17 ms·
Why do older individuals have greater control of their feelings?
- codevark 6y agoThey've learned to lie better.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nsoonhui 6y agoBecause those who can't control their feelings don't tend to live as long, due to poor health and less meaningful social life, all resulted from bad temper?
- literallycancer 6y agoHalf of this website has no social life. Anyone dead yet? Show of hands?
- lame-robot-hoax 6y agoOnly inside
- me_me_me 6y agoLack of social ties, interaction, spouse all are statistically significant factors of shorter avg lifespans.
- hnedeotes 6y agoWho produced these studies? The imperial college of london?
- red75prime 6y agoThose are correlation studies. Such studies cannot tell would you live longer if you were to force yourself to improve your social interactions. Being married at least has a tangible causal link: support in health-related emergencies.
- Tade0 6y agoIT is well past that point. Now it's a job like any other, not something done by people who would otherwise be shut-in NEETs.
- kcmastrpc 6y agoPractice, lots of practice. Also, natural selection has a way of deprioritizing people who are emotionally unstable.
- saiya-jin 6y agoHormones go down and we get more experienced with all the crap life throws at everybody. Older folks tend to know themselves much better and also what they want in life, what actually matters and what is shallow bullsh*t. Enough reasons to be chill just about everything
- mycologos 6y agoYeah, I'm surprised that the article seems to just ignore the role of hormones. There's certainly a decline in testosterone as men age [1]: > Total testosterone levels fall at an average of 1.6% per year whilst free and bioavailable levels fall by 2%–3% per year ... [t]wenty percent of men aged over 60 have total testosterone levels below the normal range and the figure rises to 50% in those aged over 80. I know there's been a lot of pushback on the idea that testosterone is just a masculine hormone, but the link between testosterone and aggression [2] seems pretty well-accepted. So it seems reasonable that declining testosterone might make you more even-keeled. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2544367/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2544367/ [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Testosterone#Aggression_and_criminality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Testosterone#Aggression_and_cr...
- xorfish 6y agoOr it could just be that in societies, where aggression is rewarded with social status, testosterone will increase aggression because it increases the thrive for social status: > The relationship between testosterone and aggression may also function indirectly, as it has been proposed that testosterone does not amplify tendencies towards aggression but rather amplifies whatever tendencies will allow an individual to maintain social status when challenged. In most animals, aggression is the means of maintaining social status. However, humans have multiple ways of obtaining social status. This could explain why some studies find a link between testosterone and pro-social behaviour if pro-social behaviour is rewarded with social status. Thus the link between testosterone and aggression and violence is due to these being rewarded with social status.
- Hitton 6y ago>When older people say, “This is the best time of your life, enjoy it while you can,” that’s a form of abuse. I guess that these days anything can be called "abuse".
- ChrisRR 6y agoI realise that a lot of people have anxiety issues, but to call it abuse is just stupid. They are genuinely people looking back on their life experience and giving advice.
- 8fGTBjZxBcHq 6y agoI wouldn't call this abuse either but there is a huge huge gulf between "that was the best time of my life" and "this is the best time of your life. It's at best just extremely rude to tell someone about their own life and how they should feel about it.
- cj 6y ago> It's at best just extremely rude to tell someone about their own life and how they should feel about it. I have to disagree. My grandparents often have great perspectives on life situations that they readily share when relevant to the people around them. No one sees it as rude, and if they do, it’s usually because the advice hits a little too close to home. Like “when I went through my divorce…”
- dredmorbius 6y agoSharing insight and/or experience != telling someone how to feel about something. The truly insightful manage to prompt you to think without explicitly telling you to do so. (And are sometimes wrong. People can in fact be living in a truly dismal present, whatever their age.)
- 8fGTBjZxBcHq 6y agoYes, I am not disputing that. I am talking about the difference between giving someone advice about a situation they're in, and telling them how to feel about it. "When I was your age, I didn't appreciate certain things so I'm pointing them out to you" is really different from "this is the best time of your life" which is a statement an external observer is just not equipped to make about someone else's life.
