11 ms·
For those in the EU, the upcoming travel pass will cover three categories of people: vaccinated, PCR-tested negative, and recovered (i.e. positive antibody test
by walterbell 6y ago
For those in the EU, the upcoming travel pass will cover three categories of people: vaccinated, PCR-tested negative, and recovered (i.e. positive antibody test of immunity), https://www.schengenvisainfo.com/news/all-your-questions-on-eus-covid-19-vaccine-certificate-answered/ https://www.schengenvisainfo.com/news/all-your-questions-on-...
> For travellers who have recovered from the virus: date of the positive test result, an issuer of the certificate, date of issuance, validity date
The bureaucratic stumbling block will be agreement on antibody and T-cell testing definitions across country borders.
- sharken 6y agoThus limiting those that are not vaccinated and making it difficult to move freely for them. The travel pass is a horrible idea, that effectively will force many to be vaccinated. That should not be the european way.
- gls2ro 6y agoWhat should be the european way? I ask this as I understand your concern about politics forcing personal decisions, yet I am not finding a pragmatic workable solution to the current crisis.
- sharken 6y agoPersonal freedom should be the european way, like it is with the free movement of labor. You can use UK to gauge how the Covid situation will become and i dont think anyone will say there is a crisis now. https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/uk/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/uk/
- lazyjones 6y agoThe European way should be to treat the EU as one country and stop restricting movement. We've had Schengen for a long time, which meant no border checks whatsoever on most borders (we were driving through without even stopping or slowing down most of the time). With this vaccine passport, Schengen is pretty much history and that removes one of the main liberties the EU was offering.
- p49k 6y agoSchengen has been deteriorating for a long time. Denmark has totally ignored it and has road checks at the border for more than 5 years now and other nations have done similar (although to a less extreme extent).
- pjerem 6y agoI’ve been to Denmark two years ago and I have no memory of any border check. It was by plane btw, maybe the checks are different but it would be surprising. It is totally possible however that the check was so fast that I don’t remember it. Do you have any information about this ?
- ben_bai 6y agoCan't speak for Denmark. But usually those border-checks are done couple km/miles after the border. Police will just stop "random" cars/trucks and do a "routine check". And "random" it might be as much as 50% of the passing cars.
- p49k 6y agoNote I said “road checks” as in arriving by car. They totally closed the border and stop basically all non-Danish license plates for inspection. They are only supposed to be able to do this for emergencies for a max of 6 months. Instead, every 6 months they declare a new “emergency” so they can keep it closed indefinitely.
- gattilorenz 6y ago> The European way should be to treat the EU as one country and stop restricting movement. At least in Italy, movement was restricted inside regions (sometimes provinces) of the same country due to the epidemy. It's not nice for anyone involved, but the primary goal is to stop/limit the contagion. I'm an expat, so it goes against one of my interests, but I'm in favor of limiting border crossings, unless you can show that you won't spread COVID around.
- gls2ro 6y ago
- tomp 6y agoAs exemplified by the UK, enough people will want to get vaccinated to reach herd immunity. Then you don’t need to care about / oppress those who don’t want to / can’t get vaccinated.
- gls2ro 6y agoI would like a lot to believe that this is how it will be in all EU states, but I am not sure. As far as I can see the vaccination rhythm is decreasing in some countries and it is not even approaching 50% of population. It might be because of the back and forth with Astra Zeneca the EU did or it might be because EU is pretty big as in diverse with respect of culture, set of beliefs, approach to health … Anyhow everyone is demanding EU to do something so their response will not be “wait so that everybody wants to be vaccinated”. Also because being that big means that heard immunity will not be reached.
- azinman2 6y agoWhy not require vaccination?
- chrisco255 6y agoLiberty. It's a terrible a precedent to restrict freedom of movement on a forced personal health decision. It's basically subverting your body to the state.
- wfhbata 6y agoIt’s a terrible precedent to let people prolong a pandemic and endanger innocent people’s lives in the name of their personal liberties. If you don’t want to take measures to protect others, you can sit home for a while. It won’t kill you, and it won’t kill the people around you.
- T-hawk 6y agoNo, once everyone who wants it is vaccinated, their health is their problem not mine. If anyone is still scared of unvaccinated people, they can keep themselves at home forever, they don't get to force medical choices and restrictions on others.
- stormbrew 6y agoIf anyone is scared of getting vaccinated due to nonsense conspiracy theories, they can keep themselves at home forever, they don't get to force a deadly disease on others.
