16 ms·
Charter charges more money for slower Internet on streets with no competition
- jacob019 5y agoUnacceptable. Would you accept paying more than your neighbor for water or power? Why do we not regulate internet like water or power?
- nashashmi 5y agoI think we regulate them like telcos. Verizon is supposed to provide everyone fios in my neighborhood but our dead end street is underground working. I don’t get fios but the cable company thinks we do and keep offering great rates. I don’t dare tell them that we don’t get fios.
- geocrasher 5y agoI wish I could be surprised or shocked at this. But my first reaction, just at reading the headline was "Of course they do." I may not ever use (or need to use) Starlink, but I hope it levels the playing field by providing competition where there currently is none.
- davio 5y agoIt will be interesting to see how the mobile based options drive competition. I think T-Mobile and Verizon are available in the $50-60 range at my house. At some point AT&T will have gigabit so I'll have 5 options with Starlink in beta.
- pgrote 5y ago> I think T-Mobile and Verizon are available in the $50-60 range 5G is unavailable in my area, so I haven't been able to see plans. Are there data limits? Throttling after a certain amount?
- toomuchtodo 5y agoNo limits on T-Mobile Home Broadband. In areas without 5G, the device uses LTE and still delivers reasonable speeds.
- WarOnPrivacy 5y ago> It will be interesting to see how the mobile based options drive competition. I've been watching market prices for ages, spent years as a broadband reseller. I've yet to see (or read about) an instance where wireline operators considered mobile data to be meaningful competition.
- ctdonath 5y agoWell, only now is long-range wireless becoming a viable competitor. Kodak didn't see digital photography as meaningful competition, until customers switch en masse within months. Smith-Corona didn't see personal computers as meaningful competition, until customers switched en masse within months. Ditto MySpace, AOL, CompuServe, etc. Wired monopoly-based ~50Mbps service had no meaningful competition - until wireless modest-activation ~500Mbps is individually available at comparable cost. You haven't seen it because it wasn't here. As of a few months hence, it's here. Only reason I haven't dropped local wired service for Starlink is I get a substantial discount on the former; I'm looking for any excuse to switch.
- dboreham 5y agoExcept Kodak's competition didn't need to break laws of physics.
- zbrozek 5y agoI've personally taken two properties off of DSL and onto cellular with pretty-respectable service quality. In both cases latency and throughput and cost improved. The competition from wireless is real and getting better all the time. That said, I think that's often used as an excuse to not invest in wired infrastructure which should be dramatically superior, but often simply isn't.
- WarOnPrivacy 5y agoDSL is an unfortunately low bar. Regardless, it's the only choice for tons of people so your experience is encouraging.
- PoignardAzur 5y agoAnd this, folks, is why local loop unbundling initiatives are important. Also: > Dampier found that Charter offers 200Mbps service for $50 a month "[i]n neighborhoods where Spectrum enjoys a broadband monopoly." Charter charges $70 for 400Mbps service in those same competition-free neighborhoods. Honestly, even the lower-end prices are not great. In France you can easily get 2Gbps for $60 / month.
- geodel 5y ago> In France you can easily get 2Gbps for $60 / month. In France I can get gasoline for $7 dollar a gallon. So save a bit on internet spend on different item and feel superior because EU is the best?
- 8note 5y agoIdeally it would be $20 a gallon and the related taxes would go into replacing the outdated fossil fuel infrastructure
- 988747 5y agoYou do realize that a. People still need to commute b. higher gas price means higher prices of everything, due to transportation costs? Ideally, there would be 0% tax on gas, since it is one of the most essential things in the economy.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Robotbeat 5y agoGround transportation is easy to electrify.
- PoignardAzur 5y agoPeople need to commute less if we generalize remote work for office workers, car-pooling, etc. Transportation costs are less dependent on gas prices if we build better exchange points between truck freight and train freight. Infrastructure is dependent on gas because we let gas be cheap. If we seriously want to curtail climate change, we need to rip the band-aid off.
