7 ms·
>I save money by spending less on food, drinks, and electricity. Compared to commuting (car+gas) and time-to-commute opportunity costs (to use for personal hou
by coldtea 5y ago
>I save money by spending less on food, drinks, and electricity.
Compared to commuting (car+gas) and time-to-commute opportunity costs (to use for personal house tasks, side projects, self health)? I seriously doubt it.
- d3ntb3ev1l 5y agoAgreed. The above reads like dated marketing from dinasour companies trying to convince people that office life is amazing. “Imagine the hallway conversations that could start the next…” it will make up for your 2 hour commute and 3000 one bedroom apartment!
- jackbravo 5y agoI agree with most of the parent comments. Commuting costs can be reduced, I biked to work when possible, and it was not possible when my kids were at school, which will be the same once things settle down. So it was the same cost with or without remote work.
- hwbehrens 5y agoI'm obviously an outlier, but I live an 8 minute (peaceful) bike ride from work. I hate commuting, so I optimized for that for this job, and working from home last year was absolutely a net negative for me. Distracting kids, poor work-life balance, more expensive (AC, food, water, etc). I think the lesson here is, some companies can be remote-first, some companies can be in-person, and different employees will prefer different environments based on what's going on in their lives and the choices they make. It should not be the case that one "tribe" should try to impose their preference on the other, which was the case pre-COVID (e.g. almost everyone was forced to be in-person), and I suspect fear of a return to that status quo is what is driving a lot of these discussions.
- BrissyCoder 5y agoI don't understand how so many people in this thread are saying they spend more on food while working from home. How is this possible? Does it vary by country? In Australia at least it is orders of magnitude less expensive to prepare food at home purchased from a supermarket than it is to buy food whilst out an about. Or are these people working for companies that provide food or something. I just don't get it.
- ModernMech 5y ago> Or are these people working for companies that provide food or something. It's this. Companies started offering food to keep their employees in the office longer. That people here are saying they prefer eating at work due to the cost shows it worked.
- bredren 5y agoIt isn't just that they prefer eating at work due to cost. Work provides prepared food. Preparing food means getting ingredients, tracking expiration and making and storing leftover food. In some ways this is wonderful, in others it is a huge time and energy sink compared to eating at work. Spoiled food wastes more than money and it happens easily. You can buy prepared food for home via takeout or frozen but those have their own problems.
- thrower123 5y agoFor me, going back to the office means going back to eating microwaved leftovers, or spending $15-20 a day on lunch out. Totaling up gas and mileage and food and tolls, commuting to the office is going to cost me on the order of $500-1000 a month that I'm not spending now. Just the extra time that I'd need to spend getting ready to go to work and then commuting works out to an entire extra work week of time over the course of a month.
- quicklime 5y agoOn the other hand, where I live the marginal cost of an extra bedroom (to put a home office in) for a city apartment is about $1000 a month. In some higher cost of living cities it will be more. It’s be cheaper out in the suburbs, but even then it might be another few hundred a month. I’m surprised that people are talking about things like electricity costs when real estate costs are so much higher.
- ghaff 5y agoAbsolutely for employees, the biggest (I'd probably argue only real economic downside) is more space if the company is urban and they really want to stay urban. Arguments around electricity are ludicrous and food only applies to a very limited set of companies.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoI don’t think you’re an outlier. I think online comment sections in general attract people whose preferred communication and socialization style is digital. That’s why at times HN comment sections feel like everyone unanimously agrees that in-person work universally bad. It’s great that we have more remote work opportunity post COVID, but it was never realistic to expect every company or even most company to abandon in-office work and all of the benefits that come with it. Maintaining a remote team is significantly more management and communication overhead than simply having people in one place.
- luffapi 5y ago> Maintaining a remote team is significantly more management and communication overhead than simply having people in one place. I’ve managed both types of teams and haven’t found this to be the case at all. In fact, quite the opposite. Asynchronous communication as the norm is a lot less demanding on ICs and managers. In person meetings are rarely an effective use of time or energy.
- simfree 5y agoIn person meetings make some participants in said meeting feel good. Besides this factor, in person meetings can often be less effective than email or a group chat.
- mars009 5y agoThis. Nothing like going to a meeting just to make the person that schedule it feel good or hear them talk about nothing that matters work wise.