- jeduan 6y agoIt’s always funny when white people find out about visas
- Jommi 6y agoYeah just like anyone should be able to travel or live in Asian countries without the proper vaccines. Jeez.
- murkt 6y ago> The travel pass is a horrible idea, that effectively will force many to be vaccinated. Good. It’s not like a concentration camp. There are other options if you don’t want to vaccinate. You can just stay at home (I’ve been declined Schengen visa in the past for no reason), you can get PCR-tested. You also can get ill with Covid and then recover (hopefully).
- novaRom 6y agoDo labs store collected DNA results of PCR? I wonder if a database of DNA of millions of people will emerge on black market one day.
- murkt 6y agoCovid PCR tests check for specific viral RNA. They’re not sequencing human DNA.
- aww_dang 6y agoThe potential exists for DNA harvesting. Dismissing it as impossible seems inaccurate. >(CBS) — The largest biotech firm in the world wasted no time in offering to build and run COVID testing labs in Washington, contacting its governor right after the first major COVID outbreak in the U.S. occurred there. The Chinese company, the BGI Group, made the same offer to at least five other states, including New York and California, 60 Minutes has learned. This, along with other COVID testing offers by BGI, so worried Bill Evanina, then the country’s top counterintelligence officer, that he authorized a rare public warning. “Foreign powers can collect, store and exploit biometric information from COVID tests” declared the notice. Evanina believes the Chinese are trying to collect Americans’ DNA to win a race to control the world’s biodata. https://www.klfy.com/national/u-s-intelligence-officials-say-chinese-government-is-collecting-americans-dna/ https://www.klfy.com/national/u-s-intelligence-officials-say... https://www.thelastamericanvagabond.com/bill-gates-china-23me-and-your-dna/ https://www.thelastamericanvagabond.com/bill-gates-china-23m... >China's push to control Americans' health care future: U.S. officials say the Chinese government is trying to collect Americans' DNA, and they believe a recent offer from a Chinese company for assistance in COVID-19 testing was suspicious. Jon Wertheim reports. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/biodata-dna-china-collection-60-minutes-2021-01-31/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/biodata-dna-china-collection-60... https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/07/02/china-bgi-california-testing/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/07/02/china-bgi...
- Cederfjard 6y ago> Thus limiting those that are not vaccinated and making it difficult to move freely for them. > ... that effectively will force many to be vaccinated. Yup, that’s the point. No man is an island. You already can’t walk around doing literally whatever you want just because it’s your body you’re doing it with. You depend on other people, and other people depend on you (or at least can’t avoid intermingling with you, especially if you decide to travel internationally). Those who don’t get vaccinated slow down our recovery from the pandemic, putting other people’s health and lives at risk. Society has to make these trade-offs, and this one seems very reasonable to me.
- radu_floricica 6y agoI agree with your points, but I'd really really like to avoid giving the impression of... glee? "Look at those unwashed unvaccinated Trump supporters, so good they'll be forced to do things our ways now!". I'm not saying you're doing it, I'm just piggybacking on your comment. I'm pretty much a high-modernist when it comes to vaccines - I think that having governments build sewage and create vaccines go into the same category of "damn useful for civilization". But it does involve curtailing liberties, and I just can't put it in a "fell good" category.
- unilynx 6y agoThis subthread started about the EU. What does Trump have to do with this?
- refactor_master 6y agoI completely disagree. As we say with code, there’s freedom in restrictions. I, for example, don’t ever have to worry about my safety because the “freedom” of others have been curtailed on several points, and I deeply appreciate that. There’s no inherently moral good in limitless freedom. Especially because humans are far from rational agents that can reasonably act without boundaries. If you don’t want to be vaccinated or pay your taxes, you are, on some level, a danger to society.
- 6y ago
- spicybright 6y agoYour freedom ends where mine begins. Walking around with covid effects my freedom to walk around.
- bserge 6y agoSometimes I think I'm living in a parallel universe. I know people who travel regularly and no one says anything to them. No quarantine, nothing. Most people on the streets here in Germany give zero fucks, groups of 5-10, no masks (even though there's a curfew between 10pm-5am due to an increase in cases). And I traveled all the way from Moldova to Germany by car. No one, and I mean no one ever asked for a Covid test (which I had, of course, along with a positive antibodies test). Border guards, Hungarian border patrol, German Zoll, regular Romanian and German police, they cared about what's in the bags, didn't even mention Covid. Hungarian border guards wanted to see a German work contract for whatever asinine reason, but I repeat, none of them ever asked for a Covid test or to at least keep the mask on (they need to see your face when checking the passport). Whatever bureaucratic stumbling blocks there are, they have nothing to do with reality, it seems.
