10 ms·
Hetzner has banned crypto mining and Chia farming
- john_alan 6y agoIf I pay for data centre resources, I don’t want their opinion regarding what I use them for. Crypto mining (running SHA2/Keccak/RandomX = evil) Is it ok to crack passwords using Hashcat for the same? What if the document is a password protected zip of the last picture of my grandad. Fuck off with your virtue signaling.
- dindresto 6y agoHetzner have always been picky about who they allow as customers, and I can't even blame them for it.
- ahelwer 6y agoSmart business decisions driven by profit considerations are virtue signaling now I guess?
- Spivak 6y agoI guess being anti-crypto is virtue signaling now. Guess that means we're at the turning point where crypto isn't this cool magic money thing anymore now that the harsh light of day is being shone on the industry. Or, I think more likely, is that the parent can't actually form a cohesive argument and is part of a group of people for whom the term "virtue signaling" has become synonymous with "bad" but is used to try carry more intellectual weight than it actually does.
- john_alan 6y agoOnly a moron would cloud mine crypto. This is bad for a single reason. It creates apartheid based on compute purpose. If you can’t figure that out yourself that’s ok. I’m sure you’ll be ok. You seem to know some really big words already.
- throwaway81523 6y agoThey have forbidden crypto mining on their cloud services (i.e. shared cpu hardware) since it started, but until recently they allowed it on dedicated servers. Stopping it now seems to be a result of Chia having a real impact on their equipment availability and longevity. Chia has apparently also driven up the street price of large HDD's by a significant amount, 30% according to a forum post I saw.
- striking 6y agoIt costs them more to serve these resources to you. They're not obligated to deal with customers whose use of the resources goes beyond the ordinary or regular.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- john_alan 6y agoCharge appropriately
- MegaButts 6y agoIf you don't like their service simply don't use it? Why should anybody be expected to cater to you instead of someone else?
- john_alan 6y agoI’m speaking generally about this move. I absolutely don’t use their shit service. Look, I don’t know what’s so hard here. If you sell cloud compute it should be on the basis of usage. If that usage is 100% then charge aptly.
- MegaButts 6y agoIt's their business and they can do what they want. Why is it hard for you to understand that your opinion is not authoritative? You can hate their business just as much as they can hate your patronage.
- john_alan 6y agoI absolutely agree! Just don’t market yourself as an open and non limited compute resource charged by usage. Market yourself as a QOS’d, shaped sub service.
- deleted 6y ago
- Dylan16807 6y ago> If I pay for data centre resources The biggest reason it's banned is credit card fraud.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jankassens 6y agoI'm a happy customer for their reasonable prices. If the prices require banning extreme cost outliers like crypto mining I'm okay with that.
- john_alan 6y agoGreat hopefully you never need a compute resource they consider an outlier.
- w0de0 6y agoDo you take the same attitude to a rented apartment? A hotel room? Build your own datacenter if you want to own it.
- john_alan 6y agoTo continue your retarded analogy, I’m not looking to add my own disks to their machine and hang my cpu on their wall. I just want to use the compute resource they rent me for arbitrary computation.
- olyjohn 6y agoIf I was told that I get 1300sq ft to live in, and then got in trouble or kicked out for using all of it, I'd be pretty pissed off.
- majewsky 6y agoThere are plenty of things that you cannot do in an apartment. If it's a building with multiple tenants, you'll be forbidden from doing stuff that's an unnecessary disturbance to other tenants. But even apart from that, there are physical limitations. For example, many apartment buildings forbid large aquariums because the building is not designed to handle the uneven load distribution.
- Spivak 6y agoLook, this argument basically just boils down to "businesses can't fire customers for whom it doesn't make financial, operational, or reputational sense to serve." And like sure that sounds good except that we currently take the opposite stance by having protected classes. They are the single carve-out exception for the general idea that you can otherwise fire your customers for any reason you see fit.
- dang 6y agoYou posted multiple flamewar comments in this thread. Can you please not do that? We're trying for something different here, and you can make your substantive points without it. Comments like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27212899 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27212899 are particularly bad. Please don't do that on HN—it destroys this place for its intended purpose, which is simply to have an interesting forum on the internet that hopefully doesn't suck. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- john_alan 6y agoOk understood
- wearywanderer 6y agoYou can pry my terracotta Elmer Fudd with lush green hair from my cold dead fingers.
- _Microft 6y agoTranslation: "Yes, it's true, we expanded the ToS and banned crypto mining. We received many orders for servers with large disks. Large storage boxes (?) are also increasingly often rented. With storage boxes 1/2" "this leads to bandwidth problems on the host systems. With Chia mining, there is the additional problem that the many read and write accesses put a lot of strain on the drives which will lead to failure. 2/2"
- Dylan16807 6y agoI'm curious what they mean by "bandwidth problems". At most, wouldn't you upload enough data to the servers to fill the drives once and then use a trickle afterwards? That seems like the best case for a storage box's bandwidth.
