6 ms·
The article mentions: > the solution is relatively available - get youth to first complete high school and then be equipped with skills they can use to earn a
by viraptor 5y ago
The article mentions:
> the solution is relatively available - get youth to first complete high school and then be equipped with skills they can use to earn a living
But is it? Does SA actually have lots of jobs waiting for post-high school people? With requirements which are not trainable in a few months to people who haven't completed high school?
I'm finding it hard to get answers with public statistics. Looking at https://tradingeconomics.com/south-africa/unemployed-persons https://tradingeconomics.com/south-africa/unemployed-persons for example it seems like SA lost a few million of both unemployed and employees people last year...
- hkai 5y agoIf you were starting a business, like a software company or even, I don't know, a bakery, would you start it in South Africa? No. Some countries have a shortage of people. They're hiring, but they can't find people. However, South Africa has a shortage of businesses. That shortage makes people useless: they're not hired, nobody needs them. Solution: create policies that favor businesses. Employment goes up, quality of life goes up.
- disruptthelaw 5y agoThere is a shortage of skilled workers and there is a surplus of unskilled workers. Google “skill shortage South Africa” or something like that for more info. I don’t think there is an easy solution to bringing that gap, but I’m sure getting the basics right (ie a decent education system) would help a lot.
- blacktriangle 5y agoNot persecuting your population of skilled workers would have also been a good strategy for South Africa.
- disruptthelaw 5y agoYes I don’t think anyone here disputes the historical cause.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThis might be politically difficult when the skilled workers (or their ancestors) were persecuting the population of unskilled workers for generations.
- alienthrowaway 5y agoNot only that, but the said-ancestors established a separate, impoverished, lower-quality education system to ensure that they'd be perpetually unskilled and incapable of competing for skilled jobs even if they wanted to talented. Diabolical.
- blacktriangle 5y agoHonest question: how did that education system compare to the one that previously existed for said population?
- disruptthelaw 5y agoI would speculate that, on the whole, they’re probably comparable in terms of outcome, the old system was designed for mediocre outcomes whereas the current one is due to negligence. But could be wrong, our former white public schools now serve everyone and presumably are better than the Bantu education schools that black people were previously limited to. These schools are of course the minority.
- alienthrowaway 5y agoThere is much more funding being provided now, but it's far from enough sadly. In terms of policy, its much more egalitarian on paper in the sense that every student is supposed to study the same material, unfortunately there are still under-resourced schools and egregious negligence and/or corruption. I'd say the black, middle-class-and-higher (or very gifted but poor) students have benefitted the most by getting the institutional roadblocks removed since they already have access to good schools. The the system has improved marginally for the poor, and those who are in remote rural areas (the two are often synonymous)
- the_gipsy 5y agoWe had roughly the same youth unemployment in Spain at the peak of the 2008 crisis. The problem was not education.
- ChuckNorris89 5y agoThis. Just because you have an educated workforce doesn't mean you'll be booming with jobs. More like you need a business friendly environment with low taxes, minimal corruption and frictionless bureocracy to create a thriving local economy and also attract external investors.
- ForHackernews 5y agoI guess that's one template for booming with jobs. You can also be a wealthly petrostate (with or without corruption), or a corrupt, dirt-poor state with no labor laws and be booming with outsourced low-wage textile jobs, or a command-economy with plenty of pointless make-work jobs... If your goal is just to have a lot of jobs to keep your young people busy so they don't foment a revolution, there's plenty of ways to go.
- alexgmcm 5y agoSpain has a 17.3% high school dropout rate though.[1] So education is an issue. Although yeah, many graduates were also unemployed in the crisis. I think the crisis was kind of exceptional as everyone was going to be pretty screwed either way. But furthermore, it seems that until you reach a sort of 'critical mass' of educated workers it can be hard for them to find employment as it's hard for the country to attract companies that require an educated workforce. I think the solution would be to continue investing in education to help reach that critical mass and at the same time make it easier for people to set up new companies, start-ups etc. Spain is pretty bad for this with the harsh autonomo taxes for people trying to start their own business etc., plus all the bureaucracy which often has to be done in-person and appointments are hard to get etc. At least it seems like things are improving, although the Coronavirus will be a setback. [1] https://www.euroweeklynews.com/2020/11/13/spain-has-highest-number-of-school-dropouts/ https://www.euroweeklynews.com/2020/11/13/spain-has-highest-...
