14 ms·
EU set to unveil plans for bloc-wide digital wallet for various services
- elric 5y agoI'm not really looking forward to using a government issued tool for payments. Especially one that's advertised with nonsense like "[..]can be accessed via fingerprint or retina scanning[..]". I'd love to see hard guarantees that these governments don't have access to said tool. Until then, it's a hard pass for me.
- WastingMyTime89 5y agoIt's not for payment. It's an SSO service with a strong proof of identity tied to your official id and a vault to store your official documents. France already has something very similar but which can only be used with the state. It works really well.
- heinrichhartman 5y agoBlogged about the idea of a "digital passport" as SSO service in 2016 -- https://www.heinrichhartmann.com/archive/a-digital-passport-for-digital-citizens https://www.heinrichhartmann.com/archive/a-digital-passport-...
- logifail 5y ago> an SSO service with a strong proof of identity What about those of us who prefer proof of identity to be only as strong as necessary and therefore as loose as possible? I don't want my mobile devices to have a strong proof of identity associated with them. Ever.
- unionpivo 5y agoYou don't have to use it. It's for convenience when you do.
- elric 5y agoYou don't have to use it ... yet. Give it a couple of years, and you won't be able to buy a beer without it. Sure, sure, downvote. But it's no longer possible to buy beer from vending machines without inserting your ID card as proof of age.
- unionpivo 5y agoWell I have never seen vending machine that had beer or other alcohol, so I'll take your word for it. But that one small downside. It's not like you can't get beer anywhere. I know I can order beer from our grocery stores online, and as far as I know they don't perform any age checks since I pay with cash on delivery most of the time. But I am in my 40s and look that way so I maybe they just don't bother asking.
- PoignardAzur 5y agoHeh. Reminds me of a public debate a few years ago about forcing porn platforms to securely verify the age of their users. I think a government member said something like "We could use FranceConnect (the government SSO service) for authentication in these cases". Needless to say, people were not enthused.
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoI agree, I hope this wallet will have some safeguards issued by the states, like “If someone crack you wallet and steal your e-money, the state will refund you”. Anyway you can still use it for the more useful things like personal ID, driver license, vaccine green pass, etc… I think the payments will be delayed in a next future, still there isn’t nothing like a testing of a ‘governament e-money’.
- airza 5y agoThe dutch government's SSO app is a complete pleasure to use for this- I hope they use it as a model for everything else.
- gmueckl 5y agoThat would mean getting the German government on board. And their track record around these things has been less than stellar, to put it mildly. They always find a way to add wrinkles and complications that make initiatives such as this one pretty much useless in the end.
- Etheryte 5y agoI think the problem many people miss in this context is that it's not a bureaucracy or a technology problem — it's a cultural one. There's a reason cash is king in countries like Germany and Switzerland. As someone who lived in the latter as an expat for a while, they often simply prefer the option you can physically hold. Trust is the name of the game, and I think the cultural bridge will need to be crossed first before adoption becomes the norm.
- logifail 5y ago> There's a reason cash is king in countries like Germany and Switzerland. As someone who lived in the latter as an expat for a while, they often simply prefer the option you can physically hold. It might also be cheaper to use cash, given banking isn't typically free in Germany.
- looki 5y agoI'm not sure why you're trying to say here. Pretty much every German and most definitely every merchant has a bank account. Personally I've never had an account that wasn't free either, although some banks are changing this in light of the low/negative interest rates.
- wink 5y agoI don't agree with this analogy. Most Germans I know (especially those who like cash) are not against the existence of electronic payment at all, but about the choice to have both ways. It's mostly lamenting that you still can ONLY pay in cash in so many places. (Covid has actually improved the situation at a lot of places.)
- ipatec 5y agoI live in Belgium where we already have eID and SSO apps that work okish. But I fail to see the need for an EU wide ID. I don't think most EU citizens use services from other EU countries than the one they live in. Not services where they need to ID themselves. How much of the population would be in the category needing something like this? I'd say this should be left to the national Governments.
- scrollaway 5y agoThe EU wants it to be as smooth and painless as possible to go from one EU country to another. If you see it under that lens, this moves makes a lot of sense. Such a service would be useful for me for example: a french living in Belgium with relatives in Greece.
- admissionsguy 5y agoAbsolutely, right now it's often incredibly difficult to establish residence in another EU country. If you move to Sweden, for example, it can take over half a year [1] before you can access government services, banking, healthcare, or even much of online shopping. [1] https://www.thelocal.se/20210510/my-first-visit-to-the-swedish-tax-office-whats-the-fuss-about-personnummer/ https://www.thelocal.se/20210510/my-first-visit-to-the-swedi...
