7 ms·
I don't get it. Isn't anyone else as creeped-out by the idea of a Google social network as I am? I'm definitely not thrilled at the idea of Facebook being the
by timr 15y ago
I don't get it. Isn't anyone else as creeped-out by the idea of a Google social network as I am?
I'm definitely not thrilled at the idea of Facebook being the One True Social Network, but the idea of a Google social network makes me sad, and more than a little nervous. The fact that Google is trying to exploit their search dominance to funnel people into a Facebook competitor screams "anti-trust violation" to me, and the information-control consequences make me a little woozy -- I'd rather that Facebook dominate the space completely than give Google any more of my personal information. Google+ may not be evil, but it isn't exactly lily-pure, either.
I'm hoping that this is another classic case of Nerd Blindness (much like Rob Malda's famous proclamation that the original iPod was 'lame'): Google has an exceptionally good technical reputation, so techies are foaming at the mouth to get access to their newest plaything, while everyone else just sees this as an attempt by a gigantic company to destroy a good service that it sees as a threat.
Cheering for Google to win in the social network space seems to be to be a bit like hoping that IBM will take down Microsoft. When giants fight, I can't summon up any other feeling than fear that the rest of us are going to get squashed.
- ryanhuff 15y agoCompetition is good. Facebook hasn't shown to be a proponent of users rights, made convenient because of their dominant market position. If they had a serious competitor, their attitude of forced acceptance of new features would likely change.
- timr 15y agoCompetition is great, but I don't think Google gets especially high points for "forced acceptance of new features", either. After all, they're pushing google+ by putting it on every other property they own.
- Kylekramer 15y agoWhat company besides Microsoft (out of fear/legal obligations) doesn't do that? It is nice and all to say everyone should start on a level playing field, what is wrong with a company advertising to their well earned and legally obtained users?
- dannyr 15y agoYou don't make sense. You admit it, they own it. Why can't they put it in a property they own? You know you can choose not use Google services right?
- timr 15y agoYou've missed the point. Of course Google can do whatever they want. But if you're one of the people thinking that Google is going to be better than Facebook as far as forcing their users to accept change, well, I've got a bridge to sell you.
- dannyr 15y agoIt's a toolbar at the top of GMail, Calendar, Docs. It's as subtle at it can get. You call that forcing?
- mgkimsal 15y agoEvery change they make you're forced to use. And that's pretty much the nature of web applications, until someone starts seriously focusing on discretely versioned web apps. Google forced me to stop using Notebook, by taking it away. They seemingly forced previews on my search results, so that when I hover there's a bunch of big graphics that now pop up. Possibly I can opt out of it, but why do that? People bitch up a storm about "opt out" email newsletters, but "opt out" Google UI changes (assuming you can opt out) are met with near universal cheer and slavish devotion. I deal with it because pretty much all other players are the same - Google's really no better or worse than anyone else, as far as I can see.
- yohui 15y agoGoogle Notebook (google.com/notebook) is still available, they just stopped working on it. I wouldn't consider it an act of "force" to stop developing a product. And regardless, they're not obligated to even continue offering it. Regarding search previews, I can agree that the option to turn them off would be appreciated. However, I think it's still a stretch to say that you're "forced" to view them; hovering alone does not trigger them, only clicking within search results. Personally, I had hardly noticed that search previews were still enabled, though I've never had a use for them. They do seem more useful on reappraisal than I had originally remembered, however.
- ryanisinallofus 15y agoThat's exactly what Facebook, Apple and every other company does. Facebook "check-ins?" and deals, iTunes Ping? Personally I'm glad Google has finally stopped acting like every feature they have is a unique product. It's pretty obnoxious to go back and forth between their various services.
- bryanallen22 15y agoFor me at least, (an evil) Google could reconstruct most of my facebook information from the email alerts facebook has sent to my gmail account. This doesn't change your point, though.
- orijing 15y agoBut it would definitely lose the PR battle...
