4 ms·
But also, surely the traditional legal system will still handle disputes over smart contracts just like it does with traditional contracts. I can’t imagine that
by tshaddox 6y ago
But also, surely the traditional legal system will still handle disputes over smart contracts just like it does with traditional contracts. I can’t imagine that a missing line of code (intentional or not) would be treated any differently by the legal system than a vaguely-worded clause in a traditional contract. The legal system almost certainly will not say “your contract was just code and the code executed properly according to its technical specifications and therefore the outcome stands.”
- arilotter 6y agoIt's not necessarily true that a smart contract is controlled or operated by an individual or corporation. Once deployed, many have no provisions for administration or ownership tools. If you're using one of these contracts and there's a bug, suing the creator would be like suing someone because they put a random legal contract template online & you didn't proofread it well enough.
- lottin 6y agoI'm pretty sure a "smart contract" isn't a legally-binding contract. A smart contract is a piece of software code, like a text editor or a web browser.
- tshaddox 6y agoYes, and if you use a smart contract to hire someone to build a deck on your house, I suspect any resulting legal disputes would be treated by the courts the same as if you had used a traditional contract.
- riffraff 6y agoThe problem is that smart contracts do not come with the same capability to take your counterpart to a tribunal: you might not even know who your counterpart is, im which country they live or if there are multiple ones. Who are you gonna sue?
- lottin 6y agoA "smart contract" is a computer program that manipulates balances on a ledger. There is no way you can use that to hire someone to perform a job because this isn't something that can be expressed in terms of balances. You would need an actual contract to do that. Also the parties that interact with the so-called smart contract have no agreement between them. What could they possibly have a dispute over?
- tshaddox 6y agoYes, a smart contract is not a legally-binding agreement, although it could be a component of a legally-binding agreement. That’s my point. The smart contract in my hypothetical scenario might be something like a transaction with 3 parties: you (the customer), the construction company, and a third-party verification service, that executes your payment to the construction company when any 2 of the parties agree to execute. This theoretically prevents the possibility of any 1 party defecting and running away with a monetary benefit (including the third party verification service, which couldn’t run away with the cash like a traditional escrow service hypothetically could). But my point is that even in this case, if the construction company and third-party verification service colluded to run away with the money without completing the work, you would still sue one or both of them, and my prediction is that the courts would treat this essentially identically to a scenario using traditional contracts.
- lottin 6y agoBut for this arrangement to work the customer, the construction party and the third-party need to enter into an agreement, i.e. a traditional contract. A traditional contract is legally binding, so of course the courts would treat it as legally binding. The smart contract may be part of the agreement but a smart contract by itself is not an agreement and something cannot be a legally-binding agreement if it isn't an agreement to begin with.
- tshaddox 6y agoI suspect a court would tend to take the existence of the smart contract as a pretty clear indication of the intent of the involved parties. But of course if you’re entering a significant commercial agreement like this you had better make an explicit traditional contract as well.
- unyttigfjelltol 6y agoWell ... first, what's described in the article isn't that smart. It's actually dumb. If we describe these code-as-law thingys as 'dumb contracts' it is crystal clear that 'YES' this is a dumb contract and any sane judge presented with one may well decide to give the participants exactly what they deserve, just like paper-based 'dumb contracts.' The key innovation here is that we've gone to the remedy residing in programmer malpractice, rather than attorney malpractice. Which in turn, when it becomes obvious to all involved, hopefully will have a chilling effect on any smart programmer asked to write a 'dumb contract.'
- lazide 6y agoLooking at the various issues that have come up with these ‘smart contracts’ (aka the ethereum DAO issues up until now), I think anyone who wants to write one should be automatically excluded from being allowed to do so.
- astrange 6y agoThey should maybe be forced to learn what a dependent type system is so they can regret that their smart contracts are written in a language with no safety features.
- Paradigma11 6y agohttps://juvix.org/ https://juvix.org/ is looking rather nice but is still beta.
- ZephyrBlu 6y agoIt's called a "smart contract" because it's programmable (Smart) and can be executed based on specific conditions (Contract). I've seen/read somewhere that Vitalik regrets naming them "smart contracts" though.
- varjag 6y agoThey are database triggers, but that's not enough grandeur for cryptoheads.
- tylersmith 6y agoPeople get so hung up on the word contract. Might as well spend time arguing that rodents make for bad I/O peripherals.
- BoiledCabbage 6y agoThe thing is, that's what a lot of smart contract proponents are pushing for. That the legal system has no say over contracts, so the outcome would stand. Or effectively bake into operating these contracts that the legal system isn't a reprieve against anything.
- tshaddox 6y agoThey might be pushing for it, but I just don’t think it’s going to happen, at least for transactions where it’s feasible to sue in court. The courts already deal with traditional contracts and, from what I can tell, they tend to look more at what a reasonable person would expect the outcome of a contract to be than the literal text of the contract.
- jollybean 6y ago"That the legal system has no say over contracts, " An agreement is an agreement subject to laws and jurisdiction. There's no avoiding that. It will be interesting to see how this plays out in the courts.
- lazide 6y agoIf distributed and decentralized it also runs across a common issue with courts - the ‘make me’ problem. If someone buys product x from seller y, which is based on some decentralized ‘contract’ which is defacto enforced by every node of the network independently - and that product then produces a unjust outcome. You go to court, but what if Y is just a node on the network? And everyone involved is outside the courts jurisdiction? what can an adverse court judgement actually accomplish? It can’t roll back the network activity to fix the smart contract without everyone’s consent - and that seems unlikely. It can declare product X illegal or fine seller Y - but if they have no way to enforce it, what’s the point?
- Pulcinella 6y agoI doubt the judge is going to care that the “contract” passed through a bunch of different peoples hands (nodes in a network). They could still fine the seller or order them to return the funds to X. If Y can’t be hauled into court because they are in another country or you just don’t know their identity, well that isn’t a problem specific to these “distributed smart contracts.”
- kevindong 6y agoThen what's the point of smart contracts? If you always must have some form of repudiation/reversal mechanism, you might as well go with the traditional contracts. You could argue there will be lowered costs in the happy path where nothing goes wrong, but I'm not sure that's valid since the underlying software still needs to written/supported by someone.
- tshaddox 6y agoOne obvious point would be transactions for which the traditional legal system is not an option, like illegal transactions or highly secretive transactions. But yes, I think advocates would provide other examples of lowering costs.
- TimJRobinson 6y agoSmart contracts can automatically execute code that makes transactions happen. With a traditional contract you need a third party to do that (or you have to trust the other person). This allows for a lot more efficiency as people who've never met can make trades on an open market without having to involve anyone else.