20 ms·
I bought a Mac in 2014 after a lifetime of using Windows. I never understood why people called it easier to use than Windows. Maybe this sentiment is a holdover
by rchaud 5y ago
I bought a Mac in 2014 after a lifetime of using Windows. I never understood why people called it easier to use than Windows. Maybe this sentiment is a holdover from an earlier era when people would mindlessly run executables and zip files attached in emails and AIM messages.
From a UI perspective, it's 90% identical to windows. From a UX perspective though, something fundamental like Finder is still not up to the job IMO. Why is it that when I click Finder, nothing actually opens? I have to hit Option+N to actually display a Finder window.
Don't even get me started on the sort options. What kind of file manager applies a Sort view to every single directory, instead of the one you actually set the Sort view to?
- chrisseaton 5y ago> Why is it that when I click Finder, nothing actually opens? I'm not sure what you're doing wrong here - when I click the Finder icon it shows me the top Finder window, or opens a new one if there is no window. Is this not what it does for you?
- scotty79 5y agoMaybe it's a bug. I had plenty of those accumulating using mac for few months.
- bombcar 5y agoIf finder has a window anywhere clicking on the finder in the dock doesn't open a new finder window - it just tries to bring the current one forward. If you have many windows, it can be hard to notice (especially if you have many monitors).
- vladvasiliu 5y agoBut this is the standard behavior for pretty much all apps on Mac OS, so if their complaint is specifically about Finder and not about the general behavior, that sounds like a bug to me.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- culturestate 5y agoIf you use an external monitor, Big Sur has a tendency to hide windows off the edge of the screen when it wakes. macOS will do its thing when you click the dock icon and bring the window to the front, but it can be hard to notice because only a sliver of the window will actually be visible.
- gowld 5y agoThat's only if the app is already open. If you Quit Finder when no windows are open, the first click opens no windows. Arguably, it's intuitive: * If you know what you are doing, you can go to the menu bar or click on the icon again. * If you don't know know what you are doing, the obvious action is to blame yourself and click the icon again, which does open a window (to the Recents folder). So it's gaslighting a little, but it is intuitive.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> That's only if the app is already open. If you Quit Finder when no windows are open, the first click opens no windows. I'm not sure what you're talking about - you cannot quit Finder and the app is always open. You can only force restart it but it is never in a quit state for you to do what you're say you're doing, and if you do force-start it it behaves as already described.
- qubitcoder 5y agoTry closing Finder and report back ;-). And that was definitely a bug at one point. Whenever I encountered it years ago, I was always bemused thinking about how a typical user would ever figure out how to open Finder and get to their files. No matter how many times you clicked the dock icon, the window would never appear. Of course, I know to use Cmd+N; and nowadays, a new Finder window opens as expected when clicked.
- datalus 5y agoI started off as a Windows user, but in college I switched to I think OS X Tiger at the time. To me, it was a pretty impressive upgrade & I had a *nix terminal at my disposal. But imo macOS has been running on the same UX upgrade since it started calling itself OS X. I think this sentiment largely comes from the era when Microsoft Windows XP was the dominant Windows flavor and also the ME/Vista debacles.
- mrweasel 5y agoI switch at around the same time and I had the exact same experience. You can use your Mac pretty much the same way you did 15 years ago. Some of the newer stuff is a little annoying, there’s basically “to much” operating system and it sometimes get in the way. The article isn’t wrong though, so things do seem a bit weird if you don’t know they work. MacOS is far from perfect, it is however much more consistent than Windows.
- kristofferR 5y agoThe way sort options works is pretty nice IMO. If you wanted to set sort options for a single folder you'd just right click and open Sort Options.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoAlso, by default Finder seems to hide directory structure from you. This seems to be Apple thinking it'll confuse people if they can see 'up' directories, but I think just as often it confuses people like me who are trying and failing to go up. I use all three major desktop OSes regularly now, and overall Windows just feels like the most user-friendly and straightforward, though of course it too has issues (e.g. various settings/control panel options being randomly split between new style and old style systems). Oh, and Linux seems to be by far the least stable. I have apps freezing the whole damn computer way more often there than the other two.