- Daniel14 15y ago> I'd rather that Facebook dominate the space completely than give Google any more of my personal information. I feel differently, but see quite a few (mostly non-technical) people agreeing with you - at least, here in Europe. Google already owns most of the data you've given facebook, and treats it a lot better than fb imho (e.g. allowing export/deletion). I don't see why giving Google access to a bit more of your personal data will somehow decrease your quality of life. The reason people are foaming at the mouth, as you call it, isn't the exceptionally good technical execution, but rather how Google handles consumers (giving them more rights over their data) and developers (they're the underdog, they have to). This is another reason I like Google entering social - Facebook has been behaving rather arrogantly, and it does seem like they really own the social web [1]. But with Google acting as a threat, perhaps Facebook will be forced to soften up on some of its policies. Competition is a good thing, and I really doubt it will result in the rest of us getting squashed - In fact, I really believe we'll profit from those giants having to compete. For other reasons why G+ is anticipated highly, try http://www.pcworld.com/article/234825/9_reasons_to_switch_from_facebook_to_google.html#tk.hp_fv http://www.pcworld.com/article/234825/9_reasons_to_switch_fr... Lastly, IANAL, but I doubt promoting one of your products on one of your products is in any way illegal. The Google homepage has been showing us links to Docs, Reader, Gmail etc. for a long time without anyone getting upset about it. [1] http://techcrunch.com/2011/06/13/its-a-facebook-world-other-social-networks-just-live-in-it/ http://techcrunch.com/2011/06/13/its-a-facebook-world-other-...
- BvS 15y agoI totally agree. Google has pretty much all my private and professionell emails already so there is little left they could find out about me through Google+ that I'm worried about. Giving much of the same data to fb as well on the other hand doubles my risk (or even worse since I have less trust in fb). Besides competition can only be a good think. Just imagine the mobile space without Android...
- adimitrov 15y ago> Google has pretty much all my private and professionell emails already so there is little left they could find out about me through Google+ that I'm worried about. That's the point: why is Google interested in the social graph? They already have GMail, they can scrape twitter… what do they need G+ for? To me, the conclusion is that they do this to crush FB, which they might perceive as a threat. Or, the other idea is that they might just want to extend their brand to encompass more of the consumer market. More adspace, and the likes…
- jeffreyhsu 15y agoI'd be more creeped-out if Facebook dominated the space completely.
- dannyr 15y agoHave you observed what is happening to the mobile space? Apple & Google are competing and they are trying to outdo each other. What resulted is more advanced phones and cheaper prices. Consumers win. Can you imagine if nobody challenges Facebook? Did you know that what Facebook released recently (better Photos, messages, etc) is a preemptive response to Google+? We have seen time and time again that monopolies are bad. Internet Explorer did not innovate for some time when it was in 80+ of computers. Microsoft started paying attention to IE again when Firefox and Chrome came out.
- orijing 15y agoDo you really think Facebook would stop innovating if it weren't for the threat of Google behind its back? Perhaps the timing is influenced by G+, but the actual introduction of those products are just evolutionary steps in Facebook's mission to make the world more connected. It hires so many people (including hundreds of interns) because it wants to build a platform and a tool for people to use to keep in touch with each other. I don't think Facebook is playing from the same opening book as Microsoft. IE is a different story because it is not a core product of Microsoft. Facebook is the core of Facebook (obviously), so it cannot just let the product atrophy like MS let IE.
- rxin 15y agoFacebook might not stop innovating, but the pace of innovation will be slower. Competition fosters innovation. This is really simple business.
- dannyr 15y agoI never said Facebook would stop innovating but it wouldn't be as fast. Facebook is stepping up it's game. Same can be said with Apple. IPhone would keep improving with or without Android. But I feel like Apple is being more agressive about it with Android around.
- pkulak 15y agoBesides, how would Apple know how to make a notification system without Android?
- localhost3000 15y agomaybe i am being naive but i would much prefer a google social network to a facebook social network. i trust google far more than i do facebook. i can't quite explain why, but facebook has always felt like an unwashed pair of jeans to me. They're comfortable, and they look cool, but you know in the back of your mind that they're dirty and need a wash. google, on the other hand, is like a freshly pressed pair of chinos. not exactly hip, but chances are they don't smell. ...i don't know where this clothing analogy came from. probably because it's Saturday and i was just doing laundry.
