11 ms·
The digital natives are not who you think they are
- raverbashing 6y agoYes. Today's "digital natives" just mean they know how to open Netflix on their phones and make a tiktok video. Not dissing those activities, but it's not technical knowledge per se. Ask them what's an IP address, how would they go about replacing a hard drive, etc, and get empty stares. I've been hearing from some companies/hiring managers that candidates in entry level jobs have difficulty with basic Word/Excel usage.
- awestley 6y agoI've thought the same thing. I was lucky enough to grow up with computers. I matured as they did. This allowed me to understand the hardware and software fundamentally. It seems like a lot of that knowledge has been abstracted behind the well polished machines that exist today. It makes it hard to really learn what these devices are actually doing.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoFortunately, these abstractions are horribly broken, so you get to peek behind the curtain on the regular.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- solraph 6y agoI grew up in that era as well - but I realised it doesn't matter. I used to have compile my own kernels and fumble around with downloading and installing the nVidia drivers, and now my distro deals with that for me. I can go look if I want to, but I don't need to. And you know what, it's better that way. The tech scene and civilisation moves forward because those abstractions lets us achieve more with the same amount of time. I fully embrace that notion that one of the problems of the well polished machines is that access to the underlying layers is actively blocked. I think this is a very real problem. However, if you want to learn programming, electronics, operating systems or any other level of the stack there is a plethora of options available to you. Most people simply have other interests.
- awestley 6y agoYeah. I suppose that is right. For me, that was an ideal way to learn but that doesn't mean their aren't different/better ways. And don't get me wrong, I'm all for these layers of abstraction helping simplify complex systems and allow for progression. In fact, that's a big part of my career now.
- Smithalicious 6y agoAnother instance of "middle-aged tech nerd makes fun of kids these days" I get it, you're not too old to be good at computers, but I don't see the need to put down the younger generation and act like their tech knowledge doesn't extend beyond "video streaming". Acting like kids are computer wizards is an exaggeration, but acting like young people know less about computing than this older generation is simply wrong.
- oraphalous 6y agoYeah... I agree, and would argue further that there is a specific kind of mistake being made in this post that I see many in tech make... That of believing that living lower down the stack makes you superior somehow... Here's an example of someone I think is clearly fucking amazing but arguably lives much higher up the stack than this guy... https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.theverge.com/platform/amp/22370260/codemiko-twitch-interview-stream-technician https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2...
- zozbot234 6y agoFixed link: https://www.theverge.com/platform/amp/22370260/codemiko-twitch-interview-stream-technician https://www.theverge.com/platform/amp/22370260/codemiko-twit...
- teachingassist 6y agoI have taught kids for 20 years. Young people (on average) know less about computing than they did. The author of this article says "floppy disks, or 'the save icon' as the young kids would recognize it" - except that they often wouldn't. Kids don't have any experience of saving and loading files.
- worker767424 6y ago> Young people (on average) know less about computing than they did. They know less about desktop computing.
- abootstrapper 6y ago“Oregon Trail” generation here. I’m more tech literate than my older and younger family members. But I also made tech my career so I’m not sure if this is a fair anecdote.
- moshmosh 6y agoSame, same, and same. I think there's a tendency for anyone who halfway gets how computers work to end up in tech, because halfway getting how computers work pays much better than almost anything else that's anywhere near as easy to get into. About the only reason not to is if you can't stand sitting in front of a screen reading and typing arcane crap all day (a sentiment I very much sympathize with). If you're an Excel whiz and kinda understand how to navigate a filesystem and how that relates (and how it doesn't) to what you navigate to in a web browser, then you're not that far from being a Javascript jockey, which pays better than most mid-tier or lower office work, even entry-level. So mid-tier office workers, and others at or below that pay level, are usually not much more than barely competent at using computers, because if they were better they'd rarely stay in those roles. I don't find that younger generations are much more inclined to "get" computers in that way than, at the very least, Gen X and Millennials are/were. And the main thing driving younger kids to learn actually-useful computer skills seem to be the same as before—PC video games & modding. Dunno what will happen if those stop having a unique appeal compared with mobile and console games. Probably universities will have to get used to most of their best CS candidates not having already done half the university's job for them, in self-directed free time from ages 8-18. I do get the sense that a hell of a lot of kids are better at video production and photography than in our generation, but the tools they have for that are so much better, easier to use, and cheaper, and there are more incentives (YouTube and such) for them to at least give it a try, that it'd be surprising if that weren't the case. Smartphones, free YouTube how-tos, free non-terrible video & photo editing software, and much faster computers, completely changed the accessibility of getting hands-on with those things. You can do more experimentation with, say, lighting, in 10 minutes now than you could in an hour with your folks' old tape camcorder.