- chrisseaton 5y agoAre you looking for 'Go', and 'Enclosing Folder'? Or if you navigated to a folder from its parent, you can click the back button, just like a browser, which is probably what most users expect. It's like navigating links.
- sgarland 5y agoThe inability to easily go to $HOME in Finder is of great annoyance to mevwhen combined with app signing. Hashicorp seems to run into this most often - download a new version of Terraform/Packer/whatever, install to ~/.terraform.d/plugins/darwin_amd64, and MacOS sternly tells me I can't run it, with zero instructions on how to proceed. Manually type the path in Finder/Go, Option+Open the binary, then you're good to go. I understand the reasoning for protecting the end user, but like UAC in Windows, or Developer Mode options in Android, you should be able to disable these protections. If I want to run a binary, I want to run that binary.
- selykg 5y agoYou can actually just goto your home folder. Goto Finder>Preferences, then Sidebar, you'll find your home folder is stashed away in there but not checked. It'll just be your username. You can also unhide hidden dot folders as well if you wish but by default those are hidden. I don't have the instructions for that right now but a google search can find it for you if you want it.
- asattarmd 5y agoThe worst: pressing Enter to rename a file in finder. Command + Down arrow to open it. WTF!
- ninkendo 5y agoThe worst in windows: Command+Down doesn’t open a folder, and Enter doesn’t rename it. WTF!
- lucideer 5y agoI think this is a common view held by experienced computer users, because they don't consider which parts of their own usage patterns are a component of their advanced knowledge, and which are inherent to all users. For example: an experienced user is more likely to notice that closing a window in macOS backgrounds the app, and more likely to figure out how to fully exit the app process completely (either via Cmd+Q or menu>Quit). Given that, an experienced user is less likely to grow accustomed to all of their apps being in a backgrounded state, and find Finders forced background state unusual/exceptional. In contrast, an inexperienced computer user will likely leave all apps they use open all the time (possibly not realising they're running) and as such grow more quickly accustomed to having to Option+N for everything (not just Finder). There's a lot of such examples in macOS.
- liprais 5y agoIt is obvious you are used to windows.
- lucideer 5y agoI'm a Mac user. I'm re-reading my own comment as both replies to it seem to have taken the opposite point that I intended, but I can't see where I said the macOS behaviour is bad. I personally like it (though I wasn't saying that either). My only point was that it being less intuitive for more techy users doesn't mean it's not generally very intuitive for the majority.
- allenu 5y agoI think you mean “experienced Windows user using macOS”. What you describe are consistent design choices on the Mac. If you flipped things around and only knew Macs and went to Windows, you might be surprised that closing a window there exits an app! There’s no reason one behavior is more correct than the other.
- jbverschoor 5y agoThat’s only by convention. Both OSes have an application with 0-x windows. macOS is just more transparent
- jdlyga 5y agoI've noticed a lot of convergence these days. There aren't a lot of differences between iOS and Android, Mac OS and Windows, PS5 and Xbox. I used Mac OS 7 and 8 extensively back in the day, and despite some UI similarities it was a totally different experience from Windows machines. The computers had totally different ports (parallel and ps/2 vs proprietary mac connectors), and a different set of software (Clarisworks vs Word Perfect). There were even developers who made games just for Macs like Ambrosia Software. Nowadays, you can basically use the same software (Chrome, Slack, VSCode, Steam) on Windows, Mac, or Linux. And can share a USB-C hub between a Macbook and a Dell.