- skarayan 15y agoAny social network today is going to need critical mass to survive. Critical mass brings to tons and tons of user information. Is the combination of search and social so much worse? Google is trying to get into social the only way it knows how, by combining it to search and putting it on all their properties. Is this really evil or the only way to compete? I would actually prefer if more companies got into both search and social. It would be great if Facebook would build a "social search" function as well. I think this is more realistic than wishing that companies would stick to one thing only. Google, Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Microsoft - they all want it all. More competition would mean a better experience for all, including better privacy, and perhaps something more federated. These guys are all attacking the same problems in different ways, but in the end, it's all the same thing.
- qjz 15y agoYes, it's depressing to see that the battle in social networking is over exclusive ownership of user data instead of establishing standards and protocols. It should be possible for users of the big players like Facebook and Google+ to include each other in their social networks, along with more independent or paranoid users who have established their own hubs. You could argue that the Internet has always supported social networks with email, World Wide Web, FTP, etc. But social networking sites add another layer that ties everything together in a way that's accessible to the layman. In that sense, social networking sites are really in the business of authentication and authorization. Unfortunately, they're doing a lousy job of it, with their walled gardens.
- glassx 15y agoI completely agree with you. Google already rules in search, phones, and now our social life. With Chromebooks they will get a bigger chunk of it. They have ten times more potential for evil than Microsoft ever dreamed of having in the nineties, and they're mainly an advertising company, instead of a business-software supplier like MS or IBM. Just to compare, Apple might be 'evil' and has a lot of indirect influence in the market, but an end user can perfectly avoid using ALL of its products with absolutely zero strength. Same with Microsoft today (except for MSN and Skype, or Windows if you're a gamer). Facebook and Twitter are the same, completely disposable (unless you're doing 'social marketing'). But to stop using Google, you need to jump trough hoops. It became like a drug dealer that's bringing new stuff day by day. I used to root for Google, but these days I only hope for it to get smaller so don't get squashed. =/ Disclaimer: YES, competition is good, and Facebook NEEDS competition to improve, but I don't like the fact that Google is trying to 'rule', instead of pushing for open protocols (like OStatus), federation (like XMPP and e-mail) and such. I'd say that Google+ killed the possibility of having something like Diaspora (which was already dead, but there was still hope in the air), unless they go back and make Google+ federated.
- jamesbritt 15y agoBut to stop using Google, you need to jump trough hoops. How so? You have alternatives to all of their products. About the only way you're compelled to interact with them is if you want to send E-mail to someone with a Gmail account, or if someone insists on you viewing some Google doc. It became like a drug dealer that's bringing new stuff day by day. And this is different from Apple how?
- glassx 15y agoQuoting myself: "an end user can perfectly avoid using ALL of its [Apple] products with absolutely zero strength" Maybe it is just me, but in a scale of 1 to 10, how hard it is to voluntarily stop buying/using products from Google, Apple, Microsoft and Facebook?
- Daniel14 15y ago> They [Google] have ten times more potential for evil than Microsoft ever dreamed of having in the nineties. I disagree - Can you clarify why you think so? You see, Google is probably the most vulnerable of the tech giants: If users stop visiting their sites for <i>whatever</i> reason, they'll die. It's really easy to switch to an alternative if you don't like what Google does, and Google even promotes this ease because they think people will be more willing to try out their services (think about the DLF team). Microsoft, Apple or Facebook on the other hand, have already sold their product, and now the consumer depends on <i>them</i>. MS, Apple and fb sell products that tie people into their services once they buy into them. After that, they don't have to care what Joe thinks about their business practices anymore, and can therefore act almost any way they want. I get the impression that the folks at Google actually take their unofficial motto "Don't be evil" seriously, but even if I'm mistaken I don't have to be scared - Google would quickly be out of business if they piss consumers off. And they know it.