- bm3719 6y agoAt age 20 or so, I read a quote in a book (on day trading, IIRC) that went something like: "Master your emotions, or they will master you." After thinking about it, I realized that despite identifying as a logical-thinking individual, I was nevertheless at the mercy of the more primitive parts of my brain. Sometimes totally, but pretty much all executive functions were influenced by it to a large degree. That might be fine, but my limbic system tended to make poor decisions; ones that my more conscious brain would have to pay the price for later. It's also no match for the brains of people not in emotional mode, and would be taken advantage of by things like appeals to emotion in advertising, politics, and rhetoric. I decided my internal caveman was not my friend, and took steps to sideline his vote in decision-making.
- yberreby 6y ago> I decided my internal caveman was not my friend, and took steps to sideline his vote in decision-making. Could you elaborate on what those steps were?
- StavrosK 6y agoProbably the same as changing any behavior: First try to notice when you're doing the thing you don't want to be doing, then try to abort when you find yourself doing it. The time between "start" and "abort" will keep getting shorter, and eventually you'll not do it in the first place.
- DrStartup 6y agoSounds like the ACT Matrix
- bm3719 6y agoI settled on the triune brain model as a good-enough approximation for my needs in relation to this (whether it's factually accurate is another issue). I would then categorize my thoughts and subsequent actions based on that model (mainly limbic vs. neocortex). It's pretty easy to tell them apart with some high-level introspection. Then, I'd short-circuit any emotional thinking once I spotted myself engaging in it, and injecting rational thought into those times when the limbic system would normally be in control. I'd spent decades of life not doing this, so it took a long time for this to not feel weird, but eventually it became natural. Once the big reactive emotions (e.g. anger) were dealt with, I turned attention to the more subtle influences. I think there's a middle ground of thoughts that are a more complex or a mix of emotional and rational (think things like national pride, identity, career progression). That's a harder job and a more involved topic. In fact, I can't say I've completely got that done, or even fully mastered the first part. The caveman is always there, of course, and perhaps the best you can hope for is restraining him.
- ggambetta 6y agoMy entirely unscientific theory is that like other cells, we're born with a limited number of fucks in our body. When we're young, we (instinctively, subconsciously) feel like our fucks reserves are plentiful, so we give a fuck about a lot of stuff. As we get older, our reservoir of fucks gets progressively depleted. The fucks are rarer, so we give a fuck less and less often. I've recently turned 40 and I can definitely feel this in myself; just like recovery from workouts takes a little longer than when I was 20, I don't give a fuck about things so easily. By the time you're officially old, you're almost out of fucks, so it's not like you don't give a fuck because you don't want to, but because it's more difficult physically (harvesting of the last fucks takes more energy, because biology). Brb, submitting to Nature.
- hnlmorg 6y agoI think what you're describing is more down to desensitisation through exposure to stressful environments. When you're younger smaller problems seem larger because you've not been desensitised to larger problems. As you progress through life you generally experience greater stress and thus the smaller problems feel smaller. You could look at it like desensitisation to capsicum, salt, violence or pornography.
- ggambetta 6y agoThat's preposterous! I'm sticking to my "fucks are finite and biologically limited" theory. I'll use the TED talk to promote my upcoming self-help book around this mind-blowing new theory.
- halgir 6y agoSurprisingly relevant to my post from last year, actually titled "Fucks are finite": https://halgir.com/fucks-are-finite/ https://halgir.com/fucks-are-finite/
- SJetKaran 6y agoReminded me of this song "I've No More F**s To Give!" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vqbk9cDX0l0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vqbk9cDX0l0
- rriepe 6y agoAs an emotional philosopher, I've found that the emotions of guilt and pride don't stop developing until you're in your 60s. EDIT: No, really, I do philosophy, it focuses on emotion. I don't deserve downvotes for something I've worked for years on[1]. [1]: http://eristicstest.com/ http://eristicstest.com/
- pomian 6y agoHey that was fun. I first read your page, and based on descriptions, tried to predict my result. Took test, result was close - same category(row), but other side.(column). Neato.
- rriepe 6y agoThanks, I'm glad you enjoyed it. And yep the category (order) is the big one. But six results didn't really capture it all.
