5 ms·
I'd like to see a worldwide agreement that no country will ever stop a citizen from leaving, as long as they have permission to enter another country. Even if
by londons_explore 5y ago
I'd like to see a worldwide agreement that no country will ever stop a citizen from leaving, as long as they have permission to enter another country.
Even if the person is in prison or debt, they can always leave with just themselves to another country willing to take them.
If all nations agreed to that, we could stop worrying about most other human rights abuses, and country governance becomes more of a free market. If you don't like your own system of government, you can move to another. Countries would have an incentive to treat their people well, or see a mass exodus.
- refactor_master 5y agoThe free market has a pretty terrible track record when it comes to human rights, though. What would countries stand to gain from this, realistically? No country wants economic refugees.
- axiosgunnar 5y agoWhy does Germamy willingly accept so many then? Genuinely curious
- ForHackernews 5y agoEither for humanitarian reasons, or because Germany has an ageing population and desperately needs young workers to support its welfare state.
- hef19898 5y agoIt is one. The majority of migrants, qualified or not, have a hard time getting work permits. Finding work, low paid but paid, isn't the main challenge. Doesn't do any good if you aren't allowed to take that work so. Also, our social systems are doing well. Thanks for worrying.
- inglor_cz 5y ago"our social systems are doing well" If you include pension systems, not so much. "Altersarmut" ("poverty of the old age") was not a widely used word in the 1990s, now it is a frequent topic in German media. In many other European countries, old people live in their own properties with mortgages long paid off, so they aren't directly touched by rent increases. But Germans, for some reason, mostly like to live in rented flats and have a comparatively low home ownership rate, even in their old age. And the rents have grown quite a lot in big German cities. This means quite a squeeze for the elderly.
- hef19898 5y agoTrue. And we have Hartz IV, a national shame in my opinion. My point to OP was that, besides these facts, our social system is nowhere near to collapsing. No matter how many refugees we take in. That we as a nation, and that includes myself through our representative democracy, are ok with poor and old people being squeezed out of living space by rent seeking investors and treating people under Hartz IV as second class citizens is a different story. But we have elections in September, so there is a chance to shake things up a little bit.
- avh02 5y agomostly the latter - plus a need for more highly skilled workers in certain shortage occupations.
- radiator 5y agoGermany or the government of Germany?
- londons_explore 5y agoThere are a few countries who will pretty much let anybody in. Migrants often bring with them skills that the locals don't have, and in any mass migration, those who migrate (vs stay where they are) tend to be the fitter, smarter, richer people. The main reason not to take migrants is you might see substantial economic losses as migrants send income back home to support family. You might alienate your existing population with conflicting cultures. And with enough immigration, the migrants might eventually outnumber the original population and persecute them (eg. indian reservations). It's all a tradeoff, but I suspect there always a few countries worldwide who will take anyone.
- EliRivers 5y agoyou might see substantial economic losses as migrants send income back home to support family. Is that a real problem? Assume they get paid in local currency (e.g. US dollars). Option one; they buy a foreign currency with those US dollars, and send that foreign currency overseas. The dollars stay in the US and get spent. Option two, they send those US dollars overseas; those US dollars ultimately either come back to the US to be spent (in which case the fact that they circled around the world matters as much as if they sat in a wallet in Utah for a year), or they never come back and the US is ahead on the deal, given that the worker did some work but US society will never need to hand over goods/services in exchange. I guess my hypothesis is that either those US dollars get spent in the US, or they don't. If they do, it's just like a non-migrant worker. If they don't, US society got work done and didn't have to give back goods/services - bargain for US society.
- londons_explore 5y ago> If they do, it's just like a non-migrant worker. It isn't quite. Imagine dollars leave the US, get sent to Nigeria, and eventually return to the US to buy some music. Compare that to the case where the dollars do not get sent to Nigeria, but remain in the US. In the latter case, the Nigerian person wanting their music needs to find another source for the dollars to buy their music. That in turn makes the dollar more valuable, and reduces Nigerias buying power for US products and services.
- simonh 5y agoDoes the not-free market have a better track record?
