8 ms·
Why have cameras and lenses become so expensive?
- alephnan 5y agoSupply and demand. Everyone has a capable smart phone now. This removes the middle market for cameras, and only the pro/prosumer high end cameras which adds all sorts of bells and whistles.
- gruez 5y agoIsn't that more "economy of scale" than "supply and demand"? The latter only really works as an explanation when there's a supply/demand shock (ie. surge in demand or crash in supply).
- mc32 5y agoBut... shouldn't there a "thriving" market of used lenses as people have moved to phone camera only ditching the old D/SLRs? Or were most of the dedicated cameras point-and-shoot with a kit zoom lens?
- khuey 5y agoI don't think we've yet gotten to the point where everybody is unloading their old consumer-level DSLR equipment that they no longer use because their cell phone camera is almost as good. Give it another 5-10 years.
- kemayo 5y agoArticle doesn't present any data on that -- it ignores used prices entirely, discussing only what the manufacturer is charging. So, it's certainly possible!
- Kalium 5y agoI read it as implying that there are far fewer entrants into the market because people are using phones where they would previously have used mid-grade specialized equipment. The demand for mid-market equipment is drying up, but the high-end demand for professional equipment isn't.
- mc32 5y agoI see. I think that makes sense. As the EOS "Rebel" market is replaced by phone cameras, the pros still need their equipment which tend to be the higher end equipment which would drive up the median price. I just looked at the Sony site and the 70/80-200, 200-400, prime 2.8s, etc., look to be in the normal range.
- mark-r 5y agoNote that much of the demand for professional equipment isn't coming from actual professionals, just from ambitious amateurs who want good stuff.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- perardi 5y agoThat’s an interesting point, so I went and checked briefly on what used Canon lenses are going for, at an online dealer that specializes in such things. https://www.keh.com/shop/lenses/canon--canon-eos.html https://www.keh.com/shop/lenses/canon--canon-eos.html And whoa. None of that is cheap. So, my guess? It’s as you said: a lot of the market was APS-C cameras, like Canon Rebels or Nikon D3xxx. And those were overwhelmingly paired with the 18–55mm kit lenses, and then with either a 70–300, or perhaps an 18–250-ish superzoom. Most DSLRs were effectively welded to the lens that came in the box.
- dmingod666 5y agoYou have to factor in the additional people making YouTube content buying camera equipment.
- kemayo 5y agoNot sure precisely where you draw the prosumer line, but the article is also comparing the prices on the same models of pro camera over time and still seeing an upwards trend. I'd suspect this means that smartphones eating the middle-tier of cameras has had a spillover effect to also hurt the pro/prosumer market. I'd speculate that although even a cheap DSLR is still better than a good smartphone camera, the phones are good enough that the upgrade (and hassle) doesn't appeal to most people. Thus the high end market shrinks despite not being competed with on its own terms.
- Aeolun 5y agoI can confirm that with phone cameras (especially iPhone) where they are now, I feel no need to bring my 8 year old DSLR anywhere any more.
- eloff 5y agoHonestly the weight doesn't appeal to me. I own a lovely DSLR, but I don't take it anywhere because I don't like lugging it around. The smartphone serves most of my needs in a camera. Yeah the photos aren't as good, but they're good enough.
- sdenton4 5y agoI wouldn't be shocked if the wide bottom of the demand pyramid was doing a lot of work to support the tiny, pointy top... Economies of scale on lens and body production. For example, with lenses, you can produce a thousand lenses with somewhat random quality, sell the best ones to the pro market, and then sell the not quite as good ones to the cheaper end of the market. When you take out there low end market, you then need to either produce more consistent high end lenses, or raise prices since the low end market isn't there to buy the lower quality outputs.
- underwater 5y agoThat's not what supply and demand is. Supply and demand would insinuate that there are less cameras available in the market, or more people are buying them.
- dboreham 5y agoLower volume, higher unit price. Also cameras and lenses are (generally) much much better than they used to be. Perhaps people are willing to pay more for a better thing.
- seoaeu 5y agoYeah, hard to justify buying a low end camera when your phone has a better one built in
- perardi 5y agoYour phone camera is not as good as a cheap DSLR paired with a cheap 35mm f/1.8 in absolute terms. Your phone camera is way better at the job to be done, which is to quickly share pics of your cock, cats, or kids, depending on what age bracket you are in. Traditional cameras, in which I include mirrorless, are still terrrrible when it comes to quickly bouncing a photo to Instagram, and arguably even worse when it comes to quickly making a video for TikTok.
- lumost 5y agoEntry level DSLRs are roughly the same price as a low-end smartphone. For many, simply switching from a low-end smartphone to a high end phone will produce better results. In particular the software assistance for capturing dynamic range and shooting in odd lighting conditions on an iPhone is pretty spectacular. Replicating the point and shoot experience requires a pretty substantial amount of skill on a traditional DSLR.
- boulos 5y ago> cheap DSLR paired with a cheap 35mm f/1.8 in absolute terms. I think this depends on the shot. The Pixel 4 easily beats “cheap DSLR” in several settings, particularly low light. I know folks who have an iPhone as a phone and a Pixel as a camera :). It’s true that it’s also much better at “photo production” (capture => minor edit => post), but I think you can find examples where the photo itself is strictly better.
- chunkyks 5y agoMy new cellphone literally has a Hasselblad camera on it. I get all the things that make better cameras better, but I already have stupidly high end living in my pocket. It's not like that company would put their brand on anything crap. So, it's really basic economics. The middle of the market is getting eating by what used to be the bottom. So all that's left is the top
- towergratis 5y ago> My new cellphone literally has a Hasselblad camera on it Sorry to bust your bubble, but no, your phone doesn't have a Hasselblad camera on it. It has a lens that Hasselblad worked on, together with the vendor. Which in itself tells more about brand dilution, and the market loss of cameras to phones, than the quality of your phone's camera.
