8 ms·
Human rights were not an issue as long as China provided cheap labour and lax environmental laws. Now China is outgrowing its status as a cheap manufacturing an
by croes 5y ago
Human rights were not an issue as long as China provided cheap labour and lax environmental laws.
Now China is outgrowing its status as a cheap manufacturing and copying country and then they are an issue again.
As with oil-producing countries, as long as they supply oil, it doesn't matter if they are dictatorships, as soon as they don't supply any, they need democracy.
- moksly 5y agoThe real issue isn’t the size of China or its financial power housing, it’s that it’s market isn’t open. If it was you’d see all the western oligarchs abandoning us in favour for better markets in a heartbeat.
- oblio 5y agoThat wasn't a problem until China started moving up the economic food chain.
- AzzieElbab 5y agoOf course it was. It is a completely different issue now after it became clear that China will not open its markets, and went openly adversarial
- oblio 5y agoIt was a minor issue at the time and the second part should have been obvious to any half decent intelligence agency. Greed.
- FooBarWidget 5y agoChina "will not open its markets", yet foreign direct investments in 2020 were at an all time high. There are serious problems with the narrative that "China will not open its markets".
- moksly 5y agoThe money people still think they can change China. Maybe it’ll turn out they were right, maybe not. I think it fits rather perfectly into a narrative with 30 years of western investments into China with the expectancy of it opening up more. The money men are just rustling their swords because it’s not happening fast enough, maybe some are even beginning to worry a little about the past year of not being capable of exploiting their insanely long supply lines, but it’s probably mostly just impatience still. Either way it’s not like they won’t do anything to keep making what money they can at the same time.
- FooBarWidget 5y agoHow does that make sense? How do you surge foreign direct investments to record highs when markets are not open? Your statement is also based on a false premise. Companies don't invest in China to change China. They invest in China to make a profit. And making a profit, they did and they do. Wanting to change China is, ironically, something which mostly non-businesspeople want. Which makes the narrative that "we're being hostile to China because they don't open up markets" all the more insane. China has opened up. Walk down the street in China for 10 minutes and you see a ton of foreign companies. There are so much more foreign companies in China now than 30 years ago that the entire statement "China hasn't opened up" makes absolutely no sense. Not everything is open, sure, but that's still a far cry from "China hasn't opened up". China is also continuing to open up more parts of the markets. This comment here is on point: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27333819 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27333819 The fact is, even if China isn't opening up as quickly or as much as you like, the trade agreement with China was never based on symmetry in the first place. It wasn't the goal, and more importantly, symmetry isn't needed for both parties to get what they want. Both parties did get what they want. What the US now wants has changed. It's entirely possible to renegotiate and get what you want, without devolving into useless, illogical and dishonest aggression rherotic. This whole cold war is entirely unnecessary, but I guess people care more about making up an enemy and being able to moral grandstand, than to address actual issues.
- chii 5y agoThe problem was that during the Clinton administration, it was assumed that China would become more "democratic" and open politically, as their economic advancement progressed. It was assumed that their people would slowly change the CCP as they became wealthier - turning them more and more western. Unfortunately, that did not come to pass - their capitalism under authoritarianism is working (not to mention that CCP is trying hard to prove that their style of gov't is "better", and the trump administration, and the west's handling of covid aren't helping). There's no real way to contain china. The only way is to let the future play out - the biggest problem china has is the demographics. Provided there is no war between the west and china, their inevitable rise cannot be denied. This, of course, is known to CCP, and hence, why they are able to take hong kong, and increase their activities in the south china sea.
- simion314 5y ago>The problem was that during the Clinton administration, it was assumed that China would become more "democratic" and open politically, as their economic advancement progressed. It was assumed that their people would slowly change the CCP as they became wealthier - turning them more and more western And what is the plan/assumption for Saudi Arabia? Is there an assumption that they will soon start respecting human rights?
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoThe assumption is that the world will move on to EVs soon enough and we can wash our hands of the KSA completely.
- simion314 5y agoAnd what about human rights and who what if when oil runs out some extremists ideas will popup ? When things go bad the people will try to find someone to blame and there might be a risk that extremist ideas will grow.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago
- aritmo 5y agoThat is the sad truth. All the talk about democracy, open markets, are just a ruse. There is a real economic war against China and we play dirty against them.
- ceilingcorner 5y agoBecause China has played so cleanly with the West? Please. The West is only returning the favor.
- croes 5y agoYou mean China just returned the favor. China is very resentful about what happened to them especially in the Opium wars.