- mjburgess 5y agoThe phrase here is "The State" and no. c. 30 states are "free", c. 130 are dictatorships now. Those numbers get worse as you wind back the clock.
- EliRivers 5y agoHow are you defining "economic refugee"? Lots of countries benefit from people coming to that country to work. In many cases, those people end up as net contributors to the public purse; the individual is better off, the recipient country is better off.
- DocTomoe 5y agoThis would not apply to "economic refugees", because those would - if unwelcome - lack the permission by the target nation to take them.
- staticautomatic 5y agoFYI US common law permits asylum claims by economic refugees.
- rsj_hn 5y agoUh, anyone can make an asylum claim. An asylum claim is basically a plea to not be deported. It is usually a last ditch tactic when you are caught on US soil illegally, and you are not disputing that you are here illegally but are making a plea that you should not be returned anyway. It was a law introduced to aid Cuban boat refugees who were unable to apply for refugee visas and so always came here illegally. The question is what are the grounds that would make such a plea legally successful, and being an economic refugee is not one of them. So while you are correct that economic refugees can make the claim, you are incorrect in that such a claim would succeed. People with red hair can also make the claim. Anyone can make the claim.
- staticautomatic 5y agoYou are quite wrong. See Baballah v. Ashcroft
- tpm 5y agoa lot of countries want "economic refugees", even the same politicians that are posturing against them
- matkoniecz 5y ago> No country wants economic refugees. Depends on cultural differences and their qualification. For example basically noone complains about Ukrainian/Belarusian programmers working in Poland. There is quite significant presence of Ukrainians in Poland and it is widely accepted and so far no major problems happened. > On 14 September 2018, 33,624 Ukrainian citizens possessed a permanent residence permit, and 132,099 had a temporary residence permit.[4] About 1 to 2 million Ukrainian citizens are working in Poland.[5][6] There are also 40,000 Ukrainian students in Poland.[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukrainians_in_Poland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukrainians_in_Poland
- throwaway292893 5y agoI don't think that would solve the North Korea, Uighur, Hong Kong, or Taiwan crisis. Holding China accountable would solve 70% of human rights abuses.
- ketzu 5y ago> Holding China accountable would solve 70% of human rights abuses. Do you mean that "70% of human rights abuses" in china or worldwide? And if worldwide, do you think the 70% of human rights absuses happen in china or that other nations will stop based on the fear of consequences? Right now my first impression was that you claim that 70% of all human rights abuses happen in china, which, to me, seems like it is very very wrong. But that would be an uncharitable reading, so I'd be interested in if I get it wrong.
- fuzzylightbulb 5y agoAlways assume the more charitable interpretation. I think the person was just being hyperbolic, and used "70%" to mean "a lot". Pedantic squabbling over the exact number of something that is essentially unknowable is not particularly helpful to anyone except for the human rights abusers. With that out of the way: I do think that if there were a mechanism in place that was sufficient to hold a huge state such as China accountable, it actually would have a significant impact on worldwide human rights abuses. If China was not able to get around this, what options would smaller tin-pot dictators have other than to reform? Proving to the world that the rules apply regardless of relative size/importance has significant downstream effects beyond the single entity that is brought down for noncompliance with those rules. Likewise, the visible lack of required accountability for large players undermines faith in the system and encourages smaller players to see what they can get away with.
- gpvos 5y agoI'd love to see something like this as well, but it's not going to happen as long as so many people and/or their governments don't like large influxes of people.
- dannyw 5y agoIn Australia, it's currently a crime for citizens to leave without a permit. The system for permits is quite arbitrary, with some reporting approvals in minutes, and others reporting rejections without reason. It is worth noting that a recent survey showed a vast majority of Australians preferring closed borders as we have been relatively unscathed from COVID.
- sbarre 5y ago> It is worth noting that a recent survey showed a vast majority of Australians preferring closed borders Of course they do, but as with most other human rights declarations, these rules are there to protect the minority, not the majority.
- teachingassist 5y ago>these rules are there to protect the minority, not the majority. That's not clear. Democracy protects the majority (but not always the minority); in an absence of democracy, the majority are also vulnerable to breaches of human rights.