- perardi 5y agoAnd how long has it been since Hasselblad has been particularly relevant? They were sliced into pieces, and now they are owned by DJI. https://www.slrlounge.com/dji-now-majority-shareholder-of-hasselblad-what-does-that-mean/ https://www.slrlounge.com/dji-now-majority-shareholder-of-ha...
- zmk_ 5y agoIt might be even worse, if I recall correctly, Hasselblad might be only responsible for the color science.
- jacquesm 5y ago> It's not like that company would put their brand on anything crap. No, but that company no longer exists and the owners of the brand really have no problem selling the name for use on crap. You simply bought into that myth. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hasselblad#Fuji,_Shriro,_Imacon,_and_the_digital_age https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hasselblad#Fuji,_Shriro,_Imaco...
- chunkyks 5y ago
- epx 5y agoSome niche markets are irrationally expensive e.g. bicycles.
- tachyonbeam 5y agoI was shocked when I started shopping for an electric bike, to see that in my city, there are multiple bike shops selling e-bikes from 5K to 15K a piece. I'm surprised that these businesses can all survive, because the median income before taxes here is about ~62K. I mean who's actually buying this? But I guess if you're selling 15K bikes, you only need to sell about two a month to pay the bills.
- andromeduck 5y agoI used to hear it described as the rich white people sport.
- mc32 5y ago15K is decent motorcycle, very low end car territory already. That's exorbitant.
- defterGoose 5y agoHeck no, you can get very reliable used cars for $5k. 15k gets you into a reasonably well used BMW (not that thats a sweet spot of value or anything.)
- hellbannedguy 5y agoThey are all over Marin County, CA. And I'm jealous. I wish I had a high end electric bike, but my patched together Zapp bike is kinda ok for now. If I was younger, with money, and connections; I would be all over manufacturing electric bikes. These high end bikes are basically motorcycles. They look fun, and practical. Right now they are not regulated, and I hope it stays that way. They have given out of shape, or disabled, people a way to get out in nature. I do see a lot on Craigslist though. I have a feeling, my wealthy neighbors buy them, but were never bicyclists to begin with. The minute I see one at my price point ($500 used), I'm buying one. Oh yea, cops in my county have become revenue collectors. They harass anyone out after 10 pm. They pull over people at random for no reason. I think they assume everyone drinks like they do? They seem to be leaving electric bicycles alone--for now? My dad bought his first Zapp bike because he was tired of being pulled over in the Richmond District in San Francisco, by cops looking for an marginal DUI. The Zapp bike made his life less stressful. The price point of the nicer bikes needs to come down though. Even if I had 5-15 grand that I could blow, theft is still a concern.
- jurassic 5y agoI'm a prosumer hobbyist with a Nikon D850 and a handful of expensive lenses that I enjoy, but I'm not sure I would buy them again. I love the experience of shooting with them and loath the experience of getting my images off the device and onto a computer or phone. It creates a film-like experience where by the time I get around to processing images I've often forgotten what I've shot. What I really want is an iPhone software experience paired with the physical ergonomics of a specialized device like a DSLR/mirrorless camera. Whoever can deliver that will get a lot of money from me. I want real connectivity built into the device made an integral part of the experience, not what you have today which is usually some half-baked thing where you have to attempt numerous times to pair over bluetooth with the unpolished companion iPhone app.
- perardi 5y agoPreach it. Shooting on an interchangeable lens camera is still effectively like shooting a film camera. They do have software to pair to your phone. I am most familiar with Fuji’s solution for that, which is, to put it charitably, execrable. It is painfully slow and glitchy. (I’ve heard better things about Nikon’s latest, but I haven’t used it.) Thing is: I think that would require a partnership with Apple or Google, or perhaps Samsung. I think you’d need a lower-level API for very quick pairing and a smart handoff to a low-power mode that doesn’t suck your camera battery dry over the course of about 4 hours.
- etrautmann 5y agoI recently bought a sony a7r IV, expecting the phone integration to be much better than my 5 year old Fuji X-T2, and both are unbelievably slow and painful to connect and download photos. It's such an outdated and bad experience, and the apps are glitchy and connections fail the first 2-3 times.
- jacobjuul 5y agowhat I do is have an SD card reader for my phone and ipad. It's miles better (of course) than all the different connectivity apps that the camera brands offer.
- 5y ago
- syntheno 5y agoI own a zeiss 55mm e-mount lens and it is absolutely incredible. Never fails to blow people’s minds with its sharpness and depth of field. No comparison with smartphone lenses and easily worth the money. I cherish many photos and moments with that lens. Also, a side note: one of the biggest advantages of a larger sensor like those used in full frame and medium format cameras is the ability to crop in post. Its really about treating photography as an artform - composition matters.
- rich_sasha 5y agoOne point of interest is that Nikon and Canon, the giants of DSLRs, were very resistant to do mirrorless, even as Sony, Fuji and Olympus went down that way. They are now going into mirrorless big time. Part of it I guess is that the technology got better, but also oh what an excuse to sell everyone their lenses again! You can use adapters on older lenses, but usually with some (minor) loss of optical quality, and more clunkiness - bit like with dongles I guess! Old DSLR lines are also being phased out, making sure all the pros move sooner or later. What the article doesn’t mention in full is that there are now new independent makers of lenses. These are often (not always) inferior optically, often don’t have autofocus etc but are much more affordable than branded equivalents. Interestingly, even there you find they evolve out of cheap and cheerful to quality for a price! Samyang comes to mind first and foremost.