8 ms·
I find it interesting that the people who screamed "trust/listen to the CDC!" the loudest when the CDC's position was "everyone wear your mask and stay home as
by josephcsible 6y ago
I find it interesting that the people who screamed "trust/listen to the CDC!" the loudest when the CDC's position was "everyone wear your mask and stay home as much as you can" are now the ones looking hardest for reasons to ignore/downplay/criticize the CDC's guidance.
- rsfern 6y agoI think most probably have a more nuanced position than that. My personal hesitation is that people are just going to ignore the explicit condition of full vaccination. Worst case outcome could result in dragging the pandemic out and providing opportunity for new variants to develop. A concern closer to home is that this will increase risk for my parents, who have been hesitant about the mRNA vaccines and refuse J&J because is produced using a fetal cell line.
- dalyons 6y agoNot sure why the rest of us should be required to continue to change our lives because of your parents (unfortunately) unfounded, anti-scientific personal views?
- rsfern 6y agoThat’s fair, my point is just that it’s a valid source of anxiety. And it’s not just my own parents. Like 30% of the US seems like they are not going to get a vaccine any time soon, and I worry that the guidance critically depends on the assumption that unvaccinated people will still mask up and distance. I don’t think it’s a very good assumption (would love to be proven wrong), and I don’t know what that means for the public health outlook of this new guidance.
- Kye 6y agoIdeas are easy to be against. Right now, covid is just an idea to a lot of people. They don't know anyone who's gotten sick, or worse. It's harder to be against a person. Once a few people in their social circles get the vaccine and live to tell the tale, the hesitance will fall away. Polls are a snapshot and can turn quickly. That's why pollsters keep repeating them.
- kelnos 6y agoPlease tell your parents the truth, that the J&J vaccine is not produced using a fetal cell line.
- rsfern 6y agoThanks, but I don’t think that’s actually accurate. AIUI, J&J grow their adenovirus vector using the cell line PERC.C6. This is a super emotional topic for a lot of people, so it doesn’t really make a difference for them that there are no PERC.C6 cells in the actual vaccine, or that the cell line is from the 80s, or any of that. I can at least understand this hesitancy, unlike the misinformation-fueled notion that the mRNA vaccines will change your DNA or something. https://www.reuters.com/article/factcheck-johnson-aborted-idUSL1N2LU1T9 https://www.reuters.com/article/factcheck-johnson-aborted-id... https://www.janssen.com/emea/emea/janssen-vaccine-technologies https://www.janssen.com/emea/emea/janssen-vaccine-technologi...
- Siira 6y agoYour parents are making their own tradeoffs. People need to accept responsibility for the tradeoffs they choose.
- rsfern 6y agoYes, I agree. The point is, how much does this new public health guidance depend on the assumption that people will accept the responsibility to either mask up or get vaccinated?
- ceejayoz 6y agoThe folks who won't do either have likely been doing that for the last year and would thus be already factored in to any case/infection numbers they're evaluating.
- HWR_14 6y agoI'm not sure the cause of their concern with the J&J being produced with a fetal cell line, but the Catholic Church has some fairly vocal guidance on why the J&J vaccine is acceptable that address this. Also, for the mRNA vaccine, you may want to emphasize that this is the result of several decades of research, not a one-year crash program in new technology.
- josephcsible 6y ago> the Catholic Church has some fairly vocal guidance on why the J&J vaccine is acceptable The Catholic Church's position is that the J&J vaccine is acceptable if it's the only vaccine you can get, but you should not get it if any of the other vaccines are available to you. Your comment makes it sound like they consider it acceptable unconditionally, which isn't the case.
- HWR_14 6y agoI didn't mean to misrepresent the Catholic Church's position. I have no idea if that helps the poster's parents decide to get vaccinated, but it's very clear that the Pope wants them to take the J&J shot if they don't have an alternative. And they currently don't have one they will accept. None of the other vaccines are available to the poster's parents (held up mRNA technology fear, even though they are available via distribution), so the Church's logic should still hold
- josephcsible 6y agoThere's a big difference between "don't have an alternative" and "don't have one they will accept." I don't think the Church means that it's okay to take J&J just because you don't like the others.
