4 ms·
20x20mm Package. That is quite large. ~10W Controller. Doesn't matter on a Desktop or Server. But we sort of hit the limit what could be done on a Laptop. Hav
by ksec 5y ago
20x20mm Package. That is quite large.
~10W Controller. Doesn't matter on a Desktop or Server. But we sort of hit the limit what could be done on a Laptop.
Having said that it doesn't mention what node it was fabbed on. I assume there are more energy efficiency could be squeezed out.
<6us Latency. Doesn't say what percentile it is and under what sort of condition. But Marvell claim this is 30% better than previous Marvell SSD Controller.
I think ServeTheHome article [1] is probably better. ( Cant change it now >< )
We also have PCI-E 6.0 [1] finalised by the end of this year which we cant expect to be in 2023/2024. SSD Controller with 28GB/s.
I am also wondering if we are approaching the end of S-Cruve.
[1] https://www.servethehome.com/marvell-bravera-sc5-offers-2m-iops-and-14gbps-in-a-pcie-gen5-ssd/ https://www.servethehome.com/marvell-bravera-sc5-offers-2m-i...
[2] https://www.anandtech.com/show/16704/pci-express-60-status-update-draft-071-coming-soon-final-release-by-end-of-year https://www.anandtech.com/show/16704/pci-express-60-status-u...
- bhouston 5y ago2023/2024 I suspect you meant to write. I do like the fact that SSD bandwidth may be approaching memory bandwidth.
- ksec 5y ago>2023/2024 I suspect you meant to write. ROFL. Thanks. Keep thinking about the good old days.
- CyberDildonics 5y agoSSD bandwidth is not really approaching modern memory bandwidth - a computer with one of these will probably have 4 to 8 channels of DDR4 at 25GB/s each with DDR5 released about a year ago. That is 100GB/s to 200GB/s currently and more by the time PCIe 5 becomes a reality. I am sure if you go back a few years you can find systems that have the same or less memory bandwidth than this has now, but they have both been moving forward enough that SSDs are still not close. That being said, between bandwidth and random access times, swapping out to disk backed virtual memory is very pragmatic and isn't the death of performance it used to be.
- dekhn 5y agoI think a fairer comparison would be 1 DDR channel to one SSD, or comparing the 8 channels to a multi-SSD striped RAID array. SSDs are ~7GB/sec, so I would say that SSD bandwidth is roughly within one or two orders of magnitude slower than RAM. I certainly wouldn't want to replace an app optimized to use all the RAM on a machine with one running on a lower-RAM SSD machine, though.
- muxator 5y agoMaybe I'm old. I never used to think that an application that is able to use my whole ram is optimized. It evokes exactly the opposite impression, indeed. I think I understand what you mean, but the gut reaction is that one. Yeah, I am really old, after all. Edit: let me explain. Something that is able to use the whole space of a flat memory model is way less sophisticated than something that is able to deal with a complex memory hierarchy. Our machines are indeed a complex pyramid of different subsystems with varying bandwidth and latency characteristics. A program that is able to embrace the inherent hierarchical nature of our machines (or multi-node systems) is way more "optimized", according to my sensibility.
- dekhn 5y agoI'm talking about situations like search, where you hold the entire index in ram. Total # of machines = size of index / indexserver ram. Usually the apps that run on these have, say, 96 cores and they're using about 80, and the idle time is mostly instructions waiting for memory fetches. Typically that index fronts a disk repository which wouldn't fit in RAM, although over time, what fit in RAM, what fit in disk, what lived in RAM, what got cached in RAM, etc, have changed over time. BTW, I'm probably of the same generation as you and the single most important lesson I ever learned for computing performance was "add more RAM"; in the days when I first started using Linux with 4MB of RAM, it wasn't enough to do X11, g++ and emacs all at the same time without swapping, so I spent my hard-earned money to max out the RAM, at which point it didn't swap and I could actually do software development quickly.
- terafo 5y ago
- jagger27 5y ago10W definitely matters on servers. You can easily have a dozen of these in 1U. 120W isn’t nothing to dissipate. I wonder what node this controller is made on. If it’s made on TSMC N7 then they could cut power consumption roughly in half by going to N5P. The package size makes me wonder if it’s an even older node however.
- dogma1138 5y agoIt’s not an issue in servers really, look at how much power high end NIC consume heck 10GBE SFP+ modules can consumer 5W> each and you can easily have 48> of those in a switch...
- dylan604 5y agoBut a switch doesn't include a hairdrier, er, GPU generating heat within the enclosure. Server cases have potentially multiple GPUs, CPUs, plus now these 10W controller chips
- lostlogin 5y agoYou are correct. Some switches could do with much better cooling. A POE switch or one that is putting 10gb down a cat 6 cable is very toasty though. I’ve got one that is borderline too hot to touch. Thanks Ubiquiti.
- touisteur 5y agoOh you don't want your hand near a Mellanox connectx 6 then. 200GbE doesn't come cold...
- zamadatix 5y agoMost switches don't allow 5W pull in every port, those levels are usually only found in 10G copper SFPs which can't reach full distance due to power requirements so typically pull max allowed (or higher) levels. Typical 10G SFP+ SR or Twinax will consume about a watt per module. The ASIC may be a couple hundred watts under load. Servers typically have much higher power density unless you're talking 400G switches compared to low end servers.
- lmilcin 5y ago> ~10W Controller. Doesn't matter on a Desktop or Server. Of course it does. For one, that's heat you have to efficiently remove or face SSD throttling back on you or degrade over time. It does not make sense to buy expensive hardware if it is going to show impaired performance due to thermal throttling. This makes the business of putting together your PC this much more complicated, because up until recently you only had to take care about CPU and GPU and everything else was mostly afterthought. We are already facing motherboards with their own fans, now I suppose it is time for SSDs.
- dragontamer 5y agoWeren't 10,000 or 15,000 RPM hard drives like 15W or 20W or something? These 2U or 4U cases, or tower desktop cases, were designed to efficiently remove heat from storage devices, as well as the 3000W++ that the dual socket CPU and 8way GPUs will pull. 10W is tiny for desktop and server. Barely a factor in overall cooling plans.
- lmilcin 5y agoThey were, but 3,5" drives are large hunks of aluminium with many times the surface. Meaning that as long as you have some airflow around them and the air is not too hot they are fine. Also the heat was mostly generated by motor and an actuator and not the controller.
- zamadatix 5y agoHigh performance m.2 drives come with removable finned heatsinks for this reason. Without them they rely on throttling during sustained heavy workload. Dissipating 10 Watts in a desktop isn't the concern.
- baybal2 5y agoThe thing is the flash chips themselves are relatively cool. It's the controller that gets most of the heat from running PCIE at top speed.
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoProbably not a small node, remember flash gets more fragile the smaller the process. SSD makers are layering on larger nodes, and focusing on multibit (they are basically at PLC/5bit flash for consumer or non-heavy wear, which is frankly a bit nuts)
- Dylan16807 5y agoThis is a controller, not flash.
- fulafel 5y agoThe 9.8 W is peak power. Probably the rest of the system is going to need a couple of watts to deliver and process application data at 14 GB/s as well.