15 ms·
Facebook says I'm abusive content [video]
- bigyikes 6y agoLouis, while sometimes brash, has got to be one of the most genuine people on YouTube. As far as I can tell there is nothing about his content which is abusive. While I’m still not really sure how I feel about right to repair, I would hate to see him be censored as one of his best qualities is his uncensored nature.
- simondotau 6y agoI support the majority of right to repair principles but I find Rossman himself to be a person whose personality has suffered from its ever-increasing exposure to YouTube celebrity. I certainly don't blame him. I know my own mind and I'm certain I wouldn't fare any better in his situation. I think most people would be unprepared for the psychology of becoming Internet-famous, of having their opinion continually validated by a hungry audience. In fact it's genuinely fascinating to me when occasionally you see an individual who remains seemingly unaffected by celebrity, psychologically unaffected by their thought-leader status in a large community. I'd actually pick Linus Sebastian—of all people—as be a canonical example of this. Whether it's sincere or incredible acting skills, the stratospheric growth of his channel hasn't made him any more insufferable. The few people who can nagivate this perfectly truly shine in the world of YouTube. (The Slow Mo Guys is another example. And weirdly, I'd have to give a nod to Project Farm as well, for content that seems entirely unaffected by channel success.) A lot of my favourite creators fall somewhere between these extremes. (e.g. Technology Connections, Mark Rober, savagegeese, Engineering Explained.) Not unscathed by their popularity, but seem to be able to cope with the mindfuck thus far.
- civildude 6y agoi mean, he knows how to take care of PPS, got good balls soldering and always splashing that nice flux on the nastiest stuff
- Causality1 6y agoSuffered in what way, exactly? Rossman's new content seems very much like his old content to me.
- atoav 6y agoAs a long viewer of Louis channel: IMO the change that you think you see with him is more a function of age (remember he is a lot younger than he looks like) than having anything with internet fame. I changed a lot in my life as well at a similar age. Louis is certainly someone who always likes to work on hard (but not unsolveble) problems. What he does with right to repair, is just yet another one of those. This is just trying to repair the underlying cause for a lot of troubles reapir shops are or will be in. I guess the only impact internet fame might have had is that he now sees this as a problem that can actually be solved (rather than one that he as yet another small repair shop owner cannot solve).
- theshrike79 6y ago> he is a lot younger than he looks like ...the dude is 32 (born in -88). So that means he was in his late 20's when he started his channel. Why does he look like a 50 year old IT veteran who has seen it all, twice :D
- KozmoNau7 6y agoStress and constant battle ages you, no joke.
- rraihansaputra 6y agoMaybe because he did. I can't fathom how hard it is building a good, reputable third-party service center and really wanting to serve his customers the best way, while being pretty much road-blocked by Apple. Harvesting ICs and caps from donor boards is definitely hampering the technicians' work.
- manigandham 6y agoHow has it suffered exactly? Current videos seem just like those from years ago to me, although he now covers even more topics in the "Adventures of a small Apple repair shop"
- pyaamb 6y agoPlaying devils advocate here The reason you become famous in the first place is because you do a good job being creative with the possibility space in your present environment. Once you become famous that environment and possibility space changes, and you are forced to chose between being grounded which may mean choosing not to use the new superpowers given to you, or to continue doing what you have always done with your new capabilities...
- simondotau 6y agoI'd argue that isn't devil's advocate — rather it's pretty much spot on. Being restrained in the face of influence isn't the norm. The default state of the Human On The Internet to be certain of our own opinions and want to shove them in front of everyone who will listen.
- kwanbix 6y agoLove Louis myself. Very bright guy, great work, honest. What puzzles me is how can anybody not be sure about the right to repair.
- jmull 6y agoSome bad and crazy ideas are attached to that label. Also, some perfectly reasonable ones. I’m not sure about “right to repair” because I never know which ones we’re talking about.