- conformist 6y agoHow big a role does survivorship bias play? It seemed like in the case of chimpanzees the article sort of implies that the effect "nice and more self-controlled chimpanzees live longer", mattered too? I wonder what portion of "older people being more emotionally balanced" can be explained by more emotionally balanced people surviving longer in Western society? Sounds like something somebody will have tried to quantify at least in terms of the order of magnitude?
- maleta 6y agoThey enjoyed and suffered more, so they are not reacting on smaller emotion hits.
- paublyrne 6y agoWe're too tired to get upset about things.
- gatestone 6y agoI experienced my worst emotionally stressfull events at age of 39 and 55. The latter was harder, and the trauma is not really healed after three years. Everything that you can say shortly about feelings and age is going to be badly oversimplified.
- pdimitar 6y agoTrauma and desensitization would be my unscientific guess.
- williesleg 6y agoLess soy and less internet. But we sure know how to play all you youngsters, look at BLM and all that horse shit.
- nautilus12 6y agoI think its simple, we don't have as much to lose as we get older so we relax.
- eplanit 6y agoAnd we've "been around the block" (i.e. cycles of life, relationships, career, health, ...) a few times. We've become a bit more familiar with the patterns, and familiarity reduces fear and anxiety.
- 31tor 6y agoDegradation of tissue in the amygdala
- dangerface 6y agoDo they really? show them something foreign or a new technology and ask them how they feel, you will see how in control of their emotions they really are.
- dang 6y agoPlease don't take HN threads into flamewar. This is a noticeable step in the direction we're trying to avoid here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- amarant 6y agoNatural selection. At a young age, some people know how to control their feelings, others don't. The ones who can't then die from road rage or similar, leaving only the ones with at least a modicum of self control in the older age groups. Basically, it's survivor bias, but literally.
- exegete 6y agoHow many people do you think die from road rage (or similar) annually? How do you account for all the people who couldn’t handle their emotions when young and now can when older?
- Kye 6y agoAll the older people who go on tantrums at retail and food service workers throw a monkey into this theory.
- kulig 6y agoIn my experience, a tendency to lash out at others also comes with an exagerated sense of self preservation.
- amarant 6y agoNah, natural selection sometimes works slowly, and it's not infallible, it's all about probabilities. Old people who are angry throws a wrench in the original statement, not this explanation of it.
- mikewarot 6y agoI think it is survivorship bias, those who couldn't control their feelings were more likely self-destruct through a variety of direct and indirect mechanisms.
- gorbachev 6y agoPersonally I just don't give a shit. I still get upset the same way as I did decades ago, but it's just not worth my time and energy to get all up in arms about most things that are upsetting to me. On most things I either know nothing I will do or say will make a positive impact, or I know the issue will take care of itself or someone else is taking care of it, just not right at this very moment. So why bother. I have better things to do with my life. Like lie down on my couch and binge watch Golden Girls. I make an exception on things endangering the well being of my wife and kids. Older and wiser? Or older and lazier?
- FredPret 6y ago...or does lazier == wiser?
- terminalserver 6y agoGolden Girls?
- terminalserver 6y agoBecause when you’re young, your feelings control you. So you end up doing and saying things that don’t actually serve your own interests, or those of people around you. Also because when you’re young you don’t yet know that certain displays of, or acting out of, impulsive emotions, isn’t acceptable in our society. So over time, to stop fucking your own life up, your progressively learn to say less, to hold your tongue, to decide later, to consider things from the perspective of others, to reserve and hold back. To give things time and think before acting or talking. To give people the benefit of the doubt. You earn that things are likely to change so there’s less reason to respond in an extreme manner to right now. You learn that you’re not as important as you think you were when you were younger.
- quesera 6y agoI think it's simple: Perspective, and emotional fatigue. The first time <insert good thing> happens to you, you might be overwhelmed with excitement and joy. The 85th time, not so much. Hopefully you still appreciate it, but for the same dramatic response, the reward center needs more. Anything that happens to you 85 times isn't special enough to be life-changing, by definition. The first time <insert bad thing> happens to you, you might be crushed. By the 5th time it happens to you, or you've seen it happen to others, you are just kind of immune. You know bad things happen, and you either decide to move forward or you do not. Interestingly though: seeing someone else experience the now-banal-to-you positive thing can be it's own reward. Watching a child's first taste of ice cream is somehow magical. Or a puppy's first experience of snow. And we try to have patience for the corresponding first-negative experiences too. A child who does not get exactly what they wanted for dinner, or who must go home from the park earlier than he or she might like... (Examples above intentionally light-weight. There are real bad things that happen to people, but the level of emotional energy elicited by the trivialities can be enormous!)