- photonios 5y agoReally? I moved from the Netherlands to Romania a few years ago and all I had to do was register for residency at the immigration services. That took about 15 minutes. I opened a bank account the same day. Healthcare was also easy once I was employed.
- dariosalvi78 5y agoYou can survive, but most online services depend on the availability of a fiscal number, which sometimes takes ages to come especially if you are not employed. Once you're in the system everything becomes smoother. An EU-wide system would be absolutely great for those coming to live here from other EU countries.
- habibur 5y agoNext, we are waiting for a any central bank issuing "world-wide" digital wallet. EU-wide is a good step towards that.
- NullPrefix 5y agoCould it be worse than paypal?
- yoz-y 5y agoAs somebody who never had any issue with paypal, why is there so much hate about it? Are problems on the merchant side?
- Leparamour 5y agoMy only hope against ever-increasing surveillance and nascent social scoring remains the technological incompetence of the parties involved.
- ipatec 5y agoI think this is the biggest worry. With the vaccine passport system soon to be revealed and now an universal SSO tracking a variety of EU wide actions... I feel the risk of getting to a social credit score system as China is high.
- arcturus17 5y agoIncompetence could mean you're both fully surveilled and at the mercy of other bad actors.
- kasperni 5y agoI recently moved to the UK from Denmark which has a national SSO solution. It feels like going back 10 years in time. The amount of times I've had to provide copies of my passport, drivers licences, council tax bills, credit card history, or other things to prove my identity/address is ridiculous.
- ckolkey 5y agoTo be fair, I think Denmark is living 10+ years in the future with respect to that stuff. It's far more the exception than the rule :)
- kasperni 5y agoPoint taken. What I will say though is that a national SSO solution is a great enabled for digital government. Having to go through a multi-day authentication phase just to access a particular service is such a barrier for adoption.
- vishnugupta 5y agoNetherlands SSO (DigiD) isn't too bad either, on a stand alone basis. Onboarding could be improved I suppose which is an offline process but past that just about anything to do with the government is linked to it.
- Phurist 5y agoIt's about priorities. Maintaining and managing millions of cameras is just more important perhaps.
- calpaterson 5y agoThere was once a plan for a national identity database. It even got as far as pressing and distributing id cards but was repealed due to immense opposition. Just look at the list of supporters for the NO2ID campaign: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NO2ID https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NO2ID All parties except one (Labour - who probably would oppose it now), most trades unions, the Scottish parliament, the Welsh Assembly, the London Assembly, major charities, famous authors, the list goes on and on. So it will be driving licences and previous addresses forever I'm afraid!
- toyg 5y ago> Brussels is engaged in talks with member states to provide guidelines on technical standards for rollout of the digital wallet, which is expected to be fully operational in about a year Big LOL. A year for a project like this is hopelessly optimistic. I'd expect it will take 2 to 5 years for the basic centralized infrastructure to be made available, and 5 to 10 years for for countries to actually integrate it in their existing systems. It's a great initiative which I'd strongly support, I hope it doesn't get discredited by pursuing unrealistic deadlines.
- odiroot 5y agoI'm just afraid SAP, Telekom, or Big "O" will get the contract and it'd be over budget, delayed and half-assed as usual.
- capableweb 5y agoIf we assume good faith in that piece of quote, I interpret it as "The system will be ready to start being implemented in member countries in about a year", not "All member countries will have implemented it 100% in about a year". With that lens the quote makes more sense, although it still seems a bit rushed.
- tumetab1 5y agoIt might be possible because there was previously work for that. In other words, there was already a try in the past to implement an authentication federation between all UE countries. Tried to use that in a Spanish government site but it was broken at the time but it already supported authentication from other UE countries.
- 0xy 5y agoThis will be used for surveillance, and most likely immediately hacked and sold off. The EU is absolutely incompetent when it comes to cybersecurity. Nearly every single one of their member governments have been pwned, including Germany, France and Belgium among others. These people can't even keep their own communications secure (Merkel's emails were hacked less than a year ago), why would they give a damn about your personal data?
- adriancr 5y agoIf you're worried about surveillance you should probably know governments already have your data right now... they issue your passports/ids/etc... This is to just allow you to sign in to other parties with your government ID if needed. (instead of other parties asking you for passport/ID for compliance/KYC)
- 0xy 5y agoInstead of needing to hack 3,000 companies to get the data of EU citizens, you now need to hack 1 central repository. And guess what? It's run by an incompetent bureaucracy with a history of security mismanagement.