- 0xcde4c3db 6y agoOn paper, you already have the right to repair things that you own. However, it's hard to materially ensure the right to repair without regulating the market to ensure availability of replacement parts and schematics, ban certain classes of security mechanism, mandate a certain level of openness for manufacturing/diagnostic/recovery software, and so on. A lot of people see any initiative shaped like this (cf. net neutrality, product safety regulations) as little more than an excuse for government overreach, and even supporters can have various concerns about the laws/regulations being worded or implemented in a way that inadvertently ends up doing more harm than good.
- rasz 6y agoIs Asus employing reputation management firms?
- fdroidmstrrce 6y agoIsn't it better to assume every major company is than to blindly assume good actors? The only ones I company I can't imagine is doing this is Google. They have an Awful reputation. Their Fruit counterpart, Nintendo, Samsung, and more are suspiciously positive at anti consumer news.
- dvt 6y agoBetween bad actors taking advantage of DMCA takedowns and brigading mobs, it seems that automated (or semi-automated) moderating is absolutely a no-go at scale. Incidentally, it's also why these networks (YouTube/Facebook/Twitter/etc.) can achieve such a massive scale with basically zero human moderation (i.e. cheaply). Remember when we had forums and there were a few unsung heroes that kept our communities clean and tidy(-ish)? Even here, I'm pretty sure @dang is basically reading HN and cleaning it up all day. Doing this at scale with semi-automated systems is quite literally impossible but until the courts start sanctioning social networks for their ad-hoc censorship (if this is even enforceable), we are sadly unlikely to see a change.
- onion2k 6y agoObviously, automated (or semi-automated) moderating is absolutely a no-go at scale. I don't think that's obvious at all. You're saying that it's more important not to remove videos that aren't in violation of the platform's terms, eg false positives in the automated removal process, than it is to remove videos that are, eg actual content that should be removed. Why is it more important that someone's video remains on Facebook than Facebook removes illegal or toxic content? If acceptable videos are removed by mistake is that actually a problem that means the automated process isn't fit for purpose? ... social networks for their ad-hoc censorship... Facebook removing a video is not censorship. They're not saying "no one can see this video". They're saying "we don't want to host this video". Those are absolutely not the same thing.
- josephcsible 6y ago> Why is it more important that someone's video remains on Facebook than Facebook removes illegal or toxic content? For the same reason that "It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer". > Facebook removing a video is not censorship. They're not saying "no one can see this video". They're saying "we don't want to host this video". Those are absolutely not the same thing. Facebook has so much market share that they're uncomfortably close to the same thing.
- 6y ago
- open0 6y agoWe need long prison sentences for Apple executives and anyone else engaged in the subversion of governments and destruction of our environment. These people are traitors and need to be treated accordingly. When are all of you going to realize this?
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoExamples like this show the time is ripe for alternative social media platforms to replace the established networks. Dealing with bad actors in public forums is not as hard as tech companies would want you to believe. This is evident, because we do it today. Its our system of courts. Take any platform, and implement a simple e-court system with juries, being random users from the network. The injured party can effectively e-sue , and the pool of randomly users must all agree that abuse took place. This takes care of " No more frivolous takedowns. This also takes care of the pesky catch-all ToS. Platform no longer needs to define abuse. Instead, we take approach of Justice Steward: "I know it when I see it" Juries participating get rewards (badges, recognition, opportunities as judges / advocates, etc) The reason companies do not implement such a system is because it takes power away from them (management, staff) and gives it to the users. That's precisely why such a system would be a winner.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jsnell 6y agoI can't imagine what could go wrong with showing a random pool of your users suspected CSAM, beheadings, animal cruelty, and so on. Just out of curiosity, what do you plan to do in the unlikely case that you can't get people to do this grueling work for free? Just leave all of that content on the site? It does mean that you won't be able to act on anything except the grossest of abuse. Given the hyper-partisan divide in America, you'd never get 10 people to agree on any case with even a whiff of politics. People will not vote on "is this abusive", they'll vote on "do I agree with this". But, hey it's not all bad. Want some viewers for your video? Here's a growth hacking tip: Just have a friend file an abuse complaint against it, and you'll get it sent into the jury rotation pool.