- Glench 6y agoThis is something people don't seem to understand about Chia. Mining ("farming") Chia is a very low-resource activity that can be done easily on Raspberry Pis — it's mostly just doing a few disk seeks every 30 seconds.
- mwpmaybe 6y agoIf they're just farming, sure, but plotting is extremely I/O intensive.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- peterkelly 6y agoIt's possibly a reference to internal I/O bandwidth on shared machines hosting VPSs, i.e. plotting is very I/O intensive so other virtual machines running on the same host will suffer.
- breakingcups 6y agoI've been suddenly unable to order any storage servers from Hetzner. I already suspected it was Chia even though they only cited "exceptional circumstances with hardware deliveries". Nice to see it confirmed.
- temptemptemp111 6y agoGreat, but how can they detect what you're exactly doing in your VM?
- MauranKilom 6y agoNot sure if this is of use (since submissions should link to english content in the first place), but here is a rough translation: Joshua: > @Hetzner_online has silently changed their T&C and banned entire IP ranges this morning around 9:20 am. [I] cancelled and moved 50 AX41 in the past 36h. Deeply disappointed, even though the change does not affect me. Hetzner Online GmbH: > Yes it's true, we have amended the T&C and forbidden crypto mining. We received many orders for servers with large hard drives. But increasingly large storage boxes are also being rented for this. For storage boxes this leads to problems with the bandwidth of the host systems. For Chia mining, the disks are additionally extremely taxed due to the amount of read and write operations, causing them to break quickly. Joshua: > I understand that. But when I rent a server, I want to be able to use the hardware. That is, if I want to roast the CPU or write to the disks 24/7, I should be able to do that, because I rented the full server.
- elliekelly 6y ago> I understand that. But when I rent a server, I want to be able to use the hardware. That is, if I want to roast the CPU or write to the disks 24/7, I should be able to do that, because I rented the full server. I wonder if the legal concept of “wasting” has been (or could be) applied to rented servers. Edit: Wikipedia[1] for anyone curious but the article seems a bit incomplete/inaccurate to me because it insinuates the concept applies only to "real property" but it can apply to trust assets, including personal property, as well. I suppose the difference is a trustee owes an equal fiduciary duty to all beneficiaries, including future beneficiaries, while a server user has no such duty to the server owner or future potential server users. I don't see why an anti-wasting provision couldn't be included in the rental agreement, though. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waste_(law) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waste_(law)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gruez 6y agoSuch concept exists? If I want to rent a car to go on relaxing drives up and down the interstate, what business do they have to stop me (assuming the car rental comes with unlimited miles)?
- karmakaze 6y agoI don't know what the German tweets are saying, but it's an interesting thought experiment. If all the major cloud vendors were to make it so regular consumers are unable to spin up a server and participate in mining, then what makes it 'distributed' and fair? I don't even know to what extent mining is prevalent on Hetzner. Is this more of a statement or are they having shortages for non-crypto applications? A similar case could occur with GPUs where the ones effective for mining are not generally accessible to the public and only those who can get them, a small subset of people in some position of power, isn't that different than a non-crypto-distributed currency. The 51% is really being tested by China. How many countries have governments/citizens with the capacity to be represented at that scale?
- Spartan-S63 6y agoIf all major cloud vendors altered their TOS to forbid mining, only those who can sustain it themselves would mine and we'd be forced to internalize the externality that cryptomining is not a sustainable way to produce currency and record transactions. If anything, a ban such as that would be good at finally putting the nails into the crypto-coffin. Currencies and transactions are really one of the worst blockchain applications that could have been chosen for the first large-scale use of the blockchain.
- pjc50 6y ago> Currencies and transactions are really one of the worst blockchain applications that could have been chosen for the first large-scale use of the blockchain. But that's the only reason it exists? All the other uses so far have flopped. It is a disaster that somebody made a system by which wasted electricity could be turned directly into financial speculation, though - a subsidy for raising the temperature of the earth.
- majewsky 6y ago> If all the major cloud vendors were to make it so regular consumers are unable to spin up a server and participate in mining, then what makes it 'distributed' and fair? Not everything is cloud. You can still have regular colocation where you bring your own hardware and pay for rack space, network and power consumption. Then you can trash your CPU and disks as much as you desire.
- the_mitsuhiko 6y agoFor Hetzner's business model chia is a big issue. The run an auction system to resell machines others no longer want. If you mine your SSDs to death for chia and then cycle them to newer ones, someone unhappy is going to bid on that machine.
- trulyme 6y agoI can understand the reasons, but it would probably make more sense to transfer the costs to the customers (for example for excessive IO, energy consumption,...) and let them be if they are willing to pay them. It's not illegal after all.
