11 ms·
Gravity is not for physics lovers. Its physics make no sense. And contact is more fantasy than anything else. A pretty poor list.
by ekianjo 6y ago
Gravity is not for physics lovers. Its physics make no sense. And contact is more fantasy than anything else. A pretty poor list.
- JimBlackwood 6y agoAgreed. Glad to see Particle Fever in there though.
- hnlmorg 6y agoI don't get the love for Interstellar either. Their black hole rendering was about the only interesting thing about that movie. The rest of it was predictable and generic right up until the end at which point is felt like a jumping the shark movement with its ridiculousness.
- PopePompus 6y agoAnd even the black hole rendering was defective, because although they did GR ray tracing, they suppressed the doppler beaming effect which makes the side of the black hole moving towards the observer much brighter than the side moving away. So the image they produced was not very realistic.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoBy this argument, anything that doesn’t include every possible level of physics is defective.
- ConceptJunkie 6y agoNolan was aware of that effect, and it was simulated. He exercised artistic license in leaving it out. That doesn't take away anything from the movie.
- PopePompus 6y agoYes, I know that (Kip Thorne commented about it publicly), but still in my opinion it was a stupid choice. What would be so bad about trying to actually show what the BH would look like, if you're going to go to all the effort of GR ray tracing? My comment is being downvoted, but I stand by it. Why include lots of the physics, but not one of the most important effects?
- iainmerrick 6y agoI mostly agree about Interstellar, but I think it was the first time a lot of people encountered the idea of time dilation. It’s old hat in written SF, of course, but hadn’t come up much in major movies before (or at least that’s the impression I get from reactions and reviews by people who don’t read SF).
- willis936 6y agoTime dilation is a great and underutilized storytelling device. Far and away the best example I know of is Gunbuster. Most Western audiences don't want to sit through two and a half hours of 80s anime, regardless of the quality.
- craftinator 6y agoTime dilation is used to great effect in the Ender series by Orson Card, though not in the first book (Ender's Game). Highly recommend reading the rest of them if you've only read the first (or seen the movie).
- EricE 6y agoAny time Ender's Game is mentioned I immediately think of this review that was way more entertaining than the source material: http://somethingshortandsnappy.blogspot.com/2013/03/enders-game-chapter-1-part-1-in-which.html http://somethingshortandsnappy.blogspot.com/2013/03/enders-g...
- daishi424 6y agoAh, yes, the infamous Rip Van Winkle effect. I consider time dilation to be an inherently literary format, and Forever War is where the idea is turned up to eleven. There's also a short comic adaptation if you like.
- teraflop 6y agoThe first installment of Ursula K. Le Guin's Hainish universe is a time dilation story in the style of a folk tale: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dowry_of_Angyar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dowry_of_Angyar
- chickenmonkey 6y agoI liked the picturisation of the different planets and of course, the time dilation effects. I think they're great for a general audience, who may not be exposed to the latest developments in astronomy.
- fsh 6y agoPeople love making fun of the bad orbital mechanics in Gravity, but Interstellar is no better. In the beginning they need a Saturn V-size rocket to leave earth orbit. Later they simply decide to leave the laws of physics behind and start zipping around earth-size planets in a tiny scifi-shuttle. Not to speak of the impossibility of kilometer-tall waves in knee-deep water and the ridiculous spinning spaceship scene.
- phonypc 6y ago>the impossibility of kilometer-tall waves in knee-deep water FWIW I think those were supposed to be some sort of extreme tides due to the black hole. Maybe still impossible, but I don't think it was just "Big waves are cool lol".
- jacksonkmarley 6y agoThose big waves were really cool. Every now and then I watch it mainly for that bit. Fun movie, ending sucked.
- TchoBeer 6y ago>Fun movie, ending sucked. these are my thoughts also
- pintxo 6y agoWasn‘t the knee deep water just the trough of the wave?
- bena 6y agoYeah, the whole planet was essentially an ocean, but the gravity of the black hole was such that it was pulling all the water to one point. With the spinning of the planet, it was essentially a wave. Basically, the water was acting as a comet's tail does. But backwards.
- slowhand09 6y ago
- jiggawatts 6y agoIt's one of the few realistic scifi movies out there. No aliens eating your face. No sound in space. No unobtanium. No gravity plating. Etc... It was made by someone with attention to detail. When Cooper looks out the window, it looks exactly like the real footage of Apollo astronauts looking out the CM window. The music is great. That can't be understated. The organ music lends a gravitas that's missing in other scifi movies. But most importantly, it goes to the core of what I want from science fiction: it changed my world view, permanently. Remember Doctor Mann, and his desperation to return to Earth? No other piece of fiction has made me feel that way. That utter, unspeakable, unbearable isolation of being the only human on this side of the universe. To be so far from everything that it's hard to wrap your brain around it. And if you do... you experience a Lovecraftian horror that drives you mad. That's why I like Interstaller. It's proper, classic science fiction!