- Supermancho 5y ago> I don’t think you’re an outlier. Not sure what inspired you to make a claim from a position of ignorance. Definitely an outlier. The vast majority of people have commutes that are not within 8 minutes by any means. 1 Google search and see the US - https://blog.batchgeo.com/commute-times-and-transportation/ https://blog.batchgeo.com/commute-times-and-transportation/ or Europe - http://ftp.iza.org/dp12916.pdf http://ftp.iza.org/dp12916.pdf
- rufus_foreman 5y ago>> I live an 8 minute (peaceful) bike ride from work Well that's where you live now. Average worker changes jobs 12 times in a career. Is your plan to just move 12 times (and pay the costs associated with that)? Or work at the same job for much longer (and pay the costs associated with that)? One of the benefits of living in a large metro area is the amount of job opportunities, but it you put an 8 minute circle around your residence and only look for jobs within that, that negates those benefits.
- adamjb 5y agoIf you're going to bring averages into it, the average 18 year old has ~9 moves remaining in their life, meaning that they'd only move an extra 3 times. https://www.census.gov/topics/population/migration/guidance/calculating-migration-expectancy.html https://www.census.gov/topics/population/migration/guidance/...
- paulcole 5y agoIf you live in a dense area, it’s not hard to switch jobs, keep a similar commute, and not move. I’ve had 4 jobs over the past 14 years, moved once, and never had a bicycle commute longer than 25 minutes.
- vineyardmike 5y agoThe issue is that most people who want to be in office want to be in-person. The location is secondary to the fact that you’re with your coworkers in person. If coworker A prefer digital communication, and coworker B prefers in person communication, then there is no way A and B can both be happy. A can stay at home, and B can go to office, but B is now far from home (commuting) but still over zoom. The only way to not waste people’s time is for All remote, or for A to completely not get their way and get dragged in person.
- nimchimpsky 5y agofood and water at home is more expensive ? How do you manage that ?
- aikinai 5y agoWhy does everyone here just assume that everyone’s commute is as bad as theirs? There are many people in the current working generation that avoided the soul-sucking suburban commute from the start.
- coldtea 5y ago>Why does everyone here just assume that everyone’s commute is as bad as theirs? Because statistically it would be representative. Also because even if the office is next door, you need to get dressed properly, prepare, etc., which eats at least half hour every morning.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoI just hope you shover despite working from home.
- coldtea 5y agoWFH I can shower whenever I want, not necessarily in the morning -- as would be the case when I have a morning commute. And another key benefit is that, even for those who don't shower, nobody else is hurt...
- gnulinux 5y agoYou should get dressed properly and prepare even if you're working from home.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoOur CISO made a deal with us that we'd wear collared shirts when we need to be on a video call but are free to wear whatever we want otherwise. I keep a polo shirt with the company logo in the closet of my home office for those occasions. Works well. Sometimes I wait until lunch to shower but if I have a video call in the morning, I'll be sure to shower so my hair looks presentable.
- jayd16 5y agoI live close enough to bike to work. I'm sure I don't spend a meal's worth of gas but I guess I spend 20 mins a day. Its not that strange at all.
- themacguffinman 5y agoNot everyone spends a significant amount of time commuting by personal car to the office. I see a lot of angst about hypothetically long 1-2hr commutes when the average commute in major tech cities is ~30 mins, and of course you can always control it by living closer to the office. Sure, not everyone is willing to make sacrifices for commute, which is one reason why it can be a competitive advantage.
- newsclues 5y agoI commuted 1.5 hours each way, bike in summer and public transit in winter both took the same time. I loved biking but public transportation sucks. Why? Rent was triple what I was paying to be close, or double to cut the commute in half. And I had no job security.
- themacguffinman 5y agoI'm sure you did but again, that is not an average case. You've evidently chosen a different trade-off.
- newsclues 5y agoMy point is that the economics of my salary and rent made the choice for me.
- swader999 5y agoEbike next time. Mod the motor. You can still pedal and sweat if you want.
- colinmhayes 5y agoThe exercise is a large part of what is enjoyable about bike commuting.
- HPsquared 5y ago
- Solvitieg 5y agoOnes support of WFH seems to depend almost entirely on their distance from the office. The other stuff is superfluous.
- twobitshifter 5y agoI bought a house 5 minutes from my office but I still prefer work from home. I get to spend all day with my wife where I’m most comfortable. I think some see work as a vacation from home and others see home as a vacation from work. If employees are spoiled with many benefits in the office like gourmet lunches, famous speakers, entertainment, and free massages, It makes sense to prefer working at work when your office is a luxury spa - but most offices are not like that at all.
- throwaway1777 5y agoTrain ticket is $5 each way, that’s less than one meal.
- Tiktaalik 5y agoThe amount that people go on about how WFH is saving them from their commute... Really goes to show how badly so many cities are designed that these sort of massive commutes are an ordeal required by so many It'd be nice if an outcome of this pandemic is a political change toward ending absurd commutes by building cities better, but doesn't really seem like people are putting two and two together
- mindflay 5y ago+1 to this concept. WhyTF are so many people commuting for so long in the first place? solve for this the rest follows