- agumonkey 5y agoMacs are strange. I agree that there's a lot of counter intuitive if not worse UI ideas. But it's surrounded by tons of superb tricks. Remember the live document preview years ago ? Also the GUI guidelines made the system visually more appealing. The compositor is also weird, I cannot really explain but when I use a Mac I don't see layers.. I don't feel like i'm clicking on a button, then an event is sent, then some logic occurs.. maybe it's only subjective bias (can't be 100%) but it feels more direct. Maybe they tailored the graphical subsystem / compositor to ensure extremely low latency I can't say.. but, even after using countless machines and countless desktop environments.. the first time I used a mac I felt something very different. Not better .. but deeply different.
- wraptile 5y agoAs someone who recently switched to MacOs (not by their own choice) there are hundreds of little annoying, broken or inconsistent OS things I find. One of my favorites just happened yesterday with finder - I was trying to figure out how to rename a file, well the usual fx keys aren't doing it so the common process was to go to the toolbar context menu where hotkey is indicated next to the action's text. Rename for some reason had no hotkey indication! [1] so naturally I'm thinking it's somehow not bounded, google around for hotkey editing etc just to findout it's the least obvious key: return. 1 - https://i.imgur.com/LtcrBPU.png https://i.imgur.com/LtcrBPU.png
- chrisseaton 5y ago> well the usual fx keys aren't doing it When you say the 'usual' function keys... do you really mean some other system's function keys? Why would you expect macOS to use the same function keys as a different system? There's no standards body for these things.
- wraptile 5y agoit was just muscle memory but that's not the point.
- fao_ 5y ago> There's no standards body for these things. Yes there is -- it's called CUA (Common User Access) "The subset of CUA implemented in Microsoft Windows or OSF/Motif is generally considered a de facto standard to be followed by any new Unix GUI environment." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_Common_User_Access https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_Common_User_Access
- FabHK 5y agoThe original Mac predates that, and I think it is quite conceivable that "Enter" to select a file name and edit it was in use back then.
- 5y ago
- EamonnMR 5y agoTrying to find a file you know the name of in finder is absolute murder. I often find myself resorting to `ls | grep` then `open` in the terminal.
- ghaff 5y agoThe Finder isn't great. You might take a look at Pathfinder.
- Mauricebranagh 5y agoYeh when I switched for work, I though this is in some ways worse than filemanger in windows 3.1 !
- klodolph 5y agoFirst, not going to claim that macOS is "intuitive", because my in my experience, "intuitive" usually means very different things to different people. As a long-time Mac, Windows, and Linux user... I'll say that there are plenty of random broken things on the Mac, but there are also a few nice things that work very consistently on the Mac, but you'd never think to try them because you're used to them not working on Linux or Windows. So if you have been using Linux or Windows a long time, you will probably find macOS frustrating, just for the reason that it is different from what you are used to, and not because there are fundamental flaws with macOS or Windows. Just an example of a couple simple things that are easy on a Mac, but hard on Linux/Windows: saving a file to a specific location. Let's say you have a Finder window open, and an unsaved document open in an application, and you want to save the open document to the folder that's open in the Finder. 1. You could go to the app and hit save, bringing up the save dialog, and then drag the folder (perhaps from the icon in the title bar) into the save dialog. This moves the save dialog to point to that folder. 2. You could save the file somewhere else, and drag the file (perhaps from the icon in the title bar) into the folder. 3. You could save the file on the desktop, and then move it into the desired folder. I have not really ever figured out a nice way to do this on Windows. I often end up having to navigate through save dialogs on Linux and Windows and it seems unnecessary. Windows certainly doesn't let you move files that are open, which is a frustrating restriction when you run into it. > Why is it that when I click Finder, nothing actually opens? It brings Finder forward, and opens a new window if there are no Finder windows open, which is the same behavior as other Mac apps. > Don't even get me started on the sort options. What kind of file manager applies a Sort view to every single directory, instead of the one you actually set the Sort view to? Command J lets you set the view options, it's per-directory and includes sorting & grouping. Per-directory options don't do anything in column view. I'm not sure what you're doing, so I don't know what's missing. I switched to column view in the early 2000s and only occasionally switch to list view when I need to sort a massive folder by file sizes (which, unfortunately, requires command-J and checking "calculate all sizes", which is not something you'd know to look for).