- sampo 5y agoCovid restrictions are also there to protect a minority, not the majority.
- Dah00n 5y agoDoes no-one complain that it breaks The UN's Universal Declaration of Human Rights?
- londons_explore 5y ago> In Australia, it's currently a crime for citizens to leave without a permit. As long as a country allows a citizen to leave, it doesn't matter if it's also against local laws. It simply means that the person should expect punishment if they were to ever return.
- louloulou 5y ago
- ForHackernews 5y agoThat seems like it would give carte blanche for criminals to flee the country to avoid justice.
- jonplackett 5y ago*only if someone will take them
- bob_roboto 5y agoMaybe I'm cynical but I'd bet money on people being able to turn this into a business...
- londons_explore 5y agoI'd actually be fine with criminals using this to leave my country... Housing and feeding criminals is expensive. Letting them leave permanently is in my eyes a better solution.
- DocTomoe 5y agoWhich would become an one-way route, because once a nation has become a criminal-refugee paradise, why would third countries accept them travelling to their shores?
- Ichthypresbyter 5y ago>I'd like to see a worldwide agreement that no country will ever stop a citizen from leaving, as long as they have permission to enter another country. It's in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Article 13 Section 2: >Everyone has the right to leave any country, including his own, and to return to his country. Of course, it's not clear how much legal force the UDHR has.
- bmmayer1 5y ago> Of course, it's not clear how much legal force the UDHR has. I think we all know the answer to this question :)
- pc86 5y ago> Of course, it's not clear how much legal force the UDHR has. It's perfectly clear - zero, unless the violation is so egregious other countries are willing to go to war over it.
- tpm 5y ago> Of course, it's not clear how much legal force the UDHR has. Depending on the jurisdiction. It has a lot of legal force in countries that are members of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR; violations go to that court if they are not satisified by local courts or other means of member states; member states usually respect the Court's decisions). Belarus applied for membership in 1993 but was never admitted, because well I think it's clear why.
- monksy 5y ago> much legal force the UDHR has. They won't enforce it, they won't even say anything. Upon request they'll even hand over the names of people of interest to regimes that wish to execute or torture innocent people. See the UNHRs response to handing over names of Uighurs. https://www.aa.com.tr/en/americas/human-rights-whistleblower-claims-un-wants-to-fire-her/2109271 https://www.aa.com.tr/en/americas/human-rights-whistleblower... "it's not a problem" https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/2/22/china-rejects-uighurs-genocide-charge-invites-uns-rights-chief https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/2/22/china-rejects-uighu... When you're talking about exit bans, that's something China is known for, and it's gotten bad enough that the US State Department mentions it. (That was a long time coming)
- staticman2 5y agoA country would turn into "religious terrorism refugee land" and people would murder nonbelievers and then immigrate there. Russia would assassinate people and the assassins would have safe travel home. Billionnaires would murder their divorcing spouses then flee to billionnaire refugee land with their money.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoAll of these three already happened
- staticman2 5y agoYou are missing the point that none of these happened without the criminal taking the risk that they would be caught before escaping the country where the crime occured. The proposal is to make the law change so these are risk-free crimes. The law would not be a deterent to commiting crimes. The fun thing about this proposal is when people say they want "countries to compete" they are often pushing for a market solution for the rich to get richer. But in this case it would hurt rich and poor alike. Jeff Bezos has little to gain from american law to be optional for americans and anyone to be able to murder him and opt out of the law by leaving the country.
- disabled 5y ago> Russia would assassinate people and the assassins would have safe travel home. They already largely do. Also, in many countries that have experienced illiberal trends recently, they can still get you emigrated abroad and they still have power over you abroad. As the journalist Sarah Kendzior says “This is a transnational crime syndicate masquerading as a government.” To win something like this, it is better that large amounts of people who can stay be able to as long as feasibly possible. Once people leave en masse (sometimes there is no choice) the situation only gets uglier. But you do absolutely have to know when to leave.
- triceratops 5y ago> Countries would have an incentive to treat their people well, or see a mass exodus Only the ones with options to leave. That is, people with money or skills.