- niknoble 6y agoIf this were the whole story, it would mean that a man who had been in a coma his whole life up to 60 would have the same emotional control as a little kid. For example, he would cry at losing a board game. That's very hard to believe. I'm pretty sure the difference between old people and young people is mostly just energy. Old people can't feel intense emotions for the same reason they can't run a marathon. They just get fatigued too easily.
- quesera 6y agoThat's an interesting idea. I wonder if there is any data on that sort of thing. Anecdotally, though much less dramatically: When my Mom switched from glasses to contact lenses (and received an improved prescription), her sense of happiness and wonder at being able to see the details of tree leaves, etc, is something that I still remember a few decades later.
- jerf 6y agoOne of the interesting results from psychology is that emotions are a complicated feedback loop from stimulus, around through the body, back to the feeling, but critically involving bodily response, not just states of the brain. I've personally experienced "feeling anxious" simply because my heart was beating too quickly for purely physiological reasons. (I've had some heart troubles.) Once I addressed those reasons, the anxiety faded with it. This is a handwave in the direction of this research and ideas, not an explanation of it; consult the web if you're interested in more. I propose something that neither the article nor anyone else is in the comments so far, which is that we age, our bodies simply get less physical about the emotions. It makes it easier to be more level if your body is literally being more level, and the aforementioned feedback loop is literally weaker. Everything else gets weaker in old age, why not the physiological strength of emotions, too?
- djanogo 6y agoData. Older people have more data or results of data processing stored.
- 0xEFF 6y agoThe biggest change I noticed was having a kid. It’s like there’s been a process running in my head since birth called “affects me?” A few months after kiddo, there’s a new process, “affects kid?” The new process seems to have taken a third to a half of the resources the first was using. Much of what bothered me doesn’t affect the kid so I don’t care nearly as much.
- Taylor_OD 6y agoIt's just from feeling more right? When I was 9 the best pizza I'd ever had came from a Walmart food court. Now that I'm closer to 30 I'm had a lot more pizza that was far better and far worse than that pizza. If I were to eat that same pizza again it probably wouldnt taste better than any pizza I've ever had. My experience is informed by past experience. Just like my emotional reaction is informed by past emotional experiences.
- ARandomerDude 6y agoI think you're onto something here in certain ways, but the expanding relative emotional scale idea doesn't explain why the young tend to be the thrill-seekers and the old tend to enjoy more of the "simple pleasures" of life. If the Wal-Mart pizza were the main factor, it seems to me we'd expect to see the reverse: the young would be more content with the simple, but as they got bored over time, they'd seek greater and greater thrills as they aged. That said, I do think you're right when it comes to a sense of sadness. A middle-schooler is devastated when another student says his shoes are out of style. Someone in their 50s is generally devastated by more substantive things like the death of a child.
- Taylor_OD 6y agoOh interesting. I think the same is true for thrill seeking but there is an added element which is perspective. When I was young I feared little and did stupid things, sometimes to disastrous results. Now I know I could do those stupid things if I'd like but I'm also more aware of the potential results. Young people know some of the things they are doing are stupid but until you feel it yourself its hard to really know it right? There is also an element of realizing that certain highs are not actually satisfying in the long term. When I was younger I thought X would make me happy. Now I realize that X is very unlikely to actually improve my overall happiness. Some people never realize this or they stumble into taking drugs which is in some ways does cause them to seek greater thrills/highs but they typically don't make it very long in that lifestyle.
- Tycho 6y agoOne of my theories is that older people are just as impulsive as younger people, it's just that they have better impulses owing to a superior understanding of the world and other individuals (gained through experience).
- citizenpaul 6y agoThey are but they are not by default. I've seen old people that cant control their emotions. 1.Experience : Every situation is new when you are young therefore much more stressful/emotional. 2.Hormones : obvious but an 80yo is not getting the same surge of adrenaline for things as a 20yo. 3.Control : Old people general have money, options, connections, safety nets. Much easier to stay unemotional when something cant affect you. There didn't need a PHD for that....
