I wanted to ask a question on the community forum, cannot login,probably limited to users as well. I will end up sending an email to the contact address but this was not a great experience. To be clear - I have no idea about the service itself, it sees to be very good from the technical descriptions (at least they understand email delivery).
- jarland 5y agoApologies for the bad first impression. This is somewhat intentional. MXroute was originally created for sysadmins who don't need bells and whistles, and just need their email to get to its destination without fussing with IP reputation and things like that. You know the old saying "If you want God to laugh, tell him your plans." Well, we became very popular with end users that weren't sysadmins at all. Still convinced that we could offer high deliverability at low cost while slowly improving UX to fit a new type of customer, we entered a bit of a dark age where support tickets were going unanswered for months. Because our pricing was meant to be extremely competitive and completely ditch the whole "per user" pricing that plagues the market space, and we were becoming more popular with end users, we were overrun with basic support questions and pre-sales inquires. The first thing we did was cut out pre-sales inquiries. With enough sales occurring organically without advertising, and with pre-sales inquires having a high correlation with cancellation requests (because our UX wasn't designed for the end user who happened to be the most likely to have a huge list of questions before purchase), we decided that we weren't going to let our overhead (and as a result, our prices for existing customers) suffer at the hands of something that wasn't generating revenue. The second thing we did was to cut back on direct support and focus on publicly available information for troubleshooting. Ideally, we'd funnel customers or prospective customers into our community forum and community chat, where they could ask questions and help each other with answers, and build up a list of questions/answers that were given in the language of the customers, to help reduce repetitive support requests. Because we found that 15 customers might ask the same question in 15 different ways, by having a community resource where the questions and answers fit those different scenarios, we could do more there than we could by automating responses to keywords. Leveraging these community resources assisted us in building customer facing documentation and automation rules for our direct line of support, which in turn allowed us to begin leaning back into more directly available support with automation and documentation to fall back on. Now, we're back offering more direct support after having weathered the storm caused by the unintended shift in our customer base. This is of course assisted by our documentation, and articles are regularly added to address common questions. We're routinely adding automation to auto reply to repetitive questions, and taking those repetitive questions to form better onboarding processes that intend to prevent them. Time and time again I saw that companies were getting lost in the overhead required for providing support. You'd see in my employment history that I've been on the front lines of that with support at HostGator and DigitalOcean. I always had a vision of how to scale support in a way that would not require the seemingly inevitable steps of outsourcing, followed by selling the company. But only on MXroute did I have the direct opportunity to implement my vision. It hasn't been a flawless process, but I do think that the present result is some of my best work. Of course, as with anything, opinions may vary.
- explorigin 5y agoTry Infomaniak (https://www.infomaniak.com/en/hosting/web-and-mail/mail-hosting https://www.infomaniak.com/en/hosting/web-and-mail/mail-host...). I've been using them for years. Solid platform, not 5-eyes, good webmail experience, cheaper than fastmail.
- mfsch 5y agoJust be aware that they require a phone number to sign up (can’t remember if it’s Swiss numbers only) and if their security systems trigger, they ask you to upload your government-issued ID.
- asnelt 5y agoI moved from fastmail to Runbox many years ago. The Runbox service is very reliable and all the servers are outside of the US.
- declnz 5y agoLong-time (edit: 15+ years) customer of Fastmail, have only praise for them. For me it's a service that just gets out of the way and I get on with life, not worrying about who's mining emails etc.
- vbezhenar 5y ago> I wonder if the fastmail protocol could be hidden in AWS-like data streams to take an approach like telegram. If they try to block it, they shut down their entire digital business infrastructure. As long as server name sent in cleartext in SNI, blocking any website is trivial. Telegram uses a different approach with multitude of proxy servers and dynamic proxy changes via Apple/Google push messages. It's not applicable to an ordinary website. If/when encrypted SNI is widely implemented, it might work.
- patrakov 5y ago> If/when encrypted SNI is widely implemented, it might work. No. China is already blocking all connections with encrypted SNI. If such services become popular or make the encrypted SNI mandatory, then the choice will be to either install a government MITM certificate or not use the internet at all.
- vbezhenar 5y agoMy point is that right now Russia does not have to choose between blocking entire CDN or allowing all websites. Unencrypted SNI allows to selectively block some websites while keeping CDN for other websites untouched. Russia's situation is far from China, AFAIK.
- justusthane 5y ago+1 for Fastmail. I've been happy for several years. I wrote about my experience switching off of Gmail with some tips here if it's helpful: https://www.justus.ws/tech/how-to-ditch-gmail/ https://www.justus.ws/tech/how-to-ditch-gmail/
- lemoncucumber 5y agoNice blog post. I made a similar switch, but in the back of my mind I worry that I’ve introduced a new risk factor, since it’s much more likely for my custom domain to get hijacked than gmail.com. See for example this story of someone’s Twitter account getting stolen via a social engineering attack on their registrar: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/01/picking-up-the-pieces-after-the-n-twitter-account-theft/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/01/picki... A Google search suggests that setting up a registry lock could be an additional layer of defense against these types of attacks. Have you done anything to guard against this type of attack?
- justusthane 5y agoThanks! And no, I have to say I hadn't really considered that angle. In the example that you linked, they didn't steal the domain, they just changed the MX records, so transfer lock wouldn't help. That being said, my account with my registrar is 2FA-enabled and I do have transfer lock turned on. I hope that someone wouldn't be able to social engineer their way into my Hover account, but who knows. Maybe I just mention this in a footnote.
- Sylamore 5y agoI've been a paying customer for a few years (since Dreamhost shutdown catch-all support) and when I 1st migrated I tripped over a bug in their IMAP implementation that made thousands of messages disappear from my mailbox. Their support identified the bug and pushed a code fix into production in less than 24 hours, which immediately resolved my issue. Gmail on the other hand keeps kicking my devices out of being able to log in and activating a security lock down, and the closest thing to support I can get about it is a webpage that implies that can only happen if my devices are hacked.
- ashton314 5y agoFastmail has been nothing but awesome. Currently using PO Box, which is a a sub-company or something. I get all the Fastmail features and it's been awesome. So happy to fork over my money for such a reliable service.
- czottmann 5y agoThere's German mail provider Mailbox. https://mailbox.org/en/ https://mailbox.org/en/ They tick a lot of good boxes for me.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ivrrimum 5y agoI have my own Digital Ocean droplet and have a docker_mailer smt server. Super easy to setup + you dont rely on big tech for basic email service.
- SyzygistSix 5y agoI've been using fastmail for years and I love it.