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoThose proxy icons are brilliant. I only discovered them a short while ago but use them all the time now. It’s a shame they are hidden in Big Sur.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- city41 5y agoI used Macs exclusively from MacOS 7 up until about 3 years ago. And I will always stand by Macs were easier to use, more consistent and more intuitive before OSX. Yes, the OS was archaic architecturally and it was downright primitive in many ways. But the UX was far superior. Finder is bizarre in that it hasn't really changed much at all in 20+ years.
- throwawayboise 5y agoThat discontinuity is because OSX is decended from NEXTSTEP, not classic MacOS. Finder was "ported" but many of the other NeXT-isms remain.
- runjake 5y ago1. If you click Finder and nothing opens, it means you already have a Finder window open somewhere or your device is broken. It's dumb and I wish it just opened a Finder window. As far as I know, there's no way to do this without scripting. 2. Right-click on the folder name in a Finder window to see and go up the folder hierarchy. 3. Make sure Finder is active and go to the View menu and select Show Path Bar. 4. I'm not sure what you're talking about with Sort View here, but Windows works the same as macOS and on both platforms, you can have it both ways. https://support.apple.com/guide/mac-help/welcome/mac https://support.apple.com/guide/mac-help/welcome/mac
- jbverschoor 5y agoCmd-n for new window
- michaelmrose 5y agoStrictly speaking a directory doesn't have an order and you are just switching the UI to show folders sorted.
- screye 5y agoI for the love of me, can't understand how to use a macbook. I don't mean being productive on it. I mean: how to open something or how clicks work. It might simply be the fact that I've never used a mac as a primary device. But, clicks, navigating the explorer and settings menus seem to be a lot simpler on windows. It also seems to be almost malicious in punishing you for using something that isn't a 1st party application. The only other time a software has made me feel so incompetent is shitty TV UIs and Snapchat. I can see why it is loved by people deeply invested in the walled garden and programmers who get a happy marriage of Linux and mature consumer OS. But, I would find it hard to recommend a macbook to someone who didn't lie in those 2 camps.
- TurningCanadian 5y agoIt's not even great for programming these days. Docker on Linux or even Windows is a walk in the park compared to the horror show of slowness (https://github.com/docker/roadmap/issues/7 https://github.com/docker/roadmap/issues/7) and missing features that it is on Mac.
- perryizgr8 5y agoDocker is complicated. Try running gdb on a Mac. I gave up after a reboot and 15 minutes of searching and trying different things. Unbelievable how devs put up with this.
- zwily 5y agoI feel the same way when I’m forced to use Windows or a Linux desktop.
- geraltofrivia 5y agoAmongst other gripes people have mentioned (and I agree with), here's another: cut. There does not seem to be a way to cut and paste a file/folder. The best I could figure out is to drag the icons, hold down the finger, and move the cursor to the desired folder on the sidebar (or another window) and release the finger. This is either extremely difficult to pull of, or I am less dexterous than I think I am. Why not have cut as an option in the drop down menu? I really can't figure this one out. What UX mantra suggests this. Also, dragging files around is also a difficult feat to overcome. You either press down too hard (end up opening all selected files in their target applications -- RIP ram, let's restart the computer), or too gently and nothing happens.
- lawkwok 5y agoTry Command + Option + V to paste and delete the source file (cut and paste). I remember this command was I implemented a few years back and I think it was to reduce chances of unpasted files from disappearing or something. In fact, opening any menu and pressing option reveals many secondary functions.