- ghaff 6y agoI spent way too many hours in a darkroom in high school and college. While it was fun, I'd never want to go back to all the time spent messing with chemicals. Video of course was even worse. In fact, I was somewhat into film at the time but the overhead of dealing with heavy tape camcorders and editing was more than I could deal with. I'd definitely have done more if I'd had access to even an iPhone and Final Cut Pro X. Good photography and good video are still hard of course. But so many barriers have been removed.
- ghaff 6y agoWhile the author's point is probably valid to some degree, it's not really what digital native means. [1] It was popularized by an education consultant so understanding it primarily in the context of consuming media and interacting with computers of all types is likely the right lens. It's not really connected to being able to program and having a lot of under the hood computer knowledge. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_native https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_native
- CalRobert 6y agoThere's something to be said about growing up using devices that are made for creation and not just consumption - the barrier to go from "this is a cool web page! How can I make one?" is a hell of a lot higher on a phone than a computer, or now vs. the mid-90's (if only because the standards are so much higher). But this guy is just being a jerk: "Digital natives my ass, all they do is stream videos on YouTube and Twitch." Which is a shame, because it crowds out what I was hoping would be a more thoughtful discussion about devices created purely for consumption, or perhaps walled gardens, and how they don't afford people the same opportunity to learn as general purpose computers. I wonder if early car enthusiasts felt the same about people who learned to drive when you no longer needed to know how to fix your car all the time.
- ghaff 6y ago>I wonder if early car enthusiasts felt the same about people who learned to drive when you no longer needed to know how to fix your car all the time. I don't think you need to go back to early car enthusiasts. A lot of people would argue that at least being able to do basic car maintenance is a life skill everyone should have. I don't necessarily agree but I do think it's useful to understand at least the basics of how a car operates.
- ggggtez 6y agoThe car is a black box. Gas goes in, vroom comes out. If the box stops working, I pay someone to fix it. You might argue I'm not car literate, but I'm not sure that is particularly insightful, as the type of specialized knowledge is not actually relevant to doing almost anything with a car that people want to do. Similarly, while coding is great and all, I'm not sure that not being able to code is the same thing as not knowing how to use a computer effectively.
- ghaff 6y agoI won't argue. And I grew up at a time when cars were less reliable (and my first clunker certainly wasn't). I do think some basic things like changing a tire, jumping a battery, and at least knowing how to check fluid levels is useful. You don't always have something go wrong where you can easily just call for help.
- alex_young 6y agoWhile I feel similarly, this strikes me as a nearly perfect example of No True Scotsman. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman
- johanneskanybal 6y agoThe phrase digital native is silly, like petrol positive to describe the 1900+’ers. Being exposed to apps won’t make the next generation supperior. But having parents from the previous generation surely will without any doubt at all.
- worker767424 6y agoThis is confusing knowing how to use technology with knowing how technology works under the hood. I can drive a a car, but I'm a shit mechanic, and only vaguely know how to go about designing an engine.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- carbonguy 6y ago> When it comes down to the meat and potatoes, they do not know jack shit. Don't forget to tell the kids to get off your lawn after you're done shaking your fist at that cloud. I find it pretty difficult to believe that, in the age of universal instant access to technology information at every level of abstraction, "kids these days" are somehow less knowledgeable about computers than they were in the author's glory days of, presumably, the early-to-mid 80's - "I grew up with the 286, 386, 486 and all the other x86’es." If I had to, I'd bet that just as many (or just as few, depending on your perspective) "kids" get their hands dirty (as it were) with the guts of computing as ever have - and having written this out, my assertion sounds absurdly conservative. How is it possible that more kids don't know more?
- AussieWog93 6y agoI'm a late millennial, born in 93. I've met a few of the vintage computing nerds in my travels, and am constantly impressed by the depth of their knowledge. I wouldn't say that young people are bad at _using_ a computer, or even building/servicing them, but we don't understand the technology in the same way the older generation had to. "Computing" just isn't a hobby the way it used to be.