- pfp 6y agoIndeed. It should be common knowledge that shared platforms work because the company can make assumptions about load patterns and provision resources accordingly. Some might call that fair use, others overprovisioning. Mining crypto under such a cost structure would force other users subsidize your buttcoins. Personally I wouldn't feel too happy about such an income transfer. > transfer the costs to the customers (for example for excessive IO, energy consumption,...) That would be fair, but enabling it might have costs beyond the plain consumed resources: io/cpu/etc schedulers that take the exceptional loads into account and mitigate performance impacts, metering and other business overhead, productisation, investments into all that, etc.
- gruez 6y ago>Mining crypto under such a cost structure would force other users subsidize your buttcoins. Personally I wouldn't feel too happy about such an income transfer. The "buttcoins" part or the "income transfer" part? I guess if you have a grudge against crypto users there isn't anything worth arguing. On the other hand in a multitenant situation there's always going to be users using more resources than others, which means the "income transfer" part will always exist.
- pfp 6y agoThe latter. I don't care about buttcoins one way or another > there's always going to be users ... that fit those predictable load patterns I mentioned.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> transfer the costs to the customers Have friends in the hotel business. There is a particular type of rich customer who serially trashes every room they stay in. Some hotels indulge them. These customers pay for their damages and then some, after all. Others turn them away. The extra cash doesn’t make up for the toll taken on employees and other guests. These are both sensible business decisions, and they each have consequences. Miners are the loud, trashy guest who can pay. Hetzner is saying they don’t want them because they’re ruining the experience for their other customers.
- srmarm 6y agoSeems fair enough - just like you can't take your rental car racing because it causes more risk + wear on components than day to day driving. These guys are wise to ban this activity if it causes more wear on their SSD drives and attracts more risky customers. I do wonder how they'll monitor it though?
- bitexploder 6y agoI don't think this meaningfully reduces the life of a CPU. It is more about sucking up shared resources and making the customer experience all around worse for everyone else not mining crypto.
- MereInterest 6y agoThis is also exactly analogous to why cryptocurrencies should be banned entirely. They are sucking up shared resources and making the things around them (e.g. electricity use, turning on of fossil fuel power plants, mucking up the GPU markets for productive or entertainment purposes) all around worse for everyone else not taking part.
- gruez 6y ago> They are sucking up shared resources and making the things around them (e.g. electricity use, turning on of fossil fuel power plants, mucking up the GPU markets for productive or entertainment purposes) all around worse for everyone else not taking part. that seems like an overly broad definition of "shared resources". With the exception for rentals with unmetered utilities, those are all billed by usage. Nobody says that driving a SUV is "sucking up shared resources (fuel)" simply because it uses more fuel to do the same thing as a sedan.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y agoTo be fair, SUVs are widely criticized for that reason, too. https://www.wired.com/story/suvs-are-worse-for-the-climate-than-you-ever-imagined/ https://www.wired.com/story/suvs-are-worse-for-the-climate-t... "SUVs are the second-biggest cause of the rise in global carbon dioxide emissions during the past decade. Only the power sector is a bigger contributor." https://www.theguardian.com/environment/ng-interactive/2019/oct/25/suvs-second-biggest-cause-of-emissions-rise-figures-reveal https://www.theguardian.com/environment/ng-interactive/2019/... "If SUV drivers were a nation, they would rank seventh in the world for carbon emissions"
- hs86 6y agoIf crypto mining on their systems becomes profitable for us, why would they continue renting out their servers? Instead, they could cease their operations and become full-time miners themselves. Their pricing seems to rely on customers that don't maximize power consumption and hardware wear all the time, and I can fully understand if they ban specific use-cases like this from their hardware.
- vageli 6y ago> If crypto mining on their systems becomes profitable for us, why would they continue renting out their servers? Instead, they could cease their operations and become full-time miners themselves. This does not logically follow. Why does Nvidia bother to sell hardware then when they can just keep the most powerful cards for themselves and use them for mining?
- hs86 6y agoOperating a datacenter for crypto mining is a bit more than just having suitable GPUs for it. If you rent out your servers at a fixed price and they can mine crypto on them for a profit, then there is a high chance that your flat-rate pricing is not high enough. They would need to consider their missed earnings from not mining themselves as an opportunity cost of renting out servers instead.
- Method-X 6y ago>If crypto mining on their systems becomes profitable for us, why would they continue renting out their servers? Instead, they could cease their operations and become full-time miners themselves. Long term vs. short term thinking. It's more beneficial for them to maintain long term customers than mine a volatile cryptocurrency in the short term.