- ceilingcorner 5y agoThat was nearly two hundred years ago. It’s resented because the government finds it useful for building internal unity. Periodically stirring hate against foreigners is a tactic as old as time. It’s a bit like America being mad at Britain for burning down the White House in 1812. At some point you need to get over it.
- beaunative 5y agoOnly that the Opium Wars was just the beginning, the whole series of events lasted until the end of WWII before people can have any sort of peace, not the case for Britains burning White House
- ceilingcorner 5y agoAnd the US caused the Chinese Civil War? I don’t think so. The US also supported China against Japan during WW2. Apparently that doesn’t matter. https://www.britannica.com/place/China/U-S-aid-to-China https://www.britannica.com/place/China/U-S-aid-to-China
- vagrantJin 5y agoI think you've summed up geopolitics of the last few decades quite aptly. The whole "they need democracy" and suddenly farmers have an absurd amount of AK47s - and talks of a coup - should not fool anyone really. But it does fool most people. Especially folks in "western industrial countries" whom one would think would see such a ruse. But alas, who cares as long as we have netflix and iphones. Such is life. Such is dignity.
- ChemSpider 5y agoThis is only half correct. Until Mr. Xi came to power, China was getting wealthier and (somewhat) more open. Since ~2010 China is becoming more closed and more aggressive. See for example Xinjiang, Hongkong and Taiwan. 1938's Germany was also much worse than 1934's Germany. So it is no point of saying, well, you did not complain about Hitler in 1934, so no right to complain about him in 1938. Another geek datapoint: I travel to China often, and every year it gets harder and harder to access outside websites (yes, even with proxies).
- truth_ 5y agoYes. Deng was more concerned about growing silently. He cared about his people, and did not want to draw too much attention to China. I knew Xi was a textbook dictator when I heard about him banning Winnie The Pooh in Chinese internet [0]. [0]: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/aug/07/china-bans-winnie-the-pooh-film-to-stop-comparisons-to-president-xi https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/aug/07/china-bans-win...
- lucian1900 5y agoThat didn’t happen though. Even today you can find Winnie the Pooh memes on Chinese social media. Most Chinese people think they’re racist and uninteresting, but that’s a different matter.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoI don’t think the Pooh censorship was Xi’s doing, and the apparatus would have done some similar proactive censoring for the previous president as well. Xi crossed into dictator territory when he was able to declare himself president for life. Otherwise, we’d be talking about his successor by now.
- xtian 5y agoXi never declared himself president for life, the National People's Congress simply passed a law removing term limits. Angela Merkel has been chancellor of Germany for twice as long as Xi has been president of China.
- dominotw 5y agoThats a super cynical take. I would say what you said is def is a part of it but society now is more aware of these issues and more willing to take these on. Intially i think the expectation was that china would westernize and adopt our rulesets gradually but thats hasn't come to fruition.
- lordgroff 5y agoWhy is Chinese repression so much more interesting than Saudi repression? We focus on the sins, both real and perceived, of our enemies; the United States and more generally the Democratic West has zero issue with allying itself with all manner of brutal dictatorships, as long as they do our bidding. I don't think this is a cynical take, but frankly a matter of public record, and ignoring it is to fall for our own propaganda.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoSaudi repression is super interesting, and I think we should talk more about it. MBS got off way too easily on his assignation of a journalist, and that the USA continues to ally themselves with him is despicable. Incidentally, we should be talking more about Turkey now, they aren’t going in a good direction, or even some of the crazy things happening in India right now. And of course, Myanmar has gone to heck recently. China is a country on the cusp of development, they have the chance to go in the liberal society direction and it’s so sad to see them backsliding. That and their size is why they get the most attention, but because they are by any means the worst.
- zaphirplane 5y agoI’ll take your what about and raise you. Why didn’t the EU sanction the US for Guantanamo bay and Extraordinary rendition aka kidnapping Or the fabricated WMD story make Blair and bush war criminals FWIW I don’t think 2 wrongs make a right but also to take the moral high ground a group must have the moral high ground consistently
- alisonatwork 5y agoChina is interesting because over 15% of the entire world's population lives there. China is interesting because it has the second largest GDP in the world. China is interesting because it has the largest military in the world. The government that runs China may not be especially worse than any other authoritarian government in the world. But because China is a world leader, they rightfully attract the attention of the rest of the world, just like America has for decades and other great powers did before it. I get the sense that the Chinese government wants to have its cake and eat it too - it wants to run the most powerful country in the world, but it does not want to accept the criticism that comes with that position.