- adriancr 5y agoThis is an SSO for ID purposes. (passport/national ID). Central repository won't store anything, the same as google SSO doesn't store your data if you sign in to third party sites. (it just authenticates you). Maybe this is what you are misunderstanding? Also, government already has your data, so that 1 central repository for IDs already exists. As for hacking... going after any one of those 3000 is less likely to get you in trouble then going after a government (as incompetent as they are). See oil pipeline hack to understand consequences.
- ultimape 5y agoThe article says > "The digital wallet will securely store payment details and passwords and allow citizens from all 27 countries to log onto local government websites or pay utility bills using a single recognised identity, the newspaper said, citing people with direct knowledge of the plans." Doesn't that directly imply that it is more than a simple SSO?
- tarsiec 5y agoThis is most likely bad news, unless privacy is the #0 priority
- hocuspocus 5y agoThe status quo in many countries implies sending scans of your ID to many administrations and service providers, which is way worse.
- fenk85 5y agoI think the recent attack against the Irish health services agency shows the need for something like this Once you have an EU wide digital identiy+authentication (with multifactor and biometrics and all that) You can then move onto implementing fine grained authorization for people to manage what data various government agencies get and can share They will probably create a system very similar to what Okta does which is great as it would save 27 countries reinventing the wheel, and one thing about security that is important is not to reinvent the wheel.
- vishnugupta 5y ago> The digital wallet will securely store payment details and passwords and allow citizens from all 27 countries to log onto local government websites or pay utility bills using a single recognised identity, the newspaper said, citing people with direct knowledge of the plans. Does it seems like solution in search of a problem? I'm sure there's a % of people who deal with multiple EU governments at a time or frequently move. But to me that seems like a tiny fraction. Would be good if they published some stats around this i.e., y% or x million would use this on a daily/monthly basis or some such. Would be a shame if such a mega undertaking would end up useful to a niche customer base.
- arc-in-space 5y agoTo "aim to enable EU citizens to study, live, shop, work and retire in any EU country" is an official goal of the European Union. If not many people are able to do this, then perhaps it has simply not yet succeeded.
- pimterry 5y ago> Would be good if they published some stats around this i.e., y% or x million would use this on a daily/monthly basis or some such. In 2019 1.4 million people migrated from one EU state to another [1], and 3.3% of EU working age citizens lived outside their country of citizenship (and that's rapidly rising - a 40% increase over the last 10 years) [2]. That's a baseline minimum of people who clearly need this. It doesn't count people who don't register because they only move temporarily (where it's not worth registering today because without such a system the paperwork can be a hassle!), it doesn't count migrants who now have citizenship in their destination country, it doesn't count the many non-working-age people who retire to southern europe, and it doesn't count people who interact with foreign EU governments for any reasons other than permanent residency. For example, you might want to securely access EU personal data while on holiday for health care (a digital EHIC), you might need to share your foreign driving license details with a car rental company, or your work may involve cross-EU business administration. This wallet won't be useful for everybody, but if it works well it would be a very valuable tool for many millions of people today, and likely many more in future. [1]: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=Migration_and_migrant_population_statistics https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php... (full article, first paragraph) [2]: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=EU_citizens_living_in_another_Member_State_-_statistical_overview https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php...
- ThalesX 5y agoI love the direction! Wouldn't it be amazing to have services exposed through secure APIs so that we can create a number of tools around the services, instead of using a single wallet?
- 19h 5y agoInteresting to see how this will turn out. In Germany IDs already have NFC chips so you can use them to authenticate against platforms via your phone. Using it all the time, from filing taxes to authenticating myself to my bank. You get a PIN via physical mail when you get a new ID and you're ready to go.
- capableweb 5y agoThat sounds great. Imagine if you could move to anywhere in the EU and continue using everything the same way, just have a country selector dropdown and everything works the same way.
- nicbou 5y agoThose IDs became accessible to Berlin's immigrants around a year ago. Even then, you only get it 2-4 months after your residence permit application, which might be 0-3 months after you land in Berlin.
- jopsen 5y agoSo much potential... it's hard to know what this becomes. I could imagine online service providers like a hosting provider etc. might start to integrate. After all this would have 2FA and be administered by an authority that can actually verify who I am when access needs to be recovered. Long term, maybe the EU could do a cheap micro payment system, one can dream :)
- heywherelogingo 5y agoSo much for the old saying "don't put all your eggs in one basket". What could go wrong?
- Proven 5y agoThere's no limit to the fake creativity of those idiots in order to justify their pathetic existence and more government spending.
