7 ms·
Master List of Logical Fallacies (2018)
- ggm 5y agoNeeds updating, "tu quoque" being the modern "whataboutery". Doesn't have "no true Scotsman" and the "appeal to authority" is a bit buried.
- edtechdev 5y agoYeah, Wikipedia also has a more in-depth list: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fallacies https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fallacies
- jimnotgym 5y agoIndeed a private website does not seem a great place for a master list of anything. Github or Wikipedia seem like much better places. Since it is possible to extend discussion on the validity of any member of that list, or indeed add new ones.
- denton-scratch 5y agoGithub and Wikipedia are both privately-owned. The definitions given for these "logical fallacies" are packed with rancourous comments that don't throw light on the nature of the fallacy. The names given for them are not the standard names; the classical Aristotelian fallacies are usually named in Latin (and they aren't all there). And indeed, a lot of the so-called fallacies are not fallacies at all, because they aren't a type of faulty argument or reasoning; they're just sayings. This is a much better list of fallacy definitions: https://www2.palomar.edu/users/bthompson/Introduction%20to%20Fallacies.html https://www2.palomar.edu/users/bthompson/Introduction%20to%2... It doesn't claim to be a "master list"; in fact it states on the front page that a complete list is impossible.
- nomilk 5y agoAgree that GitHub would be a great place for it. It's an incredible resource, and indeed (from bottom of page): > Open Courseware | OCW |This work is dedicated to the Public Domain.. A benefit of having such a doc on GitHub would be the ease with which others could critique and contribute, potentially making the list stronger.
- nathias 5y agoThis master list is itself a fallacy, it takes a set of actual fallacies and open questions and maps them as fallacies.
- 5tefan 5y agoAgree. It is a fallacy to assume full knowledge of all fallacies humanity did and still will invent to trick themselves to make opinion and fact interchangeable.
- Adefila 5y agoYes of course, this is right.
- Closi 5y agoAbsolutely agree - I would label some of them "arguments" rather than logical fallacies. For instance "If it ain't broke, don't fix it" isn't a logical fallacy, it's just an idiom/argument. Also some of the definitions of things that aren't logical fallacies themselves contain real logical fallacies. For instance the 'proof' of 'The Passive Voice' seems to include an a-priori argument ('Rape statistics are reported as number of rapes rather than number of rapists, thus this was intended to shift the focus from men to women and is a logical fallacy'). This ignores the fact that the number of rapists can't be known, while the number of reported rapes can be known.
- prepend 5y agoThis example is particularly odd and illogical as it doesn’t not that crime statistics are by crime, not by criminal. So it singles out “rape statistics” as if they have a particular characteristics. And of course misses what you brought up in that rapes are more knowable than rapists.
- Animats 5y agoSome of these are well-known, but were some of these recently invented?
- julienreszka 5y agoEven though this is appealing (mostly to people who are lazy) because it's like importing a library, this never actually won any argument. A better alternative is to detect whether the person is proposing an alternative course of action followed by a successful example. The person that provides the most workable and actionnable solution usually wins. A good example of this is the design of the University of Virginia by Thomas Jefferson. Quote from https://www.johndcook.com/blog/2011/03/03/thomas-jefferson-meetings/ https://www.johndcook.com/blog/2011/03/03/thomas-jefferson-m... In his multi-volume biography of Thomas Jefferson, Jefferson and His Time, Dumas Malone tells the story of how Jefferson handled the first meeting held to decide the organization of the future University of Virginia. The University had been Jefferson’s idea in the first place, but (as is the case everywhere, not just in open source projects) many other parties had climbed on board quickly, each with their own interests and agendas. When they gathered at that first meeting to hash things out, Jefferson made sure to show up with meticulously prepared architectural drawings, detailed budgets for construction and operation, a proposed curriculum, and the names of specific faculty he wanted to import from Europe. No one else in the room was even remotely as prepared; the group essentially had to capitulate to Jefferson’s vision, and the University was eventually founded more or less in accordance with his plans. The facts that construction went far over budget, and that many of his ideas did not, for various reasons, work out in the end, were all things Jefferson probably knew perfectly well would happen. His purpose was strategic: to show up at the meeting with something so substantive that everyone else would have to fall into the role of simply proposing modifications to it, so that the overall shape, and therefore schedule, of the project would be roughly as he wanted.
- cousin_it 5y agoThis is good advice. Maybe slightly dangerous to the less people-minded among us, who are prone to take it as "prepare a pile of documentation" when nobody wants such a pile. So I'd tweak the advice a bit: when preparing for a meeting, do homework on the other participants first, try to empathize with what they want and would accept. Then, depending on that, do the material homework - reading, writing, etc. It works like magic.
