3 ms·
> it is nearly oil-independent This has never been how it works. Oil is a global commodity. Even if the US produced as much as it consumes, if something happe
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> it is nearly oil-independent
This has never been how it works.
Oil is a global commodity. Even if the US produced as much as it consumes, if something happened in the middle east, the global price would go up. Because when the price went up in Europe or Asia, American oil producers would sell to the highest bidder, which would force American consumers to bid higher.
The real path to "independence" is to stop consuming oil, i.e. the electrification of transportation and heating. Which is starting but nowhere near finished.
Because electricity generated from solar/wind/nuclear/hydro is not a global commodity. Nothing that happens in Iran is going to change the cost of power generated at Hoover Dam.
- bpodgursky 6y agoThe US can, and absolutely will, restrict oil exports if prices start to skyrocket. Gas prices are an enormous electoral cudgel. It wasn't even legal to export oil until 2015! https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-21-118#:~:text=With%20U.S.%20crude%20oil%20production,of%20U.S.%20crude%20oil%20worldwide https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-21-118#:~:text=With%20U.S.%....
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> The US can, and absolutely will, restrict oil exports if prices start to skyrocket. That would cost US oil producers billions of dollars -- more than the price increase would cost US consumers. Which would only happen if oil producers had dramatically less political influence than they do now, i.e. if we stopped producing so much oil. But then there would be no reason to do it. > It wasn't even legal to export oil until 2015! Crude oil. It was protectionism for US refineries, not the other thing. Which makes oil cost consumers more, because of the reduction in competition for refining.
- lumost 6y agoOn a temporary basis this is true as the market is restricted. On a long term time horizon you would simply expect consolidation of global refineries into a new, more powerful monopoly.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoYour argument is that by having greater competition, the result would be a monopoly?
- mushufasa 6y agoabsolutely true. Since some people are questioning this in the comments: for those that want to do their own research, this is called 'The Law of One Price,' and it applies to other commodities where transportation and storage costs are low. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/l/law-one-price.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/l/law-one-price.asp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_one_price https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_one_price https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/knowledge/economics/law-of-one-price-loop/ https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/knowledge/ec... This has been well established in mainstream energy economics for ~50 years. Other disciplines seem to have trouble grokking the arguments. But ask any professional trader and they'll go with the economists on this one.
- lumost 6y agoThis rule works in any environment where traders trade freely. Historically this has lead to catastrophes such as the Irish potato famine where the price of locally produced food exceeded what locals could pay. Leading to a country that had millions starving while exporting enough food to feed the country. For this and various other temporary phenomenon governments set limits on market economies to prevent outcomes pathologically opposed to the wellbeing of residents. These limits include export controls and subsidies on food and other basic necessities. It absolutely makes sense for a country not to suddenly shift its income to the benefit of external commodity holders due to a sudden price jump in the commodity due to supply chain issues. Not doing so could destroy “higher value” “finished product” industries by making them uncompetitive. If a large supply chain issue hits a critical necessity you would absolutely expect countries to start triggering their hoarding policies making the issue worse. An economic zone not planning for such a disruption to occur in the future is equivalent to a bet that such disruptions will never occur.
- mopsi 6y ago> If a large supply chain issue hits a critical necessity you would absolutely expect countries to start triggering their hoarding policies making the issue worse. The PPE shortage of 2020 demonstrated very clearly how quickly free-market economics gets thrown overboard in a serious crisis.
- madengr 6y agoAh, but the USA is dependent on cheap, Chinese solar cells.
- jollybean 6y agoIt is how it works though. Supply and Demand are real, price spikes are real, Oil shock caused major problems for the US in the 1970's. Strategic reserves exist, and the amount of Oil is finite. So it translates into a strategic issue, and, there will be direct involvement by the US if things get bad. The US I think will stay in S. Korea until the situation changes, it's better to have chips, but that's not necessary.
- phkahler 6y ago>> if something happened in the middle east, the global price would go up. But if WW III starts with say China taking Taiwan and getting into stuff in the pacific, and Russia invading easter european countries, and maybe some other stuff... If the US were to fully engage in some kind of global conflict, they could ban oil exports and not have a supply problem. This is the kind of thinking the military engages in to ensure their own supply chains won't be distrupted in a war. The ability to operate independently is important even if it's never used.
- lifeisstillgood 6y agoI agree, and while not clear was part of my orignal thoughts about oil independence - it's about both supply and demand. The electrification of our societies in the next decades will reshape a lot of the world.
- totalZero 6y agoYour comment assumes free-market pricing, but crude oil exports from the USA used to be unlawful (the ban was lifted in 2015) and they could presumably become unlawful again. There is no legal reason why the US government could not extend such a ban to include refined petroleum. https://www.pillsburylaw.com/en/news-and-insights/us-repeals-longstanding-ban-on-export-of-crude-oil.html https://www.pillsburylaw.com/en/news-and-insights/us-repeals... Also, several oil-producing nations have off-market domestic pricing for refined petroleum that is favorable versus the international spot price. Such prices won't naturally change when, say, the Strait of Hormuz closes. The IMF has been trying to force free-market pricing, as was the cause of the Ecuador protests in 2019.