9 ms·
What's your idea of "survival"? Wikipedia has already been bleeding editors for a long time as the overall climate on the Web has shifted away from openness an
by zozbot234 5y ago
What's your idea of "survival"? Wikipedia has already been bleeding editors for a long time as the overall climate on the Web has shifted away from openness and towards profit-seeking and mindless consumption. They portray themselves as "essential infrastructure in the ecosystem of free knowledge" which looks like a factual and fair assessment to me. This is what must survive for the foreseeable future. It's not just about hosting a bunch of articles.
- neolog 5y ago> Wikipedia has already been bleeding editors for a long time Where can I learn about this?
- bawolff 5y agoA lot of fuss has been made about this graph: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Editor_Retention_Update.png https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Editor_Retention_Upd... Roughly, English Wikipedia hit its editor peak around 2007 and has been very slowly declining since then. Various people argue about various causes. Theories I've heard include wikipedia becoming too rule heavy, to community just not scaling past that point, to the internet being a lot more interesting now then it was in 2007 so more distractions, community being mean/troll-filled now, everyone using mobile phones which are crap for writing long form content, all the easy to write articles are written, etc (Probably missed some).
- gspr 5y agoCan't it just be that since 2007 most of the obvious topics for an encyclopedia to cover have been covered? It's probably less satisfying to change the wording in one sentence in an article about an Australian cheese than it is to write that article. So fewer people care.
- zozbot234 5y agoYes, the standards for what counts as "good" Wikipedia editing have gotten a lot higher as well, at least wrt. mainstream topics.
- watwut 5y agoNo it is not. Some areas are perfectly describes, others basically empty. I remember dabbing into sewing a while ago and finding out wiki is basically empty.
- throwaway2037 5y agoYes, I also notice the coverage dedicated to women vs men is extremely imbalanced. I know they have a separate team working on the issue and big advert banners about it... but the issue remains: Much more is written about men (living or dead) than women.
- pfranz 5y agoThis was brought up as a major issue about 10 years ago: https://slate.com/technology/2012/07/kate-middleton-s-wedding-gown-and-wikipedia-s-gender-gap.html https://slate.com/technology/2012/07/kate-middleton-s-weddin...
- exporectomy 5y agoAren't there far more prominent men than women though? Especially when you count the whole of patriarchal history.
- zozbot234 5y agoHistory is always written by the victors, and due to patriarchy most of the victors in recorded history have been men. This has consequences if you want your encyclopedia to rely on existing sources.
- throwaway2037 5y agoI cannot personally agree with the first sentence from a modern context, but the second sentence is reasonable. I'm most bothered with I see articles about important ministers of a country and the women have either just a stub or a few measly paragraphs, and the men have flowing pages. I see the same for business leaders.
- 5y ago
- mavhc 5y agoThe barrier to entry is often that more articles exist now, it's likely the random thing you know enough about to start an article about already has one. Having 10% of new editors stick around seems amazingly high. Has anyone done the same for post 2015?
- trothamel 5y agoThat's not completely true, as it seems like the number of editors on English wikipedia hit a low point around 2013 and has been steady or going up since then. https://stats.wikimedia.org/#/en.wikipedia.org/contributing/active-editors/normal|line|all|(page_type)~content*non-content|monthly https://stats.wikimedia.org/#/en.wikipedia.org/contributing/...
- belorn 5y agoOne of the major argument I have seen why the retention graph has gone down is that English Wikipedia is much more complete in 2021 than 2007. Writing about esoteric topics is by itself limiting to fewer editors, and the bar of notability is more restrictive. Non-English articles is easier in that sense, but much of that work seems to become a translation of the English version. Writing a non-English article from scratch is an alternative but can feel a bit less interesting when the English version is already of high quality. I could be wrong but today it seems that most editor efforts in the English Wikipedia goes towards news, politics and media. It would not surprise me if those have a natural lower retention rate than other form of articles.