- medstrom 5y ago
- apples_oranges 5y agoOne big fallacy of the thinking man, perhaps not logical, but essential: Thinking too much. Some are so good at thinking that they can fool the rest into believing that they are living in the real world.
- vixen99 5y agoI don't think you can think too much. But thinking un-aligned with reality gets bogged down sooner or later. Sadly it tends to be later with some of the more grandiose & expensive schemes people dream up for the rest of us.
- smitty1e 5y ago"Analysis paralysis" This is why deadlines are useful. The customer cares what was delivered, not how exquisitely sculpted my code was. So the acme of skill is to nail the 80% of the challenge that is readily automated, eschew the yak shaving, and then maybe "polish the cannonball" if the problem comes 'round again.
- thrav 5y agoNarrowing into a business / software delivery context is hardly addressing the objection.
- vharuck 5y agoMy favorite example is that Aristotle came to believe, through sound reasoning, men had more teeth than women. And then never bothered to count. I've never checked if this story is true. But it sounds like something Aristotle would do, so I believe it. ;-P
- numeromancer 5y agoLike most of the entries in the article's silly list, this is not a "fallacy", formal nor informal; one does not invalidate a particular argument just by "thinking too much".
- LinAGKar 5y agoNow let's see if this gets renamed to main list to avoid offending people.
- jacksonkmarley 5y ago146 dense, difficult to read blocks of very wide text. I can't comment on the content because I didn't want to read it after the first few lines, despite being interested enough to go there in the first place. As noted in another comment, wikipedia seems better for this topic.
- ChrisGranger 5y agoDoesn't your browser have a reader mode? Firefox's works fine with this site.
- jacksonkmarley 5y agoThere's a reader mode in browsers?
- ChrisGranger 5y agoI'm not sure about the others, but in Firefox, whenever a site supports its reader mode, there's a little icon in the address bar that removes all the excess stuff and reformats the page with your preferred font size, colors, margins. https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/firefox-reader-view-clutter-free-web-pages https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/firefox-reader-view-clu... I would imagine the other browsers have a similar feature... maybe as an add-on, if not built-in.
- oneeyedpigeon 5y agoThis [Illustrated Book of Bad Arguments](https://bookofbadarguments.com/ https://bookofbadarguments.com/) is nothing like as comprehensive, but it's far more enjoyable to read.
- medstrom 5y agoI'm wary of memorizing lists of biases and fallacies, ever since reading Knowing About Biases Can Hurt People https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/AdYdLP2sRqPMoe8fb/knowing-about-biases-can-hurt-people https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/AdYdLP2sRqPMoe8fb/knowing-ab... This is not the way to develop your truthseeking, in fact it may make you worse at it. The unbiased way to check validity of others' statements is to be able to check validity of your own beliefs. If you can do that then you have nothing to worry about: even if you get convinced by a flawed argument, you'll soon debug it out of yourself. To take a software metaphor, you reuse the same libraries. Work on that self-skepticism, because this ability translates into the ability to be skeptical of thoughts coming from others.
- austincheney 5y agoYou should memorize them only for your own benefit so that you are less likely to produce them and quicker to realize the foolishness and incompleteness of other peoples opinions. You cannot hope to correct people making these mistakes though. The foolishness is more important than the substance of an opinion even though poorly formed and provably so. Pointing the logical fallacy out to a HN comment will reward you with down votes and possibly flag your comment.
- medstrom 5y agoThere are better ways of doing that. This type of knowledge, we're prone to overapply to others and underapply to ourselves. You see the many flaws of the enemy camp and don't see as many in your own. So you pigeonhole yourself into staying in your camp without realizing. Better to focus on such mantras as "What do I know and why do I think I know it?" or "If homeopathy is effective, I desire to believe homeopathy is effective; and if homeopathy is ineffective, I desire to believe homeopathy is ineffective. Let me not become attached to beliefs I may not want." Or if you like memorizing things, anti-epistemology (https://www.lesswrong.com/tag/anti-epistemology https://www.lesswrong.com/tag/anti-epistemology) seems better to spend time on than logical fallacies.
- float4 5y ago
- jokoon 5y agoIt's pretty awful to never be able to advance an opinion I have because people will always criticize my person instead, and never answer the arguments. The best tactic is to avoid talking about myself so that people can't find any angle. It reminds me of several things: * "do as I say, not as I do" * "Kill the messenger" * "Separate the art from the artist" Generally pseudonymity almost allows people to express without fear of being judged.
- nickthemagicman 5y agoI've noticed a type of fallacy that's not a true logical fallacy, but it's a definite barrier to finding the truth. It's arguing to defend one's ego, group affiliation, job, or simply doubling down on an incorrect position to avoid being wrong. I guess it's more of a motivational fallacy?