- karaterobot 5y agoThis was one of my big gripes about MacOS when I had to use it for work. Evidently what you need to do is copy the file, then hold down OPT (along with CMD-V) when you paste it. You'll hear a sound effect that tells you it worked. If you right click to open the context menu, and press OPT, you'll even see the "paste item" option turn into "move item". It's 100% the wrong way to do it. Maddeningly wrong. In a world where CTRL-X hadn't existed for decades, and Apple's way of doing it was the norm, if someone came along and "invented" CTRL-X for the cut command, it would be universally recognized as an improvement.
- geraltofrivia 5y agoThis seems to be one of those things that Apple leans hard towards, just because. à la the lightening port.
- rewgs 5y ago
- throwaddzuzxd 5y agoThe Finder is atrocious. It's the worst default macOS app and probably the worst program period I've ever used. It's been so dumbed down that it's basically unusable for anyone slightly experienced. - There's no way to create an empty file - There's no easy way to cut a file/folder (Cmd-x doesn't work) - There's no (?) way to keep everything consistently sorted and aligned - ~~Tags are useless and just take up space for nothing~~ This one is entirely subjective. I retract it. - No "parent folder"... There's some great features in Finder but it sucks at so many things it's just frustrating to use. Windows Explorer is infinitely better. It has less cool features (no tabs for instance) but is so much better to actually use. I get that some features are hidden to avoid confusing non savvy users, but preventing experimented users to do basic stuff is criminal.
- Angostura 5y agoI use tags all the time, so Im not sure why you find them useless. And what do you mean - no parent folder?
- coldtea 5y ago>- There's no way to create an empty file Create it for what? To use to launch the app that handles it? Just open the respective app and save an empty or unedited file. >- There's no easy way to cut a file/folder (Cmd-x doesn't work) Copy as regularly (Cmd-C), and use Option-Cmd-V to move the file where you want to. >- There's no (?) way to keep everything consistently sorted and aligned Not sure what you mean. >- Tags are useless and just take up space for nothing They're useful if you use them. Many people do use them. What exactly would you do with that "space" anyway? It's not like they take space in your apartment. It's a UI element which you can use or not use. >- No "parent folder"... Cmd+up arrow or Go -> Enclosing Folder. Looks like all of the complains are basically "they're not where they was on Windows".
- bane 5y agoYou successfully managed to confirm all of the parent's complaints by showing that they aren't achievable in Finder, or don't follow a consistent convention and have to be done some other way.
- BombNullIsland 5y agoI moved to mac during Vista, switched back for 7, and then bailed after Windows 8. I'm still running 7 on my gaming/video editing machine. Microsoft needs to stop fucking with working UIs. Metro (or whatever they call it now) is a worthless eyesore full of ads and distracting rotating, flipping, bouncing UI elements. Get out of my face and let me do my work.
- coldtea 5y ago>Why is it that when I click Finder, nothing actually opens? I have to hit Option+N to actually display a Finder window. Clicking Finder will open a new Finder window if none was created thus far, or bring up a minimized window. >Don't even get me started on the sort options. What kind of file manager applies a Sort view to every single directory, instead of the one you actually set the Sort view to? Not sure what you mean. If I click to select a sort view, it's applied to the directory I'm looking at.
- rchaud 5y agoI should have written it more clearly. It applies the sort view globally to all folders. What I want is the sort applied only to the folder I'm currently in.
- coldtea 5y agoYou can use the global sort view settings, or you can right click, and chose Sort to override in the folder you're in. Or in table view, you can click the column bar and sort accordingly.
- thefz 5y agoFinder is irritating but don't let me started on iTunes if you want to manage a "physical" mp3 collection...
