10 ms·
I feel like this is a weird dichotomy I don't want actual politics at work. I don't want to be debating politically contentious events at work. E.g. (to pick a
by bawolff 5y ago
I feel like this is a weird dichotomy
I don't want actual politics at work. I don't want to be debating politically contentious events at work. E.g. (to pick a contentious topic that was in the news recently) a long winded debate on the palestine/israel conflict is not something i want to have at work. That doesn't mean i don't have opinions on the subject or that in a different context i wouldn't want to debate it, work is just not the time to get into it.
However that doesn't mean i think racism/bigotry/etc is acceptable at work.
I don't see these two things in conflict.
- concordDance 5y ago> However that doesn't mean i think racism/bigotry/etc is acceptable at work. A big issue is different people have different definitions of these terms. For example, say a very religous conservative doesn't want to use a trans persons preferred pronouns as they consider said pronouns to be untrue and sinful. They are otherwise polite and nondiscriminatory (e.g. they will listen to and implement ideas from the trans person and don't bring up their opinions of trans issues). Is this bigotry? Or say some people in the company want to run a BLM donation drive and a conversation then ensues where someone states that they don't think racism has anything to do with USA police killings of blacks and it's actualy down to problems in the main african american culture. Is this racism?
- notRobot 5y ago> Is this bigotry? Prioritizing made-up, vague and abstract ideas of "sins" and refusing to respect the identity of a fellow human? Yes, that is bigotry. > Is this racism? Yes, because there's plenty of research that's been done that says racism within police departments is responsible for the killing of black people in the USA. Not to mention countless videos of innocent black people being shot down by cops. Believing something stupid doesn't excuse your bigotry or racism.
- Thorentis 5y ago> Yes, because there's plenty of research that's been done that says racism Woah, so disagreeing with particular research is racist now? I've heard it all.
- fighterpilot 5y ago"racism within police departments is responsible for the killing of black people in the USA" Firstly, if they are mistaken about facts, that doesn't necessarily make them racist. That just makes them mistaken, and possibly racist depending on the reasons they are mistaken. Secondly, what is the evidence for this? I've read evidence of racism in US police departments against Blacks, but not specifically in the context of police killings.
- BellLabradors 5y ago"For every 10,000 black people arrested for violent crime, 3 are killed For every 10,000 white people arrested for violent crime, 4 are killed" https://twitter.com/LeonydusJohnson/status/1267466345844740098 https://twitter.com/LeonydusJohnson/status/12674663458447400... Consider also that there are towns such as Jackson, Mississippi which have police departments that are >90% black [1] but still have all the same problems as police forces in America generally: https://www.jacksonfreepress.com/policeshootings/ https://www.jacksonfreepress.com/policeshootings/ Not posting this to change your mind, I don't think that's possible through a single comment, but if you seriously think that there can be no other good-faith, legitimate opinion than your own, then consider that you might not be thinking about this rationally. "“He who knows only his own side of the case knows little of that." John Stuart Mill [1] https://www.governing.com/gov-data/safety-justice/police-department-officer-demographics-minority-representation.html https://www.governing.com/gov-data/safety-justice/police-dep...
- seoaeu 5y agoThe recent high profile police shootings were not during arrests for violent crimes, and in many of them the victims had committed no crime at all. You aren't going to change very many people's minds by citing statistics unrelated to their concerns, and some may even take offense at seemingly trying to steer the conversation from talking about killing clearly innocent people to violent fugitives.
- spoonjim 5y agoYou do realize that these very statistics show that the “high profile” cases you mention do not reflect the racial reality of police killings? The media decides what becomes “high profile” and cases like Daniel Shaver and Tony Timpa do not get the coverage of Eric Garner or George Floyd.
- randompwd 5y ago> Believing something stupid doesn't excuse your bigotry or racism. It is apparent to me that you are the stupid in this thread.
- bjourne 5y ago> I feel like this is a weird dichotomy > I don't want actual politics at work. I don't want to be debating politically contentious events at work. Frank and Kate is sitting at the lunch table. They are discussing "Israel's ongoing massacre in Gaza" and how awful it is. Your opinion is contrary to theirs. Do you feel that you have the right to make them not talk about this topic because you don't want "actual politics" at work? I'm curious to know where you think the line should be drawn. Suppose you are an atheist and you just got a warning from your manager because a Christian employee overheard you saying to a colleague that "all religions are such bunk." Should you not have been allowed to express that "controversial" opinion?