- mahyarm 15y agoWhat I hope is that it pushes competitors to implement private-by-default, easy and quick to sort groups and we'll have it everywhere instead of just google+.
- naner 15y agoGoogle, while not perfect, has been more consumer friendly in handing privacy issues than Facebook has. They allow adblocking in Chrome, they allow you to export your data from their properties, they allow you to delete your account, etc. Also Google's walled garden is more permeable than Facebook's. So while data collection is creepy and monopolies are harmful, I trust Google more than I trust Facebook.
- jellicle 15y agoIt will be interesting to see whether Google googleizes social networking (changing the entire genre to be more privacy respectful) or whether social networking facebookizes Google (changing Google to be less privacy respectful, just like Facebook). Note that I don't believe Google is actually very much better than Facebook in privacy terms. Google keeps everything you do, forever; while Facebook tends to share everything you do, right now. Google does less immediate privacy damage but perhaps more in the long term? What happens when Google gets hacked and it's not just your username and password released, it's everything you've ever searched for and every website you ever visited that had a Doubleclick ad on it? Privacy tsunami, that's what.
- zenspunk 15y agoIf you're that worried, you can delete your web history and permanently opt-out of Google Analytics using Google's supplied opt-out extensions for Chrome and Firefox. They allow you to do things like that (not to mention data liberation efforts), which is the point the parent was making.
- movingahead 15y agoThe point everyone keeps missing about facebook is that they were trying something new in the social space. They did commit mistakes and have accepted it. They also allow you now to download all your data. I believe that if facebook merges friend lists and groups, they have will have a strong product against google.
- nbm 15y agoFacebook allows you to export your data, and to delete your account. Export your data: https://www.facebook.com/help/?faq=18844 https://www.facebook.com/help/?faq=18844 Delete your account: https://www.facebook.com/help/?page=185698814812082 https://www.facebook.com/help/?page=185698814812082
- angryasian 15y agothe future no matter what is all companies are going to exploit your personal data to monetize. Even companies like Apple, whose core business is not ads (Iads). Its just a future we all have to accept. which social network do you use, that you feel comfortable with ?
- abrahamsen 15y agoThe trouble is that most of the other services can be improved by access to the social graph. And since Facebook isn't likely to share the social graph with Google, Google have to build their own. The driving force for the change was a company wide belief that Facebook would eventually make Google, by offering competing services that was superior because they had access to the social graph. Source: http://www.wired.com/epicenter/2011/06/inside-google-plus-social/ http://www.wired.com/epicenter/2011/06/inside-google-plus-so... That is also why Google+ is everywhere (and why it was named Google+). It is Google plus the added value you can get from social graph. The +You part of the service itself is not the main point, even though it of course provides some potential ad space. Yes, there are potential anti-trust issues. They can be seen as somewhat analogous to Microsoft bundling IE with Windows. That gave Microsoft a lot of trouble at the time, but today few would question that a consumer OS should include a web browser. Bill Gates saw where personal computing were headed, and reacted rationally. Maybe search (and friends) can stay competitive without access to the social graph. I don't know. But Google don't believe so.
- nextparadigms 15y agoMore creeped out than Facebook? No, definitely not. The kind of data Facebook sells to advertisers is MUCH more private than the kind of data Google sells to advertisers.
- Daniel14 15y agoGoogle doesn't sell any data to other companies, only fb does.
- kmavm 15y agoFacebook sells absolutely zero user data to advertisers, full stop. It allows advertisers to target users by profile fields; if you think this somehow equates to selling user data, then Google's AdSense product, with the exact same feature set, must also equate to doing so. How does Google target ads at you without a social network? By sticking a pixel on half the web and watching where you surf, and running Bayes' rule on the results to determine that you're 25-30, male, live in California, are interested in punk rock, etc. To cut to the chase, let's make this interesting: I'll give you $10k, US. Go "buy user data" from Facebook. For example: I'll put a friends-only privacy field on my profile. If you can tell me the contents of that field in a week, I'll give you another $10k. If you can't, please return $20k to me, and stop repeating this absurd meme.