- carbonguy 6y ago> I've met a few of the vintage computing nerds in my travels, and am constantly impressed by the depth of their knowledge. Sure, I've met a few greybeards too, and I'm happy to agree that they have tremendous depth of knowledge about computing that most of us millennials (myself included) lack. But keep in mind that they have a depth of knowledge about computing that most of their generational peers lack as well! Additionally, your statement that "we don't understand the technology in the same way the older generation had to" is just as true if you reverse it: the older generation doesn't understand the technology in the same way WE have to. For my part, I find it pretty difficult to look at the obvious technical aptitude of somebody like, say, Alyssa Rosenzweig or Mike Stewart - and then conclude that the younger generation doesn't "understand the technology." Perhaps the problem here is that we're trying to compare multiple unknowns. What counts as "impressive depth of knowledge" for a generation? Is there anything objective one could use to say "actually yes, this generation really does know less than that one?" Because to me it sounds like the argument being made is "the fact that they don't understand what we went through is proof they know less than us" - not that they know differently but that they know less - and I don't buy that argument.
- chizhik-pyzhik 6y agoOld man yells at children to get off his lawn
- kortex 6y agoThat's still not what "digital natives" means. Yes, sure, there's millenial nerds like myself that had to actually know a bit about computers to use them. That's not the point. Digital natives were born after the inception of the internet. If they don't want to use it to learn about computers, or hobbies, or ancient history, that's their prerogative. But I bet the percent of young folks enriching their minds is about the same nowadays as back then. But now, they are outnumbered by general users. No, you don't get 1337 skillzors by osmosis, that's not the point of Digital Natives. The point is they were born with greater intellectual opportunities than any prior generation.
- zozbot234 6y ago> The point is they were born with greater intellectual opportunities than any prior generation. Nope they weren't. This is the least intellectual generation since the latest 60 years or more. There's nothing "intellectual" about following the latest popular trends on Facebook or Twitter.
- Bukhmanizer 6y agoThat’s not what they said. The parent said they’re born with more intellectual opportunities than other generations. In other words, they have more content to fulfil whatever intellectual curiousities they want. > There's nothing "intellectual" about following the latest popular trends on Facebook or Twitter This just comes off as smug and self-serving bs.
- xboxnolifes 6y agoI think there absolutely are more intellectual opportunities. On the flip side I also believe the absolute number of distractions have increased by an amount that seems to dwarf the productive activities.
- pimlottc 6y agoFluency in digital culture is a separate skill from expertise in digital technology. Both are valuable, but the latter is what "digital natives" generally refers to.
- christophilus 6y agoPluralization are not what you think them is.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoI think the way “digital native” is someone for whom the technology is so pervasive that they don’t think about how it is implemented and spend more time thinking how it can be used. Many times, it is rarely the people that developed the technology that are aware of all the ways it can be used, but rather people for whom the technology was a given.
- terenceng2010 6y agoI kind of miss the day when everyone is chatting on the phone and ICQ, MSN and you need to be in a certain time for certain people. Nowadays, my brother who is a digital native just chat with his friends all day long with Discord, which is something that I just can never do.
- megameter 6y agoAll that comes to mind is how people who displayed deep technical knowledge online, back in the 90's, were often misanthropic, tactless stereotypes who loved hacking because they wanted power. To the extent that people who are now in their 30's and 40's "learned computers", it was mostly to get the printer working, load a game or bypass school security. Young people today do the same things, just using slightly different mediums. If you started earlier you might have learned more about your 8-bit micro's hardware, if you started later, more about servers and 3D graphics. It's just stuff.
- zozbot234 6y ago> were often misanthropic, tactless stereotypes who loved hacking because they wanted power. It's not like the SV techbros of the 2000s and 2010s are any different from that POV. We used to complain about the power wielded by the local BOFH sysadmin, but that's nothing compared to present-day "tech" monopolies.
- jackjeff 6y agoI’m always reluctant to generalize. If I remember correctly most people from our generation (the author and myself) were pretty bad at using computer. Computer Geeks were a fairly minority. I see the same thing in my son’s class. There’s a couple of kids who can mess around with HTML and JavaScript and programmable LEGO. But they’re all well versed in social media in the same way we could all type on a T9 keyboard.
- mmcgaha 6y agoThe first time I heard the phrase digital native was about ten or so years ago from a then 22-year-old guy in IT. I get what he was saying; most of his life he had digital devices and internet access so it was more ingrained in his psyche. He was trying to use it as a differentiation between him and the rest of us old farts. Of course he did not have enough context to realize that folks older than him were no less digital native with our own computers, video games and slide rule calculators. At the end of the day it is just a term millennials used to market themselves in the tech community. I am sure the kids born in the 2010s will come up with their own differentiations (first always connected generation maybe?).