- Thorentis 5y agoTo me, "no politics at work" means "the company does not get involved in political activities or discussions". Individuals are free to discuss what they want, with who they want. This means: water cooler discussion about Middle East conflict? Perfectly fine. "Bomb Israel Activism Day (with free cake in staff room)" organised by the company? Not okay. I am sick of receiving corporate emails inviting me to "x pride/awareness/celebration" activities that have nothing to do with work, and that are not neutral topics. I am happy for people to have different opinions with me, and talk about them, and even debate with me about them, but I don't want "mandatory fun" events where the "fun" is eating a cake with icing colored in whatever way symbolizes the current woke topic, and being forced to stand around and pretend I care.
- bjourne 5y ago> To me, "no politics at work" means "the company does not get involved in political activities or discussions". Individuals are free to discuss what they want, with who they want. Wouldn't that mean that certain tech companies' bans on politics is a form of involvement in political activities and discussions? > I am sick of receiving corporate emails inviting me to "x pride/awareness/celebration" activities that have nothing to do with work, and that are not neutral topics. Interesting, can you give some examples of any such activities that you have been invited to? Note that the agent compelling you to attend these events is the company you work for - not the "woke crowd". Since if pays you for your time it most certainly has the right to order you to attend to these mildly political events (gay pride, that you have as an example, isn't very controversial).
- mam3 5y agoThe line is when you are fired for saying you are pro trump on twitter.
- fithisux 5y agowhat happens when your "work" does business with politicians then? Why shouldn't you be allowed? Directly or indirectly all "works" do business with the politicians and they favour politicians for their interests, not YOUR interest. Sounds some kind of perverted game. The big ones are allowed to do whatever they want, the small ones should obey the rules of the big ones. So should perverted games be allowed to the workplace? Another interesting question.
- Google234 5y agoI’m against discrimination- so companies should do business with everyone (that is legal).
- seoaeu 5y agoEmpirically, companies do not make equally sized political donations to all candidates and most certainly do not spend equal amounts lobbying for and against each bill. Post citizen's united, the political desires of corporations have a big impact on the direction of government.
- fithisux 5y agoPoliticians are not another business. and doing business with them is not legal in all Constitutions. But this is the attitude of business to be the next king or emperor without any legal binding. Chaos and anarchy, oppression and boasting. The evolution clock goes back 10^{5} years.
- late2part 5y agoYour statement "I'm against discrimination" hits me as ambiguous. Do you discriminate between bananas and durian? Do you discriminate between the man who beat you up and your spouse/partner?
- bawolff 5y agoI dont see the connection really. Some common sense applies. Selling services to a mainstream politician isn't really political in any major sense. Selling services to terrorists/neo-nazis/etc is something different. Yes, you can make grey examples that are unclear, but in practise i dont think its usually that ambigius of an issue most of the time.
- spoonjim 5y agoMany people would call your refusal to hear their opinion on Israel/Palestine or any other issue “problematic,” or contributing to an “unsafe” environment. You can say you’re against racism at work but do you think you can push back against the next BLM workshop with “this isn’t appropriate for work?” Doubtful.
- paganel 5y ago> BLM workshop I live in Eastern-European, one ocean away from the States, I'm curious about these workshops, do they really happen as often as people say they happen? (let's say once a month or so, which I would consider "often" for this type of meetings). I'm asking because they do look to me like pretty much resembling the communist party indoctrinations work-place meetings my dad had to attend in the 1980s (my dad's workplace was in the business of building stuff inside a steel mill factory, so nothing intrinsically political about it), those communist party meetings seemed to be taken seriously by absolutely no-one and were seen just as a huge loss of one's time.
- knorker 5y agoThey're often called Marxists. I've not grown up in eastern Europe, but yeah probably right. Everyone thinks it's bullshit waste of time, but will anyone speak up? No, you sit through because it's easier than dealing with the consequences of denouncing the indoctrination.
- ecshafer 5y agoThey call themselves Marxists, but Marx didn't care about diversity, or think white people are evil, or that there's toxic masculinity, and would deride these ideas. They are not marxists.
- muyuu 5y agothey pretty much are if the yardstick is Marx and his manifesto + Das Kapital series, then practically nobody was a Marxist - not even Marx himself later in life and certainly not Lenin, Stalin or Mao since Gramsci the mainstream of Marxism replaces material determinism with a hybrid of cultural hegemony and social gatekeeping, with things like religion, race, feminism being much more central than they were for Marx - and this has been the mainstream of Marxism for 100+ years, so hardly a new development in this particular respect
- rayiner 5y agoTo be clear, the new generation of political activist is the one creating the dichotomy. The kind of workplace you’re describing in the first paragraph would be, according to Kendi, racist.
- tptacek 5y agoPlenty of people who are deeply concerned about racism find Kendi's arguments risible.
- rayiner 5y agoHi we’re the “old generation” now.
- tptacek 5y agoThere are antiracist activists who find Kendi risible.