- strogonoff 5y agoOn one hand, Wikipedia has become more “complete” in the last 10 years (though information never is, really). On the other hand, the grown amount of content means there is proportionately more content to maintain—which might take even more effort and attention to detail than writing new content. That, as well as the reputation and pervasiveness of links to Wikipedia, together make it more vulnerable to and a more compelling target for instances of blatant or stealthy misinformation, censorship and vandalism. On that topic, I suspect a resource that tracks change histories for sensitive Wikipedia articles[0], aggregating and correlating changes by IPs and usernames along with some smart NLP analysis on text contents of the diffs, could end up being insightful. [0] Many of us know a certain date coming up, publicly remembering which starting this year is already punishable by a prison sentence in Hong Kong. Maintaining the article covering this one is hopefully taken care of for now as it is pretty conspicuous—but for how long, and how many lesser known articles are there…
- usrusr 5y agoBeing disgruntled about supporting a donations scam might be another reason to leave.
- thomasahle 5y ago> Wikipedia hit its editor peak around 2007 It's a very sharp peak. What happened in 2007?
- exporectomy 5y agono-follow was added to links in Jan 2007. I wonder if the drop was a drop in spam editors when SEO stopped working.
- thomasahle 5y agoI didn't know they did that. Sounds like a great decision!
- j-pb 5y agoThen let those projects fight and advertise for themselves. People donating to wikipedia only want wikipedia, they are unaware of the other stuff wikimedia does. Those projects would crash and burn though, because frankly, no one cares about them. Stuff like wikidata and SPARQL endpoints are an academic curiosity with no real value. The semantic web won't happen, articles do and will. In addition to that, the whole deletion first and no primary information attitude makes sentences like "ecosystem of free knowledge" laughable.
- kqr 5y agoEvery long-term successful operation needs to sustain a few wild bets that look pointless today, with great probability will turn out to have been pointless tomorrow, but has just a tiny chance of becoming really important. If you just optimise for today, you will die tomorrow. Gradual improvements won't get you out of a local peak when that local peak is swallowed by rising tides. If your organisation isn't doing things that look pointless today but in a principled way, I don't think it has great prospects of long-term survival. Heck, even the wiki concept itself started out as this long-shot experiment nobody at the time expected to be successful.
- j-pb 5y agoWikipedia exploded over night. The semantic web is "tomorrow technology" for 20 years now. At what point does tomorrow technology become yesterdays vaporware to you?
- zozbot234 5y agoWikidata gets more edits per second right now than the English wikipedia does. If that's not "exploding overnight", I don't know what is. It's just that fewer people are aware of it, because it powers sily things like search engine infoboxes and AI assistants - in addition to fostering unprecedented cooperation among knowledge producers in the Linked Data/Semantic Web ecosystem.
- 5y ago
- EdwardDiego 5y agoI do wonder what role Wikipolitics plays in the editor bleed.
- coldacid 5y agoIt's a huge part of what made ME give up on the whole thing.
- onurcel 5y agothen why they don't beg for editors? they also have enough cash to develop a more appealing editor experience, but all they are asking is money.
- zozbot234 5y ago> then why they don't beg for editors? They do, particularly in educational contexts - getting students interested in Wiki projects and having them write review articles with good sources as "homework" that can then be posted to Wikipedia. But supporting that takes money as well!
- denton-scratch 5y agoFixing student's homework projects is actually a burden on other more-experienced editors.
- xenator 5y agoVery solid point. I personally don't trust Wikipedia articles in many subjects. There are many proofs that Russian Wikipedia have paid by government editors solving its own propaganda. I think +/- the same situation for other countries. Also, I know companies or celebrities who pay for their Wikipedia pages. You can find this service in 5 minutes by googling. "Profit-seeking and mindless consumption" can be a motto for the current WMF.