- samatman 5y ago> Why is it that when I click Finder, nothing actually opens? This would be an example of the 10% of the UI which isn't identical. One of the fundamental differences between macOS and Windows is the menu bar. There's only one at a time, and it belongs to the program which has the focus. A corollary of this is that you don't need a window to have a program. It's not just Finder, most macOS programs are perfectly happy having no window open. I've been on OS X since 2003, and it took me a second to figure out what you were talking about here, because if I don't see the window I expect to see, my eyes immediately flick to the upper-left corner. If I see what I expect to see, I've probably already typed Cmd-N or Cmd-O, depending. There's a lot to complain about with Finder; my personal peeve is that I want two-finger-swipe-right to go back one directory, like the back button in browsers. But this particular behavior is just macOS working the way that it does. If you close all open windows in Preview and quit, then start it again, it will do the same thing.
- shawnz 5y agoRight, so it's not a problem with Finder but actually the window manager. Why would you ever want to have a "menubar-only" app? It would be better if the design didn't create the possibility of that happening at all.
- samatman 5y agoSee I firmly disagree with this. If I have some document editor open, and I close all the documents, what should happen? Should it quit? Well if I wanted to quit, I would have done so. Should it display some blank pane? Why? To let me know it's still running? The menu bar does that! I say it should close that last window, and then I can open up another one and keep working. In other words, I want to have a "menubar-only" app every time I'm done with all the windows I had open, and intend to open more. This happens frequently enough that I'm glad macOS works the way it does.
- shawnz 5y agoWhen you are done with all the windows in your editor, do you open a new window by choosing File > New? You don't open a new window by clicking the dock icon? If you close all the tabs in a browser window, should it close the window or display a new tab page? Or just do nothing but show an empty tab bar and a blank window pane? That seems like the worst possible solution, because it always requires more clicks to do whatever you were intending to do. At least closing the window or opening a new tab will save you some clicks 50% of the time.
- ryanmccullagh 5y agoAnd why can't you ever 'close' Finder? One can only hide it.
- robertoandred 5y agoWhy can't you close Windows Explorer?
- rchaud 5y agoYou can. explorer.exe may still be running as a process, but visually its presence can be eliminated from the GUI.
- robertoandred 5y agoWhich sounds just like the Finder?
- Steltek 5y agoExcept I get a new window when I click on the Explorer icon. So no, it's the opposite of Finder's fail-silent behavior.
- dabernathy89 5y agoWhen I click the Finder icon in my dock, or open it with Alfred, I get a new Finder window. Doesn't appear to be a configurable setting. Not sure what's wrong with your setup.
- m463 5y agoI find one thing very very very useful with finder. spacebar to preview. select multiple items to preview them all.
- m463 5y agoWhen I click the finder icon, I get a finder window. As to ease of use... MacOS is not easier to learn - it has just as many quirks as windows, except in different places. However, I have found it much more consistent than any other desktop. The menubar is one example - always there in the same place, with all the File, Edit, etc menus as expected. Keys are consistent (mostly) consistency is the key.
- carabiner 5y agoI mean, you're biased by an entire lifetime of using Windows. So you'll likely find whatever you're used to "easier to use" - using a GUI vs a CLI, typing in QWERTY, being righthanded, speaking English, driving on the righthand side of the road, and so on.
- mumblemumble 5y ago> Maybe this sentiment is a holdover from an earlier era It's a holdover from two different earlier eras. First, you have everything up to about 1998, which covers MacOS Classic through Mac OS 8, and Windows up through Win98. At the beginning of this period, when "PC" meant MS-DOS, the usability difference was obviously stark. But even in GUI era of PCs, System 7 compared favorably with Windows 3.1, and Mac OS 8 compared favorably with Windows 95. Then Windows 98 and Mac OS 9 came out, and I'd say that things at least evened up. All else being equal, OS 9's GUI was still simpler and more intuitive, to my taste, but all else was not equal. Windows 9x had memory protection and pre-emptive multitasking, and Mac OS Classic didn't, and there were issues with system extensions and stability in Mac OS that I personally felt were more troublesome than Windows's famous BSOD problem during that era. This opinion could be a product of my experience working tech support at the time. BSOD was usually fixed by cursing profusely while rebooting. System extension conflicts were fixed at great physical and emotional cost to the person doing the fixing. So I'd say Windows was generally easier to use than Macs for a while, until OS X eventually came into its own. It's harder to place a start time on this, but let's say 2002ish, with the release of Jaguar. And then there's been a sort of long slow decline as they clutter up the GUI, while at the same time Microsoft was putting serious work into cleaning things up. I'm not sure if the switch happened during the Windows 7 era or the Windows 10 era, but yeah, I'd definitely say I find Windows easier to use nowadays. Personally, the main thing keeping me on Macs nowadays is frankly just the touchpad, to which I seem to be addicted.