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- treespace88 6y agoBecause I’m lucky. When I was younger I wasn’t, nothing ever really went well for me. But after close to 30 years of gainful employment, and stability in marriage and work ( This is the good luck) I’m calmer.
- bitwize 6y agoPractice?
- dustinmoris 6y ago> Why do older individuals have greater/better .... ? Practice
- zarkov99 6y agoIt's not older individuals, it's more experiences ones. An experience's impact is significantly dependent on its novelty.
- tachyonbeam 6y agoTo expand on this, when you're a kid, things that affect you emotionally can seem to have disproportionate impact on your life. When you're older and more experienced, you've been through many crisis situations, and you've seen that things usually work out OK. You know better how to deal with various situations, and you have a much more realistic predictions of how things will eventually unfold. You probably also know, from experience, that even if you have an initial emotional reaction to something, that doesn't mean you should trust those emotions and roll with them. Getting angry rarely fixes anything, feeling sad is normal but it doesn't mean your life is going to shit, and getting excited about something is good, but you know it might not be worth getting excited too quickly.
- Dumblydorr 6y agoOlder individuals have less strong feelings, their bodies and minds are less primed for survival and mating, they're in the grandparent stage evolutionarily. Younger people feel things more acutely, they are more sensitive but also the worst thing that's happened to them is almost certainly coming, multiple times, and the same for the best thing.
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoBecause they are dying from old age?
- breckinloggins 6y agoPersonally speaking the answer has been mostly "practice". I realize things would suck less if I didn't let my emotions control me on topic X, so I work on that. It's simple, but it sure isn't easy.
- klmadfejno 6y agoI would expect survivor bias. The author isn't saying "greater control of feelings", they're saying "higher emotional well being and more satisfying social contacts". Old people with low emotional well being probably die off sooner. Old people with poor social relationships are probably harder to find and talk to to study.
- slightwinder 6y agoIsn't the answer simply experience? The more one experience an emotion, the more one know on how the emotions works, unfolds and how to handle it. Similar, with age and experience we have more understanding on how situations arise which trigger specific emotions, which also means we have more time to prepare, manage and probably even avoid them.
- S_A_P 6y agoI’m not sure how I interpret this. I am much more apt to show my feelings as I get older. As a kid I would bottle every emotion and attempt stoicism so I didn’t look uncool or embarrassed or sad. These days I will be much more likely to show emotion unless doing so would be some sort of unprofessional or faux pas. To me that feels like the opposite of control of feelings.
- prionassembly 6y agoI have a 1 month-old baby at home right now. God, talk about not having control of one's feelings.
- jes 6y agoI'm 61. I question whether it's greater control of my feelings, as against, more recognition that feelings come and go and don't require that we act on them. The study and practice of non-dualism and other ancient Indian regions has been helpful to me. I'm generally at ease in the world.
- danschumann 6y agoRay Dalio, "Another one of those"
- bena 6y agoThe older you get, the more you've experienced and the less any individual moment represents of your accumulated life. When you are a child of like 5, a year represents 20% of your entire life. When you don't get that toy. That is literally the worst thing that's happened in your life up to that point. You have absolutely no frame of reference. You don't even have the capability to imagine and compare hypotheticals. You are unaware they even exist. As you get older, you get more experience, you become capable of hypothetical thinking and comparing events to things you haven't directly experienced. And, any given year is less of your total lifespan. That's what we call maturity, that ability to reference our own experience. That's why children who have experienced great trauma seem more mature. Because they've been given experiences we don't expect even adults to handle alone. Like kids in cancer wards. They're mostly chill because not getting a lollipop after chemo is kind of insignificant to, you know, having cancer. It's also a perspective we lose as we get older. We don't remember what it's like to not have that life experience. Not really. I can remember being really disappointed at not getting that really sweet Lego space set when I was 9 or 10, but I can't really feel it again. I look back on that kid as almost someone else. Even though I feel as much myself now as I did then.