- mschuster91 5y ago> I personally don't trust Wikipedia articles in many subjects. For the smaller ones, that is warranted - for example, the Croatian Wikipedia is infamous for its bias towards nationalist positions (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Croatian_Wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Croatian_Wikipedia), something that's only made worse by the aftermath of the Balkan wars decades ago... as a half-Croat myself, I can only say: let's keep it at "the situation is complex and sucks all around, Wikipedia is just one symptom of a much deeper problem". For bigger projects such as English and German Wikipedia, sheer numbers make outright disinformation spreading much more difficult - there the problem is different: what you see is usually factually correct and neutral-ish, but there is a widespread consensus that Wikipedia editors skew towards white, male and somewhat privileged (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia#Coverage_of_topics_and_systemic_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia#Coverage_of_topics_a...). Personally, I trust scientific and pop culture related articles in most if not all versions of Wikipedia - but keep a healthy skepticism for everything political, since there it is the hardest to judge completeness and accuracy of any subject.
- denton-scratch 5y agoAny article on the Middle East, in particular, is unreliable. Zionist gatekeepers are on constant patrol.
- KingOfCoders 5y agoWikipedia is bleeding editors and keeping others away because of the ever more hostile environment. Try to edit something and you get blasted of Wikipeda very fast with a boatload of jargon. This is something they should work on. But as every club that get successful and was open (I attended many Wiki/Wikipedia meetups 20y ago) it gets more restricted and close to keep the masses out. What a shame.
- zozbot234 5y ago> Try to edit something and you get blasted of Wikipeda very fast with a boatload of jargon. "Trying to edit something" is a bad idea these days - the content is far too developed for that. Instead, post on the talk page with a description of your suggested edit, wait for people to object/complain/discuss, refine the text on talk if needed, then edit. It's pretty indistinguishable from a "pull request" workflow on github. Yes, I know that a lot of novice-focused content advises people to edit directly. That's fine for fixing typos and bad grammer, not for substantive work.
- KingOfCoders 5y agoQED.
- xvector 5y agoI do not see why it needs to be easier than making a PR. What would you propose?
- KingOfCoders 5y agoBecause the easier it is the the more people are involved. That was the original idea of the WikiWay, to make editing simple [1] Second if this is the way to go - and I don't agree [2] - the UI should reflect this workflow and not propose a different one that mostly fails. [Edit] PRs also assume some kind of owner and committer relationship, which might be right for open source projects but is not the case of Wikipedia - even if many editors on Wikipedia consider the content "their own". [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WikiWikiWeb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WikiWikiWeb - "Cunningham's idea was to make WikiWikiWeb's pages quickly editable by its users, [...] . The usefulness of Wiki is in the freedom, simplicity, and power it offers." [2] Wrote a quite successfull wiki 20y ago called SnipSnap, the engine of which started Atlassian Confluence, and did several years of research in using Wikis back then.
- isaacremuant 5y agoThey bleed editors because they keep censoring and shunning people for not having the same monolithical point of views with regards to politics and social issues. Money won't change that.
- frzj 5y agoWhat bias are you talking about? I thought Jimbo was an Rand Fanboy, freedom of speech is their religion.
- codeecan 5y agoIn the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Floyd https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Floyd article, they mention an event where he "held a pistol to a woman's stomach", but leave out that she was pregnant so it doesn't look as bad. Example 2, there was two mass shooting in March: - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Boulder_shooting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Boulder_shooting - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Atlanta_spa_shootings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Atlanta_spa_shootings In the Boulder shooting, all victims where white and the shooter was targeting white people but they don't mention any of that. In the Atlanta shootings, the article goes out of its way to mention 6 of 8 victims where asian (asian-hate narrative). In reality, many spa owners are asian. Theres is definitely a bias in their editing.
- middleclick 5y agoThe George Floyd thing is not mentioned because it's not true: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2020/07/15/fact-check-viral-photo-doesnt-show-george-floyd-assault-victim/5415937002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2020/07/15/fac...
- codeecan 5y agoyes, I was misinformed, the report says there was a young child at home, but NOT that she was pregnant. The child being there is not mentioned in the wiki, my original point was wrong, but I think the bias still stands.