7 ms·
Okay, but I just don’t think it makes sense to say that companies who cannot afford to pay market rates for software engineers are experiencing a shortage of so
by tshaddox 5y ago
Okay, but I just don’t think it makes sense to say that companies who cannot afford to pay market rates for software engineers are experiencing a shortage of software engineers, unless there is something preventing market clearing.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> companies who cannot afford to pay market rates for software engineers are experiencing a shortage of software engineers, unless there is something preventing market clearing By definition, the market rate should involve zero shortage. That said, search costs and regulatory barriers are significant frictions. In the midst of an unforecasted surge in aggregate demand and you have an explicable event.
- bestouff 5y ago"By definition" if you believe in the Free Market religion. There ain't no such thing in the real world.
- josephg 5y agoGood point, but it sounds like you’re disagreeing on the terms, not the ground reality of the situation. Lots of companies can’t afford to compete with G / Fb / etc for principal engineers. (And many companies who should hire good people cheap out and don’t spend the money.) Thus lots of important, otherwise valuable projects are staffed by people who struggle to take technical responsibility for the tasks in front of them. This becomes self reinforcing - senior engineers have a lot of market power. They (we) generally don’t enjoy working on projects with mountains of technical debt alongside the processes which have a track record of creating them. “You’re really talented. Why would you work at a bank / corporate?”
- mandelbrotwurst 5y ago> By definition, the market rate should involve zero shortage. Labor supply isn't perfectly elastic - there are only so many people who are capable of doing a particular job, and it takes time to train more. On top of that, of the pool of folks who could get trained up, some of them wouldn't be interested in the work at any rate of pay!
- pas 5y agoThere are different markets. It's easy to hire full remote juniors on upwork for next to nothing. Hiring a senior staff superhero full-cyber stack-ninja who happily relocates to where you are... now that's not that easy. And thus on the low end you have a market glut and on the high end you have a shortage.
- nradov 5y agoBut that's still not a shortage. The government hasn't imposed a wage cap. Employers can just increase wages to the market rate.
- Rapzid 5y agoWhat's a shortage?
- mannerheim 5y ago> In economic terminology, a shortage occurs when for some reason (such as government intervention, or decisions by sellers not to raise prices) the price does not rise to reach equilibrium. In this circumstance, buyers want to purchase more at the market price than the quantity of the good or service that is available, and some non-price mechanism (such as "first come, first served" or a lottery) determines which buyers are served. So in a perfect market the only thing that can cause a shortage is price. > In common use, the term "shortage" may refer to a situation where most people are unable to find a desired good at an affordable price, especially where supply problems have increased the price. "Market clearing" happens when all buyers and sellers willing to transact at the prevailing price are able to find partners. There are almost always willing buyers at a lower-than-market-clearing price; the narrower technical definition doesn't consider failure to serve this demand as a "shortage", even if it would be described that way in a social or political context (which the simple model of supply and demand does not attempt to encompass). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shortage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shortage
- ZephyrBlu 5y agoIf 1000 companies want to hire top tier experienced engineers and there are only 100 on the market, that is the definition of a shortage.
- chmod600 5y agoLet's say you are a forward-thinking manager in a company making artisinal flowerpots. You know tech is the future and will set your company apart, and you want to build a top-tier team to take you there. You are willing to pay twice the compensation per engineer as google. Now a deluge of engineers show up for interviews. How do you tell which ones are top-tier and which ones are third-rate? Even tech companies struggle with this problem; surely you'll have no chance. You know you'll get mostly third-rate, because those are the ones looking for jobs. So instead of overpaying, you adjust your pay downward to compensate. So it looks like there's a shortage to the company (because the top-tier engineers aren't appearing even though they are willing to pay), but to top-tier engineers it looks like they are underpaying.
- brundolf 5y agoTangent: I've thought about this "bootstrapping dev hiring" problem before (you don't know which candidates are good because you don't have anyone technical to interview them) I wonder if there's a business opportunity for a firm of experienced devs who do nothing but interview devs for other companies
- pmiller2 5y agoThat’s very close to what Triplebyte does.
- brundolf 5y agoNice, I didn't know about this
- playing_colours 5y agoIt can go beyond hiring developers - companies may need help with deciding on initial MVP, organising development process, and regularly checking for a while if things go well.
- Redoubts 5y agoEh, I don’t like this theory because it’s hard to get real numbers until after the interview. The employer should know precisely what they’re buying at that point.
- tarsinge 5y agoFAANG salaries are not the market rate, it’s a market rate for specific companies for high qualified developers. On another market, I have a small agency, and I simply don’t see how a developer could provide enough value to a client on a typical web project so that we could bill the client enough to pay the developper that kind of salary. That discussion motivates me to try to increase our rates though. Edit: clarification of "justify that kind of salary".
- jnxx 5y agoFollowing that, wouldn't it be more efficient if companies said from the outset what their rate is? That would be a lot more efficient. Of course, the money the company is able to pay depends on the process and the business environment, and the company wants to hire as much qualification as it can afford. But nobody is helped if somebody goes through the interview process only to learn that the salary at offer will never match what he/she wants. ((BTW this is why in my case, I decided to leave the UK for mainland Europe - most job offers in the UK were at little more than half the compensation from what I had earned in Germany before. And the difference was even larger when factoring in the cost of housing!)