- SunlightEdge 6y agoAlternatively, your brain is way more 'energetic' when you are younger. You feel things more strongly, can be over whelmed with all the competing signals and are inexperienced. Maturity does reduce the sensitivity and improve the focus (e.g. pruning of the neocortex). But I also think experience helps too e.g. Knowing your body is feeling anger you are experienced enough to walk away or not send that email. 'Not giving a fuck' is also a strategy to avoid harmful repetition of negative memories.
- at_a_remove 6y agoWhat was that bit from The Breakfast Club? "When you grow up, your heart dies." I believe several factors are in play. First, instinctual self-regulation of cycles. It seems that babies need to figure out how to sleep on a regular basis, but eventually they "settle down." Similarly, I suspect that the outbursts of childhood self-regulate, without reflection. I also consider conscious self-reflection. In the American remake of La Femme Nikita, one character adopts another's line, "I never did mind the little things" as a response to provocation. Mine has been "Well, this is hardly the worst thing that has happened to me." Which leads into the third factor -- the more we experience, the greater breadth of experience we have and so we have greater highs and lower lows against which to compare our current experiences. Fourth, declining energy levels. We get tired as we grow older. It becomes easier to deprioritize simply because we must spend our limited reserves on other things. All of this sounds reasonable, but I do wonder, in the pallor of middle age, about the idea that your heart dies. Just a little.
- irrational 6y agoWhen I was younger thing seemed so black and white. The older I get the more I see that everything is shades of gray. Everything is more nuanced. I say "it depends" a lot more than I would have when I was younger. Plus, I've been around long enough to realize that what seems really important and earth shattering right now will probably not even make it into the footnotes of history. Very little is worth getting worked up over. Plus, I have so many more responsibilities taking my attention combined with not having the energy of youth that I simply don't have the ability to care about anything above the very most important things.
- innocentoldguy 6y agoWisdom through experience.
- TeeMassive 6y agoI'm 32. Control over my feelings has always been important to me as a way to survive an abusive household when growing up. I've noticed it has become easier for the following reasons: * I've been through worse. * Time flies faster when you're older. * Having experience means I have an explanation for most of the things I experience around me. * I can assign words and concepts to what I feel, making it easier to understand what I experience inside of me. * I've seen people die. I accept death as a possible outcome and rationalize it for what it is: part of life. Like a dreamless sleep, like before I was born, which wasn't so bad.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoBecause having control of your feelings is a skill and can be obtained through "suffering" for example, and older individuals have more experiences in life.
- AcerbicZero 6y agoThe stoics got it right several thousand years ago, now we're just waiting on the rest of humanity to catch up.
- archontes 6y agoThis contacts something I think about. When we do science in a rigorous, non-anthropocentric, fashion, we find that the universe is a clockwork mechanism, life is a thermodynamically favorable process, and that there doesn't appear to be any objective meaning. Which leads to a person asking, "Knowing this, what do I do [with myself, perhaps]?" And I think that there are four philosophies that begin with that premise: stoicism, epicureanism, absurdism, and nihilism. And people go on and on about which one is the 'right' one, and I just think they're tools in our toolbox, suitable for different situations. A slave from the mines of Laurium would find in stoicism very useful tools for enduring hardships in life. Epicureanism is full of tools for how to comport yourself when you have a lot of control over your surroundings. Nihilism and absurdism contain reasons to keep getting out of bed. There isn't any objective meaning or god? Well, good news, that means that anything you decide is important is as important as if god himself said so. Still upset that there isn't any objective meaning? More good news, friend. You can keep searching for meaning even though it isn't objectively there, because the search for meaning is a rewarding human experience. And you can decide that a thing is meaningful, and that has weight because you're god. To say that stoics 'got it right', I think, is a bit incomplete; it implicitly buys into an idea that a single philosophy or way of being is 'the right one', where instead they can each be well suited to different situations.
- okareaman 6y agoI'm 63 and for me the answer is simple: more self-awareness. I am aware of what thoughts my emotion is in response to. I am aware of how my emotions are cascading other emotions and triggering feelings based on memories of similar circumstances. I am aware of how my emotions are affecting the people around me and how their response is feeding back into my thoughts and feelings. Finally, with self-awareness comes the meta-cognition ability to debug and reprogram my thoughts and feelings. My emotions are often based on something that is not quite true, so stepping back and looking at truth based reality calms them. I developed this ability only recently. I honestly think I was sleepwalking through most of my life being driven to and fro by thoughts and feelings that were difficult to understand.