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y ago1) RE: what could go wrong with showing suspected CSAM to users. You are not describing something that doesn't happen in real life. Jury pools are introduced to a summary of the case to precisely ask jurors to recuse themselves if the content of said case is too X. Ejury adjudication would make this incredibly simple via flagging system. "X user has stated this is animal cruelty, and the algo concurrs". So you know what you are dealing with before anyone hits play. 2) RE: No one wants the work. Real-life Jury pools consistently have 100+ candidates for a final 12. E-juries are much better because they can actually scale and can cycle much faster. The world has 7B people. With the right incentives, you can find 10 or so people to take a case on. Plus, you are forgetting that there are also real penalties for losing a case that can act to fend off the undesirables. For example, you could make it so that losing a case means the platform discloses your IP. Makes all your private postings/messages public. Open up the logs of use. Take your pick. There's a million ways to punish degenerates which now do not happen because algos decide and they have such a high false positive rate, to punish would be doubling down on a failed strategy. 3) RE: No agreement except for gross abuse. I have to disagree. 98%+ of people would be in agreement that death, CSAM, animal cruelty etc are offenses that should be dealt with. You already have consensus there. Anything else is in the spectrum of spam / hate / etc. Yet, if it is not beyond reasonable doubt, then its probably not gross. 4) Growth hacking: You seem to forget there are penalties for false accusations in real life. This is no different. If your friend wants to lose access to his own account, he can go right ahead and report a video for the 10 extra views....
- systemvoltage 6y agoI like Rossmann’s spirit and 100% onboard with right-to-repair movement, just not his toxic delivery. His videos are ramblings of something that can be summarized in 30 seconds. It’s filled with hateful contempt and everything to bring out the worst in people. It’s a reality show. I wouldn’t call it abusive and shouldn’t be banned, but it’s not without issues either. Most people find him great, perhaps something must be misjudged by me.
- ergot_vacation 6y agoSometimes bad things are being done, by bad people, and those things and people should be spoken of harshly, not in neutral, Vulcan-like delivery. Rossmann can be a bit severe, but nearly always with good reason: the people he's speaking ill of are generally crooks of one kind or another. Of course, speaking or writing with nothing BUT appeals to emotion is vacuous and cynical, and the horde of youtube grifters that have sprung up to make money off getting people wound up are trash. But unlike them, Rossmann actually has well-considered content behind his passion, not just hot air.
- 0xbadcafebee 6y agoHaving a well-reasoned argument doesn't justify abusive language. And just because there are bad people in the world doesn't mean it's okay to treat them badly. Sometimes abuse and badness are necessary, such as in war or for self-defense. But when it's not necessary, it shouldn't be used just because you find yourself on the convenient side of the moral picket fence.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- imperialdrive 6y agoA well-reasoned person can handle abusive language, especially at the level you're comparing Rossman too. If you're comparing what Rossman outputs to the level of abuse and badness found in war or self-defense... well... think about that and maybe edit the comment afterwards.
- kanwisher 6y agoAll these tech companies have a lot to lose from right to repair, so I wouldn't doubt someone is trying to take down his videos
- perryizgr8 6y agoWell, Facebook is free to ban anybody from using their services, since it is a private platform. If Rossmann wants, he can start his own billion dollar social network and post whatever he likes over there.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wesleywt 6y agoYes, Facebook do have that right. But they also have a right to look stupid while doing it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lettergram 6y agoIm fairly confident it’s because he owns theDonald.win (the community migrated to patriots.win).
- bozzcl 6y agoDo you have a source for that? A DDG search only shows he’s mentioned in one article of the site, which seems to have a few other domains as well. I tried to do a whois on those domains, but it seems they’re managed by an intermediary and anonymized.
- inyorgroove 6y agoPerhaps they assume because that domain now redirects to a page that embeds one of Rossman's videos this is the case? thin evidence at best, that is simply one among many explanations for the availability of that redirection.
