12 ms·
Sixth grader expelled after Zoom provided possibly inaccurate IP address
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- diogenesjunior 5y agowhen the zoom ip is sus
- sschueller 5y ago"Our apologies, unfortunately our website is currently unavailable in most European countries due to GDPR rules." It's 2021, Come on. Also I'm in Switzerland which is not in the EU and not part of the GDPR.
- bpodgursky 5y agoThis website owes you nothing.
- portemonnaie 5y agoWhy should they bother to cater to EU rulings?
- greenwich26 5y agoEvidently they don't, since I live in the EU and I was able to bypass their retarded IP-block in one click.
- lucb1e 5y agoWell they do. If they didn't care and weren't planning to comply with EU rulings, they wouldn't have put a block in place to avoid processing data of EU citizens. (Also, 90% of complying with GDPR is just ethics -- tell if you sell data to third parties, ask consent if you want to do nonessential processing, etc. -- and 10% is adding boilerplate text like reiterating your rights. But that's a bit of a separate discussion, I just feel like most people are not aware of this when starting these discussions and it might be good to know when talking about the topic.)
- portemonnaie 5y agoGDPR didn't really work out that way, everybody still tries to collect and sell as much data as possible, only with more clicks. But that's besides the point. To be honest I also don't see the point of the EU blocks, as you say. I assumed it was mostly just lazyness and unwillingness to deal with the issue at all.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- underseacables 5y agoHow long do we reach a point until the police finally recognize an IP address is not a person?
- sathackr 5y agoDon't think the police were involved here? Regardless the [bad] police will never care and the good ones are likely mostly ignorant. It's the judges and DAs that need to learn. Even more so now with more carriers doing CGNAT (and this number will go up as IPv4 gets more and more expensive.)
- elliekelly 5y agoThere isn't a DA involved because it isn't a criminal matter and there isn't a judge involved (yet) because there isn't a law suit (yet). It's the local school board who needs to learn but I suspect they care more about saving face than this little boy's education or even their own. Here's hoping their appeal to the state board of education goes well.
- jstarfish 5y agoSchool SROs are sworn police officers.
- OJFord 5y agoGood lord.. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_resource_officer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_resource_officer (Non-American perspective.)
- st_goliath 5y ago> How long do we reach a point until [people] finally recognize an IP address is not a person? "But I've seen it on CSI! Everybody knows that that's how this hacker stuff works." Well that, plus we hired an expert who said "possibly", so we've got em!
- koheripbal 5y agoWhile that's not relevant in this case, the ISP can correlate an IP address and datetime to an account, which can definitely narrow down the suspects from millions/billions to a single household.
- ratww 5y agoArchive copy: https://archive.is/OiQir https://archive.is/OiQir
- WarOnPrivacy 5y agoAppreciated
- ratww 5y ago> but four other students who did not appear to be Zoom bombers were also listed as having Malachi’s public IP address, an impossibility since they were not in the same house Could be Zoom messing up their logs, but could also be NAT from the provider. A few years ago, me and my sister noticed we had the same IPv4 address, despite not living in the same household. We had different IPv6, though. It seems to be becoming more and more prevalent due to IPv4 exhaustion.
- valleyer 5y agoYeah, sounds possibly like: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carrier-grade_NAT https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carrier-grade_NAT
- dreamcompiler 5y agoThat was my first thought. I wonder what software reported the IP address? If it's the Zoom client then it's obviously meaningless because it's guaranteed to be in a private IP address range (if it's IPv4). If it's the Zoom server and CGN is being used by the student's ISP, then it's equally meaningless because while that will be a public IP address, it could be shared by 100 households. I'm also assuming the "experts" didn't make the bone-headed mistake of failing to verify the IP address was in a public range, but I've seen dumber errors.
- matja 5y agoThis is DS-Lite (Dual Stack). Entire regions of ISP users may share a single IPv4 address. There are some IPv4-only websites I visit that show a CloudFlare captcha on every single visit (for 30 mins), presumably because they see a huge number of requests from this one NAT IP.
- ratww 5y agoInteresting! I was not familiar with the term DS-Lite! https://techmusa.com/dual-stack-lite/ https://techmusa.com/dual-stack-lite/
- zu03776 5y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20210522204453/https://ajc.com/news/gwinnett-student-challenges-suspension-over-zoom-bombing-allegations/UMQAYE3COVAB3DE4M2Q6QPHVCI/ https://web.archive.org/web/20210522204453/https://ajc.com/n...
- marcinzelent 5y agoThanks! I couldn't read the article because I'm in Europe.