- slownews45 6y agoI've never had AWS block me from S3 - they just charge more for more tx. I've never had AWS block me from compute - they just charge more if I want more. I used to chase the "unlimited" services various of the cheaper providers offered - partly because HN always suggests that. But there are often weird limits. Ie, unlimited but... at some point its not worth dealing with. Either peering and latency is garbage, there is some fine print, or they just can't actually deliver the traffic volume. AWS same availability zone latency / bandwidth is really pretty OK between most nodes I've found.
- john_alan 6y agoPrecisely. That’s why I just use AWS. Costs more but they just do what they say on the tin.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cblconfederate 6y agohetzner never blocked me for traffic or compute. The only time i had a problem when i tested an ipfs node which triggered their DDos detection, but that's fixed with a command line option.
- lostmsu 6y agoAFAIK AWS prohibits GPU mining as well.
- mikl 6y agoAWS generally charges based on actual usage, where Hetzner is largely a flat-fee model with acceptable use policies. Hetzner is also much cheaper than AWS. Very different companies with very different business models. You can’t really compare the two.
- that_guy_iain 6y agoMy only issue with this is it seems like they've secretly changed the terms and conditions without telling anyone and that people haven't agreed to and then put them into force. I got bit by this before with a hoster when I was much younger and starting out where I put a webproxy on a web host. The web host then changed their terms and conditions and blocked my account without informing me. Then to add insult to injury they said they would unblock it for 3 hours a certain day for me to remove. I'm still salty about that to this day.
- caymanjim 6y agoNo one can anticipate every possible risk. That's why rules change over time. They should give advance warning, let people out of long-term contracts, or refund prorated monthly bills if they're changing the ToS mid-cycle, but there's nothing wrong with defending yourself against unforeseen abuses. The people mining crypto on shared resources know they're abusing the system; they're just trying to take advantage and spoil things for everyone around them.
- that_guy_iain 6y agoI have issue with changing the ToS and not notifying people and giving them a chance to make a decision. Not just randomly find out the service they pay for is no longer the service they thought they were paying for.
- Animats 6y agoBecause some crypto mining wears out the SSDs, or because it doesn't do enough network access to incur bandwidth charges?
- yread 6y agoBandwidth is more or less free on Hetzner
- drivingmenuts 6y agoSoooo, Chia farming. If I read the article right, you're not actually storing anything useful, like copies of the Library of Congress or SciHub or, say, anything that might be useful to humanity in the long run. You're just storing a pile of randomish numbers? Bitcoin, et. al., sounds like a scam to me, but Chia farming sounds like next-level stupid.
- supergirl 6y agocorrect, you're storing random bits. there is filecoin that actually stores things, but it has its own problems
- skjoldr 6y agoEthereum Swarm is the saner model where you rent out your disk space for other people and get paid for it in ETH. It's still in beta tho.
- leppr 6y agoStoring data has low cost versus continuous computing. This is what makes Chia mining have less external impact. Unused storage space can be used to make a little bit of money. If the "useful" data you're talking about has nobody willing to pay for its storage, is it really that useful? That's where the economical argument is with Chia: rewards are already low, and will get lower with time. So if some data has any kind of value, then there's no incentive to mine Chia instead of storing this data. Just store the SciHub library and rake in donations. Hetzner decided there's more value in reserving their hardware for other usages. If the incentive to mine starts getting very big, then they can just mine themselves. From a blockchain-security PoV this is the same as customers-managed mining. Crypto mining incentive mechanisms are working as intended here, so as a cryptocurrency enthusiast I don't consider this development negative. It's easy to look at something new, the use of it you don't understand, and instantly conclude it's stupid. "Why make data use up x10 more space by encrypting it? You should just store it in a secure location to begin with! Disk encryption is a scam!". "Why waste resources to secure some distributed ledger when you could just use Visa and Mastercard? Cryptocurrencies are a scam!"
- reincarnate0x14 6y ago
- mark_l_watson 6y agoAs a long term customer, I think banning mining is reasonable. I base this on personal experience: a few years ago, I rented a server with a GPU to run my own deep learning experiments. If my DL queue emptied, a script would run to start etherium mining. I monitored the GPU temperature and configured the mining software to only utilize about 75% of the GPU. I bet lots of people wouldn’t bother to do this.
- shaicoleman 6y agoA better link for T&C in English: "We strive to keep our networks operating at the highest possible level, so all of our clients benefit from it. Therefore the following actions are prohibited: * Operating applications that are used to mine crypto currencies" https://www.hetzner.com/rechtliches/root-server/ https://www.hetzner.com/rechtliches/root-server/
- hrbf 6y agoThis is a double-edged sword. Changing the TOS silently is a no-go but so is the absurd resource-burning just for crypto mining. Had they done this with a couple of days’ notice it would be a non-issue.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 5y agoI rent an AX41 from hetzner and from outside my activity looks like mining - I run all 4 cores at 100% 24/7. However I don't mine, I use it for machine learning. Wonder if they will axe my setup too? what are the criteria?