- EForEndeavour 6y agoInterstellar had plenty of unphysical/unrealistic/fantastical content. Five-dimensional descendants of humans tearing open an Einstein-Rosen bridge in the outer solar system to screw with causality? Their ship requiring multiple-stage launch from earth, but taking off without similar assistance from subsequent planets? "Love is the one thing we're capable of perceiving that transcends dimensions of time and space. Maybe we should trust that, even if we can't understand it"?? I think the point we'd agree on is that sci-fi definitely doesn't need to adhere slavishly to known physics to be good.
- me_me_me 6y ago> I think the point we'd agree on is that sci-fi definitely doesn't need to adhere slavishly to known physics to be good. This is my biggest pet peeve. So many people dont get it. Its a movie, not a physics book readout. Smart-asses on twitter pointing out this or that being incorrect is boring and they ruin a movie for themselves. Gravity is a little silly sci-fi movie and I enjoyed. I understand enough of orbital physics to chuckle at an astronaut flying on an extinguisher from a space station to another space station. >> But ISS and Chinese stations could not be so close >> But in the opening the debree from the original crash has different relative V therefore it would completely miss the station on second pass Who cares? Just enjoy the movie. If you can't - read a physics book.
- HideousKojima 6y agoI loved Interstellar, but not for the physics. I thought it was a great story about the human spirit, the power of love across time and space, etc. and the sci-fi elements were there to help make it more interesting and to provide explanations for a lot of the events like how Cooper got the messages that lead to the events of the movie in the first place.
- shuntress 6y ago> I thought it was a great story about the human spirit The character literally named MANN destroys himself due to shortsighted selfishness.
- gavinmckenzie 6y agoI love Interstellar despite some of the liberties it takes. For me the number one thing Interstellar did so well was communicate clearly that the universe does not care about us. We are infinitesimally small and insignificant. I felt the scale of space and the unforgiving progress of time, as characters dealt with the emotional impact of time dilation on them, their colleagues, and family. And we, as viewers, get to experience it as we see minutes pass from our POV only to return to Endurance and realize Romilly has aged over 20 years in orbit, all alone; and Cooper’s kids have suddenly grown up without us noticing. And as others have noted about the film before, it also relates to the phenomena we experience as we age and our perception of time accelerates. If you’re a parent, you feel yourself slipping farther and faster away from your children with each passing year. Chances are if you watched Interstellar as a parent, you felt the film deeply on another level.
- cgriswald 6y agoI enjoy re-interpreting the movies by taking them at face value and assuming what happened happened but not for the reason we were told. This can sometimes mean burning things: a character is wrong about the gravity of a planet. It can also have more interesting results: Kowalski didn’t have to die and he knew he didn’t have to die and chose to die anyway while encouraging Stone to keep going.
- pessimizer 6y agoIt's also the 9 millionth sf movie/series about exploring an unknown frontier and finding your father there. I have a feeling these are just wish-fulfilment portraits of the mental state of a certain type of high-achieving dude i.e. succeeding in something that no other humans have yet, and finally seeing daddy's approval for the first time.
- beloch 6y agoActual physicist here. Don't get me started on Interstellar. There is so much needlessly dumb crap in this movie that I don't even know where to start, and the fact that people think it's realistic is just a kick in the pants. Just for one example... The crew being sent to save the Earth blasts off in a big ol' chemical rocket with stages. Yeah, fine. I guess rocket tech hasn't advanced all that much in this future. Then they land a ship on a planet in a gravity well so intense that it causes big relative time differences (Note: the gravity alone should have killed them). Then they blast off with the same ship and no big clunky chemical rocket stages. Why didn't this ship just blast off of Earth as is? The energy to get off Earth is nothing compared to getting out of a gravity well that deep! I guess Nolan thought an oldschool staged rocket looked cool. The SFX people did some actual science to figure out the black hole visuals but, other than that, this is a far worse movie than Gravity as far as science is concerned. The new age emotions resolution was just a big ol' F U to the crowd. Lazy, sloppy writing. There are plenty of unrealistic movies on this list, and that's fine. Some are just damned fun movies (e.g. Back to the Future). Interstellar sticks out from the pack for it's pretensions and underlying ridiculousness.