- benhurmarcel 5y agoFor non-Europeans wondering: https://imgur.com/a/H9cU2EZ https://imgur.com/a/H9cU2EZ
- content_sesh 5y ago> The Zoom bombers’ public IP addresses matched Malachi’s — but four other students who did not appear to be Zoom bombers were also listed as having Malachi’s public IP address, an impossibility since they were not in the same house, said Scott Moulton, a Woodstock-based forensics expert hired by the attorney working on Malachi’s case. So in other words, 5 students plus the zoom bomber had the same "public IP address" (probably due to NATing) in this list, and they picked him as the culprit. What did they do, roll a dice?
- LorenPechtel 5y agoI'm going to guess he was the first one to show up and they quit looking at that point.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- KaoruAoiShiho 5y agoSounds like a story well suited for gofundme.
- lostlogin 5y agoHow is a suspension that long even vaguely appropriate? At some point the school is just abandoning the kid and their future. If the kid did it there needs to be a punishment, but surely education is a key part of what needs to happen?
- Zak 5y agoIt's likely connected to school shootings. A student making threats results in long-term suspension or expulsion as well as criminal charges for the protection of other students (a suspended student who shows up at school can be arrested for trespassing without any other suspicious behavior). The lack of criminal charges in this case suggests the evidence isn't strong enough to support them, and it seems to me that similar standards should be applied to a long-term suspension or expulsion.
- Spooky23 5y agoSounds like a big school district with administration that is a bunch of assholes. Making disciplinary referrals to a police officer is gross. My sister had a classmate who ended up with a felony conviction for counterfeiting money, using a low-end HP OfficeJet and glueing two sides together as a joke. It was absurd, to the point the sentencing judge made his displeasure known.
- deathhand 5y agoThere is a system and it will be used. It is important for everyone reading this that either takes part or directs their own little systems to ask the question, what is the ramifications of this being abused? This can relate to cyber security, social fabric, and school systems. We all don't have to play along and it's important for everyone to stand up for what is right. (Says the misfit who befriended their SRO[school resource officer])
- Spooky23 5y agoAgreed. My beef is the chickenshit school people who escalate things out of laziness or malice. Heck, the teacher’s doubts made it into the article.
- liveoneggs 5y agothe article keeps saying "LOCAL ip address" and "reconfigure his router" so it appears they might be talking about 10.0.0.0/8 addresses.
- dfgasdgsd 5y agoYeah I'm assuming his computer was in 192.168.x.x and the local ip was 10.x.x.x.
- dcdc123 5y agoThey mentioned local and public IPs. Five students, including the one suspended, shared their public IPs with the zoom bombers. The client also reports its local IP and none of the zoom bombers had local IPs that matched the student's.
- jessaustin 5y agoI was not surprised to discover that a student kicked out of a USA public school based on clearly ridiculous accusations happens to be black.
- nrmitchi 5y ago> Malachi was suspended through the end of the school year, exactly three months. In what world is a 3 month suspension appropriate at all? At that point you're basically expelling the student. This sounds like they're purposely setting this kid up for failure with this "suspension"; I don't see how it's possible for them to pass the grade given they were suspended for 30% of it. This punishment is effectively "You fail the grade for something that is unrelated to your performance" (with extremely shoddy evidence at that). Even if this student was guilty of 'zoom bombing', why is "failing the entire grade" a reasonable punishment?
- a3n 5y agoI suspect there was bureaucratic and personal digging in once the district and its technical staff were challenged.
- lamontcg 5y agoYou know that Family Guy meme with the skin tones?
- labster 5y agoWelcome to America, where we use political correctness to put people of color in their place. We’re only a couple decades removed from that kid getting a beating by the cops, so things are improving. So three months suspension is getting off light. Our schools don’t have solitary confinement yet but I’m sure we’ll get there someday. Sure, we could try treating the student as a person, but that just makes it harder for society to exact the retribution it so deeply desires.
- iudqnolq 5y ago> Our schools don’t have solitary confinement yet "The spaces have gentle names: The reflection room. The cool-down room. The calming room. The quiet room. But shut inside them, in public schools across the state, children as young as 5 wail for their parents, scream in anger and beg to be let out." https://features.propublica.org/illinois-seclusion-rooms/school-students-put-in-isolated-timeouts/ https://features.propublica.org/illinois-seclusion-rooms/sch...
- ALittleLight 5y agoHuge mistake to refer to this as a "Zoom bombing". That kind of language is unnecessarily incendiary. This is a boy using bad words. He should be scolded, get detention, forced to do chores of some kind (at my school misbehaving students had to clean the cafeteria). Suspending or effectively expelling this boy is an egregious overstep - unless there's something that the article is leaving out.