- deepserket 5y agothe invisible hand doing its work
- adamcstephens 5y agoWe just need to pray harder to the market god, and maybe we’ll get competition?
- _jal 5y agoUnfortunately, the reason you can't see the hand is because it is up the government's dress. If you think we have a free market in the US for telecom (or medicine, or a lot of other things), I have a monopoly to sell you.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoOr maybe it is extremely wasteful and expensive to run 5 different water pipes, 5 different sewer pipes, 5 different electrical lines, 5 different natural gas pipes, and 5 different fiber lines to each house.
- ryandrake 5y agoObviously the solution is to give more tax breaks to these businesses. All that extra money will surely flow down in the form of lower prices to consumers, and not in the form of bonuses and 4th-homes for the company execs.
- hourislate 5y agoI actually experienced an interesting incident that made me switch from Charter with no intention of ever giving them my business again. They had upgraded their default speed in my area from 200 Mbps to 300 Mbps but you wouldn't get it unless you called in for them to increased it. Then a short time later they announced it as a increase to service at no additional cost and it would automatically take affect. Then a couple of months later they reduced again and said it was never an option. I was just so annoyed I switched to 1 Gbps service for an extra $30. I really hope that one day cellular or satellite gut them. Charter/Spectrum is one crooked company that should be sued out of existence.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mtalantikite 5y agoI had a similar experience with Spectrum. They offered a faster service at a cheaper price, but said they couldn't upgrade me because I was an old account from the Time Warner merger. It took a while, but I was able to get them to switch me to the faster, cheaper service. Then after a year my price went way up again, and since I have no other options at my home in Brooklyn I'm stuck paying $80/month for 200 Mbps. All these mergers have been awful for consumers in the telecom space. My relatives in Europe are always shocked at how expensive service is for such mediocre setups.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoI just got 250Mbps service from Spectrum with a two year deal for $35 per month then the regular price will be $65. The neighborhood is on the roadmap for a new fiber provider so hopefully I can get a better deal when the special rate expires. They can make money with cheaper service. I just had a fixed $35 200Mbps plan with Optimum in an area with overpriced competition from Fios. Verizon would send their minimum wage sales drones out to personally plead with me to sign up for $80. The new $50 subsidy is going to ruin cheap internet by setting an inflated price floor. I would gladly take 20 Mbps service for $20 per month but that is never going to happen.
- adamcstephens 5y agoEven on streets with competition, such as mine, they charge more than the competition so I’m not sure why you’d use them if you have a choice. I have the following three lines run to my house, so are active options: Spectrum 1Gig: $110/month WOW! 1Gig: $65/month AT&T 1Gb Fiber: $60/month Guess which one I have?
- nick__m 5y agoWOW! ? 60$/y doesn't seem too expensive to avoid the incumbents.
- randyrand 5y agoalso this just in - charter exists to make money!
- adamcstephens 5y agoalso just in - monopolies are bad and eliminate many of the positives in capitalism!
- sundaeofshock 5y agoMonopoly seems to be the inevitable outcome of capitalism.
- adamcstephens 5y agowithout regulation, perhaps. But no ism is pure, and needs countervailing forces, such as government in the case of capitalism.
- falcolas 5y ago"That's capitalism, baby!" That's how a company is "supposed" to act in a free market, right? They have all the only supply, and can thus "should" charge whatever the market on that street can bear. <s> I mean, it even creates a perfect opportunity for someone to come in and undercut Charter, amirite? </s>
- andrew_ 5y agoI downvoted this because the guidelines [1] specifically state "Don't be snarky." There are plenty of outlets for snark. I like HN for thoughtful replies, even when I disagree with them. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html#:~:text=Please%20don't%20use%20HN,find%20interesting%E2%80%94not%20for%20promotion https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html#:~:text=Ple....
- falcolas 5y agoThey guidelines also recommend not discussing downvotes. "Don't feed egregious comments by replying" Downvote and move on - comments like this feel like mob-mentality karma farming.
