9 ms·
A competitive market would enable me to sort by salary and benefits and apply for the best job. However companies don't want to compete on salary, and potentia
by ClumsyPilot 5y ago
A competitive market would enable me to sort by salary and benefits and apply for the best job.
However companies don't want to compete on salary, and potentialy drive them up - they want maximum leverage. They get more leverage if process is obscure, so that you only agree salary late in the process and for the applicant, pulling out is risky.
The market is not really free - its being manipulated by one side.
Similarly with healthcare you don't know how much you will be charged upfront, so there is no competition on price.
With housing (in UK) there is no competition on quality because the seller doesn't have to disclose any problems with the house. If it falls of a cliff the minute you sign on the dotted line, it's your problem.
You have to pay for the surveyor to find out any issues the house might have, and that means you can only view a few houses before you've paid the house price in survey fees.
- nairboon 5y agoThere should be a job board exactly like that, with base salary x + y% per year specific experience for 1-10y, z% 11-20y etc. and u% per year for general industry experience.
- Finnucane 5y agoIn the US, real estate sellers have to disclose known problems, but they can claim they didn't know, and then you might have to fight it out in court. It's still in your interest to get an inspection before closing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ensignavenger 5y agoThis varies somewhat by state, as I understand. Some states only require disclosure for specific classes of problems.
- sidlls 5y agoThat's why people include inspection clauses in their offer contracts. If the inspection reveals an issue it must then be disclosed by the seller going forward, if the buyer can back out due to the clause.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- calvinmorrison 5y agoSort of, except recruiters definitely know salary ranges. I don't always use recruiters but I did previously and was placed well every time. They're a annoying middleman that can really help.
- gambiting 5y ago>>With housing (in UK) there is no competition on quality because the seller doesn't have to disclose any problems with the house. If it falls of a cliff the minute you sign on the dotted line, it's your problem. I'm in the UK and that's absolutely not true. If you think the owner knew about the problem and purposefully omitted telling you, then you definitely have a court case and any law firm worth their salt will win this. I bought a house recently and the documents the sellers had to fill out for the solicitors very clearly say there are are no known issues with this house, so if that's a lie then the sale can be rendered null and void. >>You have to pay for the surveyor to find out any issues the house might have, and that means you can only view a few houses before you've paid the house price in survey fees. I've had a few mortgages so far and I'm yet to find a bank not willing to cover the cost of a full survey, as the bank also wants to know the house they are securing the loan against is actually worth the money.
- aaronax 5y agoThe bank may be requiring the survey but you are paying for it. If not directly then at least in a very clear indirect way.
- gambiting 5y agoThe last mortgage I took was with Bank of Ireland, they offered a full survey for £400 but I rang them and asked if they would do it for free if I took their mortgage on completion - they said yes, so I paid nothing for the survey. Other mortgages I had the survey was just included in the mortgage, no extra cost.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoIn sane countries the seller must comission a survey and provide it to the buyer. The UK system where each buyer comissions a survey is absurd. I do not understand how the mortgage helps you - you are still paying for it, and if the survey uncovers issues, you either take mortgage on a house with problems, or you are out of pocket. If you pull out, and next house you view has issues too, you have to take it because at some poijt you run out of money
- bb123 5y agoThats just nonsense. There absolutely is a requirement to disclose known faults with the property, and if a survey (which every buyer does) shows up something serious, there is a legal requirement to disclose it to all parties. Also most banks will cover the cost of a survey.
- sokoloff 5y agoThe buyer is the only one bringing money into the transaction. Regardless of who signs the check, the buyer is paying for all of the things.
- bb123 5y agoThats true, but you really can't have it both ways. You either want a professional opinion on the quality of the house or you're willing to run the risk. Anyway, the banks aren't doing inspections for the benefit of the buyer. They want to know that should the house be repossessed they are likely to recoup their investment. The fact the buyer might find something out about the house is a happy side effect.
- mountainb 5y agoInspections are pretty cheap at least in the US. Inconsequential compared to the price of the house or any other expense related to buying, really.
- bb123 5y agoCorrect - the homebuyers report on my house cost £300.
- ck425 5y ago> With housing (in UK) there is no competition on quality because the seller doesn't have to disclose any problems with the house. Note that that's an issue on England (and presumably Wales too?). It's not the case in Scotland. Not sure about NI.