- phonypc 6y agoTime dilation during their trip to the first planet was because of its proximity to the black hole, not the planets own gravity well.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Then they land a ship on a planet with a gravity well so intense that it causes big relative time differences Pedantically, no, they don’t. They land on a planet deep enough in a black hole’s gravity well to cause significant relative time differences. (Obviously, this doesn’t change the issue of delta-V to get back to the mother ship, though the difference is relevant to your “the gravity alone should have killed them” comment, since that would only occur of there was a hard surface not in free fall with respect to the gravity well for them to be crushed into.) > Then they blast off with the same ship and no big clunky chemical rocket stages. Why didn't this ship just blast off of Earth as is? Maybe because the super drive it uses would have adverse environmental impacts used in Earth’s atmosphere, and Earth has enough of that to deal with, but they cut the exposition-that-doesn’t move-the-plot-forward about that because they were making a movie, not a technical report on the mission’s decisionmaking.
- geophile 6y agoThat is quite charitable. Emotionally hollow and manipulative, and jaw-droppingly turgid and stupid dialog. Just a terrible movie.
- the_af 6y ago> I don't get the love for Interstellar either I enjoyed some of Interstellar, but disliked the anti-scientificism. When they need to pick planet, probably humanity's last hope, you know there will be two options -- the scientifically sensible option and the "go with your heart" one -- and of course the latter is the right one. When scientists follow the scientific method they end up making a mistake, because science is cold and uncaring but nothing can stop the power of the heart, I guess. I would really like a scifi movie that showed instances where intuition, common sense and "love" mislead you, and sometimes you just have to follow the more methodical procedure and check your blindspots.
- mavhc 6y agoThat's because films are about people, not science. I would really like a scientific paper that showed instances where intuition, common sense and "love" don't mislead you, and sometimes you don't have to follow the more methodical procedure and check your blindspots. Actually most science is intuition, followed by checking if it's correct. Intuition misleads people all the time, and letting people in the spaceship after the xenomorph has infected them is illogical, and really bad.
- the_af 6y agoI don't agree with this. Scientists are people too, and science is a human endeavor after all. I really, really dislike when Hollywood portrays scientists and science as fundamentally blind and cold, and that what will really save you is The Power of Love. The good old "leave your cold facts and numbers and follow your heart" trope, which tends to triumph in movies because Hollywood thinks audiences are uninterested in science (which becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy). In Interstellar this is manifested in that the "logical" choice of planet (i.e. the one we would have wanted this group of people to pick, were this a real situation) was wrong (because obviously a scientist lied), and the right choice was following your heart all along. As for xenomorphs: I utterly love Alien and Aliens (a pity they never made any sequels, right?) but they aren't examples of realistic movies, and the characters often make movie-logic decisions, and that's fine: these are horror-scifi and action-scifi movies, respectively, and don't try to be anything else. > I would really like a scientific paper that showed instances where intuition, common sense and "love" don't mislead you, and sometimes you don't have to follow the more methodical procedure and check your blindspots. Those exist. Unlike with movies often ridiculing science and scientists, science doesn't downplay the usefulness of emotions and intuition.
- spodek 6y agoAgreed. Plus ". . . in their lifetime" is a pointless affectation.
- cm2187 6y agoPerhaps "Chernobyl" and "Fat Man and Little Boy" (on the Manhattan project).
- Vaslo 6y agoCame here to recommend Fat Man - a little overacting in it but still a really good movie without overwhelming the non scientific folks
- js8 6y agoThere is also https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Day_One_(1989_film) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Day_One_(1989_film), which I like better. I also really enjoyed Einstein & Eddington (from the list) for some reason.
- cfallin 6y agoFor anyone looking for a documentary on the Manhattan Project, I'd highly highly recommend The Day After Trinity, a documentary by Jon Else with a bunch of interviews of the original participants (it was made in 1980). Really fantastic look at the personalities behind all the science.
- mavhc 6y agoAnd the fictionalised version is good https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manhattan_(TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manhattan_(TV_series)
- amelius 6y agoWhat's wrong with the physics of Gravity?
- larrydag 6y agoTravelling between orbital spacecraft is not as easy at it sounds.
- amelius 6y agoIn general. But in specific cases it can be?
- larrydag 6y agoHere's some interesting commentary on the delta-v and the movie Gravity. https://www.rocketstem.org/2013/11/03/delta-v-gravity-situation/ https://www.rocketstem.org/2013/11/03/delta-v-gravity-situat...