- hammerdr 15y agoCan't tell you yours, but I can tell you about 200 million others: https://graph.facebook.com/search?q=bob https://graph.facebook.com/search?q=bob
- kmavm 15y agoYes, the information that is public is public. And searchable. Just like the rest of the Internet. What doesn't happen, is Facebook "selling data": taking money in exchange for ("selling") information you wouldn't otherwise have. It doesn't happen, and never has.
- bonch 15y agoI don't get it. Isn't anyone else as creeped-out by the idea of a Google social network as I am? For the most part, only social networking techies are praising this thing. The last thing I want to do is give Google even more of my information, my friend's information, and so on.
- Lewisham 15y agoHaving a good product is not an anti-trust violation. People are free to leave Google Plus at any time. It can be turned on and off. You can take your data in and out. You can go to Bing whenever you like.
- jaredmck 15y agoPeople can switch to bing, but that doesn't mean advertisers can (unless they are trying for an obviously suboptimal choice). Only Google search has ad volume and broad scope sufficient for most of those spending the bulk of search advertising $. Advertisers are google's real customers.
- ZephyrP 15y agoWe are however making economic decisions on what sort of people we let control our information and the future of our great human enterprise of the Internet. Facebook consistently disregards user privacy issues and doesn't work in a fashion many people believe to be ethical in any sense. Google, if by a superior PR strategy or their true drive to expand and 'Use Technology for Good' appeals to many people in the tech space and outside. Although Google is certainly a corporate giant, they are a giant we can trust is run by "People Like Us"(TM), and if for the good or the bad, I tend to trust Engineers and Scientists (Notice my bias in associating Google with Engineers and Scientists) a lot more than Businessmen and Politicians (And likewise for associating Facebook with the latter). Although I think the ideal Social Network would be run by some sort of neutral party, I recognize that the money is simply too great for that to be a realistic expectation - So in the interim I'm happy to have an alternative from Google, even if the implications for information dominance are daunting - I'm putting all my faith in their resolution.
- pkulak 15y agoI completely disagree. I probably trust Google more than any other company. I bought a cheap phone on CL and put Android on it, which Google (and the wonderful folks at Cyanogen) have made available for free. I keep loads of my data on Google servers for free, and importing and exporting it is easy. If it wasn't for Google I'd be paying for email, using slow and/or expensive desktop calendar, email and document clients, have no control over the software on my own phone, and be printing out line-by-line MapQuest directions any time I wanted to drive somewhere new. I got a Gmail account in 2004 and since then have moved more and more of my life into Google's system. In those 7 years I've never been disappointed. I don't really have anything against Facebook, but if Facebook can do it, Google can probably do it better while also giving me more control and transparency. That's what they've done with everything else they've touched.
- richardw 15y agoFacebook has had my whole social graph for years and can't even get it together to show me one single advert I care about. It's just not that useful a set of info. Google+ is getting more of a public social graph. I'll watch investors and traders, startup-types, media, local digeratii. What evil do you think it's going to do with that? It's a message board with some semi-private messages and maybe a spark or two. If it hasn't figured out my 'likes' by now then certainly an extra spark isn't going to flip the switch. Many of the messages are public anyway, like Twitter. Much of the social graph is public - you can see who I follow and who follows me, like Twitter. Google could already max out the evil with the Twitter social graph if it wanted to. Google has my credit card number, my email (all of it), my location, my _email_ social graph, and my multi-year search history. What it already has dwarfs a few extra messages. Adding a bit of public social graph just isn't going to turn it into Skynet. Edit: my friends and family will largely stay on Facebook. It's a nice safe place and I've set it up to be pretty secure. G+, well, that'll be my personal Twitter equivalent with hopefully a bit more bandwidth. I like the threads. Twitter I'll keep for my company's persona.
- mike-cardwell 15y agoI like the way Moxie Marlinspike put it on Twitter: https://twitter.com/#!/moxie__/status/86620176832929792 https://twitter.com/#!/moxie__/status/86620176832929792 'The "circle" I want is the one that doesn't have Google in it.'