- throwkeep 6y agoBecause it's a publicly visible political statement and tribal signaling. What the MAGA hat was for the right, the mask is for the left.
- paganel 6y agoIt's crazy how politicised the mask has become in the States. Over here in my parts of Eastern-Europe the government just announced yesterday that starting tomorrow (Saturday) the mask won't be mandatory anymore in almost all outdoor spaces for everyone, a statement which was received with joy and relief by almost everyone, no matter their political orientation.
- cko 6y agoAh, Romania. Though this country does seem to have one of the lowest vaccination rates.
- Jataman606 6y agoIt could be also Poland.
- kelnos 6y agoYup, as an American I agree with you. I'm also thrilled to see these new CDC guidelines. It's absolutely sickened me that refusal to wear a mask is seen as "patriotic" in some circles.
- dguaraglia 6y agoThis is such a bullshit strawman. Most of my friends are family are very liberal. Most of them are already vaccinated. Not a single one of them wants to wear a mask unless absolutely necessary and everyone is ready for this to be over.
- slowmotiony 6y agoIf they've been vaccinated and still insist on wearing the masks, I kinda think you're proving OP's point here. What do you even mean with "waiting for this to be over"? You're vaccinated, it's over, are you now waiting for a super-vaccine or something?
- kelnos 6y agoI don't find it "interesting" at all that a particular group of people has decided to err on the side of caution in both cases. It's entirely consistent. This is how critical thinking works. If an organization advises something you think might be risky, you question it, and maybe don't do the potentially-risky thing until you have more information. But if an organization advises you to do something they claim reduces risk, you go ahead and do it. If information later comes out that this risk-reducing thing wasn't useful, then you stop doing it; you haven't lost anything by trying it. Regardless, we've all seen what happens in places where restrictions were lifted earlier than they should have been. Being cautious is the right move. As for myself, I'll be fully protected by the vaccine in about two weeks. I'll likely continue wearing a mask in public in order to help others around me feel more comfortable (because they have no idea if I've been vaccinated or not), but among people I know, I'll take the mask off. Once the vaccination rate is high enough around here, I'll leave it off in public, too, assuming state/local mandates allow it.
- josephcsible 6y ago> If an organization advises something you think might be risky, you question it My point is that last year, the party line was "the CDC is above questioning." > If information later comes out that this risk-reducing thing wasn't useful, then you stop doing it; you haven't lost anything by trying it. Pretty much every COVID mitigation has some negative effect, so I don't think "you haven't lost anything" is accurate.
- refurb 6y agoThey are just "following the science" (when it suits them).
- ceejayoz 6y agoOne must evaluate the consequences of not following a particular piece of advice. If masks work, and you don’t wear one, you are potentially killing people and worsening the pandemic. If they aren’t needed, and you do wear one anyways, no harm has been done.
- Siira 6y ago> If they aren’t needed, and you do force other people to wear it There, corrected your typo for you.
- ceejayoz 6y agoNo, you entirely changed my point to construct a straw man.
- stolenmerch 6y ago> no harm has been done This isn't the evaluation we're having though. If it was purely a personal choice to wear one or not then maybe. As it stands, most people were compelled by law to wear a mask under every circumstance whether it made sense or not. The argument quickly went from "wear a mask to protect yourself" to "everyone MUST wear a mask under every situation". It then split into two silly sides signally to their camps and a horrible political divide got much worse. Yeah, harm has been done.
- ceejayoz 6y ago> As it stands, most people were compelled by law to wear a mask under every circumstance whether it made sense or not. The CDC's recommendations changed yesterday. It'll take a couple days for states to adjust accordingly.
- stolenmerch 6y agoOf course. I'm talking about the life we all had for over a year and some of the harm it did.
- coffeefirst 6y agoOn the other hand, I walked down the street last night without a mask and almost everyone I crossed paths with wasn't wearing one either. This would have been unthinkable yesterday.