- swiley 6y agoI'm a millennial and have never heard anyone younger than my parents use this phrase. I've always hated it for similar reasons, the "digital natives" are mostly just used to being slaves to cooperate software publishers/authors and don't understand the freedom that a properly configured PC provides.
- tomrod 6y agoThe author has a point. I disagree with it fairly strongly however. "Digital Native" doesn't meant built digital, it means uses digital means first. I get it's a slippery concept. YouTube creator sounds like a narcissistic ploy. It is, to a minor degree, but it's creating content for others to use. So to map an analogy, this guy is complaining about people using the roads he builds and knows how to build, and fails to recognize the farmer, the opera singer, the teacher, the Cloud Engineer, and so on that use those roads regularly.
- worker767424 6y agoSomething that's missing in all of this is why the author was into computers. They obviously were, and running a homelab is as good of a hobby as any, but to what end? Kids aren't learning this because why would they when they just want to watch Tiktok videos.
- tibbydudeza 6y agoComing from using dialup with a USR Robotics Sportster 56K modem using Mosaic browser on Win 3.1 with Winsock I am glad my kids have the iPad. I learned a lot but things are now far complicated but easier for ordinary people to use.
- motohagiography 6y agoTalk to kids about cryptocurrency mining and suddenly you have teenagers who understand Merkle trees and zero knowledge proofs. They understand mining rigs and GPUs, which are about as ground up as anyone in the PC generation ever got. They also use raspi's, there are real advantages to learning reverse engineering (Hackaday is evidence of this), and I'd even say ethereum is the new netbsd. The abstractions we spent the last 30 years on (operating systems, protocols, etc) will fade like musical genres. There were literaally people who spent 5+ years of their lives learning OS/2, SCO, VMS, Novell, and others. I"m optimistic about kids. Also, there are demographic issues. Consider that aptitude is Pareto distributed, which means the population lull between millenaials and the younger zombie apocalypse generation creates a smaller total sample of people in that range, so you don't encounter as many upper percentile people in that cohort because there just aren't as many of them. Any minority demographic is necessarily going to appear less exceptional because even if the distribution is the same (pareto), you're going to encounter more of the long tail cohort, and fewer of the very tiny exceptional elite in that selection. This guy is on about a group of kids who have the same aptitude distribution as older folks, but since there are fewer of them than the mega generations like X, Y, and M , he's ignoring their exceptions and focusing on their long tail.
- IdiocyInAction 6y ago> Talk to kids about cryptocurrency mining and suddenly you have teenagers who understand Merkle trees and zero knowledge proofs. Yeah, an extremely small subset of nerdy kids. When people speak of "digital natives", they mean the population at large. Nerdy kids are nothing new.
- kyle-rb 6y agoThere are a lot of teenagers who are interested in cryptocurrency, but I think relatively few of them are actually mining themselves, and an even smaller subset of them understand much of the cryptography at work. I'm speaking from experience; I mined some Dogecoin in high school, but at that point I was just barely learning for-loops.
- sethammons 6y agoKey quote: > If anybody is a digital native, it is me. I did not just grow up with computers, I grew up alongside them. Yes, this. I grew up and grew with technology as a member of the Oregon Trail Generation. Of course, kids these days will learn to operate with the greatest and latest abstractions and will continue to awesome things. The folly is calling the whole generation "digital natives." Just because you are exposed to (consumption based) technology, it does not mean you understand it at some foundational level. It is similar with cars - I've driven cars all my life, but working on them? I'm terrible at it.
- koala_man 6y agoI don't think "digital native" was ever intended to mean or imply "skilled in computer science", and more "takes digital technology for granted (and therefore thinks differently)". For example, if you ask where someone lives for the purpose of meeting them there, an analog native might answer in terms of driving directions. This would never occur to a digital native, who would instead answer with an address under the assumption that you'll plop it into your GPS.
- ud_0 6y agoIt took myself a while to admit, and I get why this is an unsatisfying take for a community as heavy on creatives as HN: there are digital native makers and digital native consumers, and the latter is utterly dominating the young population to the point of relegating the makers to the fringe. The age of making tools and coming up with workarounds in the face of limitations has come to an end as a mainstream computing activity. A person using a computer in the 90s had to know a lot of technical details and was far more likely to need this knowledge in order to accomplish something. A person growing up today does not, in general, have this need: they can go their whole lives without ever needing to know anything "technical" by virtue of never brushing up against serious limitations that seem surmountable with personal expertise. Before judging what's good and bad about this, other people have rightfully pointed out the exact same shift in other technology/tools sectors, such as the car industry. The most positive way I can frame this shift in respect to computing is: In the beginning, the tool itself mattered the most. Its composition, its setup, its ever-evolving but inspectable properties. For many, the tool itself was the purpose. Overcoming its limitations and improving it was the purpose. By now, the tool itself is no longer relevant. It only matters what you can do with it. The works made with the tool are center stage. Whatever limitations the tool still has are accepted as unchangeable and/or not worth contemplating. Spending time on the tool itself is considered, at best, a weird hobby.