- ddingus 5y agoAnd a suspension really won't work to improve his choices.
- hellomyguys 5y agoAfter reading the article I’m not sure I have the same takeaway that this child did anything?
- ngngngng 5y agoEven if he did do what he was accused of (he likely didn't), the punishment is bizarrely overdone.
- bittercynic 5y agoIt's unfortunate that "bombing" is part of this, but it is a reference to photobombing, which is a cute/funny prank, not a violent offense.
- plussed_reader 5y agoI'm curious the tech backend that corroborated these details for the site/district staff to make a decision.
- renewiltord 5y agoYet another reason why government services in the US are a bad idea. They are ruled by local arbitrarily-capricious lunatics. Universal health care will be the same disaster. Fight it tooth and nail. Protect your healthcare. Maybe you win the case where your son is denied an online advice nurse because he “yelled racial slurs” but it’s too late; maybe he’s terribly sick now, maybe he’s dead. You can sue them but you can’t bring him back. Just like this kid’s grade is gone. He fails this one. And you can sue but he’s not going to get it back. The learning is gone. Constantly beware those who arrogate to themselves great power over you.
- hellomyguys 5y agoAs opposed to private services? Have you ever had a medical bill that your insurance provider tried to deny coverage for?
- renewiltord 5y agoSure, but I know private schools are better about this so now you’re adding the horror of normal medical care in the US to this public services horror. Twice the horror is hardly an appealing idea.
- foobar33333 5y ago>Sure, but I know private schools are better about this In my experience, private schools are much more likely to expel someone than public schools. At my private school they tried to work out who was writing prank reviews of the school online and threatened that they had requested the users IP from the review service. I'm guessing they failed when the IP was just the schools shared address.
- renewiltord 5y agoYeah, but I can go somewhere else, rather than be blackballed by the single system.
- 5y ago
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoThis type of event reminds me why it's unbelievably dangerous to have the decision making of someone's life at the hands of people who don't understand tech is prone to errors. "The computer is never wrong" is a pretty scary statement knowing that code behind the scenes still isn't flawless and can break.
- nix23 5y ago>Our apologies, unfortunately our website is currently unavailable in most European countries due to GDPR rules. I love it, thanks for your apologies.
- fauria 5y agoAJC Atlanta. News. Now. Our apologies, unfortunately our website is currently unavailable in most European countries due to GDPR rules. Well, the 4 Internets... https://stratechery.com/2020/india-jio-and-the-four-internets/ https://stratechery.com/2020/india-jio-and-the-four-internet...
- corobo 5y agoWe still doin this EU block thing? Wonder what GDPR rules they're not compliant with https://cdn.imgy.org/rOyn.png https://cdn.imgy.org/rOyn.png
- Tabular-Iceberg 5y agoFor starters using the range ban dodge, as if an EU data subject can’t conceivably use a VPN to circumvent it.
- Aerroon 5y agoMaybe they just don't want to spend money on figuring out whether they're compliant or not? It's not like they'd be making much money from serving Atlanta news to Europeans.
- corobo 5y agoIt amazes me that there's people on HN who play fast and loose with their data to defend a company that clearly doesn't care about the safety of it It's easy to be GDPR compliant. It just is. You do have to respect your users though, I can see why many companies had trouble with it
- Aerroon 5y agoIt amazes me that there are people on HN that don't want to acknowledge that complying with regulation costs money even if you're doing everything right. Just to simply figure out what the regulation says will cost a fair amount in lawyers. If a company can't justify this cost because Europeans don't make them money, then why would they do it?! >It's easy to be GDPR compliant. And that's why companies spent millions on just paying lawyers to figure out what it said, right? >But when it comes to the cost of maintaining GDPR compliance, it found that 88% spend more than $1 million and 40% spend more than $10 million. https://www.itgovernance.eu/blog/en/how-much-does-gdpr-compliance-cost-in-2020 https://www.itgovernance.eu/blog/en/how-much-does-gdpr-compl... If European customers don't make them this money back then there is no point in doing it. It sucks for us, Europeans, but the EU decided for us that we shouldn't have easy access to the whole internet.
- cyberpunk 5y ago"Our apologies, unfortunately our website is currently unavailable in most European countries due to GDPR rules." ..... Yeah...
- Black101 5y agoHow can they be so retarded? I guess that's what you get when you hire 1000 people to do the job of 1 person.