- andrew_ 5y agoI wouldn't classify the comment I replied to as egregious. I can't find in the guidelines where it mentions not discussing downvotes. Perhaps you could cite that, specifically.
- db48x 5y agoAlmost. It’s how capitalism is expected to work when you have to get permission from the city before you can support customers on a new street. The existing companies could roll out fiber to everyone in just a few years if they didn’t have to go through the whole process of getting approvals, waiting through public comment periods, rebutting stupid public comments, etc, etc for every single street. Or worse, getting approval from your direct competitors because you’re required to use their telephone poles.
- 5y ago
- move-on-by 5y agoThe only good thing about Charter is: * No data caps / usage-based pricing * No termination fees * No cable modem fees These three points were a requirement of their merger and expires in May 2023. We need to stop allowing these mergers to happen, they are not good for the consumer in the long term.
- andrew_ 5y agoExperienced the same in Florida. We had to relocate while our home was being cleared of hazardous material. I had Spectrum at that location being worked on at one price. The temporary digs were about 3 miles away and the price was 1/3 more for the same service (this was not with a promotion at either location). The only difference is that the new digs had no other option, while our home being worked on also had a FiOS option. I pointed this out to the sales rep on the phone and they couldn't give me a reason why.
- MarkusWandel 5y agoI don't play this game personally, but where I live in Canada, it seems that the main internet providers (Bell and Rogers) each offer heavy discounts if you bug them enough and threaten to switch. A year later your temporary discount expires, and you play the game again. We still have alternate ISPs that the above two have to share their last mile infrastructure with, and mine has no-BS pricing and policies so I stick with them. But a friend who does play the game routinely gets his internet access cheaper. Rogers is really offering heavy discounts in streets where Bell has just installed their fiber-to-the-home stuff.
- ev1 5y agoWhat the hell is Bell offering? FTTH? FTT neighbourhood then copper? The product is called "Fibe" but their lowest plan is 10 Mbps down, 1 Mbps up? What on earth type of optics even offers that?
- nick__m 5y agoFibe is an umbrella marketing term. In my neighborhood, they offer FFTN then copper , a few blocks away it's FTTH (speedtest at 900M down 800M up). In both case they call the service Fibe and charge a similar price .
- ev1 5y agoThat explains a bit. Also very on point for Bell to advertise copper as "fibe"...
- mthoms 5y agoIn the West, Shaw is getting sued by Telus for calling their service "Fiber+" even though the "last mile" is copper. https://mobilesyrup.com/2020/06/12/telus-shaw-lawsuit-misleading-fibre-ads/ https://mobilesyrup.com/2020/06/12/telus-shaw-lawsuit-mislea...
- MarkusWandel 5y agoBell markets FTTN (i.e. VDSL) as "Fibe" and FTTH as "Fibre". Not the most ingenious branding IMHO. I'm on 15/10 FTTN and have no reason to go faster (it tops out at 50 down). Bell's new FTTH offering (conduits being buried on my street as I write this) starts at Can$85 for the lowest practical tier (150M and unlimited). Their nominal cheapest tier ($55) only gets you 100G/month which is a joke. Rogers offered my friend $39/month for 500M unlimited on his street, where Bell's FTTH service is already live.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- llbeansandrice 5y agoNot to excuse this or anything but aren't Verizon, Comcast/Xfinity, etc. also guilty of this? It's an issue with the industry as a whole not just Charter right?
- elliekelly 5y agoYes. The major ISPs in the US are territorial cartels[1] tacitly colluding[2] in restraint of trade with juuust enough plausible deniability and a heavy helping of political campaign contributions to keep the gravy train running. [1]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cartel https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cartel [2]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tacit_collusion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tacit_collusion
- fma 5y agoLikely yes. Where I used to live we had AT&T and Comcast as providers. We'd always get decent subscription rates. I moved, and now only have AT&T fiber...no discounts, very expensive. Wife and I own a small business with a brick and mortar location. It has AT&T DSL and Spectrum. Well...AT&T DSL is slow as hell and for "ok" speeds is expensive. Spectrum knows this. Hence, no discounts...still very expensive for "ok" speeds. At home at least the speeds is OK and the monthly fee is manageable (not the best). But having to pay AT&T to rent their device annoys the heck out of me.