- dghf 5y ago> You have to pay for the surveyor to find out any issues the house might have, and that means you can only view a few houses before you've paid the house price in survey fees. How much are you paying for surveys? Even a full structural survey -- which would be considered over the top for most purchases -- should only cost £1,500 or so. And you're not going to get any sort of survey for most of the houses you view. You only usually bother with one once you've made an offer and the vendor's accepted it: if the survey reveals anything significant, you either pull out or try to renegotiate the price.
- cecilpl2 5y ago> You only usually bother with one once you've made an offer and the vendor's accepted it. This is no longer the case in most of North America, where your offer only has a chance of being accepted if it's unconditional.
- dboreham 5y agoHmm. I lived in the UK (both England and Scotland, which are slightly different) for 1st 1/2 of my life then moved to USA. In my experience the housing market is one of the few things that is handled pretty much the same.
- sandworm101 5y ago>> The market is not really free - its being manipulated by one side. The market is free, it just isn't a healthy market. Those are different concepts. Participants in a totally free market are free to use their size/power/leverage as they wish. A free market is one where the little guy, the job applicant, will be hammered by the big guy. A 'healthy' market is one that is regulated in such a way that the little guy has at least a hope in the negotiation process. This then fosters competition, innovation, yielding a free-but-healthy market. Regulation needed to do those things that the "free" market cannot.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoExactly - if you are free to manipulate the market, then it decends into Mafia game. If you call that 'free market', then its like communism - a concept that never works in the real world
- cblconfederate 5y agoProfit most often rests on the asymmetry of information, thats why monopolies are so profitable
- compiler-guy 5y agoMonopoly profits are based on dominant market power, not asymmetry of information.
- insert_coin 5y agoWhere is the "dominant market power" coming from? Asymmetry of information is what got you to the top. You know more than your competition, more on a productive process, on consumer behavior, on business partners, on leveraging financial avenues, on political "contributions", on questionable use of insider information, etc. And Information is what keeps you at the top: knowing who to "lobby" to create convenient regulation that hurts your competition the most, is the most effective way monopolies use to stay that way. Monopolies are not monopolies in the abstract, they have to fight everyday to keep being a monopoly and they do that by leveraging information asymmetry.
- dcow 5y agoIt’s not simply asymmetry of information though. Monopolies often have an incredible amount of financial power that they deploy against people trying to enter their market. Or maybe a company is on top because of their execution. I really don’t think the entire phenomenon can be explained by information asymmetry.
- insert_coin 5y agoThe financial power comes from somewhere. > Or maybe a company is on top because of their execution. I already explained that part.
- compiler-guy 5y agoThe at&t monopoly came about via government power, and the only fighting it did was to keep the government enforcing and maintaining the monopoly.
- xyzelement 5y ago> A competitive market would enable me to sort by salary and benefits and apply for the best job. I am always surprised to see comments that make it sound like jobs (or, employees) are fungible commodities that can be bought and sold purely on price. One simple example - two jobs may have the same title (Senior Developer, or whatever) but have totally different expectations of communication skills, leadership skills, ability to handle pressure, etc and would pay very differently. So you (and everyone else) would be tempted to apply for the top-paying job but potentially not be qualified. Or the situation where a company is very flexible on who they hire and thus would pay a lot more or a lot less depending on what the individual brings to the table. In a way, I think there's a bit of "you don't know what you don't know" principle at play here. If someone has limited perspective on how career development, seniority, and hiring work, they may really believe that the big problem is "I can't sort my opportunities by salary." Someone with more experience and understanding may recognize how non-fungible people and roles can be in a way that a simple "sort by price" cannot capture. To use your real-estate analogy, would you ever buy a house that came up first in a price-sort? No, you'd both want to really understand the nuances of the house (location, condition, etc.) and how it compares to your needs and your ability to pay. IE, you'd often take "not the best price" because either there's something wrong with the property or it's just not suitable to your needs." Hiring is much the same.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoWe do recognise that, and that's why you publish a salary range. If your salary range for a dev is 50k - 90k, then publish that. The point, a candidate who know they are a good developer can know what to expect. If someone shows up for interview with leadrship skills so amazing they can run the whole company and you want to pay them 4x, then it's probably a different job, maybe a TeamLead. Publish several jobs and just fill one of them, cancell others. But the argument is bordering on "we are so flexible we have no structure at all and we have no clue what we are doing" and is difficult to taje seriously.