- 5y ago
- zamalek 5y ago> get youth to first complete high school [...] But is it? Yes, but it will never happen. I've seen this playbook in 3 countries now (one of which South Africa): attack education so that people aren't educated enough to understand why they need to vote you out. If you speak to the people who keep voting for the regime, it's "I hate the ANC, but we must vote for them." In terms of destroying education to stay in power, that's a slam dunk. Education is the Achilles Heel of democracy.
- barry-cotter 5y ago> > get youth to first complete high school [...] But is it? > Yes, but it will never happen. This implies a model of the world in which education causes prosperity. The fate of large parts of Central Asia, the Caucasus and Mongolia after the end of the subsidies from Russia suggests this doesn’t work that well. Broad based high levels of education weren’t great for Ireland either last century. There were at most three decades 1900-2000 when Ireland didn’t export its people. By contrast China got rich explosively fast once with a population that mostly hadn’t finished primary school starting in the 1980s. The evidence that education causes prosperity is at best weak. People like to buy education once they have money for similar reasons to west they like to buy nicer houses or travel, intrinsic enjoyment and conspicuous consumption.
- disgruntledphd2 5y ago> Broad based high levels of education weren’t great for Ireland either last century Can you clarify this remark? Ireland didn't provide free secondary school education until the late 60's (my Dad was sent to secondary school for three years as he was the smart one), so I'm having trouble understanding what you mean here.
- oblio 5y agoThe Asian Tigers rose precisely through masive investment in education. Edit: you don't have to believe me, read any half decent economic study about them.
- zamalek 5y ago
- jokethrowaway 5y agoPeople don't find jobs because of their corrupted government destroying the economy, not because they don't know calculus.
- mberning 5y agoRight. We have to come to grips with the fact that not all people are cut out for college or to be white collar knowledge workers. Many of the jobs that these people used to enjoy have been shipped overseas, meanwhile large amounts of unskilled labor is allowed to pour in. This has destroyed opportunities to make your way in life as a blue collar worker. But instead of reversing sweetheart legislation that makes it easy to ship jobs overseas and bring in cheap labor at home, we talk about UBI and raising minimum wage. Both of which will have even more devastating impacts on the middle and low economic classes.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> But instead of reversing sweetheart legislation that makes it easy to ship jobs overseas and bring in cheap labor at home, No or low taxes on imports is sweetheart legislation? There is no way US labor prices (some of the highest in the world) were ever going to compete with the labor prices in developing countries where families live in a single room. Not to mention the lack of labor and environmental standards. I am not aware of any US import taxes that were removed to allow this labor price arbitrage to occur. It was simply a fact of international shipping efficiencies making trade and the labor price arbitrage much easier.
- mberning 5y agoThere is a black market for labor.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhy is that relevant here? The scale of manufacturing causing jobs to be outsourced surely dwarfs it.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoThese situations can become traps for local economies: People don’t want to invest in education without job opportunities. Companies don’t want to invest in more jobs without educated applicants. Self-reinforcing cycle. The inverse of this situation is why high cost of living cities continue to thrive: It may cost more to hire and retain people, but you’re guaranteed a supply of motivated and educated applicants. It becomes worth the premium to operate in those expensive markets. I can’t speak to SA, but there are definitely cities and even regions in the United States that have high unemployment but also struggle to hire reliable employees regardless of wages offered. Even if a company pays well, the well-paid and well-educated hires often want to use those jobs as a springboard to move out of the city rather than risk tying their career to a declining local economy. Turnover is high simply because educated and motivated people leave the area.