- lasagnaphil 6y agoThe knowledge of making and maintaining these tools is still incredibly important and should be handed out through generations (while also inventing innovations to make more efficient and powerful tools). But what many older generations in tech who constantly lament about the “new generation of tech-illiterates” ignore is that there are actually quite some people (both old and young) who understand this and are actually dedicating towards learning, teaching, and creating low-level mechanisms and systems (such as the people in the Handmade Hero Network, the young new Linux hackers contributing to the kernel, and hobbyists creating their own game engines). And it’s a grave disrespect against them to say that nobody actually cares about anything. If you really are worried about this, don’t just complain and cry about it, be the change you want to see in the world.
- batch12 6y agoNothing I read in this article has anything to do with somone being a "digital native". I read digital native as digital-first. In this case "digital native" rings true. Hell, reading this rant, I caught myself thinking along the lines of pshh-- 286? What, you didn't breadboard your first PC and clear your eeproms with a UV light? The feeling that the youth knows less than the olds is something I have heard as long as I have been able to understand the concept. If this was really the case, we would all know nothing by now.
- voldacar 6y agoIf you havent, make sure you teach your kids proficiency with desktop systems and the command line. That way they will be lords instead of serfs
- Ekaros 6y agoI think millenials are the first and last generation of digital natives. That is the group that had to deal with computers when they were yet not polished and hiding everything, but still grew up and adopted the modern way to use it. Good question for this group is what use of technology they wouldn't be able to pick up if needed? That is new app or skill? Ofc, young people using the apps and social networks know what is going on there and how to use them, but that isn't really key. Key is being able to do that and understand computing at some level.
- deanCommie 6y agoOK, Digital Native, go create some content edited to the quality and style of something like https://www.tiktok.com/@happykelli https://www.tiktok.com/@happykelli [1] Content Creators today on TikTok and Youtube are as talented and multifaceted as some of the most talented musicians of previous generations. And they're using the tools of the day. Don't be condescending because they don't know the low level abstractions that are completely irrelevant to them any longer. They are pushing the envelope and doing advanced shit with the best tools available to them JUST LIKE YOU USED TO. [1] I feel like I might even have to use this example for anyone whose understanding of TikTok is just "pick an effect from a dropdown list then make funny faces at the camera until the ML algorithm generates something awesome". Most of the videos of this person are completely impossible to create natively through the app. They require a clever combination of built-in filters, and offline video postprocessing, and extremely precise editing. Plus some awesome dancing.
- lamontcg 6y agoI'm in the same generation (or maybe even slightly older) than the author of that article. And at work I tend to see a lot of the "digital natives" who can't understand how the black box was built and they put together things that they don't really understand and they really like to throw around a lot of lingo to deal with what I suspect is a bunch of imposter syndrome going on. There are really fairly few people who understand how its built and will drill down until they find and fix the problem.
- seoaeu 6y ago> If anybody is a digital native, it is me. I did not just grow up with computers, I grew up alongside them. How is that not misunderstanding the meaning of native? Google's first definition for native is "a person born in a specified place or associated with a place by birth, whether subsequently resident there or not." Growing up alongside computers is another way of saying they weren't with you since birth.
- BTCOG 6y agoAs a commenter on the article stated and summed up better than I've seen here in these comments (maybe Sam is one of you here) a native doesn't at all mean that it's someone who knows the ins and outs of today's modern computers. A native is simply someone born right into using. These kids may not know anything about how their phone chips work, or how their school laptops work, but they had cheap computers in their pocket and laptops in school where us older generations didn't have any of this stuff growing up. Digital native meaning that they are born into it and everyone is using it. This has nothing to do at all with being born in the 1970s, and having used computers as the odd guy out in the mid 1980's. That's cool and all, but nothing to do with what makes a digital native.
- nerddad 6y agoI think the most generous reading of this article is something like: The general public falsely believes that most people in their 20s are much more proficient with technology than even nerds in their 40s and 50s, simply because they have had access to computers and smartphones most of their lives.