- slver 6y agoMore reflection, sure. Experience. Humility. But also less hormones. Young people are hormone-driven action-reaction machines.
- faeyanpiraat 6y agoEveryone is just a machine
- okareaman 6y agoYes, we have become very efficient in doing things. What we are doing, we have become so efficient in doing that we don’t need any awareness to do it. It has become mechanical, automatic. We function like robots. We are not men yet; we are machines. That’s what George Gurdjieff used to say again and again, that man as he exists is a machine. He offended many people, because nobody likes to be called a machine. Machines like to be called gods; then they feel very happy, puffed up. Gurdjieff used to call people machines, and he was right. If you watch yourself you will know how mechanically you behave. http://www.pomyc.org/blog-details/55 http://www.pomyc.org/blog-details/55 The exact quote by Gurdjieff is worth reading. Kurt Vonnegut's "Breakfast of Champions" dealt with this theme in an extraordinary way. He created a character who was going mad because he felt he was living among robots. At last, his character finds an artist that had a "light" in him, a soul, and the character decides everything is ok. At this point Kurt Vonnegut inserts himself into the narrative (which struck me as extraordinary) and says that he decided not to kill himself because he wrote this story (his mother committed suicide.) This book also helped me become more self-aware.
- raincom 6y agoUsually, life experiences along with learning impact how one control their feelings. The more one lives, the more one experiences, the more one learns.
- jfengel 6y agoIs it even true? There is a common stereotype of "older individuals", at least in the US, as cranky and irritable. Stereotypes aren't truth, but I think we've all encountered at least some examples of this. I'm not actually sure that contradicts the article, which takes a somewhat specific view of "control". But I've just spent four years dealing with a very prominent older individual who seemed to have absolutely zero control over his feelings, and also seemed to bring out a very large cohort of similar individuals.
- alisonkisk 6y agoIt's a statistical observation. And the President/salesman/actor/demagogue is not a representative sample of psychological behavior. Not are his "cohort" largely his own age.
- fidesomnes 6y ago> There is a common stereotype of "older individuals", at least in the US, as cranky and irritable. For older men this is a side effect of dropping testosterone levels that decreases some small percentage point each year after age 35. They are irritable all the time because they are irritated all the time and the effects are slowly cumulative until they are irritated all the time and their temper is on a short fuse. This happens to all men and only therapy and awareness can ward off its effects.
- m463 6y agoI think there might be an inflection point where someone transitions from "personal sovereignty" through a gradual decline of choices and capabilities. Sort of a movement to more dependence on others. Could be a bumpy ride for a bit.
- b0rsuk 6y agoMaybe older people just feel... less? My feelings get less and less intense as I grow older. OH NO Anyway
- permo-w 6y agoMy personal observation is that emotional control and resilience comes from experience. It comes from being exposed to lots of different emotional triggers. The times when I’ve been the most emotionally strong have been after my most socially diverse periods Perhaps the effect is somewhat cumulative
- munificent 6y agoIndependent of any biological or hormonal causes, I can think of several reasons why older folks might be more even keeled merely by virtue of where they are in their life span: 1. The more experiences you have, the less likely any new experience is to be an extreme outlier. A toddler has the best and worst day of their life once a month or so. A twenty-something every couple of years. By your sixties, there's a good chance that most of the extreme emotional outliers are all in your past. So when you're going through something that would overwhelm a younger person, it's likely you can correctly say, "Eh, I've been through worse." And that realization, and the memory of what it was like after it is itself an emotional buffer. It's hard to feel like your world is falling apart when you clearly remember yourself putting it back together once before. 2. The stakes for your decisions are lower. When you're a teen, it feels like every decision can radically alter the course of your life. Maybe that after school sport becomes your scholarship ticket to an expensive college. Your major determines your career. Deciding whether to go to that party could mean meeting the love of your life of not. The butterfly effect iterated future ahead of scales the magnitude of every single thing you do. But when you're older, there is simply less time for that scaling to occur. No decision a seventy-year-old makes will change the course of their life radically for the next sixty years because, well, they don't have sixty years. Most bets are thus relatively safer. 3. Your existence is more secure. By the time you reach middle age, you likely (though not definitely) have accumulated skills, experience, a social network, job contacts, a career, and wealth. You live in a pretty well-feathered nest, able to withstand most bouts of bad weather.