- fortran77 5y agoThe original article: https://stopthecap.com/2021/05/26/a-tale-of-two-homes-in-spectrum-territory-what-competition-does-to-pricing/ https://stopthecap.com/2021/05/26/a-tale-of-two-homes-in-spe...
- minikites 5y agoBasic utilities (electric, water, internet) should be run by government, not private enterprise, for the same reason we we do this for roads. Applying market forces to infrastructure has no benefit and many downsides. The value of infrastructure is multiplied by the number of people with access to it, meaning it should connect all of us. That's not compatible with a market system.
- mikeweiss 5y agoFor everyone living in an area with no competition other than a singular incumbent telecom or cable company... or perhaps no broadband option at all.... I expect 5G fixed wireless to come into play in a big way over the next 5 years. T-Mobile, Verizon and AT&T are going to be eating the cable companies lunch. Likely coaxial networks will become an antique of an older era. the same way POTS (plain old telephone service) did.
- drewg123 5y agoDo they have plans to raise or eliminate data caps? 10-20GB caps just don't work for home internet.
- djrogers 5y agoMost carriers don't have hard 10-20Gb data caps anymore, and the fixed 5G services that are rolling out from T-Mobile and Verizon don't either. That data cap thing was very 2015, and I haven't seen one other than a tethering cap for a while...
- drewg123 5y agoThank you so much for pointing this out. I'd given up on something like this ever happening. I have a colleague living in the northern California wilderness who maintains a point-to-point wifi antenna at the top of a 300' redwood tree because he needs to use a WISP rather than an LTE provider to get uncapped data. I just looked at these plans and they look like a dream come true for him.
- selectodude 5y agoAnd it's less of a tethering cap and more of a soft cap to stop egregious users. I tether pretty frequently on Verizon and have never noticed any slowdowns.
- ghayes 5y agoI have a T-Mobile unlimited 5G data plan. Not exactly inexpensive, but whenever my Wifi acts up, I simply turn it off and barely notice.
- jraph 5y agoFor me, this is a textbook consequence of a "free market" based system. If you don't like this but believe in free markets, maybe think a bit more. If you see nothing wrong with this and believe in free markets, then you are probably consistent.
- djrogers 5y agoThe wired ISP market in the US is the exact opposite of "free market". It's government enforced monopolies, or in the better cases, duopolies. The point to it as a failing of the free market is to misunderstand how regulation and free markets work.
- jraph 5y agoI'd like to learn more about this. Do regulations force ISPs to make people pays more when there are no competitors around? Do regulations set the the price? Aren't duopolies a possible consequence of a free market?
- aranchelk 5y agoThe regulations literally stopped any competitors from even being allowed in the same area. If you’re genuinely curious about how that screws up industries (not just short term pricing) I’d recommend Luigi Zingales‘s A Capitalism for the People, it has a very thorough analysis of crony capitalism.
- jraph 5y agoYes, I meant it, thanks for the reference! My first message was needlessly provocative
- fchu 5y agoFree market includes when competition can reasonably enter a market that's not structured through legislation to be overly favorable towards incumbents. Note that there are natural monopolies/oligopolies, which are the result of the nature of the market (eg need for scale) rather than legal lobbying.
- linsomniac 5y agoFunny coincidence: The same week that the city started running conduit in our neighborhood for municipal fiber, a Xfinity "account manager" came to our door and left a handwritten note saying great customer service was their goal and to call him if there was ever a service problem! Funny how legit competition makes them sit up and take notice... At some point after that, Xfinity dropped their gigabit service level from $190 to $70/mo (IIRC). In theory we have competition, but the alternatives are: Century Link 40Mbps DSL, or Rise Broadband terrestrial wireless (which hasn't proven a very good alternative for my coworkers).