- greatgib 5y agoIn term of features, it would be awesome. But in term of privacy and surveillance society, this will be a nightmare... Imagine, the dream for all eu gov and tax/police forces to have a mandatory unified controlled system for identification anywhere. From there, it will be more easier to go one step further in surveillance for average citizen. The thing is that currently, the multitude of not centralized, authenticated system allows to remain anonymous or quasi anonymous for a lot of things. But, once there will be an official guaranteed EU identity authentication system, everyone will want to use it. You are visiting a city, and you need to pay the parking fee? the EU SSO will have to be used, and states will be able to know where you were, at what time. You want to access a website that is required by law to do age verification? EU SSO has to be used and again, the state can monitor your internet browsing. You buy/sell a few things online, on peer to peer website like "leboncoin" or "ebay"? or do car sharing on "blablacar"? Mandatory EU SSO id has to be used, and so everything you do can be monitored.
- the-dude 5y agoWait until you become unwanted or fall through the cracks and your wallet is blocked.
- beebeepka 5y agoThat was my first thought as well. It could be a powerful weapon
- kasperni 5y agoAnd this is different for status quo in what way? In every EU country the government can go to a bank and freeze your account via a warrant.
- Aerroon 5y agoBut at least right now it won't block you from viewing websites as an example. If this becomes commonplace then most websites with accounts will do this kind of identity detection. Why wouldn't they? Think about it. If people's real identities are involved then they're less likely to be abusive, because everything tracks back to them. But it also means that websites like Facebook and pornhub might not let new users in without that kind of authentication.
- swiley 5y agoFacebook is going to love this.
- qnsi 5y agoto everyone saying "My country has something similar". Yes we do, thanks to EU eAIDAS regulation. This also explains how they can implement this in a year. Most of the countries (probably all) already have a lot of groundwork done
- ThomPete 5y agoThis sounds great but will be counterproductive to any progress EU wishes to have in digital technology. India have UPI and while that also on the surface sounds great it's filled with all sorts of wacky rules for implementation (on thing is that you have to show it prominently on the first page). The primary issues is that it will basically be competing with a lot of private companies and thus once again hinder the ability for many startups to get off the ground because they are in competition with the government. The never ending problem of the EU, they try to solve problems politically that the market is perfect for.
- amarant 5y agoSounds like it'll be similar to BankId[1] but for all of Europe instead of just Sweden. I like it! Hopefully someone will make swish[2] for the rest of Europe shortly afterwards! [1]https://www.bankid.com/en https://www.bankid.com/en [2]https://www.swish.nu/ https://www.swish.nu/
- madspindel 5y agohttps://empsa.org/ https://empsa.org/
- denton-scratch 5y agoUK resident here. I am a Brexit supporter; but I don't trust the UK civil service to build an ID system that is both secure and privacy-preserving. Based on past performance, they'd build a system that runs 10x over budget, and isn't secure. I'd want to see the details, but I'd be much more inclined to trust an EU ID system than a UK one.
- rgblambda 5y agoHaven't the UK delivered an ID system, Gov.UK Verify?
- denton-scratch 5y agoYes. I think you can still use it; but it was not wildly popular. The NHS is busy trying to sell all of our health data to companies like Google. Again. The NHS dataset is the most valuable and complete in the world - it's worth a lot of money, and it's unique. Unfortunately, NHS Digital haven't a clue how valuable - they sold a million records to the Society of Actuaries, for less than 4 grand. So I don't trust any app from the NHS to be nice with my data. I think the app will be withdrawn soon, because most people don't use it. Anyway, I simply don't carry a smartphone. I don't walk down the street, diddling away on my fondle-slab. I carry two vaccination cards in my wallet. There's nowhere I need to go that needs the NHS app.
- eplanit 5y ago"The digital wallet will securely store payment details and passwords and allow citizens from all 27 countries to log onto local government websites or pay utility bills using a single recognised identity" I find it amazing that anybody would think this is a good thing. Then again, I shouldn't be amazed. There are numerous examples of people eagerly trading privacy for [perceived] convenience.
- LunaSea 5y agoConsulting companies are already rubbing their hands and can't wait to produce garbage for a few hundred million.
- jFriedensreich 5y agoi just hope they let countries like estonia with actual experience in some e-government projects lead the development and not germany and france who ruin every piece of software they touch. but the scenario most likely is that we end up with yet another completely useless high digit multi million euro project.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ergot_vacation 5y agoAnd now we know where the recent full-court-press of anti-crypto propaganda has come from: governments want to shift everyone over to THEIR coin. One that's almost guaranteed to be even worse than Bitcoin (which is quite an accomplishment).