- rsj_hn 6y agoIt's perspective. Young people have little perspective, by definition. They can't predict how things will play out, or what the consequences of various actions will be on an emotional level. You can try to gain perspective by doing things like reading realistic novels or realism-based historical studies (as opposed to the morality tales so in vogue today). I think this type of vicarious emotional absorption is the best that young people can do if they are actively trying to improve their perspective. But then you are at the mercy of how accurately the author or historian is portraying life -- older people can detect "false notes" more easily, and I see many false notes when I watch media or listen to music, some so egregiously false as to classify those works as deception. Then you can get into a situation where your emotional depth is getting worse with time because you are learning things vicariously that aren't accurately describing how life works. But most people will eventually come to have enough authentic emotional experiences as to be able to gain some depth, e.g. perspective, even if they have consumed a lot of false vicarious experiences. In fact, those authentic experience might be incredibly jarring. I've heard that Ruskin had lots of sexual issues in his life because he was trained to work with sculptures of naked women with no pubic hair or realistic features, and was shocked when he saw an actual (non-idealized) nude woman. He may never have managed to purge himself of the false notes he absorbed as a young art student. When a brand new CS student who has never written a program, or has only written a handful of exercises, are thrown into a large codebase, you expect them to make poor decisions. That's why their work is supervised. Not because they lack intelligence, but because they lack perspective. They are not thinking of how X will be maintained over time, or the consequences of creating some dependencies, etc. Over time, they acquire that perspective and make better decisions, at which point they need less supervision and can eventually supervise others. So it is with everything that requires the exercise of judgement, whether writing code or handling your emotions or finances, or relationships. It takes time to acquire sufficient perspective to exercise good judgement. This is why historically nations had committees of elders who could block laws deemed reckless, and why traditionally young people were not allowed to vote and only gradually were entrusted with privileges that required the exercise of judgement such as signing contracts.
- martin1975 6y agoI would not label this control - more like they gain experience in recognizing their own feelings, and for that split second after they register and become aware of their feelings, they choose an appropriate response. I remember Obama being heckled at a speech by someone - you could clearly see his irritation by his pause, a second or two of deliberate delay/processing what he felt, and then just gave a somewhat calm response to the person in an effort to defuse the tension in the room. Trump notoriously sucked at emotional regulation, and he's what you'd consider 'an older individual'. He too would give measured responses, it's just that they were more direct/less diplomatic than say Obama's. I used to be more knee-jerky in my responses, say 20+ years ago in my 20's, but after a lot of screw ups in life w/relationships (close/intimate ones in particular), a failed marriage, 2 kids and a lot of therapy, both group and individual, I've made progress in being aware of my feelings and responding in a more measured way, so outwardly that appears as if I have "greater control". The reality is I'm still a mess - I'm just responsible for my mess before I vomit it outward on someone else. LinkedIn Learning actually has this great one hour or so video I just watched that covers this nicely, I think it's called "Emotional Intelligence"... Some say it predicts how you will fare career wise far more than being just technically adept/skilled. It's a process of "finding oneself" and figuring out where we fit best. Mastering responses to our emotions is a life long process and we tend to end up "automagically" drawn to similar people, cultures, companies, relationships....
- wly_cdgr 6y agoWe've seen the sun set after a warm day, and we've seen it rise again after a cold night. You live through this enough times and you learn to see beyond the horizon. Eventually you can see yourself in the distance, walking forward and away from you, towards your past
- wly_cdgr 6y agoAlso, we are deaf and didn't hear the guy who tried to pick a fight with us
- JabavuAdams 6y ago45. Because you have experience to tell you what happens when you don't, lol. I have a foot ache. Hmm, stop applying footgun to foot.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 5y agoI can name off the bat a lot of possible reasons For example, older people have more money and less debt. Medicare and Social Security. Less responsibilities. Less to gain and less to lose.