- o_p 5y agoReminder that arguing something is false because theres a fallacy in the argument its a fallacy itself too, ad logicam.
- ProfHewitt 5y agoThe list left out some very important logical fallacies including the following: I'mUnprovable I'mNotProvablyConsistent MyTheoremsAreEnumerable Unfortunately, the above fallacies are current consensus in the literature (Wikipedia, encyclopedias, text books, etc.) See the following for an explanation: https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=3603021 https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=3603021
- musicale 5y agoThis paper leaves me puzzled as to how proofs are connected to cyberattacks, etc.. Perhaps he means that deficiencies in first-order logic lead to security bugs in computing systems? I do like the idea of classifying self-contradictions (as above) and other irritating paradoxes as "monsters" or "bugs." I tend to agree that they are relied on in a number of incorrect "proofs" as well as informal arguments, often for unrelated propositions.
- prepend 5y ago> …Be-verb Fallacy, a cultish linguistic theory and the bane of many a first-year composition student's life, alleging that an extraordinary degree of "clarity," "sanity," or textual "liveliness" can be reached by strictly eliminating all passive verb forms and all forms of the verb "to be" from English-language writing. This odd but unproven contention, dating back to Alfred Korzybski's "General Semantics" self-improvement movement of the 1920's and '30's via S. I. Hayakawa, blithely ignores the fact that although numerous major world languages lack a ubiquitous "be-verb," e.g., Russian, Hindi and Arabic, speakers of these languages, like English-speaking General Semantics devotees themselves, have never been proven to enjoy any particular cognitive advantage over ordinary everyday users of the passive voice and the verb "to be." Nor have writers of the curiously stilted English that results from applying this fallacy achieved any special success in academia, professional or technical writing, or in the popular domain. This isn’t a fallacy and I’m not sure the complaint other than this author doesn’t like it. It’s particularly hilarious that somehow the author thinks there should be research for an author to choose a writing style. And doesn’t cite any research showing supporting their own style decisions or rationale for clarity, tone, etc. I’m not familiar with whatever field would study success based on writing style, but E-Prime [0] has arguments for its use and someone choosing to follow it shouldn’t be criticized for choosing this method. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-Prime https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-Prime
- BaronSamedi 5y agoI agree with you. The idea that using e-prime makes one's writing more clear isn't a "fallacy". People might disagree but it's hardly fallacious. There are many items in this list that aren't fallacies (e.g., "Dog-Whistle Politics"). This list seems to be a mix of actual fallacies and "Things I don't like". If it is a fallacy we should be able to construct a simple argument from it. With the "Be-verb Fallacy" what would that be? Perhaps, "You used e-prime in your argument but all people who use e-prime are part of a cult, therefore you are part of a cult (and are wrong)." That's a fallacy all right just not the "Be-verb" one. I also found the definition of a fallacy at the start lacking. It conflates good argumentation with rhetorical technique. I prefer T. Edward Damer's definition from my old logic textbook: "A good argument must have premises that are true or acceptable, premises that are relevant to the truth of the conclusion, and premises that together constitute good or adequate grounds for the truth of the conclusion." Fallacious arguments violate one or more of these three principles.
- skissane 5y agoI think these kinds of lists encourage a particular approach to debate I've seen on the Internet – respond to someone's argument with a claim "you've just committed the X fallacy!" Often with no explanation of how what they've said is actually an instance of the X fallacy, or justification of why the X fallacy is actually fallacious. (Just because someone calls something a fallacy, or even publishes it on a list of fallacies, doesn't actually make it a fallacy.) As if fallacies were magical spells with which your opponents arguments could be dismissed by mere invocation of their names.
- anta40 5y agoWell checking if your opponent argument commits logical fallacies is just the first part. The second part is, of course, providing your own logical counter.