- sidlls 5y agoIt's a bit presumptuous to suggest the OP "has limited perspective on how career development, seniority, and hiring work". Also, I most certainly do sort by price when I'm looking for real estate: I have a budget, after all. Same thing with employment: most people have needs that salary requirements can meet, and it's pointless to look for jobs outside the range one can accept. Therefore it's almost certainly the best and most useful first thing to sort by. Others have more freedom. For example, thanks to a recent IPO I can literally work for no salary and be fine. I have far more freedom to consider other details about a job than 99% of the population.
- ramblerman 5y ago> A competitive market would enable me to sort by salary and benefits and apply for the best job. The idea that there would be a bunch of generic job listings with fixed salaries makes you essentially a replacable drone with no unique value, and sounds horrible to me. Also a free market doesn't need to be absolutely transparent. That's just something you would want because it sounds like it would be easier, but uncertainties about the future, unknowns, and consumer wants is what drives the whole pricing game to begin with.
- an_opabinia 5y agoIf people want to better negotiate their salaries, they have to unionize. Everything else is just unproven, speculative, untested pitter patter.
- gryn 5y agowhy do you think a union would help in this ? I live in france and all big enough companies are mandated to have union, doesn't mean that they help with salaries.
- Mauricebranagh 5y agoIs this a managerial / professional union? Those normally negotiate the banding and the COL increases and also know what the rates are. Unions in the entertainment industries do :-) underpay or stiff workers and you get put on the "call first list" this is the PC name for another type of list.
- true_religion 5y agoYou know it'd break the cartel-like control companies have over employees if a law were made that all jobs must payout within the salary range posted for the job. That prevents people from negotiating higher pay than is advertised publicly, so employers would have to tell everyone what their maximum salary could be. Employers would have an incentive to post high maximums rather than miss out on quality candidates.
- neves 5y agoThis is a strong signal that this law must be expanded to the other states.
- brundolf 5y agoWeekly reminder that sometimes a functioning market can only be maintained via regulation.
- quotemstr 5y ago> A competitive market would enable me to sort by salary and benefits and apply for the best job. There is no fixed salary for a job. That's the whole point. It's a negotiation, where candidates with unique skills can negotiate higher compensation that reflects their unique skill-sets and contributions. What you want is to impose a one-size-fits-all rule on the market. That's going to produce misallocation and inefficiency. > view a few houses before you've paid the house price in survey fees Surveys and inspections cost a few hundred dollars. Houses cost several hundred thousand dollars at least.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"It's a negotiation, where candidates with unique skills can negotiate" Every snowflake is special and unique too, but nobody cares when they are shovelling their driveways. Stop spreading incredulous fantasies, companies that hire 3000 JS-React mashing "agile' dev have salary ranges, HR has them, and you can find out about them once you are hired. They just don't want to publish them upfront. Maybe if we are talking top leadership positions this argument has credence, but for most of us they aren't bending over backwards and putting together unique compensation packages.
- noduerme 5y agoThe bedrock truth behind this is that companies, even 20 years ago, were far more concerned about both retaining dedicated employees and maintaining customer satisfaction. Has anyone had to try to contact Paypal about a pending payment in the past few years? What about getting a human with authority over minimum wage on the phone at an insurance company? What has taken place is that the mass of people who were "consumers" have become "users", and are replaceable and disposable; while the employees have been downgraded to associates. It's not just the feeling of outrage you get when you're trying to establish, with a person, where $1000 someone sent you disappeared to for a month. It's the anti-human system underpinning the idea that we should build an algorithm to keep people on hold longer, the more pissed off they sound about an unwarranted charge. There are a lot of points at which business logic taken to its fullest fruition turns out not to be good business. We tend to hope the market will rebel against the excesses of companies that treat users as interchangeable parts. But the reality is we (coders) are contributing to the de-humanization of the majority of humanity, in many of these small interactions and small-change money collecting circumstances. That's our job. But at some point we should be able to see the circle closing around us; we're exempt because we can hack our way through the thicket of junk it takes to get our identity back if it's stolen, a new job if our startup shuts down; we are constantly re-inventing ourselves and innovating. But we are not our users. We wouldn't even want our users to be us. The point as I take it, of this, is that screwing your employees is treating them as users; and treating users the way we have, for a long time, is also self-defeating and bad for society.