- plank_time 6y agoIs this not libel? Labeling his videos as “abusive” sounds like it is tarnishing his reputation and denying him any ad revenue he could get. It seems like it could be pursued via a law suit.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Is this not libel? No. “Abusive” is not a fact claim.
- plank_time 6y agoIs it not a “fact”? If they say that the video breaks their rules on abusing content, it goes away from opinion and more into fact. Facebook deliberately created a set of rules/measures to determine abusive content, specifically such that they couldn’t be accused of being arbitrary, or opinion-driven. So their rules specifically ensure that their determinations are fact-based not opinion-based. If they determine that content has broken their rules on “abusive content” it seems pretty fact-based. So labeling content as having broken their rules on abusive content is literally making a fact claim.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Is it not a “fact”? No, not in the sense required for libel law. > If they say that the video breaks their rules on abusing content, it goes away from opinion and more into fact. That would arguably be true if their standards were remotely objective; they are not. > Facebook deliberately created a set of rules/measures to determine abusive content, specifically such that they couldn’t be accused of being arbitrary, or opinion-driven Whether or not that is the intent of the rules, the rules are opinion-driven on their face. > So their rules specifically ensure that their determinations are fact-based not opinion-based No, they don’t. Have you read their rules? > . If they determine that content has broken their rules on “abusive content” it seems pretty fact-based. Really? --- The following behavior isn't allowed on Facebook: Posting things that don't follow the Facebook Community Standards (ex: threats, hate speech, graphic violence). Using Facebook to bully, impersonate or harass anyone. Abusing Facebook features (ex: sending friend requests to many people you don't know). Overusing features could make other people feel uncomfortable or unsafe. As a result, we have limits in place to limit the rate at which you can use features. Learn more aboutthese limits. --- [0] Seems like a whole lot of opinion in there to me, even before lookong at the Community Standards (incorporated by reference as they’ve indicated anything bot following them can be labeled “abusive”.) But let’s look at them [1]...and find there are no fact-oriented rules ar all, but a statement that “...when we limit expression, we do it in service of one or more of the following values:” followed by a list of vague value statements without factual criteria. [0] https://m.facebook.com/help/216782648341460 https://m.facebook.com/help/216782648341460 [1] https://m.facebook.com/communitystandards https://m.facebook.com/communitystandards
- kwanbix 6y agoWhat is crazy is that since I manage a group that has 8.000 users in FB, we get lots of fake accounts requests to get into it so that they can SPAM whatever they want to sell. So I report the profiles many times (profiles with nudes, explicit pictures, etc), and half of the time, I get a response that they do not violate FB policies. I am talking abut pictures of assholes, tits, etc. And no, it is not that I am horrified of seeing that, is that if I want to see that I go to other pages.
- Uberphallus 6y agoSame, 5k user local town group here. Every day accounts with names of another continent, created in the last week, with sexually suggestive pictures that usually involve a caption with some url shortener to video chat with them, 100% of the time they follow the community standards in my experience. I honestly believe the FB UI for reviewers only shows the picture and not the caption, I can't imagine any other explanation.
- AuthorizedCust 6y agoYou’re wasting your time reporting them. They are either bot-generated or done in large sweatshop operations. Just reject the membership and move on. It’ll get better when Facebook chooses to deal with this with more accuracy. Until then, any actions that go beyond basic protection of our groups is simply tilting at windmills.
- luxuryballs 6y agoIt’s almost like they took extra measures to make extra sure their automods aren’t prudes but not enough steps making sure they don’t block perfectly fine content.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- asiachick 6y agoI ran into a similar problem on Quora. Someone left an arguably false answer. I commented that I didn't think the answer was correct and showed why. The OP disagreed. I disagreed with his disagreement. He disagreed with mine. He reported me to Quora. I got a nasty message from Quora that my comments were spam and and they threatened to remove me (they were not remotely spam and they were also not in any way abusive or personal attacks).
- heisenbit 6y agoIt is ridiculous that they refuse to publish and just reject. Even Orwell in 1948 knew that words can be cut out and substituted with an industrial scale staff. These days Apple could simply hire a KI to rewrite the offending passages.