- skissane 5y agoI think it is often better if you explain why and how the argument is fallacious without actually bringing any named fallacies into it. If you’ve done a good job of explaining the why and the how, you don’t need the name. But sometimes people think if they use the name they can skip the explaining why and how
- mejutoco 5y agoBecause it does not scale. If they did, they would spend a lot of time explaining easy-to-produce fallacious statements, in a similar dynamic to that of people „feeding the trolls“ on the internet. P.S. Or, in other words, burden of proof ;)
- skissane 5y ago> Because it does not scale Arguing on the Internet doesn't scale. And if someone says something wrong, and you don't have the time to respond to it properly, it is better to just ignore them and move on, than to answer their poor argument with a poor response. > P.S. Or, in other words, burden of proof ;) I hear so many invoke the concept of "burden of proof", without appearing to have ever really reflected on the complex philosophical questions involved – which of many distinct principles for assigning the burden of proof ought we accept? Many of them sound plausible on the surface, yet can produce opposite results when applied to particular cases. And why and how are we obliged to accept any such principle? If there are multiple competing proposals as to the nature and contents of the "burden of proof", how do we determine which (if any) of those proposals is right? Is there a single burden of proof across all of human thought, or does each discipline or field of endeavour adopt a burden of proof suited for its own needs? Do we force criminal law, high energy physics, mathematics, ancient history, psychiatry and philosophy to all share the same principles for determining the burden of proof? Or do we allow each to pick their own, and maybe one discipline's principles will contradict those of another? Such people would be well-served by familiarising themselves with some of the philosophical literature on the topic, for example James Cargile's 1997 article "On the Burden of Proof" [0]. I think it is well summarised by his concluding paragraph: > Is there one, ultimately correct standard of proof? I don't think so; but in a given case, it may be true that an appropriate standard of proof has been satisfied. It can be truly observed that a different standard has not been satisfied. Confusion can arise as to the significance of this fact. And to quote the epistemologist Keith Lehrer's (often-cited, including by Cargile's paper I referenced above) 1971 address to Vassar College [1]: > ...generally arguments about where the burden of proof lies are unproductive. It is more reasonable to suppose that such questions are best left to courts of law where they have suitable application. In philosophy a different principle of agnoiology is appropriate, to wit, that no hypothesis should be rejected as unjustified without argument against it. Consequently, if the sceptic puts forth a hypothesis inconsistent with the hypothesis of common sense, then there is no burden of proof on either side... [0] https://www.jstor.org/stable/3751305 https://www.jstor.org/stable/3751305 [1] Keith Lehrer, Why Not Scepticism?, Philosophical Forum 2 (3):283 (1971)
- dkarl 5y ago> 16. The Argument from Incredulity: > This cynical fallacy falsely elevates the saying popularized by Carl Sagan, that "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof," to an absolute law of logic. I have never heard anybody claim absolute logical validity for an argument like this. I think the author of this list mistakes other people's intentions and believes they are trying to argue by "absolute laws of logic" when they really aren't. Arguing by absolute logic is a game that can occasionally yield stimulating results, but enforcing the rules of this game isn't a constructive contribution in most conversations.
- eplanit 5y agoThese lists get longer every time I see one. The first I saw in the 90s listed 12.
- numeromancer 5y agoSince the author doesn't even know what a logical fallacy is, he has no reason not to continue to add whatever itches him as a "fallacy".
- marcodiego 5y agoPlease, somebody turn this into a wikipedia article! It would be a good companion to "list of common misconceptions"[0] and "list of biases"[1] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_common_misconceptions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_common_misconceptions [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cognitive_biases https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cognitive_biases
- marcodiego 5y agoNevermind, there's already such an article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fallacies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fallacies
- akarma 5y agoThis page is full of 'fallacies' that are technically correct — they are sometimes used fallaciously, but simultaneously, many are fair considerations that are often used correctly. It is fun to read and healthy to be aware of these, but I hope that, in reading these, one doesn't paint broad brush strokes and declare that any appeal to nature, or pity, or tradition is fallacious. As one example: > 12. The Appeal to Tradition A lack of any respect for tradition is a serious issue for a society. It's not fallacious to give credence to tradition, meaning to tread carefully around it. If people before you designed a system in a certain way, it's important to be able to fairly note the advantages and disadvantages of their system, and why they designed it the way they did before changing it. Use the principle of charity. Assume that they, intelligent and resourceful as you, had considered your option and decided against it. Why? Is there anything you're missing? In support of it being a fallacy, there are people who cling to clearly disadvantageous things based solely on tradition regardless of objective consideration, but there's just as many people who think through the pros and cons of the new and old and use tradition healthily. These days they're often labelled as fallaciously appealing to tradition for even giving the past consideration.
- blacksmith_tb 5y agoOf course the tricky thing about traditions is that they change... which is also the best thing about them, as infanticide, slavery, stoning people to death etc. are 'traditional' but humans have mostly moved on from them now, luckily. Generally I'd say when people appeal to tradition in an argument it is an attempt to derail the discussion - "it goes without saying..."
- akarma 5y agoWe also have many traditions around general morality, consideration, respect, tolerance, and so forth. To give no consideration to tradition is a terrible idea for society; it devalues the work and thought of those who came before us, and it leads to throwing out hundreds of babies with the bathwater. We're in agreement on the fallacy of "it goes without saying...," but many people in society today show no consideration to history or tradition, and see no value in attempting to understand it enough to see its advantages. In other words: this 100% can be a fallacy, but in modern society, we're currently in more danger of forgetting the value of history and tradition, than the danger of valuing it too much.