- elliekelly 5y agoI think antitrust jurisprudence in the US is far too heavily focused on consumer prices to the detriment of all of the “intangible” benefits of increased competition. (Thanks, Chicago Schoool!) Things like quality, customer service, responsiveness, and even transparency and data privacy are important aspects of competition and very real benefits to consumers but are completely overlooked in the antitrust analysis. I don’t care if I’m paying the “market rate” if I’m having to constantly argue on the phone about charges or to adjust my schedule to accommodate an 8 hour service window. Those negative consumer externalities wouldn’t exist (or would at least be far less frequent) if the market were more competitive.
- maxerickson 5y agoIt's not even focused on prices. Charter charges a lot for what they deliver.
- rhizome 5y agoI use (10mbps by now, I think) DSL exactly so I won't have to give the dickheads a penny. I do fine, websites themselves are much slower than my connection.
- sircastor 5y agoI remember when Google announced they were bringing fiber to Austin suddenly AT&T decided it was worth making an effort to compete for business...
- nathanvanfleet 5y agoThis seems like a logical thing to happen when the environment in the US right now is so pro-monopoly. Companies are stacking up vertically and companies are merging. The government has little interest in doing the basic work of preventing it. It seems like there is no way to actually stop this from happening every 20 years
- barkerja 5y agoI currently live in an area where Spectrum is the only "broadband" provider. I pay $75 for 200/10. My town finally said enough is enough and is now in the process of rolling out municipal owned internet. You can see the details for that here: http://dryden.ny.us/information/dryden-municipal-broadband-study/ http://dryden.ny.us/information/dryden-municipal-broadband-s... It's unfortunate that many states have passed legislation to block municipal internet. Corporations such as Spectrum, Comcast, etc. should not have that sort of lobbying power, but yet, here we are.
- OJFord 5y agoYeah? Wouldn't you? The greater the premium the faster competition should be encouraged to swoop in and slightly undercut, racing them down to the price of the other streets?
- jrochkind1 5y ago> Dampier found that Charter offers 200Mbps service for $50 a month "[i]n neighborhoods where Spectrum enjoys a broadband monopoly." Wow, and that's still a better deal than I can get from monopoly Comcast Xfinity service in Baltimore, where I pay $80/month for 100Mbps. You read that right. I am paying substantially more than the monopoly rip-off price in this article, and have no broadband choice but comcast...
- intrasight 5y agoI think all businesses will charge more when there is no competition. It's basic economics.
- bjt 5y agoSo that invites an obvious question: Why isn't the competitor available on that next street too? Some streets are more expensive to dig on than others. Perhaps prices are higher and competition is lower there for that reason. Don't get me wrong; I don't trust the broadband providers to do anything but try to extract maximum revenue from their customers. But I also don't immediately trust too-simple explanations that confirm my biases. The story here is more complicated than just moustache-twirling greedy corporations.
- torgoguys 5y agoI live in a Charter area and can confirm similar pricing shenanigans have recently happened here. A fiber internet service is rolling out in our city, neighborhood-by-neighborhood. However, it is only rolling out in the CITY. There are pockets of land inside of the city that have been never annexed by the city and that still remain in the jurisdiction of the local unincorporated TOWN. You could never tell you were in the town, not the city, by looking at these houses and streets--they look just like the neighboring ones. (Our city has a no-forcible-annexation policy). The fiber company (a regional player named TDS) is not deploying fiber in those town-not-city areas yet. I suspect TDS will eventually roll out to these non-annexed areas, but for right now probably has deployment targets to hit in the city since they have a deal with the city (for easy right of access and such) and are too busy to take care of those extra houses. Anyway, all of that is preamble to point out that if you order service from Charter within one of those pockets of non-city-so-no-TDS-service-yet, you will pay a higher price than your neighbors on all sides of you that are in the city (and hence in the TDS service area). That points to, yes, it is monopoly-power-moustache-twirling greed on Charter's part here. Or alternately you could just say the lower prices at the neighbors is competition doing it's magic.