- lizardking 5y agoYes, and “Boomer” is a state of mind
- h0l0cube 5y agoTurns out human beings are complicated. Individual differences are greater than the statistical differences between groups. It's odd that many of the loudest voices that vilify discrimination will often wield it to great effect, counterproductively against a project of shared humanity
- b9a2cab5 5y ago"Antiracists" coined the term BIPOC which literally excludes certain minority groups because they were too successful.
- flippinburgers 5y agoThe immediate response will be: "bawolff, through their silence, is promoting not-my-agenda (obviously!) therefore I feel unsafe and want bawolff fired!" It really is as simple as that.
- cheph 5y agoAnd bawolff would be summarily fired.
- bawolff 5y agoI'm sure places like that exist, but i think the internet overstates their prevelence. I've never worked anywhere like that.
- spoonjim 5y agoYou haven’t heard the term “silence is violence”? It’s not ironic. Anytime you see on a list of “demands” (which is a term that people feel very comfortable using) that includes “forcefully condemn X,” they are basically rejecting your choice to remain silent on the issue. You may have never seen this in the workplace but it is increasingly common in some of the most coveted (or formerly so) employers like Google, Basecamp, Medium, etc.
- bawolff 5y agoI've worked at some places that i think would consider themselves woke. I have never been asked to personally condemn anything. I'm doubtful that places like google are really like that, i suspect this is mostly a strawman that doesn't really exist. Sure, if i went around saying that hitler was just misunderstood, i would probably get in trouble. And i'm totally ok with that.
- SV_BubbleTime 5y ago> I have never been asked to personally condemn anything Wear a Trump hat to work and see how long that lasts. Just tell people you voted for him, see if “you’ll be asked to condemn anything”. “I’ve never had any problems with the people I work with“… probably just means you are aligned with them.
- throwaway894345 5y agoIt’s not a dichotomy; it’s being framed as such but that’s just sophomoric rhetoric.
- Barrin92 5y ago>I don't want actual politics at work. I don't want to be debating politically contentious events at work to take the example from the article: "In July 2019, for example, Medium chose to publish a series that included a profile of Trump supporter Joy Villa with the headline “I have never been as prosecuted for being Black or Latina as I have been for supporting Trump.”" When you're in the business of news publishing, on an incendiary and relevant political event at that, and your decisions have a real chance to influence public discourse, even engineering decisions, how is it realistic to think you're not involved in politics, or even can get away from it? Tech, in particular media and communication platforms directly sit at the intersection of politics, news and technology. Those copmanies build the platforms where moderation and editorial decisions are made that have huge impact.
- rmk 5y agoI wonder how this works in, say, the Marines, or the Navy, which I believe are much more diverse than tech. Are people discussing politics endlessly at work? Is there a code of ethics/conduct that explicitly bars such behaviors? Tech is extremely un-diverse, but it somehow seems to attract much more vocal and activist types compared to the above. For example, I have never read about such incidents in the Navy or the Marines... Is it simply my ignorance, or does the military have an established way of dealing with such things? FWIW, I'm sick of the politicization and invasion by SJWs of the discourse in our little bubble in the Bay Area. I'd heartily appreciate the day when I can spend a whole day at work with absolutely no discussion of politics and religion at work. Even private home life is not impervious to this nonsense (even talk at the dinner table often comes down to this, much to my dismay). Do others share a similar sentiment? Just like there are 'no-cellphone' train compartments, perhaps we can have 'politics/religion-free' zones at home and the office!
- ReptileMan 5y agoIn the Marines you have to prove your mettle. So people actually earn the respect of their peers. And I think that their process is quite competent in weeding out the really toxic people that are the majority of activists. Today those types are SJW, 20 years ago they would have been fundamental Christians wanting to help Jack Thompson ban violent games. And of course Marines are the one that invented the term fragging. The problem with activism in the west is lack of feedback for being obnoxious. So they can get away with it. A very popular meme is how in june all corporations turn their profile pictures rainbow in all social media accounts except in the legit homophobic and conservative countries. So it is activism entangled with safetysm. We protest where we know people will pay the dane geld.
- ecshafer 5y agoThe difference is tech has a lot more people who went to expensive fancy colleges and private high schools, and have comfortable middle class backgrounds, the military that is the extreme minority. People can talk about diversity, but its not truly diversity they are looking for, as they do not look for political or class diversity. The marines, has a lot of working class background people, and black, white, hispanic, working class people seem to get along just fine with different races without long diatribes about politics. Tech has these "intelligentsia" activists that want to show they have the right ideas and opinions. Go to a welding shop or mechanic or marines or whatever, and everyone can have different opinions about something and nothing bad happens. People might laugh it off and call someone an idiot, that's about it.