12 ms·
Danish whistleblower details NSA collaboration, cable and data center spying (2020)
- slater 5y ago(2020)
- Ninn 5y agoThe reporting with the new information about the case, nor the whistelblower outing is from 2020. See the timeline in the end of the following danish article: https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/indland/blev-udsat-amerikansk-spionage-danmark-en-skandale https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/indland/blev-udsat-amerikansk-spio...
- vesinisa 5y agoBut this specific article is dated in November 2020.
- filipncs 5y agoA lot of new information was released today in a collaboration between danish, swedish, german and french media. Sadly, I haven’t found a good english language article yet.
- filipncs 5y agoAh, there’s already a bbc article on the front page: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27338555 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27338555
- robert_foss 5y agoApparently it is related to Denmark being a Nato member. And was targeting politicians in Sweden, which is a non-Nato member.
- nguyenkien 5y agoThey target also include NATO members: "France, Germany, the Netherlands, Norway"
- legulere 5y agoAlso Denmark itself and the US. Intelligence Agencies are simply out of control and a threat to democracy.
- powerapple 5y agoLuckily Danish didn't have Huawei equipments, otherwise it wouldn't be possible. Tell me one reason Chinese is building a first world class technology company just to be found out for spying on customers and doomed to be out of business.
- robrorcroptrer 5y agoAre you a Chinese agent?
- MsMowz 5y agoThey're making a comment on the HN/general paranoia around Huawei in the face of the actual privacy concerns regarding the US government. Does someone need to be a Chinese agent to find this paranoid behavior objectionable?
- throwaway4good 5y agoIt is also a specific comment. The us intelligence service probably does not have as good relations to Huawei as it has to Ericsson. The original Huawei response to allegations was to open themselves up to external audits and encourage other suppliers to do the same. Of course that didn’t help them. Huawei today is banned from providing network services in denmark.
- kasey_junk 5y agoThis particular whistle blower is not alleging that the NSA or any US controlled entity compromised Ericsson equipment, rather that the US and Danish intelligence agencies collaborated but that collaboration ended up being used against Danish interests. That’s orthogonal to whether using Huawei equipment is also against Danish interests.
- xwolfi 5y agoBut clearly it's never the equipment that's a problem (who seriously believes this can't be observed or worked around with simple isolation/reverse engineering/relocation of factory/firewalling?) but the elected officials collaborating with the americans. When your telco buys Huawei, it's not to give an entry door to Chinese security services. It's because it's the best at that price point. If they can explain exactly how Huawei is supposed to backdoor their commercial partners, then fine. Ironically I have a Huawei phone, without Google services, and after the initial withdrawal phase that was painful, I now feel better knowing Google isn't tracking me and maybe Huawei is. The simple fact is my government would never willingly give them the keys, while they do with little hesitation when the fat burgers come and ask.
- moksly 5y agoI’m Danish and this is a big scandal, but the reality is, when the US asks you dance like the vassal state you are. We really shouldn’t have bought those f-35 planes either. They were more expensive, as in a gazillion times more expensive. The delivery schedule was already falling at the time. They were already terrible planes at the time compared to their competition. Most hilarious of all, they don’t actually fit into our small country because they are loud, so the government is still buying up properties in areas that they’ll have to fly over because the noise levels are so illegal they have to let people move away. They are also struggling with what to do with the airspace in one of our Airports, because the only two routes these planes have around it is over the ocean (fine but typically avoided during rain because of the low altitude they fly to avoid the airport) and our second largest city, ooops. Somehow it still won, to no ones surprise. And that’s really just how it is. The US wants bases in Greenland? Well, it’s technically not really Danish territory but we’ll make an exception and to full colonial masters. The US wants a radar thing in one of our commercial airports? Sure! (Since moved to another part of Europe). The us wants access to data on Moslem citizens? sure thing! The US wants direct access to the internet infrastructure? Well why not! I think the only thing we’ve ever really said no to was nuclear missiles.
- systemvoltage 5y agoRespectfully, this sounds like rant (without much substance) and a lot of arm chair military hoo haa. I’ll tell you how this is going to go - HN will vote it to the top just like those discussions about Taiwan invasions. Juicy? Yes, pretty fun. Completely detached from the reality? I wonder what people who are familiar with the matter think. Gellman’s amnesia much! Inevitably it will get into a heated discussion with rocks thrown from a multiple sides, some China whataboutism and voila - you’ve got a bog standard classic flame war. Sigh. Let’s talk about data collection and NSA, please. Not F-35s and nuclear weapons.
- a0-prw 5y agoIt's not rant. It's justified indignation. We should definitely not have bought those F-35 pieces of shit. I've been saying for years that our politicians are traitors, and yes our military intelligence has aided and abetted a foreign power in spying against Danish interests. Traitors.
- ExcavateGrandMa 5y agoI'm french and yes, I can tell you that depending how rational & clever you are; It gonna takes you only few minutes to understand how things are... keep calm & try profit your life...
- quyleanh 5y agoI think US is very good at taking advantage of Europe's dissidence. US and Europe are ally but US doesn't want Europe's countries unite, maybe they are scare when Europe becomes stronger.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoIt's standard divide and conquer strategy. The US are much bigger in every way than any European country. That suits them and ensures the US' dominance.
- torh 5y agoQuestion: Is anyone really surprised about this? It's not the first time. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/jul/08/nsa-tapped-german-chancellery-decades-wikileaks-claims-merkel https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/jul/08/nsa-tapped-g... (2015) and Sweden also knows how to play this game http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/7463333.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/7463333.stm (2008)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]