- eatbitseveryday 5y ago> Why is it that when I click Finder, nothing actually opens? Perhaps this was changed now? Big Sur does open a new window for me.
- dsego 5y agoWhat kind of file manager doesn't have tabs? Windows explorer.
- derefr 5y ago> From a UI perspective, it's 90% identical to windows. That's convergent evolution. The UIs started off very different. MacOS's current set of UI abstractions was mostly enshrined in an era when its competitor was Windows 3.1. > Why is it that when I click Finder, nothing actually opens? I was going to give a few justifications for this, but I just tested it, and clicking on the Finder icon in the Dock does open a new Finder window for me. (In Big Sur. This definitely wasn't always the case; I'm not certain when it changed.) But those justifications, for the long period where it didn't, are still kind of interesting/relevant: 1. the Desktop is a Finder window. IIRC, on some versions of macOS, using a switcher to focus the Finder would — if you don't have any open Finder windows — focus the desktop (insofar as keyboard navigation goes.) 2. You can do useful things with the Finder without any windows open. IIRC, Apple's HIG only recommends creating a new window in response to a click on the app's icon (and or having a Cmd-0 accelerator), if the app is useless without having a window open. But the Finder has a bunch of menu-items in the "Go" menu (with keyboard accelerators) to open windows showing specific locations, or to open dialogs for connecting to networks, etc. It'd be annoying if you wanted to open one of these, but focusing the Finder always opened a default window you had to get rid of first. I personally often focus the Finder and then press Cmd+K to mount an SMB share on my NAS, then immediately close the resulting window, because the point was to get it mounted for command-line use.
- MonaroVXR 5y ago> Sort view The stock file manager in Fedora, Pop!_OS and Ubuntu do this. And it's great, so you don't have to make all your folders the same. Not sure about the Finder Window though.
- fukmbas 5y agoInstalling an application is even worse. Drag here, long click there. What the hell, just install it
- tablespoon 5y ago> I bought a Mac in 2014 after a lifetime of using Windows. I never understood why people called it easier to use than Windows. Maybe this sentiment is a holdover from an earlier era when people would mindlessly run executables and zip files attached in emails and AIM messages. IMHO, it's mainly holdover from when Windows was DOS. For a very long time using a Mac was kind of like a religion (they even had explicit evangelists), and many people who used Macs were irrationally attached to the platform. One of the main tenets of the faith was that Macs were much easier to use than PCs (because GUI and no autoexec.bat and IRQ assignment, etc). I think that meme has gotten stuck in popular consciousness, even though Windows has had literally 30+ years to catch up. Also, especially since the OS X era, I think the usability of Macs has stagnated or even regressed in many ways.
- estaseuropano 5y agoÇa 2008, one of my first times using MacOS, I had to move thousands of photos using a friends macbook. After hours of moving files from SD cards to a en external harddisk I learned that Mac standard behavior is not 'merge folders with the same name into one another' as on any other OS, but rather to replace folders with the same name completely. Whoever sets the standard behavior of such an important operation as destructive seriously knows nothing about UI.
- notriskfree 5y agoThe Mac finder always drives me nuts for the same reason. Both the finder and explorer are tedious to use. I drag the explorer to the task bar and open it by right clicking File Explorer. Both seem to prefer creating new folders to creating new views of the file system.