- eli 5y agoComcast does the same thing. I moved less than one mile but from a block that was wired with FiOS to one where Comcast was the only option and the same plan with 30% more expensive.
- acdha 5y agoBack in the late 2000s we had Comcast for about a year prior to moving to a different city. During that point I had to almost monthly call someone in the executive office (I found contact info online) to get my bill corrected to show the rate we had been quoted rather than the much higher rate we were billed at. When we moved, I went with 8Mbps DSL instead of dealing with Comcast again. This was theoretically much slower than the 25Mbps Comcast we'd had but since this was during the network neutrality wars it was actually faster for Netflix since they weren't throttling it. We later bought a house in a neighborhood with Comcast, RCN, and FIOS (the rollout halted just south of us). Unsurprisingly, all 3 deliver great service to our neighbors — and Comcast and Verizon customers a few blocks away have reported that they are given worse service and higher prices because it's _very_ clearly known that their options are take it or leave it.
- leguminous 5y agoMy apartment building forced us into Charter/Spectrum "community wifi" and it's obnoxious. The speed is actually decent but they screw around with the traffic. * Everyone is NATed. There's no option to upgrade to a dedicated IP address if this is a problem. STUN works, but some things don't. Nintendo Switch online play doesn't work and I haven't dug in to figure out why. They know it doesn't work and have said that they won't fix it. * They intercept all (UDP/53) DNS queries. You can change your DNS servers and it won't make a difference because they will spoof 8.8.8.8 or 1.1.1.1 or whatever in response. They'll even spoof root servers, so you can get strange things like a "root server" serving you an A record for pages.github.com. * Of course there is no IPv6 support. * Everyone is on the same ESSID with the same PSK. I suspect someone could sniff their neighbors' traffic if they were motivated enough. It would be nice to have some competition here.
- theo-born 5y agoWhy wouldn't they?
- ncphil 5y agoShocking! TWC Internet was pretty good here, at least they were technically competent. The field service people were pretty good too. But our bill was slightly different every month. Never got any explanation for that. Eventually, Internet-only was over $100 for 300/20. The only competition was AT&T, but their data cap would have doubled our bill. Then Google came to town. Real competition. 1G/1G for $70. With their new config I didn't have to mess with their VLANs, and finally got IPv6. Of course we swapped out the Fiber Box for our own router immediately (an ER-4), and a year on haven't had a single outage -- although sometimes have to work on battery backup because Duke Energy...
- at_a_remove 5y agoI found out that my ISP, which was bought out several times, is folding service in my area. Goodbye, some co-lo. And so now I have to make the choice between Charter and AT&T. This seems like a no brainer but I need an 8-block of static IPs (yes, I know about dynamic DNS and VPNs) and apparently you cannot get static IPs on a home fiber account with AT&T. I suppose I will have to pay, because my base feeling is anything but Charter.
- walterbell 5y agoT-mobile now offers 5G home internet service for $60, which might convince a cable provider's retention department to offer a discount. https://www.cnet.com/home/internet/t-mobiles-60-home-internet-service-6-weeks-later-service-review/ https://www.cnet.com/home/internet/t-mobiles-60-home-interne...
- tristor 5y agoI have Spectrum gigabit service. They decided to deploy gigabit in the wonkiest way possible so a normal DOCSIS compatible modem was unable to provide service, so for the first time in over a decade I’m renting the modem instead of having my own. I also pay an outrageous sum for the service. But none of that is what bothers me. What bothers me is that they don’t even deliver on their promise. Most of the time I am silently downgraded to the “standard” high speed service which is 300mbps. I’m usually not a fan of government intervention, but in the case of ISPs in the US, there’s a desperate need for more oversight.