- jasonhansel 5y ago> The Zoom bombers’ local IP addresses, which identify the exact device being used Why would Zoom even be logging the local (private) IP address?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dylan604 5y ago"Malachi’s family said they want to clear his name and expunge the incident from his record," I understand the need/want to get rid of bullshit like this from one's record. However, it's now all over the internet and the internet does not forget. Will this expungement include every news article that clearly uses his name and details of the accusations? Will that also include any articles detailing the final results if he is cleared (if news actually covers that part)?
- ThrustVectoring 5y agoIt's pretty cheap to send letters to news sites legal departments after a victory in court over the district, demanding an amendment to the story or removal of the child's name. Most sane newspapers would not risk a defamation suit over it.
- disgrunt 5y ago> The Gwinnett County Board of Education on Thursday rejected his appeal of the suspension. The institutional doubling down like this never ceases to amaze.
- Bluecobra 5y agoMoulton said the school district’s technology employee who investigated should have been able to tell that many of the IP addresses in the Zoom report were wrong. I don’t think the education sector is going to attract many high caliber IT people. The school shouldn’t have had this rest on the shoulders of a low wattage tech.
- Abishek_Muthian 5y agoFalse accusation for children especially if the accusation goes totally against their values can have profound negative consequences. When I was in grade school(early 2000, India), I went out to take a photo-copy(xerox) of a study material in a shop nearby school. After I returned to the class, I was called to the headmistress office; The shopkeeper was there and I was falsely accused of stealing his mobile phone. HM defended me for my good character and that was the end of it. All my life I have been taught to return things which I find to the rightful owner by my parents. When I was even younger I have returned expensive things to the school authorities like Timex data-link watch when I didn't have a watch. Couple of days later I learnt from another student that someone notorious for stealing things in our school was the one who stole that phone. I didn't do anything about it. I had nightmares of that incident when I was a child. Mental health/Counseling was not a thing in India(Still isn't for most). I had been ruminating on 'Why me, I'm not a thief' for a long time. In my late 20s I found that thief on Facebook, He was a DJ in an European country. My friend request was accepted, My goal was to ask him about the incident, May be if he accepted his wrong-doing I could have some closure. I didn't ask him. I'm 34 now, My philosophy towards life have changed and so is my understanding of science. I think the reason shop keeper accused me was just because of cognitive bias. I'm a dwarf with visible limb deformities. I think the shop keeper accused me, because he remembered just me in a shop where there could be two dozen people anytime. Now I'm overtly conscious of my environment and cognitive biases of people who see me due to my disability. If you have read till now, Thank you for your time.
- rsync 5y agoI wish you peace and well-being.
- Abishek_Muthian 5y agoThank you. It's scary to think that incompetence of a large software developer can put children through lot more trouble than I faced. I hope U.S. judiciary system can provide faster closure to this child.
- bawolff 5y agoAssuming dynamic ip addresses are fixed and not shared (was he on an open wifi? Did he have subilings sharing wifi) Seems silly > The Zoom bombers’ local IP addresses, which identify the exact device being used, did not match Malachi’s And his device cant be multihomed? He cant have two devices? > Nor did the local IP addresses match any of the possible sequences available under the configuration of the router in Malachi’s house, Moulton said. There were no other routers or devices in the house that could have used those local IP addresses, Moulton said. > It is possible to change a router’s configuration, but Malachi did not know how and the process would have kicked all his devices off the internet for 10 minutes each time, according to the appeal. Or you know, setting up another NAT layer on the computer, or any other of many other configs. I mean fair, that's a bit much for an 11 year old, but still lots of theoretically possible explanations -- They're blaming zoom as innacurate, but it seems like both sides are making assumptions about ip addresses that might just not be true. The entire thing is utterly rediculous.
- FateOfNations 5y agoThere is also the possibility of CG-NAT being involved. Thousands of customers sharing a single IPv4 address...
- voiper1 5y ago> > The Zoom bombers’ local IP addresses, which identify the exact device being used, did not match Malachi’s > And his device cant be multihomed? He cant have two devices? He could. But the only evidence of his guilt is the IP address.
- bawolff 5y agoRight. The evidence for his guilt is BS, but the counter-evidence is kind attacking a weird part of the evidence.
- tomcooks 5y ago> Our apologies, unfortunately our website is currently unavailable in most European countries due to GDPR rules. A recap?
- zhdc1 5y agoPlease stop posting georestricted links. I don't even live in the EU and all I see is an "Unavailable... GDPR" banner.
- milankragujevic 5y agoThis is yet another reason why CGNAT (Carrier grade NAT) is cancer on the internet and needs to die.