- zardo 6y agoJust considering the orbital heights, they fudged it a bit. What makes it laughable is the inclination, the ISS is ~51 degrees and the Hubble is ~29. That's something like a 3500m/s burn.
- AnotherGoodName 6y agoWell the Russians used to do this when they had Salyut and Mir space stations. As an example multi-space station mission: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soyuz_T-15 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soyuz_T-15
- troyvit 6y agoTears that float away from your face as a perfect lil' sphere ... that's what encapsulates it all for me.
- 6y ago
- aitchnyu 6y agoWatching this after Planates anime (2002) was so underwhelming. Its about an underequipped team tasked with retrieving space debris. It featured a kid born on moon with accelerated ageing, risk of cancer, inequitable fight for resources, token compliance of environment cleanup. Trailer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=igmZSI3kILY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=igmZSI3kILY OP https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CeBPzoilfQk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CeBPzoilfQk
- miltondts 6y agoThe first episodes (5-6 I think?) aren't spectacular. I hate the type of humor they use (which is actually quite common for anime of the same era). But when the main story gets going, it really is one of the best hard sci-fi shows I've seen. The trailer you linked is quite good and representative of what to expect.
- isatty 6y ago+1 for planates Though yes like the other comment says be aware that not all anime kicks off well, a few bad episodes at the start are pretty much expected at this point.
- saagarjha 6y agoPlanetes is great, although I felt the ending cheapened the themes a bit. But the reintroduction of seemingly one-off characters to tie up loose ends and advance the plot, coupled with the fairly hard science fiction, was excellent.
- question11 6y agoContact was written by Carl Sagan... I believe the science holds together.
- jerf 6y agoThere isn't much "science" in it to hold together. Obviously the entire wormhole machine, the wormhole trip, what was on the other side, etc. was fantasy, and what's left is just receiving signals.
- daishi424 6y agoWormhole devices in movies keep puzzling me for quite some time - why does a significant number of them look like rings rotating around each other? Contact is one example, another is Event Horizon. The Terminator also had a similar looking time machine.
- magicalhippo 6y agoNot sure if there's some pseudo-physical explanation, but I've imagined it has something to do with visualizing the three dimensions that are manipulated. Interestingly both Event Horizon and Contact (movie) are from 1997...
- goldenkey 6y agoPretty sure it mostly stems from initial illustrations for The Time Machine by H.G. Wells.
- hnlmorg 6y agoI suspect the reason is as simple as it looks cool and dramatic on screen.
- at_a_remove 6y agoI've often thought about this. Currently, our sole way of manipulating spacetime is by cramming a heck of a lot of matter in one spot, which is to say that we don't really do much of it. Any way short of crushing down mountainsful of matter into a thimble would necessarily be more complex, with more moving parts. I can only think that rotation would come into play, and if one dimension is good, three would have to be better if you want to shred spacetime. I don't think it's doable but in the sense that you want something to visually convey it, it may as well be the equivalent of lightning to stand in for electricity.
- arnejenssen 6y ago"Contact" could be seen as interpretation of General Relativity. On earth, to the outside observer, it appears like the space travel took no time. On board the spaceship the time lasted much longer. I guess the space ship curved the the space-time.
- ModernMech 6y agoThis is a list of movies that would be interesting to people who like physics, not movies that accurately depict physical phenomena. As someone with a physics degree, I've enjoyed almost every movie on this list, so I would say it has something going for it. People watch movies for the fantasy element, including physics lovers. Some of us watch gravitational simulations all day long as part of our work. We don't go to the movies to watch them in cinematic form when we're off the clock. It's fine if they get the physics wrong imo, and again, I say that as someone who invested a lot of time and money in understanding physics.
- twirlip 6y agoWhile true, Gravity was an incredible spectacle when viewed in IMAX 3D. I would argue seeing it in a normal theatre or at home would be such a lesser experience, it would be as if you were watching a different movie. The IMAX 3D movie conveyed the black emptiness of space, the splendor of Earth from orbit, the velocity of moving objects, and the inertia of a human body in a way that dazzled the viewer. It was astonishing. True, the physics was wrong. By not as wrong as other films.
- rcpt 6y ago"oh shit looks like we're going to miss our connecting flight? Alright let me just jump out the door and land on the next airplane"
- mikestew 6y agoGravity is not for physics lovers. Not all physics lovers, no. Just the physics lovers who love to throw things at screens.
- forgotpwd16 6y agoContact is the film every single one of my astronomy professors have recommended at some point. It may be fantasy but seems to really resonate with scientists.