- mns 6y agoBecause in most of the cases you are transiting and no one cares. If you would have said to any of those border guards that you are coming to stay in any of those countries, they would have cared and asked for more things. Saying this as I travelled recently from Germany through 4 countries. In the destination country they asked for test, proof of sickness or vaccine proof.
- lbotos 6y agoI'm pretty sure it's because you traveled by car -- which means the odds that you were exposing your fellow travelers was limited to the people that would get in a car with you. I've traveled 2 times now by air from NYC -> London during Covid. Last year, a 14 day quarantine on both sides, and on the NYC side, a phone call everyday to make sure I was quarantining. This year on the London side, a 10 day quarantine, 1 negative test before flying, and 2 at home tests while quarantining, with a phone call everyday to confirm. I also got hassled at the airport because I didn't print out the day 2 and 8 receipt, just included the code on my passenger locator form under penalty of perjury. So, the UK by air does care I suspect because of the increased exposure risk.
- lazyjones 6y agoWhen was that? I traveled in the opposite direction (more or less: Vienna to Bucarest) more than 3 months ago and wasn't asked either, but on the Hungary-Romania border, they put me in a tiny room (1/3 shipping container or so) with ca. 10 people and gave me quarantine papers. They didn't check bags. I'm pretty sure they'd check for a test or vaccination now on the way back, I'm not eager to find out and will stay here in the Covid exile for a little longer.
- oldgregg 6y agoI think Covid is definitely revealing how reality is largely a projection of whatever media/tech outlets you consume. In particular everyone physically isolated greatly magnifies the ability of the tech companies to manufacture a narrative environment ala McLuhan et al. Or, as many would say, covid is primarily a psyop by technocratic globalist elites to consolidate power.
- glial 6y ago> covid is primarily a psyop by technocratic globalist elites to consolidate power. I keep hearing this, but what power are they supposed to be consolidating, exactly?
- hackflip 6y agoI wouldn't claim it's a conspiracy, but lots of companies are benefiting from the lockdowns due to the lockdowns killing their competitors. I'm not allowed to shop at most stores in my neighborhood at the moment, but I'm allowed to buy from Amazon. Until recently I wasn't allowed to buy non essentials from family owned stores deemed non essential, but Walmart was still allowed to sell them.
- NullPrefix 6y ago> the upcoming travel pass will cover ... and recovered (i.e. positive antibody test of immunity) From the linked article: >For travellers who have recovered from the virus: date of the positive test result, an issuer of the certificate, date of issuance, validity date EU Travel Pass doesn't care about your antibodies.
- walterbell 6y ago> EU Travel Pass doesn't care about your antibodies. Hmm, you are right :( The rules are still evolving. They will need to care, since the people who recovered after a positive test are much fewer than people who recovered without being tested. From https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/qanda_21_1187 https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/qanda_... > The period of relevance of certificates depends on scientific evidence and will be determined by the verifiers following their national rules. As new scientific evidence is emerging, the periods for which certificates are relevant for waiver of applicable public health requirements could be adjusted ...The regulation also introduces some basic principles, for example, setting the maximum validity period of the certificate of recovery at 180 days. These principles could be adjusted by the Commission through delegated acts to align with new scientific evidence once it is available. Going strictly by the text above, what would happen to the recovered people after 180 days? If they have immunity they cannot get another positive test, so no recovery certificate and no travel? Or if you already recovered more than 6 months ago, you cannot travel? It will come down to some metric of immunity, which is apparently "TBD" but will almost immediately be a concern, as all stakeholders look more closely at the rules, logic and implications. The EU and many western governments are not dictatorships, relying on human judgement to enforce policy. If proposed policies fail basic checks of reason and fairness, humans at border checkpoints can exercise judgement. If and when policy makers find their policy is not enforceable, they can improve the policy until it is supported by science, citizens and enforcers. The travel industry expects these passes to bring their customers back. They will not sit quietly while their recovered/immune customers are blocked by incompetent bureaucracy from spending money across the EU, without a substantive scientific case.
- virgilp 6y ago